Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The freedom of speech surely means one is free to be an a-hole if one chooses too. The fault here is not in the a-holes but in the perpetrators. We should never forget that or make allowances for people who feel free to kill someone for simply saying what they want to - whatever their motivation.

When did that happen?

There is plenty of fault to go around. I didn't spend my weekend drawing cartoons of Mohammed. I didn't get attacked by Muslim zealots. I think those two things are correlated.

There is no one worth cheering for here.
 
And we should consider not kissing venomous snakes too.

It's amazing to me that some might advocate stirring up trouble in the service of what? Some higher ideal? The thinking seems to be that if we just keep insulting zealots they'll stop being upset by it.

What's the point?

The point is to draw out their behavior in order to force fence-sitters to accept that they can't hide from it until the US is full of pockets like Europe has, and to get the Muslims to demonstrate through their actions how incompatible they are with our way of life.

Lots of people think we can go along to get along with them. Those people are incorrect. They need their comfort bubble popped and to see, with crystal clarity, the nature of the conflict and what will result from trying to ignore it.

Get them to show their true colors now while something can be done, instead of later when it's harder or impossible due to numbers/influence/becoming slowly accustomed to appeasement.

You may be thinking that we COULD get along with them if not for people who deliberately seek to provoke them. I believe you'd be very incorrect to think that, but even if you were right, too bad. We exist and we won't go along with integrating them. They have their own societies already and we don't want them in ours.

You should expect a LOT more noise and action from us in the decades to come.
 
Last edited:
The freedom of speech surely means one is free to be an a-hole if one chooses too. The fault here is not in the a-holes but in the perpetrators. We should never forget that or make allowances for people who feel free to kill someone for simply saying what they want to - whatever their motivation.

The ONLY reason for an event like this is to provoke the very reaction they got. Now they get to say "See- gotcha! Muslims = baaaad"

I'm sorry. I can't for the life of me feel one iota of sympathy for any of those people at that event.
 
I agree that it is useless to provoke these idiots.

But banning it means changing the US constitution.

There are countries that ban speech, and offending religious feelings.
Israel comes to mind. That place is on a knife's edge anyway. Why give some individuals the right to set the whole country on fire by burning a Koran in Zion Square?

Maybe diversity makes some practices impossible.

You don't have to ban anything. You also don't have to be surprised when incitement incites. And, if the consequences can be inferred, then there's a negligence element in play.

If I know a dog is likely to bite me and I taunt the dog, then where's my complaint when I get bit? I am left to complain that dogs bite. Well, duh.
 
I'm no lawyer, but i think this will be difficult to codify in law.
And unwelcome, I suspect.

I said nothing about law. I'm simply asking why we have to be jerks. We don't. This was 100% preventable, simply by not being a jerk. Feeding the trolls so to speak.
 
The ONLY reason for an event like this is to provoke the very reaction they got. Now they get to say "See- gotcha! Muslims = baaaad"

I'm sorry. I can't for the life of me feel one iota of sympathy for any of those people at that event.

Nah, I think rational people will draw the correct conclusion that certain Muslims aren't open to reason regarding their beliefs.
It's a tiny, very dangerous minority.
 
I said nothing about law. I'm simply asking why we have to be jerks. We don't. This was 100% preventable, simply by not being a jerk. Feeding the trolls so to speak.

If it had been prevented, the two individuals would still be alive.

So, why on earth would we wish it had been prevented?
 
The point is to draw out their behavior in order to force fence-sitters to accept that they can't hide from it until the US is full of pockets like Europe has, and to get the Muslims to demonstrate through their actions how incompatible they are with our way of life.

My "way of life" does not include calling blacks the n-word, women the c-word, or insulting Muslims.

Lots of people think we can go along to get along with them. Those people are incorrect. They need their comfort bubble popped and to see, with crystal clarity, the nature of the conflict and what will result from trying to ignore it.

I don't understand what criteria you have in mind for "getting along with them." I assume you are familiar with the demographics? Five to twelve million Muslims in the US. It would appear we are getting along quite well.

Get them to show their true colors now while something can be done, instead of later when it's harder or impossible due to numbers/influence/becoming slowly accustomed to appeasement.

I think this is a fallacy of over-generalization from a dramatic, unrepresentative subset.

You may be thinking that we COULD get along with them if not for people who deliberately seek to provoke them. I believe you'd be very incorrect to think that, but even if you were right, too bad. We exist and we won't go along with integrating them. They have their own societies already and we don't want them in ours.

It's even worse. I am thinking there is no "them" and "us," making the premise flawed going in. It's not them v. us, it's just we. Insofar as I am unwilling to compromise, I can hardly complain when my fellow citizens won't. The enemy is this very lack of acceptance from the fringes on both sides.

I think the attack pretty much demonstrates the poles, the zealots from one side reacting to the zealots on the other. Neither party is one I want to support. Thankfully, I don't have to.
 
Yes, but not today, not in Texas.

So the usual bomb throwers(Pamela Geller, Robert Spencer and Geert Wilders) held a little art exhibit and cartoon contest to "celebrate free speech" and antagonize adherents of the ROP.

You need people like these. They are todays Larry Flint.
 
I think the attack pretty much demonstrates the poles, the zealots from one side reacting to the zealots on the other. Neither party is one I want to support. Thankfully, I don't have to.

Don't you realize that small groups of zealots change the course of history? That they can sometimes set the tone for how millions or billions of people will live their lives for centuries to come?

The great advantage Islamic civilization has right now is belief in itself. It has people who are prepared to risk everything and do anything to see their vision for what the world should be like come to fruition.

You should really be grateful any time you find out or are reminded that you may still have a few such people on your side, whether you want to acknowledge having a side or not, who are just as passionate about preventing that vision from coming to pass.

You would not like for that vision to come true.
 
Don't you realize that small groups of zealots change the course of history? That they can sometimes set the tone for how millions or billions of people will live their lives for centuries to come?

And smaller groups of racists can have delusions of grandeur, when in the grand scheme of things they're no more significant than gnat striking your windshied.
 
That is not fictitious at all.

Oh please. You made that up. Plainly, these people critiqued Mohammed, the prophet of a religion, and then were attacked for their trouble.

Please explain how any imagined right you have created influences this situation at all.
 
These sentiments of "why needlessly offend?" are the precursors of an electorate willingly passing religious offense laws infringing on the First Amendment.

Western civilization has lost almost all of its masculinity. Islam retains 100% of theirs.
 
I need to save some of the brilliant arguments in this thread for the next discussion on people erecting intentionally offensive Nativity scenes during Christmas.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom