Black Swan Event Under Way

I love this thread because every time it's bumped with the gloom and doom posts about how bad everything is, it reminds me to check up on my investments and they're doing really quite well! If we continue with this economic disaster much longer I may be able to retire five years ahead of schedule!
 
I love this thread because every time it's bumped with the gloom and doom posts about how bad everything is, it reminds me to check up on my investments and they're doing really quite well! If we continue with this economic disaster much longer I may be able to retire five years ahead of schedule!

Try talking to some people who don't have investments and who haven't had the benefit of zero interest rates.

It may give you some insight into what's happening outside your bubble.
 
Try talking to some people who don't have investments and who haven't had the benefit of zero interest rates.

It may give you some insight into what's happening outside your bubble.

But I'm well aware of what's happening "outside my bubble". This thread is in the "Economics, Business and Finance" [sic] subforum, not the "Social Issues & Current Events" subforum, however. Therefore here we are free to confine ourselves strictly to discussing "the bubble" of money, money, money. Which is, contrary to assertions, doing well. If you want to argue that non money things are going badly I quite agree with you -- in another subforum.
 
But I'm well aware of what's happening "outside my bubble". This thread is in the "Economics, Business and Finance" [sic] subforum, not the "Social Issues & Current Events" subforum, however. Therefore here we are free to confine ourselves strictly to discussing "the bubble" of money, money, money. Which is, contrary to assertions, doing well. If you want to argue that non money things are going badly I quite agree with you -- in another subforum.

I have no actual knowledge or keen insight into what is happening, but money was doing very well in 1999, also.

It feels the same to me.

Markets go up. Markets go down. Over time, they have always gone up, but there have been some investment bubbles, and it just seems to me like we are in one now. I could be wrong.

When The Atheist started this thread I was arguing that stocks should not crash even though the economy was headed to a very, very, bad year. Now, I am arguing that although they should not have crashed, they also should not have soared. I guess we'll find out. I did not expect things to be where they are now.
 
I have no actual knowledge or keen insight into what is happening, but money was doing very well in 1999, also.

It feels the same to me.

Markets go up. Markets go down. Over time, they have always gone up, but there have been some investment bubbles, and it just seems to me like we are in one now. I could be wrong.

When The Atheist started this thread I was arguing that stocks should not crash even though the economy was headed to a very, very, bad year. Now, I am arguing that although they should not have crashed, they also should not have soared. I guess we'll find out. I did not expect things to be where they are now.

I think the lesson is that we should behave as sense dictates, regardless of what we expect to happen. Buy and hold, don't sell based on assuming a series of moments is actually a trend.
 
I expected Covid to drag stocks down. I still expect it, but my timeframe has shifted. I don't know when the crash will occur, but it will be more than a correction when it happens.
 
I expected Covid to drag stocks down. I still expect it, but my timeframe has shifted. I don't know when the crash will occur, but it will be more than a correction when it happens.

Well I expect a strong rebound. Some countries, China in particular, are well over the pandemic and will power forward and the vaccine will accelerate the economic recovery.
 
I think the lesson is that we should behave as sense dictates, regardless of what we expect to happen. Buy and hold, don't sell based on assuming a series of moments is actually a trend.

An even better lesson than "buy and hold" is that we should buy good companies when their prices are below their fair value, keeping in mind the fundamental rule of securities pricing, which is that the fair value of a security is equal to the net present value of all future cash flows generated by the security.

For those of you who have never seen the above statement, I'm not making it up. That was the biggest single takeaway I had from what little study of corporate financing I have ever done. The only problem with using that fundamental principle when investing is that it requires you to know the future.
 
An even better lesson than "buy and hold" is that we should buy good companies when their prices are below their fair value, keeping in mind the fundamental rule of securities pricing, which is that the fair value of a security is equal to the net present value of all future cash flows generated by the security.

For those of you who have never seen the above statement, I'm not making it up. That was the biggest single takeaway I had from what little study of corporate financing I have ever done. The only problem with using that fundamental principle when investing is that it requires you to know the future.

And since you can't know the future, this piece of advice is useless. Which means the remaining best advice is "buy and hold" because the point of advice is that it recommends a course of action which is within the realm of the possible.

Otherwise the best financial advice would be "discover how to transmute base metals to gold" or "attain immortality to gain advantage of compound interest".
 
If you want to argue that non money things are going badly I quite agree with you -- in another subforum.

No, you're just missing the point that sharemarkets are not the economy, nor a reflection of it when central banks are spewing free money into the system.

How investments are doing reflects only on people with investments.
 
I did not expect things to be where they are now.
Almost exactly the same place 'things' were a year ago?

The pandemic isn't even close to over, our government is injecting trillions into the economy that will have to be recouped somehow, and new more rapidly spreading strains of the virus are already appearing. Investors have had it lucky so far, but this year will be a reckoning for the economy.
 

Attachments

  • indu.jpg
    indu.jpg
    28.3 KB · Views: 2
No, you're just missing the point that sharemarkets are not the economy, nor a reflection of it when central banks are spewing free money into the system.

How investments are doing reflects only on people with investments.

"Everything is awful!"
"X isn't."
"X doesn't count! Disregard X, and everything is awful!"

I guess there's no more to say.
 
"Everything is awful!"
"X isn't."
"X doesn't count! Disregard X, and everything is awful!"

I guess there's no more to say.

Couple of nice strawmen you got there - is there are a bulk buy special on?

Maybe try reading my posts next time.

The irony is that you are the one looking at only one piece of the picture.
 
Couple of nice strawmen you got there - is there are a bulk buy special on?

Maybe try reading my posts next time.

The irony is that you are the one looking at only one piece of the picture.

Put up or shut up, Chicken Little: if we're in the midst of an economic disaster what metrics demonstrate it? Not the stock market, apparently: you've decided that because it doesn't support your claim it doesn't count. What does? Or are you suggesting we're having an economic disaster that can't be quantified?
 
I looked back at the OP to remind myself of the original thread topic and it's true it was never entirely about the stock market:

I have it on record in the covid thread, but this is about money and the impact covid will have on the global economy.

Oxford Economics suggest a hit to global economy of 1.2 trillion dollars, which I think is light.

While most people won't be too sick with it, some will, and even if 10% of workforces require 3-4 weeks off sick, that is going to have a massive effect on the world's supply chain. Most importantly, it's likely to all happen at once - it won't ripple through like 'flu, everyone will get it very quickly.

Some companies will be forced to close doors for extended periods, loan defaults will skyrocket, and the sharmarkets will tumble once the size of the impact becomes known.

On Friday, I recommended to several businesspeople I know that they should invest in TVIX - a hedge fund against global downturns. The shares were $38 at Friday lunchtime, and they've opened today at $49. I know two took my advice and threw five grand in on Friday.

They've made a grand over the weekend, with lots more to come.

I can see TVIX going well into the hundreds of dollars range if the pandemic goes the way it looks certain to.

Investment advice: buy TVIX now.

Disclaimer - I am not a financial adviser.

Out of curiosity I looked up TVIX and it did indeed rise into the hundreds - a maximum of $806, in fact, on March 18. It was down to about $300 a week later, and has fallen steadily since. It's currently $25.
 
Put up or shut up, Chicken Little: if we're in the midst of an economic disaster what metrics demonstrate it? Not the stock market, apparently: you've decided that because it doesn't support your claim it doesn't count. What does? Or are you suggesting we're having an economic disaster that can't be quantified?

Sure thing, mate - let me educate you about your own country for starters - I try not to overestimate ignorance, but it seems you're unaware of some of the major problems.

Unemployment But they're probably all earning enough from their share portfolios to be not worth counting.

The largest increase in poverty since at least 1960 Now, those people don't hold shares or property, or they wouldn't be in poverty. I think that's how it works, but who cares?

30-40 million Americans risk eviction But hey, they can just cash in their Amazon shares and they'll be sweet.

My humblest apologies, the US economy is going fine. How about that Dow breaking 30,000?
 
Sure thing, mate - let me educate you about your own country for starters - I try not to overestimate ignorance, but it seems you're unaware of some of the major problems.

Unemployment But they're probably all earning enough from their share portfolios to be not worth counting.

The largest increase in poverty since at least 1960 Now, those people don't hold shares or property, or they wouldn't be in poverty. I think that's how it works, but who cares?

30-40 million Americans risk eviction But hey, they can just cash in their Amazon shares and they'll be sweet.

My humblest apologies, the US economy is going fine. How about that Dow breaking 30,000?

If you can't keep your temper and speak objectively then perhaps economics isn't for you; it's not called "the dismal science" because it's lighthearted fluff.

As for my colossal American ignorance, I did notice that all three of those items you point to flow from each other, and all three are the result of the current pandemic shutdown. Do you think they all three won't be reversed as soon as the pandemic is under control? Do you think unemployment will remain as it is now once everything else returns to normal? Or perhaps you anticipate that the pandemic will be immutable and eternal, and current conditions will never change?
 
Do you think they all three won't be reversed as soon as the pandemic is under control? Do you think unemployment will remain as it is now once everything else returns to normal?
that's the $64,000 question. Will everything 'return to normal' or are we suffering irreversible changes? I guess we will just have to wait and see...

Or perhaps you anticipate that the pandemic will be immutable and eternal, and current conditions will never change?
That's silly, of course the pandemic won't last forever. But it's already gone on for too long, hasn't reached the peak yet, and is bound to have a 'long tail'. Nobody is predicting a return to normal any time soon, and for some of us it may be too late.

As for investors, it will only take a little downturn to panic the markets. When we first went into lockdown my brother was in a big panic because his investments went down. He wanted to pull them all out before they dropped further, but - 'knowing' that the situation was only temporary - I convinced him to leave them be. Lucky for me that panned out, or I would not be in a good place with my brother right now.

Things are a lot worse now than I expected but the markets are still holding up because people expect the situation to be resolved soon - but I'm not so sure. If it doesn't come right by the end of this year...
 
If you can't keep your temper and speak objectively

It really is a shame the MDC is no more - yet another failed attempt to assign a state of mind to a post.

Ho hum.

Do you think they all three won't be reversed as soon as the pandemic is under control?

Maybe you can use your mad clairvoyant skillz to tell me when that will be.

When it occurs, yes, things will improve, but it won't be a magic wand, especially for those at the bottom.
 
that's the $64,000 question. Will everything 'return to normal' or are we suffering irreversible change

My prediction: everything will snap back first to normal then rapidly better than before. Lessons will have been learned. There will be a new appreciation for what's actually important, and a drive towards efficiency. When we look back at all this is will be appreciated as a painful period that forced evaluation of a lot of what had been assumption or just been sticking around from inertia.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom