But Why Was Obama Against The War

They are already built!!!


I would assume that he would either dismantle them or turn them over to the Iraqi government. Perhaps you should ask him.


How do you guys fall for this stuff?


Bases have been built. The Bush administration is currently negotiating with the Iraqi administration over the terms of US involvement once the current UN authorization expires.

The US built permanent bases in the Philipines. subic bay was closed in 1991. Clark Air base was destroyed with the eruption of Mt. Pinitubo and not rebuilt.
 
What do you think he is going to do with the permanent bases that we have built in Iraq?
Out of curiosity, what's the functional difference between a permanent base and a temporary one?

is it concrete buildings vs. tents?
 
:)
Wrong again, but not surprising. By my logic, it ends ...



But it takes a little bit if intelligence to stay focused long enough to read a sentence all the way to the end and then comprehend its meaning. Maybe you'll be able to do that some day. Good luck with that.
Just watch your phrasing carefully - some of our posters have a tendency to act like total fools to try to get you to write something they can report and maybe get you suspended for awhile. That's the only fun they have in their miserable existences. Nobody like that on this thread, at the moment, I'm quite sure, but slime like that does occasionally show up.:)

Mostly, just starve the trolls.
 
Last edited:
:)Just watch your phrasing carefully - some of our posters have a tendency to act like total fools to try to get you to write something they can report and maybe get you suspended for awhile. That's the only fun they have in their miserable existences. Nobody like that on this thread, at the moment, I'm quite sure, but slime like that does occasionally show up.:)

Yeah, but the slime trails are really disgusting, and they tend to mess up the garden.
 
Burger King!


... and Billions of dollars of base construction costs.




:irule:13:
Money is no object to the military. If they need to spend "billions" (unconfirmed number) on a base which suites their immediate strategic needs, they will build it. The permanance of those structures are a secondary point, and far from one that will guide decisions on staying or leaving. Afterall, it costs just that much more to continue to opperate a "billions of dollars" base, and if that continued opperation isn't useful to the military objectives, they will leave it.
 
Money is no object to the military. If they need to spend "billions" (unconfirmed number) on a base which suites their immediate strategic needs, they will build it. The permanance of those structures are a secondary point, and far from one that will guide decisions on staying or leaving. Afterall, it costs just that much more to continue to opperate a "billions of dollars" base, and if that continued opperation isn't useful to the military objectives, they will leave it.


When we start pulling our troops out of Japan, Germany, and Korea I might believe that we will at some point pull our troops out of Iraq.

I suppose those are temporary bases also?




:irule:13:
 
When we start pulling our troops out of Japan, Germany, and Korea I might believe that we will at some point pull our troops out of Iraq.

:irule:13:
be
I don't believe that you would think differently. Afterall, gdnp gave you examples of bases on foreign soil which were closed.
 
Have we decided whether the Democrats were telling an untruth about their opposition to the war or that they were not smart enough to understand that there was nothing they could do about the war despite having control of the congress?


...or it there another explanation?





:irule:13:
 
Have we decided whether the Democrats were telling an untruth about their opposition to the war or that they were not smart enough to understand that there was nothing they could do about the war despite having control of the congress?


...or it there another explanation?



:irule:13:
Changing topics because you know the truth of what I said?
 
be
I don't believe that you would think differently. Afterall, gdnp gave you examples of bases on foreign soil which were closed.

None of which are strategically important to the Empire as are Iraq, Korea, Japan, and Germany.


:irule:13:
 
None of which are strategically important to the Empire as are Iraq, Korea, Japan, and Germany.


:irule:13:
Obviously, if there is a strategic reason to keep a base, it will be kept.....duh. Strategy, however, also includes political beenfits as well. If an Iraq base results in a weakened political benefit, it will not be kept. If a base is kept out of the request of foreign governments and it suites our advantage, it will be kept.

I am certain that Obama will organize a planned strategy to ensure that the withdrawal will not result in a destablization of the area. It is possible that the deal with the Iraqi government will include a US base for troup training and support. If the Iraqi government doesn't want it, it won't be there.

Now, to help you get back on target, could you explain how keeping a base (if one was to be kept) is proof of maintaining a war?
 
Have we decided whether the Democrats were telling an untruth about their opposition to the war or that they were not smart enough to understand that there was nothing they could do about the war despite having control of the congress?


...or it there another explanation?




:irule:13:
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2007/05/20070501-6.html

the democrats have made attempts to limit the war (call for a timeline). The president vetoed it and would require more votes out of congress. This would result in deadlocking government for months and months and only serve to strengthen the republicans in the coming presidential election.
 
Obama voicing disagreement for the war is of little significance as compared to

Ron Paul, who voted against (while a member of Congress)

Hillary Clinton who voted for, while a Senator.

He was not in a position where his opinion made a difference. The other two were, as was McCain, who voted for the war.

Note from the Wiki article: Reps. Duncan (R-TN), Hostettler (R-IN), Houghton (R-NY), Leach (R-IA), Morella (R-MD), Paul (R-TX). Against.
Rep. Sanders (I-VT) Against.

Reps. Ortiz (D-TX), Roukema (R-NJ), and Stump (R-AZ) did not vote on the resolution

126 (61%) of 208 Democratic Representatives voted against the resolution. Each of those 126 was more significant in their vote than Obama in his speech to a friendly crowd.

21 Democratic Senators voted against: Akaka (D-HI), Bingaman (D-NM), Boxer (D-CA), Byrd (D-WV), Conrad (D-ND), Corzine (D-NJ), Dayton (D-MN), Durbin (D-IL), Feingold (D-WI), Graham (D-FL), Inouye (D-HI), Kennedy (D-MA), Leahy (D-VT), Levin (D-MI), Mikulski (D-MD), Murray (D-WA), Reed (D-RI), Sarbanes (D-MD), Stabenow (D-MI), Wellstone (D-MN), Wyden (D-OR).

1 Republican Senators voted against: Chafee (R-RI).

Also against: Jeffords (I-VT)

Each of those votes is likewise more significant that Obama's speech.

For those interested, the roll call votes are cited in the Wiki article in the references section: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_Resolution

DR
 
Last edited:
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2007/05/20070501-6.html

the democrats have made attempts to limit the war (call for a timeline). The president vetoed it and would require more votes out of congress. This would result in deadlocking government for months and months and only serve to strengthen the republicans in the coming presidential election.

Your argument is that the Dems did could not do what they were elected to do in the mid-term elections because they were playing politics for the Presidential election?
 
Your argument is that the Dems did could not do what they were elected to do in the mid-term elections because they were playing politics for the Presidential election?
well, yes. Would you have preffered to be congress deadlocked over deliberations of the war that won't make a difference in the short term and thereby prevent anything else getting done?

Certainly politicians have to make pragmatic choices. They want thier guy in the white house. This makes sense, because they can get done the policies they want to get done.
 
well, yes. Would you have preffered to be congress deadlocked over deliberations of the war that won't make a difference in the short term and thereby prevent anything else getting done?

You keep speaking about "getting things done". You do know that the country runs when the U.S. congress does not make new laws.

ETA: Yes, that would be my preference, there are plenty enough laws as is.

Certainly politicians have to make pragmatic choices. They want thier guy in the white house. This makes sense, because they can get done the policies they want to get done.


What level of manipulation is acceptable for the purpose of getting "their guy" in the White House?

How many people have died in Iraq since the Dems campaigned and won on ending the war?

What makes you think that they will not "manipulate" for the purpose of making longer term political gains?

What makes you think that the war will end with Obama in the White House and the Dems in control of congress?

:gnome:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom