But Why Was Obama Against The War

This was used as an analogy for why your claim that the democrats "are the party of war" is wrong. Instead of responding to the question at hand, you chose to attack the analogy.

Now you have used circular goalpost moving logic. An impressive feat!

You are claiming that my assertion that the Democrats are the party of war is invalid because we can not predict the future actions of the party.


o_logic.jpg



:irule:13:
 
Now you have used circular goalpost moving logic. An impressive feat!

You are claiming that my assertion that the Democrats are the party of war is invalid because we can not predict the future actions of the party.

Nice try. One of your better straw men.

I am claiming that your assertion that the Democrats are the party of war is invalid because recent experience does not bear it out. An assertion that you have repeatedly danced around, because you cannot refute it.

Fail. Thanks for playing. Be sure to collect your parting gifts on the way out.

:w2:
 
Wanna' bet?

The Democrats lied in 2006 to get elected. Why would anyone BELIEVE them in 2008?

Moderation in pursuit of justice is the highest political virtue. They made an attempt to leave Iraq, but it isn't happening so they gave up. Which seems eminently fair. What sort of message would it send for them to fight hard for the sake of us being able to stop fighting in Iraq? Democracy is about compromise, even if you're right you need to acknowledge that wrong people have power too. Iraq wasn't the only issue of the 2006 election; people were also fed up with the corruption and dirty tricks of the Republicans.

When I evidenced that you were incorrect you gave this:

This describes what you did here:

If you look at that data you see that in the North, the Democrats were more likely to vote for the Civil Rights Act, and in the South Democrats were also more likely to vote for the Civil Rights Act. However, Democrats were far more likely to be in the South than Republicans, and as such more Democrats voted against the Civil Right's Act. It's a straightforward example of Simpson's Paradox. All other things being equal, a Democrat was more likely to support the Civil Rights Act than a Republican, but all other things weren't equal. In a strict sense your original claim was right in that being a Democrat had predictive power in a negative sense, but only because being a Democrat allowed you to predict a person was a Southerner. And since the present Democratic very much skews towards Northerners, saying things about Southern Democrats has little value. Even if Southern Democrats are still racists, and they very well might be, they have lost their power.

Political parties are like baseball teams. The best team in the league can be the worst team a few years later for the very simple reason that the teams are made of completely different people as people shuffle in and out. There's more continuity than baseball teams because parties are driven by ideology as well as mere home-team brand loyalty, but realignments still happen. If it wasn't the case, the Democrats would still be the party of strict constructionism, liassez-faire economics, and the Gold Standard, which they were for most of the 19th century.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom