When I first proposed doing this as a way to monitor the effect of the 'Black Swan' on a small investor several posters encouraged me to do so. If the consensus is now that it's meaningless I'm happy to stop.
I will, however, continue to use the percentage by which the value of my investments has grown or shrunk to determine if I would have been better off cashing in my stocks and shares ISA back in February and putting/leaving my money in a savings account.
This is where there are different ways to review one's investment performance, because people are often measuring different things to track different goals.
What I think is being conflated here is portfolio valuation vs returns on investment.
I track my portfolio valuation to see how I'm progressing toward my retirement target number. Basically: I want to have $x by the age of 55, how'm I doin'?
Alternatively, I'm curious about how hard my savings are working for me. So, the metric for this is what's called a 'dollar adjusted return'. To calculate this, I only consider how much growth has come from the investments themselves, and exclude my new savings. If my portfolio grew 15% this year, but 10% of that is new savings, then the portfolio only returned 5%. I might want to compare that to some sort of benchmark to see how my investment choices are panning out.
This is why I mentioned in an earlier post that it's a big deal to consider this, because when we're just starting out, our annual contributions are the bulk of each year's portfolio increase. Later, as compounding takes a larger effect, our annual contributions become proportionally smaller to the point of being a rounding error.
Some people actually reach a point where compounding alone will achieve their dollar goal by the target date, and stop contributing new savings. I'm at that stage.
Here are my 2020 monthly %returns, dollar-adjusted, not annualized (so: real month over month deltas):
Jan-20 7%
Feb-20 -8%
Mar-20 -5%
Apr-20 14%
May-20 6%
Jun-20 11%
Jul-20 3%
Aug-20 27%
Sep-20 -7%
Oct-20 -5%
Nov-20 6%
Dec-20 8%
Annual return is 63%
ETA: I'm not providing the raw numbers because either I'm poor and embarrassed or rich and don't want to sound boasty.
ETA more: and the point I'm trying to make is that this is achieved with me assuming that nobody can predict what stocks, bonds, or the market will do, so building a portfolio model based on that. Dollar cost averaging into a diversified index, buy and hold.