Can you choose to believe?

Could you choose to believe that the Quran was the literal word of God?

  • Yes

    Votes: 26 17.8%
  • No

    Votes: 120 82.2%

  • Total voters
    146

Robin

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Apr 29, 2004
Messages
14,971
I am always fascinated when people say that they can choose to believe.

I cannot understand how they can do this. If the evidence points in a particular way then I have to believe that.

For example I could not choose to believe that Muhammad was the final messenger of God and that the Quran is the literal word of God.

No matter how long I spent trying, no matter how much effort I put into it.

And it would be meaningless for me to say I chose not to believe this, if there was no way I could make the other choice.

So I am interested in whether the JREF community at large think they can choose to believe something.

(Naturally to answer the poll in the affirmative, atheists would have to first choose to believe in God. The question is probably not applicable to those who are already Muslims)
 
Last edited:
Are you talking about religion specifically? Or about anything?

I think that, in general, the answer to this question for the vast majority of people (if they were honest) would be "yes". Consider if someone you love very much is accused of something (cheating on you, stealing from someone else, etc.), but swears to you that they didn't do it. There's significant evidence supporting the claim that they're guilty...but in many cases, despite the evidence, people will still choose to take the word of the person they love.

In regards to religion, while I myself would not "choose to believe" a religion in direct contradiction to evidence (in fact, it was such evidence that caused me to abandon my Christian beliefs, even though at the time I didn't really want to), I know many others that do. In fact, I've personally talked with people who've told me that they really can't provide any evidence for their beliefs, who admit there's strong evidence that their beliefs are wrong...and yet who plainly state that they choose to believe it nonetheless. And the reasons aren't entirely irrational...take the woman who's husband has died, and who misses him terribly. It is much, much more psychologically comforting to think, "I'll see him again in Heaven some day" or "His spirit is watching over me now", than to think "He's a rotting lump of flesh in the ground, he has ceased entirely to exist, and I will never, ever have the chance to see or talk to him again."
 
This question pops up at fairly regular intervals on the BBC Christian Topic message board and I read the responses, but I think it is quite a puzzling one. The only way I can decide about my own view is to remember how I thought when I still believed that there was a force/powe 'out there somewhere'. I enjoyed the many discussions with groups I belonged to, but realise that I did not have enough facts to finally dismiss the idea. There was just that small place in my mind that 'knew' I must be right, so I don't think I could have chosen to believe I was wrong. Of course, since I have removed that idea of God/force/power, there is absolutely no way I could choose to replace it!!
 
I am split on the issue. I don't think the crushing majority of people "choose" to believe their religion to begin with. I think they get simply taught it when young and never really question it.

The question might actually be much more interresting directed at *converted* people toward a theistic or similar religion. AKA: converted to hinduism, muslim, christianity, buddhism...

But even in such case, I think they are *convinced* by the argument, *NOT* that they choose to believe. ETA: interrestingly that is valid for (some ? many?) atheist too. They were convinced by arguments (lack of evidence, etc...) and did not "choose" suddenly to believe there is no gods.
 
Last edited:
Simple thought experiment should confirm that no, one cannot typically change their beliefs by sheer force of will. For instance, right now, attempt to make yourself believe that the current president of the United States is M. Night Shyamalan. Good luck with that.

This is why I'd say it's very important to note the distinction between believing something and knowing something. I don't believe in any god and I believe there are no gods, but I don't claim to know that there are no gods.
 
Simple thought experiment should confirm that no, one cannot typically change their beliefs by sheer force of will. For instance, right now, attempt to make yourself believe that the current president of the United States is M. Night Shyamalan. Good luck with that.

This is why I'd say it's very important to note the distinction between believing something and knowing something. I don't believe in any god and I believe there are no gods, but I don't claim to know that there are no gods.
Ummm...not a valid 'experiment' at all.

Try having a son accused of burglary, swearing to you that he's innocent. Witnesses say that they saw him; the police are sure it is him; you know he was in that area at the time of the burglary; but he swears it wasn't him, that it must have been someone who looked like him.

You can easily "choose" to believe that he's telling the truth, because that's what you want to be true...despite the fact that all the objective evidence indicates he is far more likely to be guilty.

Similarly, as I stated above, I know many people who "choose" to believe that they will see their loved ones in Heaven, despite the fact they'll admit there's no evidence for this, and they could be wrong...simply because it is a far more pleasant and comforting belief for them.
 
Emotions that make us feel warm inside often have no empirical basis, e.g. I am good looking, but it helps get us through the day.
 
Ummm...not a valid 'experiment' at all.

Try having a son accused of burglary, swearing to you that he's innocent. Witnesses say that they saw him; the police are sure it is him; you know he was in that area at the time of the burglary; but he swears it wasn't him, that it must have been someone who looked like him.

You can easily "choose" to believe that he's telling the truth, because that's what you want to be true...despite the fact that all the objective evidence indicates he is far more likely to be guilty.

Just because sometimes people's beliefs on an issue are not informed by evidence and rational inquiry does not mean that people choose what to believe. In the case of a loved one being accused of something with strong evidence, maybe you'd go with the evidence and believe that they did it, or maybe your attachment to the individual would cause you to believe that they are innocent when normally you wouldn't, but either way, there is no conscious choice effecting the belief.

Trust me, if I could just choose to ignore the effect of delusions, gut feelings, and emotional attachments and "easily choose" to believe only what the objective evidence indicates, I would do so all the time. But alas, I cannot.
 
Yes, you can choose to believe whatever you want. Just decide what you want to believe, then choose to expose yourself only to the information that seems to confirm that belief and choose to ignore all the information that contradicts it. Sooner or later you will believe in that thing.
 
Yes, you can choose to believe whatever you want. Just decide what you want to believe, then choose to expose yourself only to the information that seems to confirm that belief and choose to ignore all the information that contradicts it. Sooner or later you will believe in that thing.

I am just about 100% sure this is what every successful celebrity says about how how they achieved their fame.
 
If the evidence points in a particular way then I have to believe that.

What about your beliefs about evidence? e.g. the forms of evidence to accept or reject... amount of weight to give to.. priorities etc ?

You cannot point to evidence about evidence as a basis for your beliefs about evidence, as that's circular, self-defeating, and bypasses the belief issue.

In the end then, all belief systems that describe themselves as evidence-based are ultimately based on belief (though faith might be a better descriptor).
 
Lack of information can be a powerful persuasive tool. In the child example, due to the child's lack of understanding on the entirety of all the data, convincing them is easier, but they still choose to be convinced. They may be oblivious to any other choices yet its still a choice.

I joined this forum with a similar thought. I was wondering if one could be a serious critical thinker and still believe in supernatural events. I see very smart people who still have religious views or believe in supernatural events. Some even know the reasoning to debunk the issues yet still stand by their beliefs because they gain other aspects of life from those beliefs. They choose to do so.
 
I believe I could, given enough time and sufficient motivation, to self-suggest myself into believing almost anything.

I don't have proof that it would work, of course - but I didn't believe I could do it five years ago.
 
In the absence of evidence you can choose to believe whatever you want. However, all rational beliefs are at least logically consistent.
 
I'm not entirely sure how I form beliefs. But it doesn't seem to be the same method by which I choose what to eat or what to wear. In those cases, I can see options but no overwhelming reason to pick one or the other. Well, that's the day to day choosing.

I'm a bloke and I don't wear dresses. Is that a choice? I don't think so. It's just the way I was raised. Could I choose to wear a dress? I don't see anything particularly wrong with it. But, nevertheless, I would be uncomfortable making such a choice. I'd say that's because I believe dresses are for women.

What does this mean about other beliefs I may have? No doubt others of my beliefs are just as irrational. But I wouldn't call them choices merely because they aren't reached through 100% logic. To do that would imply that I have total control of myself. I don't. In fact, if I could choose I would choose to remove the irrational beliefs and replace them with more logical ones.
 
What if one were to choose to believe that belief could not be chosen? Could they ever go back?
 
I choose to believe in evidence based science. I could not however choose to believe in the biblical account of creation or n many of the miracles in the bible and other holy books.
 
I initially chose to believe the bible is not the word of a god.
Adding the koran to that list takes little more effort.
 
...
(Naturally to answer the poll in the affirmative, atheists would have to first choose to believe in God. The question is probably not applicable to those who are already Muslims)
.
Atheism is a choice, usually based on exposure to religions.
Which would mean a change from the position that one's holy book was the word of god, to the negation of the idea of god itself.
Not easy in christianity, and can be fatal in islam.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom