But Why Was Obama Against The War

You keep speaking about "getting things done". You do know that the country runs when the U.S. congress does not make new laws.

ETA: Yes, that would be my preference, there are plenty enough laws as is.
Congress doesn't just make laws. They also get to decide funding strategies, infrastructure development,...


What level of manipulation is acceptable for the purpose of getting "their guy" in the White House?
What was the manipulation here? They made the attempt, it failed. It was obvious that it wasn't going to pass yet. How is that manipulation?
What makes you think that the war will end with Obama in the White House and the Dems in control of congress?

:gnome:
this has been asked and answered.
 
Went to the WorldNutDaily link. I realized why you linked to it as the girl in the "Powered by capitalism" t-shirt was freaking hot. Then two minutes later I realized there was a web site there, too, with Ann Coulter, even, and promptly vanished.
 
Congress doesn't just make laws. They also get to decide funding strategies, infrastructure development,...

Through the process of making law. :mgduh

What was the manipulation here? They made the attempt, it failed. It was obvious that it wasn't going to pass yet. How is that manipulation?

The manipulation would be that the Democrats lied about ending to war so as to garner votes.

That, or they were too dumb to know that having control of Congress gave them not enough power to end the war.

Wait...What?


this has been asked and answered.

It has been asked. It has not been answered.

What makes you think that the war will end with Obama in the White House and the Dems in control of congress?



:irule:13:
 
It has been asked. It has not been answered.

From a man who answers 90% of questions with questions...
What makes you think that the war will end with Obama in the White House and the Dems in control of congress?

in no particular order:

1) The Democrats will have no one to blame if they don't
2) It's looking more and more like the Iraqis want us out
3) We need more troops for Afghanistan, since Bushco has allowed the Taliban to rebuild, and have to get them from somewhere
4) Because Obama will lose credibility with his core if he does not
5) Because Obama will need the money to fund his social programs and the Afghanistan escalation.
6) Because he said it because he meant it, not because it was politically popular at the time.
 
The Democrats will have no one to blame if they don't
2) It's looking more and more like the Iraqis want us out
3) We need more troops for Afghanistan, since Bushco has allowed the Taliban to rebuild, and have to get them from somewhere
4) Because Obama will lose credibility with his core if he does not
5) Because Obama will need the money to fund his social programs and the Afghanistan escalation.
6) Because he said it because he meant it, not because it was politically popular at the time.


Wanna' bet?

The Democrats lied in 2006 to get elected. Why would anyone BELIEVE them in 2008?


In fact, the Democrats are the party of war. Look to your American history.


:gnome:
 
... In fact, the Democrats are the party of war. Look to your American history.


Not totally true, Jerome, not totally true at all. (and just because I actually agreed with you elsewhere gets you no free pass here :p)

What actually happens is that the Dems often feel under great pressure from the Reps, and the Reps malign the Dems as commies / fellow travellers / wussies / [insert any line from BAC's posts here].

So under that pressure, the Dems often feel they have to prove themselves, while when the Reps are in power, the Reps can lean back and be inactive if they want to, since there is no other rightwing competition for Rep voters.

Consequently, a Dem admininstration will often be more proactive and bellicose than a Rep administration, but not because they really want to be, but because they feel too scared to do otherwise.

Lack of spine, really. But such a divide problem afflicts other countries and their own politics too.
 
Not totally true, Jerome, not totally true at all. (and just because I actually agreed with you elsewhere gets you no free pass here :p)

What actually happens is that the Dems often feel under great pressure from the Reps, and the Reps malign the Dems as commies / fellow travellers / wussies / [insert any line from BAC's posts here].

So under that pressure, the Dems often feel they have to prove themselves, while when the Reps are in power, the Reps can lean back and be inactive if they want to, since there is no other rightwing competition for Rep voters.

Consequently, a Dem admininstration will often be more proactive and bellicose than a Rep administration, but not because they really want to be, but because they feel too scared to do otherwise.

Lack of spine, really. But such a divide problem afflicts other countries and their own politics too.


You are not denying my claim, just excusing the behavior of the Democrats in regards to war. ETA: In fact you are blaming the behavior of the Dems on the GOP.

It's not my fault, the Devil(GOP) made me do it?



:gnome:
 
Last edited:
You are not denying my claim, just excusing the behavior of the Democrats in regards to war.


I'm not excusing it, I am explaining it. There is a real difference.


ETA: In fact you are blaming the behavior of the Dems on the GOP.
It's not my fault, the Devil(GOP) made me do it?


Not quite. Close, but not quite. BTW, Jerome, you forget I am not American, and consequently I have no interest at all in excusing the Democrats for anything.
 
I'm not excusing it, I am explaining it. There is a real difference.

O.K.


Not quite. Close, but not quite. BTW, Jerome, you forget I am not American, and consequently I have no interest at all in excusing the Democrats for anything.

Your potential motivations are of little relevance. The fact remains that the Democrats lied about ending the war in 2006 and they are running a candidate that is asking the voters to BELIEVE. Can you not see the irony?

:gnome:
 
In fact, the Democrats are the party of war. Look to your American history.

Since the parties of today are a far cry from those 100 years ago, and both democrats and republicans bear some responsibility for Vietnam, let us look at the post-vietnam presidents:

Gerald Ford: not much time. Mayaguez incident is all I can think of

Jimmy Carter: Didn't start a war with Iran over hostage situation. Failed hostage rescue. Didn't start a war with USSR over Afghanistan.

Ronald Reagan: Invaded Grenada. Funded the Contra war in Nicaragua. Funded the Mujahedeen in Afghanistan.

George H.W. Bush: Invaded Panama. Beiruit peacekeepers and Barracks bombing. Gulf War I. Somalia peacekeepers.

Bill Clinton: Balkan wars. Did not intervene in Rwanda. Sudan bombing. Haiti peacekeepers.

Dubya: Afghanistan war. Gulf war II.

So of the hot wars since Vietnam, the Republicans have the two gulf wars, afghanistan, and invasions of Panama and Grenada. They also funded two insurgencies (that we know of) and two major peacekeeping missions that ended poorly.

The democrats have the balkan wars, a couple of bombings in retaliation for terrorist attacks, and a generally successful peacekeeping mission.

Can you honestly call the democrats the party of war? On what planet?
 
Last edited:
Since the parties of today are a far cry from those 100 years ago, and both democrats and republicans bear some responsibility for Vietnam, let us look at the post-vietnam presidents:

I wonder why you began after the Vietnam war with your list?

BTW: The Vietnam war ended only 33 years ago. Try making the list with your 100 year initiation.


:irule:13:
 


Hey, everyone! I won an "OK" from Jerome! I am now the greatest! :D

Your potential motivations are of little relevance.


Wrong. If you accuse me of "excusing" things, my personal motivations are in fact extremely relevant to the truth or falsity of your charge.

Can you not see the irony?


Oh, I see ironies everywhere, everywhere. I just lack the time and inclination to point them all out. And I still disagree with you in part. :p
 
I wonder why you began after the Vietnam war with your list?

BTW: The Vietnam war ended only 33 years ago. Try making the list with your 100 year initiation.

Because I think recent history is more indicative of future behavior. Vietnam changed a lot of attitudes and shifted a lot of alliances. I thought this would be self-evident.

The Republicans were anti-slavery and the Democrats pro-slavery (in simplistic terms) during the civil war, but if you used this to try to predict future votes on civil rights legislation you would fail.
 
The Republicans were anti-slavery and the Democrats pro-slavery (in simplistic terms) during the civil war, but if you used this to try to predict future votes on civil rights legislation you would fail.

Actually:

Civil Rights Act
By party

The original House version:[7]

* Democratic Party: 152-96 (61%-39%)
* Republican Party: 138-34 (80%-20%)

The Senate version:[7]

* Democratic Party: 46-21 (69%-31%)
* Republican Party: 27-6 (82%-18%)

The Senate version, voted on by the House:[7]

* Democratic Party: 153-91 (63%-37%)
* Republican Party: 136-35 (80%-20%)


:gnome:
 

Actually, from that same article:

Political repercussions

The bill divided and engendered a long-term change in the demographics of both parties. President Johnson realized that supporting this bill would risk losing the South's overwhelming support of the Democratic Party. As Vice President, Johnson pushed the Kennedy administration to introduce civil rights legislation, telling Kennedy aide Ted Sorensen that "I know the risks are great and we might lose the South, but those sorts of states may be lost anyway." Senator Richard Russell, Jr. warned President Johnson that his strong support for the civil rights bill "will not only cost you the South, it will cost you the election." The South indeed started to vote increasingly Republican after 1964. However, political scientists Richard Johnston and Byron Schafer have argued that this development was based more on economics than on race.
That was the beginning of when the parties started to flip.
 
As Upchurch stated: What this vote clearly demonstrated was the split between the North and the South. Northern Democrats supported the bill more than northern Republicans, and Southern Democrats supported the bill more than Southern republicans. There were simply many more Southern Democrats than republicans at the time. This schism in great part led to to these southern democrats shifting to the Republican party, and the current Republican domination of the South.

The original House version:

* Southern Democrats: 7-87 (7%-93%)
* Southern Republicans: 0-10 (0%-100%)

* Northern Democrats: 145-9 (94%-6%)
* Northern Republicans: 138-24 (85%-15%)

The Senate version:

* Southern Democrats: 1-20 (5%-95%) (only Senator Ralph Yarborough of Texas voted in favor)
* Southern Republicans: 0-1 (0%-100%) (this was Senator John Tower of Texas)
* Northern Democrats: 45-1 (98%-2%) (only Senator Robert Byrd of West Virginia opposed the measure)
* Northern Republicans: 27-5 (84%-16%) (Senators Bourke Hickenlooper of Iowa, Barry Goldwater of Arizona, Edwin L. Mechem of New Mexico, Milward L. Simpson of Wyoming, and Norris H. Cotton of New Hampshire opposed the measure)
 
The Republicans were anti-slavery and the Democrats pro-slavery (in simplistic terms) during the civil war, but if you used this to try to predict future votes on civil rights legislation you would fail.


When I evidenced that you were incorrect you gave this:

As Upchurch stated: What this vote clearly demonstrated was the split between the North and the South. Northern Democrats supported the bill more than northern Republicans, and Southern Democrats supported the bill more than Southern republicans. There were simply many more Southern Democrats than republicans at the time. This schism in great part led to to these southern democrats shifting to the Republican party, and the current Republican domination of the South.

This describes what you did here:

shifting_goalposts.jpg




:irule:13:
 
This describes what you did here:

[qimg]http://fstdt.com/winace/pics/shifting_goalposts.jpg[/qimg]

You are, as usual, incorrect. Recall my original statement:

The Republicans were anti-slavery and the Democrats pro-slavery (in simplistic terms) during the civil war, but if you used this to try to predict future votes on civil rights legislation you would fail.

This was used as an analogy for why your claim that the democrats "are the party of war" is wrong. Instead of responding to the question at hand, you chose to attack the analogy. Even there, you failed.

Starting with the civil rights question: Your reference to the civil rights act of 1964 is irrelevant, as it is not a "future vote on civil rights legislation." Last I checked, it was in the past. In the 1860's the republicans were the party of civil rights. In the 1960's this began to change, as evidenced by the voting numbers I posted: The strongest supporters of civil rights legislation was Northern Democrats, and the strongest opponents Southern Republicans. Most of the conservative Southern democrats either switched parties or were replaced by even more conservative Republicans. The Democrats are thus the overwhelming choice of liberal and minority Southerners who favor more expansive civil rights legislation while the Republicans are the overwhelming choice of conservative, overwhelmingly white southerners who oppose it. Thus recent votes on civil rights, since these party shifts took place, will be better at predicting future votes than those from 40 or 140 years ago.

Back to the military question: recent actions of Democratic and Republican administrations demonstrate that the Republicans are more likely to get us into military conflicts than Democrats, which was the topic of discussion before your attempted derail. I thus disagree with your claim that the "Democrats are the party of war," a statement you made using the present tense. You said they are the party of war, not were the party of war.

You talk about my moving the goalposts? I'm putting them back. You tried to change the game to tennis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom