But Why Was Obama Against The War

Your weak attempts at insult aside.


Were you surprised that the Democrats continued to fund the war after they gained control of congress by running on an anti-war platform?


Not at all, given that they couldn't end the war themselves without cutting off funding and putting those in Iraq in extreme jeopardy. Again, your inability to grasp the simple logic I presented above is clearly apparent.

Here it is again ...

Even an idiot knows that once you start on a trip that you didn't even want to go on, you still gotta buy food and gas to get you there and back.


You continue to fail. But thanks for playing.
 
JdG,
Pookster answered the question as to why Obama would pay for the war now.
You don't stop a war effort by starving it of cash. that only serves to cripple the people in charge. It costs money to withdraw troops. that's something you can't achieve by preventing cash flow.

You end a war by created and executing an exit strategy.

Therefore, it makes complete sense to support the money for a war but to oppose the war and attempt to logically remove the forces.


Further, Dr. A. told no lie here and your attempt to pigeon one onto him is transparent and weak.


Finally, As I said before, I saw nothing in the article that went beyond mere rambling assertion. There have been better smears made against Obama. this one is silly.
 
I agree that WND is not the most objective site but I see articles from the Nation, Solon and many other partisan sites on the left posted here all the time.

The difference between magazines like The Nation and Salon as opposed to World Net Daily isn't a matter of bias.

The difference is that Salon and The Nation, despite their bias, actually adhere to what can fairly be called journalistic standards.
 
I have once again split off the bickering of Dr. A and Jerome to AAH. Cease and desist, both of you.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady
 
Well, I went over to World Nut Daily and read the article in question (somebody had to).

The short version of the article is that the author, Jack Cashill, systematically ignored any and all rational arguments against the Iraq war before the invasion occurred. Jack did this so well, he genuinely does not realize that anybody was making rational arguments against the war. Faced with evidence that Barack Obama was against the war before it even started, Cashill is completely baffled as to why he was against it, because Cashill is unaware of anybody giving rational arguments against the war before it started. He eventually settles on an incomprehensible "evil liberal conspiracy" type theory to explain the facts that he has actually allowed to enter his head.

You folks really should give it a read, it is a shining example of argumentum ad ignoratiam.

Cashill is a man who eats too much, doesn’t exercise, and after twenty years of living in progressively worse physical shape, suddenly becomes indignant that no one has previously told him that diet and exercise can affect your health.
 
Last edited:
:dl:


Obama votes to fund the war because... it's somebody else's fault.


The Democrats fund the war because... it's somebody else's fault.


Why even vote if they can not do what they are elected to do?





:irule:13:
 
BAC probably posts more sources than anyone on this forum. Are you trying to get him banned as a "sock"?


BAC posts "sources" of a third-rate, questionable nature, and then proceeds to insinuate that there is a fire raging where there isn't even a trace of smoke, errrr, something or other like that.

As such, his posting of "sources" is abuse of his sources, is appeal to inappropriate authority, and is entirely open to being exposed for what it is.
forum.

N.B. Illicit accusations of "sock"ism are not very nice, either.
 
Last edited:
:dl:


Obama votes to fund the war because... it's somebody else's fault.


The Democrats fund the war because... it's somebody else's fault.


Why even vote if they can not do what they are elected to do?
wow, that would be a terrible argument. I can see why you find it absurd. Now, could you show me who has actually made that argument?


Perhaps start with what Pookster or I had said.
 

I disagree. Strange hypotheses unsupported by facts. mixed with ad hominems, guilt by association, unsupported charges of antisemitism...

Absolute garbage.


jerome said:
Your logic is that Obama votes for the war because we are at war.

By that logic we should still have slavery because we had slavery.

The absurdity of this logic is astounding.

Obama did not vote for the war. He was not given the opportunity to vote for the war. He was given the opportunity to vote on a defense bill that included funding for the military, including operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. To conclude from that that Obama voted for the war is moronic.

You A rational person could, for example, be against public housing. You a rational person would not, however, vote to immediately cut off all funding for public housing. Why? Because millions of people currently live in public housing. If funding were cut off abruptly, there would be no money for utilities, maintenance, security, etc. The buildings would fall into disrepair, be taken over by gangs, and people would be left homeless. You A rational person would instead probably advocate a system where public housing was gradually privatized, or units were closed down over a period of several years so the "withdrawl" could take place in a gradual and orderly fashion.

Kind of like what Obama proposes for Iraq.
 
Last edited:
Can anyone name a bill that was proposed by Obama to end the war?


Or any of the Democrats that won mid-term elections on ending the war?





:irule:13:
 
Can anyone name a bill that was proposed by Obama to end the war?


Or any of the Democrats that won mid-term elections on ending the war?

Let's see...Democrats propose bill to end the war...filibustered in the senate, and fails...Democrats derided for wasting time on political grandstanding, since there was never any chance that such a bill would pass and override the certain presidential veto...democrats derided for "politics as usual".

BTW, Ron Paul won a midterm election. Has he submitted a bill to end the war since then?
 
Let's see...Democrats propose bill to end the war...filibustered in the senate, and fails...Democrats derided for wasting time on political grandstanding, since there was never any chance that such a bill would pass and override the certain presidential veto...democrats derided for "politics as usual".


Got it, it's not their fault.



:dl:



Would you like to buy the Brooklyn bridge?



:irule:13:
 
Got it, it's not their fault.


Oh, so you believe that the Democrats could pass a resolution ending the Iraq war over a Senate Republican Filibuster and a presidential veto?

Would you like to buy the Brooklyn bridge?


No thank you. I already have one it is very nice

BRID_0022.jpg
 
Oh, so you believe that the Democrats could pass a resolution ending the Iraq war over a Senate Republican Filibuster and a presidential veto?


They have done nothing other than vote to extend the war since they were elected to stop the war.


You can try any justify all you want, but the fact that the Democrats lied to win the congress stands.




Put you words on record!

Will Obama end America's wars when president?



:irule:13:
 
Yes, and no. What I believe is not relevant.

What is relevant is what you believe Obama means when he says that he will "pull out of Iraq".
I believe that he plans on
barackObama.com said:
Obama will immediately begin to remove our troops from Iraq. He will remove one to two combat brigades each month, and have all of our combat brigades out of Iraq within 16 months. Obama will make it clear that we will not build any permanent bases in Iraq. He will keep some troops in Iraq to protect our embassy and diplomats; if al Qaeda attempts to build a base within Iraq, he will keep troops in Iraq or elsewhere in the region to carry out targeted strikes on al Qaeda.

I do not believe that he will end our efforts in afghanistan.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom