Black Swan Event Under Way

No, but it's relevant because it shows that simplistic solutions like robbing the rich and handing out money to the poor don't work in the long run.

You mean, outside of cases where we can show that it does work?

UK was a basket-case post-WWII and taxed its way back to prosperity.

And it's not a case of handing money to the poor, but using the money to pay for infrastructure and create jobs. It also kept a very tight lid on the property market.
 
This month's update on my stocks and shares ISA.

Date | % +/- | Date | % +/-
5.18|1.3|7.20|7.8
8.18|3.4|8.20|8.1
11.18|-3.1|9.20|7.9
2.19|-0.8|10.20|9.9
5.19|1.9|11.20|12.6
8.19|7.4|12.20|15.1
11.19|6.6
2.20|10.3
3.20|3.7
4.20|-4.9
5.20|0.3
6.20|5.8

A reminder of the context: I have been saving £300 a month since May 2017, choosing a fund to invest in each month. I have so far invested a total of £13200 in a dozen different funds; the current value of my investments is £15189.
 
Who was talking about a tax cut for the wealthy? Not me.

You were talking about what wealthier people do with their money.

I'm explaining the context of the research that gives us knowledge about what wealthy do with disposable income per marginal propensity to save, and its real world policy implications.

Concentration of wealth slows down the economy, reduces wages, and increases unemployment, &c.
 
You mean, outside of cases where we can show that it does work?

UK was a basket-case post-WWII and taxed its way back to prosperity.
Yes, the UK raised taxes to pay for wartime spending, but not just on the rich. It also extended rationing for another 10 years after the war ended. During the war it introduced a 'purchase' tax on 'luxury' goods of 33⅓%, which was later increased to 100%.

Such draconian measures may have been necessary during the war for obvious reasons, but afterwards it was just unnecessary pain. The Labour government intended to continue rationing indefinitely, so it's not surprising they lost power to conservatives in 1951.

But did the UK really 'tax its way back to prosperity' or were other factors more important? Things like not having to divert manpower and resources to fighting a war, and not suffering a blockade and destruction of infrastructure.

Other countries, particularly in Europe (which suffered more devastation from the war than the UK) did not implement the same austerity measures, but did better than the UK. It could be argued that it was their economic recovery that helped the UK more than its own actions.
 

Attachments

  • uk taxes wwii.jpg
    uk taxes wwii.jpg
    16.5 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:
From the front lines: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/dec/09/coronavirus-young-economy-unemployment-mental-health

52% of Americans ages 18 to 29 now live with their parents, an increase of 2.6 million Americans since February 2020 and the highest rate since at least the Great Depression.

and even worse:

As young Americans suffer economically, surveys conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found the percentage of young adults ages 18 to 24 experiencing suicidal thoughts increased from 10.7% in 2018 to 25.5% in August 2020 and nearly 75% of young adults struggled with at least one mental health issue.
 
If you think Cinderella would even think about the idea in her wildest nightmares, you're kidding yourself.

Will not happen.

But you're right.
Yes I have been trying to find what is wrong with a land tax and all I discover is it is very right and proper, if universal including the so called family home. Intriguingly no one suffers, because the tax is optional till the owner sells or dies. In the former case they recover most of their equity and usually more than they invested, in the latter, they chuckle from on high at the wailing and gnashing of teeth by the inheritors.
Covid needs a reset and this should be it.

I see a sovereign state where there is a portfolio of land titles, each of which has shared ownership between the individual and the state, except where the individual is debt averse, and pays annually.
 
Last edited:
It would cost Cinderella votes.
Jacinda the enigma. She could do it, then walk away. It would never be repealed because it is so simple, revenue would flow like milk and honey, and governing would be easy.
 

18-29 covers a lot of college age young adults. A lot of those are moving home because school is mainly online. And moving back to your parents house is certainly a stressor. That is why my kids aren't living at home, even though they probably could. We love them, but they are young adults and they need their own space. Christmas break will be more than enough.
 
She must be getting bored with flipping nothing burgers.

Don't be silly - she has enough international adulation and feel-good stories to keep her in warm fuzzies forever.

32nd most powerful women in the world, so they say, only 12 spots behind Oprah.

What point there is to power you don't know how - or refuse - to use is, I have no idea.
 
I see a sovereign state where there is a portfolio of land titles, each of which has shared ownership between the individual and the state, except where the individual is debt averse, and pays annually.

That sounds horrible. Although to be fair, it is pretty much the case now. While you might own your house/land, you are at the whims of the local government in regards to property taxes. Adding is shared ownership to the state is just ridiculous. That might not sound like much to low tax areas but places where mortgages are nearly matches by tax payments, the idea of increased government costs does not sound like anything people would entertain.
 
That sounds horrible. Although to be fair, it is pretty much the case now. While you might own your house/land, you are at the whims of the local government in regards to property taxes. Adding is shared ownership to the state is just ridiculous. That might not sound like much to low tax areas but places where mortgages are nearly matches by tax payments, the idea of increased government costs does not sound like anything people would entertain.
Shared ownership is the default setting. And very attractive.
A 65 year old allows the state to take a 30% share if they dies at 95.
It is an effortless annuity at say 1%

Terminology may be not precise.
 
This is actually an old topic, and the research is pretty clear and looks bad for theories like trickle down economics. The active phenomenon is what's called a 'marginal propensity to save' which is progressive with income. And that makes sense, since wealthier people have more breathing space in their disposable income, having cleared the baseline human needs.

So, the effect is that if the government wants to improve peoples' lives, the money is best spent with things like stimulus cheques for everybody rather than a tax cut for the wealthy.

This is because of the mechanics: $1B in stimulus cheques helps 100MM people pay their rent. $1B in tax cuts for the 1% helps 500 people hoover up real estate and consolidate local markets, so they can raise rents, making 100MM people's rent higher.

The Atheist and I don't agree on everything but I 100% agree that there's a surge in the 1%'s asset accumulation right now, at the cost for the other 99%.

The expression is "K shaped recovery" where the prospect for individual households is either rising or falling in a bimodal pattern right now. I believe it's a problem brewing.

Thanks for explaining that.

Do you think it's likely the USA lower income households will receive much in the way of stimulus?
 
Do you think it's likely the USA lower income households will receive much in the way of stimulus?

This is the way Congress is selling it, but cynics like myself believe the qualifications get gamed too much.

"Family Businesses" get a special carve out that sounds great to small mom and pop operations, but usually that means they're last in line after the Waltons and Hobby Lobby, who know how to get the financial aid quickly because their lobbyists were involved in creating the forms that need to be filled out. That is, if there's even anything left.
 
I think low-income households in USA are receiving exactly double what low-income households got in NZ.










$0 x 2 = $0

It took me a while to get/see that. I haven't delved into your Jacinda thread, but I know I should take a look.

I saw today that the deal might be nearly reached at $600, which is roughly what Australia's unemployed got at first (AU$750).

Job Seekers then got a second bonus payment after it was realised the first wasn't enough.

This is the way Congress is selling it, but cynics like myself believe the qualifications get gamed too much.

"Family Businesses" get a special carve out that sounds great to small mom and pop operations, but usually that means they're last in line after the Waltons and Hobby Lobby, who know how to get the financial aid quickly because their lobbyists were involved in creating the forms that need to be filled out. That is, if there's even anything left.

There's also the matter of whether favouritism for businesses helps the economy, or whether helping the people, the environment and infrastructure boosts the economy more.

Having seen that the stimulus measures so far have kept things moving fairly slowly, Australia, and Victoria in particular have now budgeted a lot of spending (taking advantage of low interest rates) to boost the money flowing in the community and improve lives. (Similar to The Great Reset type thinking, thanks to our premier Dan Andrews.)

Improving home heating systems, city livability, electricity rebates, bonuses for solar installation, rail line improvement that sort of thing.

Both the cynic and the optimist would say this is to make us better producers, workers, and consumers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom