Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

I might find the results of it vile sometimes. Fixating on the thing itself seems like puritanism to me.

Please be specific. What vile results have you seen, and what good effects have you seen?
I think one of the problems people here are finding with your position is your continued refusal to say why you think racism is in any way, wholly or partly, a good thing, or at least a neutral thing.

Depends what the results of it were. The thing itself doesn't bother me one way or the other.

You are contradicting yourself here. You said earlier that you didn't believe in imposing a universal morality on everyone. Having the state dictate who can marry whom, based solely on racial grounds, is imposing universal morality- or, to be more precise, universal immorality.

No. I absolutely don't. I had rather thought that was the majority view of the forum. People keep banging on about "democracy" and the "popular vote".

Yes, you absolutely do. You have stated several times that the majority of the public are opposed to immigration. That was not a statement about this forum, but about the whole of the UK.

I'm not value free, but the world is a fallen place and man is a fallen animal.

More vague waffling. What exactly do you mean by this?

Do your values make the world better in a way that doesn't circularly refer back to your values?

Yes. Inclusivity and diversity encourage creativity and a wider range of inputs in businesses, so our values have direct economic benefits.
Ending racial pogroms stops killing, another benefit I would have thought was immediately obvious.
Being on the receiving end of racial prejudice has direct effects on mental health: curbing that would lead to better mental health.
So, reducing violence, improving mental health and making us richer are just some of the benefits of combatting racism.
Now, how about you list the opposite: what specific benefits can you give for racism?


People complain about Christian morality being forced on people. You want to force your morality on people. I don't see much difference. It's just two different groups of people who are certain they know the right way to live. Again, ultimately I doubt your ability to persuade everybody to follow your morality.... so what then?

Not true. What people here are saying is that it is wrong to impose race-based morality on people. People should have the right to marry whom they choose, regardless of the colour of their skins. The stance of the majority on this forum is the opposite of what you claim. You are the one advocating- by silence and obfuscation, as much as anything else- the imposition of morality on a populace.

Like I say. Mixed race marriage doesn't bother me. If in the distant future we get to the point where it becomes an issue, I'll probably have more of an opinion. I'm sure there are plenty of things religious people think are very important theoretical issues, but because your world view is different you wouldn't feel strongly about them.

And yet you are still unwilling or unable to say what those negative results could be.

One big difference i suspect is between us is that I see a lot more problems as coming from the implementation of liberal goods. I see a much more mixed and equivocal story. That just makes me more sceptical about jumping in with both feet without looking first.

No, you are attempting to conceal your bigotry beneath a veil of circumspection and pragmatism. Your lack of concrete examples of the kind of negative effects possible from mixed-race marriages is evidence of this. You're basically just going 'Euw! Icky!' and dressing it up as a rational and informed choice. Word to the wise: you aren't fooling anybody with this.

Why would one defend it on scientific grounds? What has that got to do with it? I'm curious.

I think this was a reference to pseudo-scientific theories of racial superiority, such as those employed by the Nazis.
I'd like to add that you refuse to condemn racism on ideological grounds, or on grounds of morality, or from a human rights point of view, or any historical, economic or cultural grounds. You have ruled all these out. Now you're saying there's no scientific rebuttal to racism either. I can't help but conclude that you find nothing objectionable about racism, for any reason. And you know what that makes you.
 
Pardon me, but I cannot help seeing in your appeal to case-by-case pragmatism a dodge.

What are your views on banning marriages between people of different colors of hair, or eyes? Of different ranges of height or weight? Different religions? Or, hell, banning marriages altogether, then?
The same.

The question of banning mixed marriages is one that makes any sense at all, even conditionally, only to a decidedly racist mindset.
Or a pragmatist.
 
To be frank, I think you're only using pragmatism as a fig leaf. Throwing in our willingness or otherwise to kill others as a distraction.
Not at all. I think if somebody thinks it is a price worth paying to see a million dead in order for their world view to triumph, having them pearl clutch over something like interracial marriage seems unbalanced to me.

What is YOUR view on racism, and on mixed marriages, independent of what others around you might want? It might help if you'd squarely answer those questions, that people keep asking, and that you keep avoiding.
I'm not avoiding it. You are a Platonist, asking questions about ideal forms. I don't believe in ideal forms, so I can't answer. You can't conceive of somebody not believing in ideal forms, so you keep asking.

You do say you'd view the results to arrive at your opinion case-by-case, but that's clearly a dodge. (Whether it's us you're dodging, or your own self, that I don't know!) Because the same might be said about ANY marriage. Surely you wouldn't point to an utterly agnostic case-by-case pragmatism if it came to a question of, I don't know, banning marriages altogether? That sounds crazy, I know; but without the blinkers of racism, even considering banning mixed marriages sounds no less crazy.
Of course I hold the same view of marriage in general.. It's the consequences I care about, not the thing itself. Marriage in general is going to be more important I would think just in terms of weight of numbers, its impact on society and so on, but the general philosophy is unchanged.
 
Of course you don't know all the consequences of any law, or much of anything else, really. But you know some of them, and in some cases (such as the racist laws I have been talking about) it's quite true that those framing them did not ignore the social impacts, incentives and other consequences of the law. Race laws were meant to have far reaching social consequences and incentives and disincentives.

We don't want to limit ourselves to the results of a law that are 100 percent guaranteed, but if the results that are 100 percent guaranteed are bad enough, the good that might eventually result might best be ignored.
Maybe, maybe not. It's hard to say in the abstract.

What law can possibly be contemplated if one cannot consider its immediate, intended effect first? Even if a cloud has a silver lining, it's cold comfort if it floods you and you drown. Religious nincompoops comfort the bereaved when a child dies, saying it goes to heaven and is folded up in God's embrace, but that grand possibility does not make it all right to murder children. I would contend that something that is wrong at its very foundation is wrong to do, even if something good might come of it at the end.
You dismiss Christians because they appeal to religious dogma, and then you appeal to your secular moral dogma. I know you have these revealed truths that you believe in. Telling me them over and over again does no more good than if a Christian were to tell you over and over again that God hates gays. In the words of The Dude "that's just like your opinion man".

I think your abortion ban analogy has a flaw here, for that very reason, though not for that reason alone. If race laws are considered in their entirety, in terms of the reasonably likely effects on society, on what I think most decent human beings would consider virtue, stability and order in the long term, justice, even godliness if you're inclined to think along those lines, they're bad.
Well, if you exclude all the people who disagree with you from consideration, then I'm sure most people agree with you. If an evangelical restricted opinion on the morality of abortion to only "good people", I'm sure opinion would be quite heavily skewed pro-life. You don't have a monopoly on the definition of "bad".

Again though, you are making a universalist judgement about a question that, when it has to be answered, is concrete rather than abstract. It goes from being the kind of question Socrates might have answered about "what is the nature of marriage" to one of "what should the law be in this society at this time to deal with this particular set of issues". Those are different questions.

History does them no favors either. You have to have a pretty florid imagination, and stretch things in a very arguable way, I think, to make racism come out well in the long run.
The long run hasn't happened yet. Is there a way that racism plays out "in the long run". It plays out the same in all places, and for all peoples? This sounds like the idea they had in the old Star Trek where all civilisations went through a Roman phase and a Nazi phase, so they could raid the props department. The modern view of racism has really only been around for, at most, 80 years.

But if individual racist laws are taken alone, as just what they are, without those consequences, they are still bad.
I don't take them on their own. Also, you are again relying on your moral dogma. It's not a self evident truth.

Of course I know you look at things differently, have a different set of values, and probably would run a different algorithm to come up with the social consequences you like, and and likely manage, while surmising unknown, unknowable, speculative benefits, to accuse others of excessive abstraction.

I still contend that if racism is required to make a society great, it is a racist society and its greatness oxymoronic, no matter whether there's a chance the remaining majority will crack the secrets of time, speak sonnets in their sleep, do ten good deeds before breakfast, and piss rainbows.
Then the greatness of all societies in history have been oxymoronic because they don't align with a morality that was invented in one bit of the world after WW2, and isn't even universally held there. This is a very parochial world view.
 
I'm not avoiding it. You are a Platonist, asking questions about ideal forms. I don't believe in ideal forms, so I can't answer. You can't conceive of somebody not believing in ideal forms, so you keep asking.

You are avoiding it. Racism is not a Platonic ideal, it is a real-world view, with real-world consequences. Moreover, it is a concept created by our own minds, not a copy of some universal abstraction.
Your constant insistence that you are too smart to have to answer is just an egotistical dodge. It doesn't make you look smart: it makes you look slippery.
 
You are avoiding it. Racism is not a Platonic ideal, it is a real-world view, with real-world consequences.
Sure, sure... but that it is good or bad in an abstract sense is a Platonic way of looking at the world.

Moreover, it is a concept created by our own minds, not a copy of some universal abstraction.
Right, the Platonic view, I think, would be that you are talking about something when you are talking about "racism" in the abstract and saying it has properties like being "bad". That something is the ideal form. Assert properties about this abstract idea all you want. I don't view the world in this French enlightenment way. I am more of a particularist.

Your constant insistence that you are too smart to have to answer is just an egotistical dodge. It doesn't make you look smart: it makes you look slippery.
It isn't a question of being smarter, it's a question of coming at it from a different perspective. I've spent several years reading quite hard to come to my current view and my ideas may change again. I think it is a bit more presumptuous for you to think that your ideas and prejudices on this issue, which are specific to particular political tribes in a particular part of the world at a particular time and don't go back very many decades, and in their current scope don't go back many years, are some timeless truths, carrying universal significance that remained undiscovered until recently. I admire your confidence.
 
Last edited:
...Like I say. Mixed race marriage doesn't bother me. If in the distant future we get to the point where it becomes an issue, I'll probably have more of an opinion.

It's definitely all well and good that mixed race marriage does not bother you at the moment. But I do have to ask: what has to happen in the future for it to become an issue in your mind?
 
It's definitely all well and good that mixed race marriage does not bother you at the moment. But I do have to ask: what has to happen in the future for it to become an issue in your mind?
That really depends on why it has become an issue in my mind. Is a race war going on? You'll need to give me the circumstances.
 
That really depends on why it has become an issue in my mind. Is a race war going on? You'll need to give me the circumstances.

Unfortunately, I can't give you any hypotheticals here, because I personally can't imagine any circumstances in which interracial marriage would justifiably be banned. Even your "race war" suggestion seems a stretch, although it does make me curious: in the exceedingly unlikely prospect that a true "race war" actually happened (as opposed to the term being used as hyperbole), why should a ban on interracial marriage be considered?
 
Unfortunately, I can't give you any hypotheticals here, because I personally can't imagine any circumstances in which interracial marriage would justifiably be banned. Even your "race war" suggestion seems a stretch, although it does make me curious: in the exceedingly unlikely prospect that a true "race war" actually happened (as opposed to the term being used as hyperbole), why should a ban on interracial marriage be considered?
I'm not getting dragged into fanaticising about the details of a future race war. I answered your question.... I'm not going further down this rabbit hole.
 
snipped to avoid rehash....

Then the greatness of all societies in history have been oxymoronic because they don't align with a morality that was invented in one bit of the world after WW2, and isn't even universally held there. This is a very parochial world view.

I see (but you apparently don't) a difference between things that are present in a society and those that are essential to it. My issue, as always, continues to be not whether a good society can contain bad things, but whether, in envisioning a good society, you would support the assertion that a bad thing is required.
 
The same.


Or a pragmatist.


Not at all. I think if somebody thinks it is a price worth paying to see a million dead in order for their world view to triumph, having them pearl clutch over something like interracial marriage seems unbalanced to me.


I'm not avoiding it. You are a Platonist, asking questions about ideal forms. I don't believe in ideal forms, so I can't answer. You can't conceive of somebody not believing in ideal forms, so you keep asking.


Of course I hold the same view of marriage in general.. It's the consequences I care about, not the thing itself. Marriage in general is going to be more important I would think just in terms of weight of numbers, its impact on society and so on, but the general philosophy is unchanged.


Fair enough, shuttit. I haven't read every one of your posts in this thread, and the other one, only some; and I don't know if what you say to me here conforms with all of that. But I'm going to limit myself to what you've said to me now, and basis that, fair enough: It does seem that you are indifferent to whether or not every racist, basis some weird (and vile) majority decision, ended up getting castrated and put to slave labor, or whether all marriages between blue-eyed folks and brown-eyed folks were forbidden, as well as racially mixed marriages. You would, basis what you say here, appear to be a true pragmatist, rather than a racist, fair enough.

Agreed, I'm more of an idealist than that. I find racism abhorrent, even in a scenario where some subset of people, even a majority of people, ended up happier; just like I find colonialism abhorrent, and slavery as well. I do think these are evil, or, to use your old-fashioned term, "wicked"; and, while like you I wouldn't be personally instrumental in killing people in order to maintain my kind of world, but neither would I support these on grounds of pragmatism, and nor would I personally have any part of these, even at some cost to myself. We continue to differ in our worldview, and in our conception of right and wrong, but that difference is in a different direction than I'd imagined.



A final question, if may, shuttit, to test the actual limits of your pragmatism: You've already expressed your conditional acquiescence with racism on pragmatic grounds, but are you actually prepared even to agree even to Nazi excesses, on pragmatic grounds, assuming that that might have led to greater happiness, however defined, of a large number of people on the correct side of whatever line they chose draw? Maybe even a society based on pedophilia? What I'm trying to get at is, is there any point where your pragmatism puts up its hands and says "Thus far and no further", or are such limits meaningless in your scheme of things?



eta: Even if the above is true, but I still continue to think of your pragmatism as a dodge, although maybe at a different level. Because I'm guessing you do participate in the everyday world, and don't live only in abstractions. I'm guessing you do vote, you do support some causes and refrain from supporting others, in some manner. So that all/many/some of these questions that we're asking, even granting your "true pragmatism", I'm sure you translate into answers that say "This is right", and "This is wrong", even if on purely pragmatic grounds entirely shorn of idealism. Therefore, the logical next level to this discussion would be to ask you what your pragmatism leads you to believe, in terms of right and wrong, on specific issues: Issues like rounding up racists and castrating them one and all, issues like slavery, issues like racism, issues like ethnic cleansing, et cetera. Phrased in those terms, you will not be able to dodge away from answering unequivocally, not without exposing that dodge. But I will refrain from taking this discussion down that route, beyond merely noting this here, and stop at simply finding out, if you'll respond to the above, whether there are any limits at all to what your true pragmatism is prepared to put up with.
 
Last edited:
I see (but you apparently don't) a difference between things that are present in a society and those that are essential to it. My issue, as always, continues to be not whether a good society can contain bad things, but whether, in envisioning a good society, you would support the assertion that a bad thing is required.
Envisioning a good society is exactly what I am opposed to doing because inevitably you are envisioning it from a position of great ignorance about what is and isn't possible and what the tradeoffs and actual consequences of your decisions are. Many of the things you fondly imagine might be features of this "good" society might have horrific consequences when put in to practice in combination with the other features of your "good" society. It all works out happily when you imagine it, of course.... Such a good society is definitionally utopian.
 
I'm not getting dragged into fanaticising about the details of a future race war. I answered your question.... I'm not going further down this rabbit hole.

Um, no you didn't, because "it depends" isn't any sort of an answer. And I didn't ask you to fantasize (or "fanaticize"?) about a future race war; I just asked why you'd consider that justification for banning interracial marriage. Which is fine, you don't owe me or anyone else an answer really. Just don't falsely claim afterwards that you answered the question.
 
Um, no you didn't, because "it depends" isn't any sort of an answer. And I didn't ask you to fantasize (or "fanaticize"?) about a future race war; I just asked why you'd consider that justification for banning interracial marriage. Which is fine, you don't owe me or anyone else an answer really. Just don't falsely claim afterwards that you answered the question.
If it was practically necessary or useful in the moment. That is the answer. I think you are looking for some moral justification about mixed race babies being subhuman or something. That is the answer. If you can't conceive of it ever, even theoretically, seeming practically necessary then I think all that is going to happen is that I will be asked for more and more specific details about some dystopian society where it might seem like a practical thing to do.
 
If it was practically necessary or useful in the moment. That is the answer. I think you are looking for some moral justification about mixed race babies being subhuman or something. That is the answer. If you can't conceive of it ever, even theoretically, seeming practically necessary then I think all that is going to happen is that I will be asked for more and more specific details about some dystopian society where it might seem like a practical thing to do.

OK, I'll buy that. You are correct, I can't even imagine any circumstances under which a ban on interracial marriage would be "practically necessary or useful." Apparently you can, or at least allow for the possibility. You may consider it a lack of imagination on my part, a possibility I can't entirely exclude.

And yeah, if you do have some ideas about the circumstances under which you'd consider banning interracial marriage justified, I'd like to hear them, because it may help me better understand the motivations behind this whole thread, instead of just suspecting that deep down at the core, it's just another symptom of racism.

But maybe like me you can't imagine any such scenarios either, you're just allowing for the possibility that at some future epoch society may evolve in ways that we can't even comprehend, and under those unknowable conditions things that may seem incomprehensible to us today may be justifiably put onto the table.
 
Sure, sure... but that it is good or bad in an abstract sense is a Platonic way of looking at the world.

I have explained several real-world consequences of reducing racism. I asked you to detail some real-world benefits of increased racism: you have, yet again, avoided answering the question.
You seem undecided whether your acceptance of racism is because you reside an an ivory tower (hopefully, the off-white of ivory is acceptable to you, I know it's not pure white) in which real-world consequences are sublimated by 'Platonic ideals', and you are far too lofty to stoop to considering such things as the actual consequences of your actions, or whether you are arguing from a point of view of pure pragmatism, in which the only consequences worth considering are real-world ones.
It is also worth noting that your rejection of any form of morality is not a decision made in isolation. If you reject morality, then others will see you as at least amoral, and very possibly, immoral. Your claims to be able to advise on a society's policies and long-term strategies, then, are unlikely to be well-received, as those around you will conclude that your proposals are not guided by any sense of right or wrong, and thus may well not result in any benefit for anyone except you.
Ironically, this will lead to a form of racism, in that you will be discriminated against because of your antipathy to morality. You may want to live like that, as a pariah, in a lofty but lonely rejection of the mores of those around you, but I would find this scant compensation for such a bleak existence.

Right, the Platonic view, I think, would be that you are talking about something when you are talking about "racism" in the abstract and saying it has properties like being "bad". That something is the ideal form. Assert properties about this abstract idea all you want. I don't view the world in this French enlightenment way. I am more of a particularist.

Racism has real-world consequences, no matter how much you wish it doesn't.

It isn't a question of being smarter, it's a question of coming at it from a different perspective. I've spent several years reading quite hard to come to my current view and my ideas may change again. I think it is a bit more presumptuous for you to think that your ideas and prejudices on this issue, which are specific to particular political tribes in a particular part of the world at a particular time and don't go back very many decades, and in their current scope don't go back many years, are some timeless truths, carrying universal significance that remained undiscovered until recently. I admire your confidence.

Preaching down at the great unwashed about how special you are still doesn't make you correct. To do that, you need to provide some evidence that racism has benefits. You have still not done that. No amount of pontificating will make any difference. People here have, for the most part, been very patient with you. Eventually, though, this will degenerate into pointing and laughing, if you cannot present some actual details or specifics. Up to you, your royal sageness. :rolleyes:
 
As I can't be bothered trawling back through the pages of this thread, and as I also have no desire to deal with yet more waffle about Burke, Plato &c, perhaps someone could do me the favour of answering this:

Have we had a clear definition yet of what European culture is, and also what connection there is between this culture and skin colour?

For example, if part of that culture is Christianity, well, there are now far more brown-skinned Christians than white-skinned ones, so opposing immigration on those grounds is not a valid reason.
 
From Wiki, Culture of Europe:

There were a great number of perspectives which can be taken on the subject, it is impossible to form a single, all-embracing conception of European culture.[3] Nonetheless, there are core elements which are generally agreed upon as forming the cultural foundation of modern Europe.[4] One list of these elements given by K. Bochmann includes:[5]

  • A common cultural and spiritual heritage derived from Greco-Roman antiquity, Christianity, Judaism, the Renaissance, and its Humanism, the political thinking of the Enlightenment, and the French Revolution, and the developments of Modernity, including all types of socialism;[6][5]
  • A rich and dynamic material culture that has been extended to the other continents as the result of industrialization and colonialism during the "Great Divergence";[6]
  • A specific conception of the individual expressed by the existence of, and respect for, a legality that guarantees human rights and the liberty of the individual;[6]
  • A plurality of states with different political orders, which are feeding each other with new ideas;[6]
  • Respect for peoples, states, and nations outside Europe.[6]
Berting says that these points fit with "Europe's most positive realizations".[2] The concept of European culture is generally linked to the classical definition of the Western world. In this definition, Western culture is the set of literary, scientific, political, artistic, and philosophical principles which set it apart from other civilizations. Much of this set of traditions and knowledge is collected in the Western canon.[7] The term has come to apply to countries whose history has been strongly marked by European immigration or settlement during the 18th and 19th centuries, such as the Americas, and Australasia, and is not restricted to Europe.

The Nobel Prize laureate in Literature Thomas Stearns Eliot, in his 1948 book Notes Towards the Definition of Culture, credited the prominent Christian influence upon the European culture:[8] "It is in Christianity that our arts have developed; it is in Christianity that the laws of Europe have--until recently--been rooted."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom