Black Swan Event Under Way

I'd like to know how automated production of goods and services affects "the economy", and if "the economy" is ever going to change its definition because of technology making human employees less necessary.

That's probably a subject for a new thread, and I have plenty to say on the subject, so fire away!

Pretty much. We're IN "the new normal".

Jury's still out on that, I reckon. It's a point to look at in six months or so.
 
This month's update on my stocks and shares ISA.

Date | % +/- | Date | % +/-
5.18|1.3|7.20|7.8
8.18|3.4|8.20|8.1
11.18|-3.1|9.20|7.9
2.19|-0.8|10.20|9.9
5.19|1.9|11.20|12.6
8.19|7.4
11.19|6.6
2.20|10.3
3.20|3.7
4.20|-4.9
5.20|0.3
6.20|5.8
 
This month's update on my stocks and shares ISA.

Date | % +/- | Date | % +/-
5.18|1.3|7.20|7.8
8.18|3.4|8.20|8.1
11.18|-3.1|9.20|7.9
2.19|-0.8|10.20|9.9
5.19|1.9|11.20|12.6
8.19|7.4
11.19|6.6
2.20|10.3
3.20|3.7
4.20|-4.9
5.20|0.3
6.20|5.8

Right, I forgot I was going to do my accountability thing too. I only track monthly, but the Nov is as of last weekend. The recent runup is not included:

Jan-20 7%
Feb-20 -8%
Mar-20 -5%
Apr-20 14%
May-20 6%
Jun-20 11%
Jul-20 3%
Aug-20 27%
Sep-20 -7%
Oct-20 -5%
Nov-20 7%

So, net YTD just coasting with no stock picking or market timing is +51%.
 
Expecting a fall in prices, my own year to date would be below the S&P 500, because I have a great deal right now in cash. Fortunately, I did not sell at the trough, but I did sell when prices were a good deal lower than they are now.

Although I did gain some of that back by buying more NVDA when it was a couple of hundred points lower than it is right now, partially making up for other gains I missed out on.
 
I got a call from my brokers, apparently I made so much money their computers busted trying to store the total.
 
Right, I forgot I was going to do my accountability thing too. I only track monthly, but the Nov is as of last weekend. The recent runup is not included:

Jan-20 7%
Feb-20 -8%
Mar-20 -5%
Apr-20 14%
May-20 6%
Jun-20 11%
Jul-20 3%
Aug-20 27%
Sep-20 -7%
Oct-20 -5%
Nov-20 7%

So, net YTD just coasting with no stock picking or market timing is +51%.

Are you saying that if, for example, you started the year with $100,000, you now have $151,000?
 
Something that's been nagging away at me is that the cost of many types of produce is going to go up sharply, due to the lack of people available to pick crops that are harvested by hand.

NZ and Australia are having a major problem, and it's going to impact on both supply and price, and we can't be alone in the world with this problem.
 
Something that's been nagging away at me is that the cost of many types of produce is going to go up sharply, due to the lack of people available to pick crops that are harvested by hand.

NZ and Australia are having a major problem, and it's going to impact on both supply and price, and we can't be alone in the world with this problem.

The kids are alright.
They might wish to pick vegetables and fruit.
 
The kids are alright.
They might wish to pick vegetables and fruit.

They don't. Growers can't get anywhere near enough people. One crowd got 100 campervans for locals to stay in and got a whole two responses.
 
Something that's been nagging away at me is that the cost of many types of produce is going to go up sharply, due to the lack of people available to pick crops that are harvested by hand.

NZ and Australia are having a major problem, and it's going to impact on both supply and price, and we can't be alone in the world with this problem.

You're not alone.

The Northern Hemisphere experienced this, especially in regions/crops that were dependent on migrant temp labour for harvesting.

One element that exacerbates the problem is remuneration. The profitability for the farmers is somewhat dependent on under-the-table sub-minimum-wage costs, which is why domestic labour has lacklustre interest.
 
Last edited:
They don't. Growers can't get anywhere near enough people. One crowd got 100 campervans for locals to stay in and got a whole two responses.

I can't speak to that example, but we had something similar here in the Fraser Valley. "Come pick our cranberries for less than minimum wage, and also we charge more in room and board than we're offering in salary. We'll accept a cheque."
 

Having said that... I *have* been contributing biweekly, so maybe all of that 51% is new contributions for all anybody here knows.

"On the Internet nobody knows if you're a dog beginning investor."
 
I can't speak to that example, but we had something similar here in the Fraser Valley. "Come pick our cranberries for less than minimum wage, and also we charge more in room and board than we're offering in salary. We'll accept a cheque."

The NZ example is exactly the opposite - 25% more than minimum wage, and 50% discount on the campervans.

If it's a worldwide problem, it's going to price fresh produce out of the market for low-income earners.

Exactly what the world needs.
 
The NZ example is exactly the opposite - 25% more than minimum wage, and 50% discount on the campervans.

Still need to see the numbers to understand if rejection is a rational economic behaviour on the labourers' part.

If 50% reduction in housing still doesn't cover their costs (if they're being asked to move, they need to pay for their existing housing on top of the temporary domiciles, and may have to pay for daycare since their kids probably can't relocate), then it's entirely rational to decline.

50% off four times the going rate is 2x the going rate, IOW.


If it's a worldwide problem, it's going to price fresh produce out of the market for low-income earners.

There's definitely been a documented price increase, but hard to say if it becomes exclusive, it's been in in the less than 5% YOY price increase range for the last two quarters, and mostly impacts specific crops that have a high manual labour component. Locally here in Vancouver, that's cranberries and hops, for example.
 
Last edited:
Still need to see the numbers to understand if rejection is a rational economic behaviour on the labourers' part.

The available people are students about to take summer holidays and youth unemployed, who almost exclusively live with their parents, and for those people, the only economic result is they'd be 1-200% better off picking fruit than sitting on the dole.

It's never going to appeal to people with families.

50% off four times the going rate is 2x the going rate, IOW.

Nicely cynical, but it was a genuine 50% decrease on quite low rates already and was done in conjunction with the most-reputable labour company.

Locally here in Vancouver, that's cranberries and hops, for example.

Now, that's getting to the disastrous territory - it might impact the price of beer!

I think it's mainly fruit at stake, and that's something that's often priced out of limited budgets, so I hope it doesn't get out of control. One encouraging sign is that it's strawberry season and they're 100% hand-picked and the price is matching last year at this stage.
 
The available people are students about to take summer holidays and youth unemployed, who almost exclusively live with their parents, and for those people, the only economic result is they'd be 1-200% better off picking fruit than sitting on the dole.

It's never going to appeal to people with families.

I still prefer to judge with real numbers.

I got a lot of grief for not participating in a local tradition of tree planting. But at the end of the day, the numbers just didn't work out, especially for my friends who were not physically very fit. The transportation costs to and from the camps, and the medical bills to recover from strain injuries, put them further behind than if they hadn't worked and impacted their ability to find better work.

Or, to put this another way: the lack of applicants tells me the offer was too low. (I say this as a hiring manager)
 
Or, to put this another way: the lack of applicants tells me the offer was too low.

That's like telling me pedestrian crossings are black and white.

Clearly, there's an amount that would encourage people to do it, but that's far in excess of what it's worth, so we will end up with higher prices.
 
That's like telling me pedestrian crossings are black and white.

I was trying to steer toward, "Those kids aren't suckers, you'll have to pay a fair price," and away from a "Those kids are lazy welfare bums and I want them to work at a loss so I can pay less at the till," kind of conversation.

To reiterate, up here in BC, the labour shortage is due to barriers to international temporary workers (who don't know their rights and end up getting underpaid) being able to migrate into the area at critical harvest periods, not because kids are suddenly lazy with the Cov.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom