Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Which other field of human knowledge would you still be quoting stuff from someone over 300 years dead? (Apart from history)
Mathematics, mostly, and a few related disciplines.
The Lebombo and Ishango bones suggest a concept of number developed in Africa some 20 to 40 thousand years ago.

When we use zero as a digit, we quote Indians from over a thousand years ago. The number zero is seen earlier in Mayan, Chinese, and Babylonian arithmetic. The Greeks were late adopters, having harbored a cultural prejudice against zero and negative numbers.

The Chinese accepted and worked with negative numbers over 2000 years ago. Indian and Islamic mathematicians have been using negative numbers for about a thousand years. In Europe, Fibonacci found a restricted use for negative numbers (to represent debts), and Euler's formula (using the "imaginary" square root of -1) was published in 1748, but many European mathematicians expressed skepticism concerning negative numbers until the mid-19th century.

When we write down the Pythagorean theorem, we quote Babylonian mathematics from many centuries before Pythagoras was born.

Our clocks and compasses quote the Babylonians' base-60 number system from over 3500 years ago. Babylonian teachers assigned mathematical homework, still preserved in clay.

Babylonians used the trapezoidal rule to perform numerical integrations. Fifteen centuries later, Europeans began to do the same.

Recognizably modern mathematics began circa 300 BCE with Euclid's Elements. Middle school geometry quotes Euclid's five axioms, and we refer to Euclid whenever we mention Euclidean or non-Euclidean geometry.

We still quote mathematical contributions by a few other Greeks, e.g. Archimedes, Apollonius, Eratosthenes, Hipparchus, Menelaus, Ptolemy, Diophantus, and Pappus.

Hypatia of Alexandria was one of the first women known to have made significant contributions to mathematics; she was executed in 415 CE by a gang of Christians who celebrated Lent by stripping her naked, cutting out her eyes, slicing her into pieces, and setting the pieces on fire. That murder pretty much put an end to the development of Greek mathematics.

We don't know a whole lot about early mathematics in China, because a Chinese emperor ordered the burning of subversive texts in 213 BCE. When we approximate the value of pi by 3.1416, we are quoting the Chinese mathematician Liu Hui; his successor Zu Chongzhi calculated that the value of pi lies between 3.1415926 and 3.1415927; it took Western mathematicians another 800 years to improve upon that approximation.

Whenever we mention words such as algebra and algorithm, we are quoting from the title of an important book by the Persian mathematician Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi, published circa 820 CE.

And so on. Not only do we continue to quote mathematics from many centuries ago, the mathematics we quote was developed in quite a variety of different cultures.
 
Mathematics, mostly, and a few related disciplines.
The Lebombo and Ishango bones suggest a concept of number developed in Africa some 20 to 40 thousand years ago.

When we use zero as a digit, we quote Indians from over a thousand years ago. The number zero is seen earlier in Mayan, Chinese, and Babylonian arithmetic. The Greeks were late adopters, having harbored a cultural prejudice against zero and negative numbers.

The Chinese accepted and worked with negative numbers over 2000 years ago. Indian and Islamic mathematicians have been using negative numbers for about a thousand years. In Europe, Fibonacci found a restricted use for negative numbers (to represent debts), and Euler's formula (using the "imaginary" square root of -1) was published in 1748, but many European mathematicians expressed skepticism concerning negative numbers until the mid-19th century.

When we write down the Pythagorean theorem, we quote Babylonian mathematics from many centuries before Pythagoras was born.

Our clocks and compasses quote the Babylonians' base-60 number system from over 3500 years ago. Babylonian teachers assigned mathematical homework, still preserved in clay.

Babylonians used the trapezoidal rule to perform numerical integrations. Fifteen centuries later, Europeans began to do the same.

Recognizably modern mathematics began circa 300 BCE with Euclid's Elements. Middle school geometry quotes Euclid's five axioms, and we refer to Euclid whenever we mention Euclidean or non-Euclidean geometry.

We still quote mathematical contributions by a few other Greeks, e.g. Archimedes, Apollonius, Eratosthenes, Hipparchus, Menelaus, Ptolemy, Diophantus, and Pappus.

Hypatia of Alexandria was one of the first women known to have made significant contributions to mathematics; she was executed in 415 CE by a gang of Christians who celebrated Lent by stripping her naked, cutting out her eyes, slicing her into pieces, and setting the pieces on fire. That murder pretty much put an end to the development of Greek mathematics.

We don't know a whole lot about early mathematics in China, because a Chinese emperor ordered the burning of subversive texts in 213 BCE. When we approximate the value of pi by 3.1416, we are quoting the Chinese mathematician Liu Hui; his successor Zu Chongzhi calculated that the value of pi lies between 3.1415926 and 3.1415927; it took Western mathematicians another 800 years to improve upon that approximation.

Whenever we mention words such as algebra and algorithm, we are quoting from the title of an important book by the Persian mathematician Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi, published circa 820 CE.

And so on. Not only do we continue to quote mathematics from many centuries ago, the mathematics we quote was developed in quite a variety of different cultures.

As mathematics is clearly a result of immigration, of ideas if not of actual dark-skinned mathematicians, I doubt he will be quoting any of it.
Not only that, it's multicultural! :eek:
the mathematics we quote was developed in quite a variety of different cultures.

Away with your shared ideas of algebra! Fie upon your polyglot geometry! Preserve the purity of our monocultural ignorance!
 


Ah, no wonder. Like the article says:

...the Mods choice of weapon -razor blades sewn onto their jacket collars and lapels (...) wielded deck chairs and any other furniture from the beach front ...


I'm, like, totally pro-everything-Mod, you know that, right?



eta: That part of it was curious, the bank holiday thing. One pictures neatly brushed fresh-faced banker types, working diligently all the week at the Teller counter or loan desk or whatever; and then, come Friday evening, suddenly letting loose with the rioting (rather than simply clubbing); and then, when the weekend's over, carefully wiping away the shards of glass and the blood, and returning back quietly to their desk jobs on Monday morning again. Very Fight Club.
 
Last edited:
He's already been shown the evidence that this is not true. He even claimed to have been aware of it before that- and yet he still rejects the evidence, and bases his conclusions on things he knows aren't true.
Less Burke, more berk, really.


ha ha ha, If that isn't nom-worthy, for pith us simple-minded souls can LOL over, then I don't know what is!



(Just the wordplay thing, and the context of it, and that's all there is to it, shuttit, if you're reading this. I've exchanged a good few posts with you, and you mustn't think we're all ganging up to call you names. Your racism is deplorable, as is your hiding behind that weird facade of taken-to-laughable-extremes pragmatism; but you're way better read than I am, for instance, at least when it comes to this sort of thing. I don't literally think you're a "berk", but tell me this phrasing wan't utterly hilarious.)
 
Sure, perhaps. The recent posts have been mentioning multiculturalism. Thinking about it, I'm puzzled what some people on this thread must think multiculturalism means since supposedly America has one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American. Anyway, one of the issues with multiculturalism is that it encourages immigrants to retain their different cultures, hence preserving race as a good proxy for culture.

When your children moved out into the world, if they moved amongst the great mass of the population, they would have found black people who are biased in favour of other black people, latino people who are biased in favour of other latino people and so on. About the only people who aren't like this are white progressives who are biased against white people. They would also discover that out in the world race does carry information about people, for example due to affirmative action, if they went to university they would likely see asians at the top of the class, while black students struggle at the bottom. If they were mugged, it is disproportionately likely to be by a black man. It's possible to shield children from these things, but people aren't racist for no reason.

What a disgusting and shameful comment.
 
I have not read every post here. But one of the things our racists-who-deny-being-racists keep ignoring is the role poverty plays in violence.

Those who are poor tend to be stuck in a violent loop. We have seen here where at least one person claims that violence per capita proves their case. But that requires them to ignore economic status of the groups they claim not to be racists about.

What happens when you add in economic class to violence data as a control rather than ignore it?

Hint:

Poor people both commit and suffer from violence disproportionality.
Some ethnic minorities are more likely to be poor than others.
When the economic class changes, so does the incidence rates of violence.

https://www.apa.org/pi/ses/resources/publications/factsheet-violence.pdf
 
I have not read every post here. But one of the things our racists-who-deny-being-racists keep ignoring is the role poverty plays in violence.

Those who are poor tend to be stuck in a violent loop. We have seen here where at least one person claims that violence per capita proves their case. But that requires them to ignore economic status of the groups they claim not to be racists about.

What happens when you add in economic class to violence data as a control rather than ignore it?

Hint:

Poor people both commit and suffer from violence disproportionality.
Some ethnic minorities are more likely to be poor than others.
When the economic class changes, so does the incidence rates of violence.

https://www.apa.org/pi/ses/resources/publications/factsheet-violence.pdf

Right, they keep doubling down on racial/ethnic/cultural stereotypes as if they're inherent traits of the people they're stereotyping, if true or relevant in the first place.

At least one poster is accepting this but the excuse is cultural traits are difficult to change, so segregation is still worth it.
 
ha ha ha, If that isn't nom-worthy, for pith us simple-minded souls can LOL over, then I don't know what is!



(Just the wordplay thing, and the context of it, and that's all there is to it, shuttit, if you're reading this. I've exchanged a good few posts with you, and you mustn't think we're all ganging up to call you names. Your racism is deplorable, as is your hiding behind that weird facade of taken-to-laughable-extremes pragmatism; but you're way better read than I am, for instance, at least when it comes to this sort of thing. I don't literally think you're a "berk", but tell me this phrasing wan't utterly hilarious.)
Look, if there were one or two liberal progressives on a militant evangelical forum, you might well get mobbed and be constantly getting your posts flagged. Every community has ideas it's prepared to treat sceptically, and ideas that it isn't if the ideas are meaningful and not totally secure. There are just some things that can't be discussed without implying that the other side is wicked, or at least that the implications of their ideas are wicked. It's a pity, but I think that is really true in pretty much any age.

I hope this doesn't get me another warning, but you mentioned Burke again, and I've seen other posters mention him as well. I agree that, a case may be made that his ideas were influenced by his background and so on. The thing is that that is true of everybody's ideas. Every age has it's unstated assumptions, unquestionable ideas, and falsehoods that it is beneficial to believe. One of the reasons for reading such things is not because thinkers in the past are some source of infinite wisdom that we have fallen from, but because they wrote with a different set of assumptions that, through its foreignness to us, is much more obvious.

If we just look at the world from the perspective of the prejudices of the moment, we see it from one angle. If we look at it through different eyes with different prejudices, I think we get a clearer idea. Books from that era are interesting as well, because that is when many of the ideas that are now unquestioned assumptions were thought and debated in a way they largely aren't today. Also, by going back and reading the arguments of people who disagreed with aspects of liberalism, you are avoiding the "history is written by the winners" issue.
 
Last edited:
Your point was valid on its own, but I just want to drive the point home :9.
It's fascinating, but unsurprising, how many racists and white supremacists are grossly ignorant of the actual history beyond their puerile fantasies.
 
It's fascinating, but unsurprising, how many racists and white supremacists are grossly ignorant of the actual history beyond their puerile fantasies.
Most people are ignorant about actual history.
 
Yeah, it had nothing to do with frontier generals proclaiming themselves emperor, marching their legions towards the home province, leaving the frontier weak, exhausting the manpower reserves (both sides casualties being Roman troops and allied auxiliaries), and the winner purging the ranks even further.

Then, look at the entire Stillicho/Aleric arc. Pure and unrepentant ethnic bigotry lead to one fantastic blunder after another. Really, it was their steadfast refusal to allow immigration into vast uninhabited portions of the empire that fed both manpower shortages and a plethora of enemies desperate to settle, willing to assist in defence for doing so. It was a policy that worked remarkably well when tried and resulted in very a "romanized" people within a couple of generations.

Look at Quintilius "give me back my legions" Varus.

TL;DR: tell me you don't know Roman history without telling me you don't know Roman history...

One of the powerful themes of Livy's history of Rome is how Rome grew in power and status by absorbing other non-Roman people and thereby Romanizing them.

In Livy's history it starts right from the beginning with the absorption of some Sabine groups and continues for century after century with progressively more and more people's become "Romans". (Also absorbing all sorts foreign religious cults etc.) (In the Roman tradition the second King of Rome Numa was actually a Sabine noble.)

This process of the continual extention of Roman citizenship to other groups continued also for century after century. One of the most important ways Roman citizenship was extended was when Roman Citizens freed their slaves. Guess what! The freed slaves became Roman citizens!!

The decline of the Empire had a myriad of causes. But sadly by then, it appears, that the Roman ruling class had almost completely lost it's former capacity to absorb outsiders into itself. The disasterous antagonism between the Imperial government and it's "Barbarian" auxiliaries played a powerful role in the collapse of the Western Empire. Such things has for example the massacre of the families of the "Barbarian" auxilaries in the Western Empire after the overthrow and murder of half Vandal Roman General Stilicho along with his family helped to speed the fall. Stilicho had expended a huge effort to save the Western Empire. His reward was to be murdered and the "Barbarian" Roman troops had their families slaughtered.

No surprise they joined the Gothic Leader Alaric who in 410 sacked Rome. (The sack of 410 C.E. was actually a pretty "civilized" sack as sacking of cities go.) The Vandal sack of 455 C.E. was much more through and brutal.
 
One of the powerful themes of Livy's history of Rome is how Rome grew in power and status by absorbing other non-Roman people and thereby Romanizing them.
In Livy's history it starts right from the beginning with the absorption of some Sabine groups and continues for century after century with progressively more and more people's become "Romans". (Also absorbing all sorts foreign religious cults etc.) (In the Roman tradition the second King of Rome Numa was actually a Sabine noble.)

This process of the continual extention of Roman citizenship to other groups continued also for century after century. One of the most important ways Roman citizenship was extended was when Roman Citizens freed their slaves. Guess what! The freed slaves became Roman citizens!!

The decline of the Empire had a myriad of causes. But sadly by then, it appears, that the Roman ruling class had almost completely lost it's former capacity to absorb outsiders into itself. The disasterous antagonism between the Imperial government and it's "Barbarian" auxiliaries played a powerful role in the collapse of the Western Empire. Such things has for example the massacre of the families of the "Barbarian" auxilaries in the Western Empire after the overthrow and murder of half Vandal Roman General Stilicho along with his family helped to speed the fall. Stilicho had expended a huge effort to save the Western Empire. His reward was to be murdered and the "Barbarian" Roman troops had their families slaughtered.

No surprise they joined the Gothic Leader Alaric who in 410 sacked Rome. (The sack of 410 C.E. was actually a pretty "civilized" sack as sacking of cities go.) The Vandal sack of 455 C.E. was much more through and brutal.
Exactly.

However, those who are will do well not using hi,story in their argumentation.
Hans
Very true.
 
However, those who are will do well not using hi,story in their argumentation.
Hans
I think it is more typical that the issue is with different readings of history, rather than that one side knows their history while the other wallows in ignorance.
 
*General assertion that history shows x, devoid of any examples*

*specific assertion that various examples of history show y, referred to by time, place, and or significant participants and referring to primary sources drawn from*

"Different readings"

Ignorant doesn't refer to not knowing or being merely mistaken, it refers to willful resistance to facts and evidence. An ignorant person ignores these things.

Bald hypocrisy, on the other hand, refers to...

But I digress.
 
Last edited:
I think it is more typical that the issue is with different readings of history, rather than that one side knows their history while the other wallows in ignorance.

No. While history is not an exact science because sources are not equally reliable, it is quite possible to establish a scale of credibility in history. Therefore, it is very easy to tell ignorance from interpretation. And, let me remind you, it was YOU who said most people were ignorant of history.

Hans
 
No. While history is not an exact science because sources are not equally reliable, it is quite possible to establish a scale of credibility in history. Therefore, it is very easy to tell ignorance from interpretation. And, let me remind you, it was YOU who said most people were ignorant of history.

Hans
Most people are ignorant of history. The kind of disagreements we have on politics threads are rarely driven by ignorance of history. Sure, some things can be established pretty well, like when did such and such battle take place. That isn't what the disagreements are generally about though. Disagreements are more typically about things like what the impacts or causes of a historical event were. Such questions are too complicated to not be a question of interpretation. These are questions professional historians manage to disagree on.
 
Most people are ignorant of history. The kind of disagreements we have on politics threads are rarely driven by ignorance of history. Sure, some things can be established pretty well, like when did such and such battle take place. That isn't what the disagreements are generally about though. Disagreements are more typically about things like what the impacts or causes of a historical event were. Such questions are too complicated to not be a question of interpretation. These are questions professional historians manage to disagree on.

How to say nothing using 7 sentences.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom