Black Swan Event Under Way

governments have limited means of helping the economy, and as it turns out, they took the worst possible option of printing an almost infinite amount of money.
Not infinite, just enough to stop the economy from collapsing.

Billionaires are truly grateful, because the trillions of dollars tipped into the economy has flowed directly upwards, and the brunt of the pandemic, like the disease itself, will be borne by the bottom half of asset owners.
But that is what always happens in a capitalist economy. The only way to prevent it is go communist socialist, which is impossible in today's political environment. And we all know that communism socialism has failed everywhere it was tried - just look at Venezuela!
 
Yes, but we will never know it because the measures we use for economic 'health' don't count people dying of disease or starvation.

Unemployment is definitely a factor, and those numbers are bad right now.

Not infinite, just enough to stop the economy from collapsing.

I dispute that. I think far more easing has taken place than necessary, and the increase in asset values tends to confirm that.

But that is what always happens in a capitalist economy. The only way to prevent it is go communist socialist, which is impossible in today's political environment. And we all know that communism socialism has failed everywhere it was tried - just look at Venezuela!

Nicely put.
 
I just moved my superannuation savings out of cash into a balanced fund. With the virus virtually eliminate in Australia and vaccines around the corner I believe this is a safe pathway. I expect to soon be earning 7-8%.
 
I just moved my superannuation savings out of cash into a balanced fund. With the virus virtually eliminate in Australia and vaccines around the corner I believe this is a safe pathway. I expect to soon be earning 7-8%.

Smart plan - as long as central banks keeps interest rates close to zero, the sharemarket will keep burning.

Rather a lot of ordinary people, however, are being ****** over.

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/bide...ss-coronavirus-aid_n_5fcb0f5ec5b6636e09256b28

We have the perfect two-speed economy now, the rich keep getting richer, at the expense of the poor, who keep getting poorer. Milton Friedman will be chortling in his grave.
 
Smart plan - as long as central banks keeps interest rates close to zero, the sharemarket will keep burning.

Rather a lot of ordinary people, however, are being ****** over.

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/bide...ss-coronavirus-aid_n_5fcb0f5ec5b6636e09256b28

We have the perfect two-speed economy now, the rich keep getting richer, at the expense of the poor, who keep getting poorer. Milton Friedman will be chortling in his grave.

Oh yes, poor people in the US will be hard hit. Not so much in Australia. Welfare payments went up sharply during lockdown and will stay higher I think. And there are billions being invested into social housing.

All in all, our welfare and pension systems are holding out well. The main losers are those who retire while paying rent (they get rental assistance) and not owning homes.

I’m hardly rich, bringing up 7 kids on one income, but comfortable.
 
<snip>

We have the perfect two-speed economy now, the rich keep getting richer, at the expense of the poor, who keep getting poorer. Milton Friedman will be chortling in his grave.

Slight clarification here. Rich means anyone whose income comes mainly from owning shares. The poor are anyone else without a good education. I also suggest that the number of people who do not fall into either group will go down over time.

The reason is that capital growth and share income will increase faster than wages, which probably will not go up much. This has some very bad consequences.
 
Slight clarification here. Rich means anyone whose income comes mainly from owning shares. The poor are anyone else without a good education.

Oh wow - only the uneducated are poor.

You should let people know that.

(and "rich" is asset rich, shares are only relevant in being one class of asset, but certainly not the only reason people are asset-rich)
 
We have the perfect two-speed economy now, the rich keep getting richer, at the expense of the poor, who keep getting poorer. Milton Friedman will be chortling in his grave.
But what good is their wealth if they don't use it? Do they hide it in a tin box under the the bed? No. They invest it. Without that investment banks wouldn't be able to make loans, business confidence would nosedive and the economy would stall. Markets would not have the flexibility required to adapt to the virus, unemployment would stay high, goods would not be produced and inflation would skyrocket. Bad news all round.

Compared to that, letting a few rich people get even richer is no big deal, and easily corrected for by simply raising their taxes. But even if we don't it's still better than if we cut them out. You only have to look at Venezuela to see what happens when you do that.

Is there another way? Sure - but the political backlash from implementing full-on socialism would be catastrophic. Like it not, we need to let the rich get richer right now. We can hit them later when the pandemic is over!
 
Investment isn't an end in itself.

We have too much investment capital and not enough investment in health, education, infrastructure.

Supply-side economics makes no sense unless you also assist with the demand.
 
But what good is their wealth if they don't use it? Do they hide it in a tin box under the the bed? No. They invest it. Without that investment banks wouldn't be able to make loans, business confidence would nosedive and the economy would stall. Markets would not have the flexibility required to adapt to the virus, unemployment would stay high, goods would not be produced and inflation would skyrocket. Bad news all round.

Compared to that, letting a few rich people get even richer is no big deal, and easily corrected for by simply raising their taxes. But even if we don't it's still better than if we cut them out. You only have to look at Venezuela to see what happens when you do that.

Is there another way? Sure - but the political backlash from implementing full-on socialism would be catastrophic. Like it not, we need to let the rich get richer right now. We can hit them later when the pandemic is over!

This is actually an old topic, and the research is pretty clear and looks bad for theories like trickle down economics. The active phenomenon is what's called a 'marginal propensity to save' which is progressive with income. And that makes sense, since wealthier people have more breathing space in their disposable income, having cleared the baseline human needs.

So, the effect is that if the government wants to improve peoples' lives, the money is best spent with things like stimulus cheques for everybody rather than a tax cut for the wealthy.

This is because of the mechanics: $1B in stimulus cheques helps 100MM people pay their rent. $1B in tax cuts for the 1% helps 500 people hoover up real estate and consolidate local markets, so they can raise rents, making 100MM people's rent higher.

The Atheist and I don't agree on everything but I 100% agree that there's a surge in the 1%'s asset accumulation right now, at the cost for the other 99%.

The expression is "K shaped recovery" where the prospect for individual households is either rising or falling in a bimodal pattern right now. I believe it's a problem brewing.
 
But what good is their wealth if they don't use it? Do they hide it in a tin box under the the bed? No. They invest it. Without that investment banks wouldn't be able to make loans, business confidence would nosedive and the economy would stall.

Sorry, but that's a load of horse hooey.

The richest people don't have billions in the bank, or billions in investments outside of their own companies, and the ability of banks to lend has nothing to do with it.

There are so many errors in that thinking I'd fall asleep listing them all.

Compared to that, letting a few rich people get even richer is no big deal, and easily corrected for by simply raising their taxes. But even if we don't it's still better than if we cut them out. You only have to look at Venezuela to see what happens when you do that.

Venezuela's situation has everything to do with corruption and nothing to do with taking money off the rich.

Your post is so out of touch I'm wondering if it's a deliberate Poe.

Is there another way? Sure - but the political backlash from implementing full-on socialism would be catastrophic. Like it not, we need to let the rich get richer right now. We can hit them later when the pandemic is over!

Yeah, and that's really going to happen.
 
Venezuela's situation has everything to do with corruption and nothing to do with taking money off the rich.

I've seen some people specifically point out Venezuela's new wealth tax, which is a 2% of certain asset valuations above a multimillion dollar threshold as an example of kleptocracy, but I point out it affects something like 200 Venezuelans, most of whom looted public assets during a previous administration and IMO is pretty reasonable.

If that's the worst case scenario, I'm actually all for it.
 
A land tax is the perfect solution. It will pay the covid debt and remedy the inequity.
 
If you think Cinderella would even think about the idea in her wildest nightmares, you're kidding yourself.

Will not happen.

But you're right.
 
Venezuela's situation has everything to do with corruption and nothing to do with taking money off the rich.
Not true.

How Socialism Destroyed Venezuela
Many in the media have blamed Venezuela’s worsening humanitarian crisis on corruption, mismanagement, falling oil prices, or U.S sanctions—anything but the rise of socialism in what was once the wealthiest country in South America.

Yet corruption and mismanagement were the direct result of increased government control of the economy—socialism—and in reality, lower oil prices and U.S. sanctions have little to do with the crisis. Instead, the mass starvation and exodus faced by Venezuelans are the natural consequence of the socialist policies implemented by dictators Hugo Chavez and Nicolas Maduro...

There are three main policies implemented by Chavez since 1999 that produced the current crisis: Widespread nationalization of private industry, currency and price controls, and the fiscally irresponsible expansion of welfare programs.

One of Chavez’s first actions was to start nationalizing the agriculture sector, supposedly reducing poverty and inequality by taking from rich landowners to give to poor workers. From 1999 to 2016, his regime robbed more than 6 million hectares of land from its rightful owners.

...as state control of the agricultural industry increased, Venezuela’s food production fell 75% in two decades while the country’s population increased by 33%. This was a recipe for shortages and economic disaster. After agriculture, the regime nationalized electricity, water, oil, banks, supermarkets, construction, and other crucial sectors. And in all these sectors, the government increased payrolls and gave away products at low cost, resulting in days-long countrywide blackouts, frequent water service interruptions, falling oil production, and bankrupt government enterprises.

The socialist regime also implemented price ceilings on hundreds of basic products such as beef, milk and toilet paper. At artificially low prices, more people were willing to buy these products but the few private factories left—not nationalized—could not profit at the government-capped price, so they reduced or halted their production. Instead of benefiting the poor, price ceilings predictably resulted in shortages...

In this way, socialism run rampant—not cronyism, corruption, falling oil prices, or U.S. sanctions—caused the crisis in Venezuela. Welfare programs that were supposed to help the poor actually increased the cost of living. A foreign currency control that aimed to reduce inflation only increased it and allowed for massive corruption. And nationalizations that should have given “power” to workers only left them unemployed and hungry.
 
I just moved my superannuation savings out of cash into a balanced fund. With the virus virtually eliminate in Australia and vaccines around the corner I believe this is a safe pathway. I expect to soon be earning 7-8%.
You know that your investments are making rich people richer, right? And if you have significant investments making 7-8% then you are getting richer too. IOW, you're part of the problem, not the solution.

Everyone here who decries 'the rich getting richer' yet is making any amount of money on investments in today's economy is actually making the situation worse. Poor people don't have money to invest, they are ground into an endless cycle of poverty while rich people insist they aren't actually rich and point fingers at a few at the top, while bragging about how much their investments are making.
 
Anyway, the thread's not about them,
No, but it's relevant because it shows that simplistic solutions like robbing the rich and handing out money to the poor don't work in the long run.

The richest people don't have billions in the bank, or billions in investments outside of their own companies, and the ability of banks to lend has nothing to do with it.
The richest people aren't the problem, and while they do have most of their wealth tied up in their businesses that doesn't mean banks have nothing to do with it.

Take Elon Musk for example, who today Passed Bernard Arnault To Become The World’s Second Richest Person. Most of his wealth is tied up in company stock, and few bad decisions or even just bad luck could easily bankrupt him (as it almost did a few years ago). Tesla is worth a lot, but also has a lot of loans to service, payroll to make etc.

If Musk's business goes under then so do the livelihoods of thousands of Tesla employees and other companies they do business with. Imagine Tesla failing because they can't get loans to expand and so can't make new car models, which rich people buy (and so spread their wealth around). You say big deal, Musk's rich so he can afford it - but the effect on the economy of many big businesses going under would be catastrophic. Musk may be staggeringly rich, buts that's no reason to let Tesla fail.

The government could just keep handing out 'stimulus' checks to poor people so they don't need a job, but that wouldn't help in the long run. The economy doesn't work unless businesses are producing goods and services for those unemployed people to buy. That's what happened in Venezuela. Not enough food was being produced, and factory efficiency dropped when they nationalized, resulting in shortages and hyperinflation. 'Printing money' to keep the financial system going works, doing it to prevent shortages due to too few people working doesn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom