Black Swan Event Under Way

They're all on some very strong drugs, mate.

The maths doesn't lie, and there's only one way it can go, and that's down.

I suspect a lot of the action right now is maximising tax losses to take advantage of the US gov't funding $1.7M to everyone earning more than $1M/pa.

As one of the guys posted a few days ago, it's easy to spend when the cost of funds is zero.

US unemployment hits 22M and the market goes up?
 
What is the "it" that can only go down? The stock market? Because there is no math that shows that.

Yes, I'm talking about the sharemarket, and with unemployment and contraction of GDP across the world, the maths is dead easy - the market can only go down.

What you're seeing is the result of a massive funds injection into Americans' pockets combined with blind optimism and a total lack of understanding of the maths.

Did the sharemarkets recover after the GFC the way they are now? Nope.

So why is it now? People are scared, and a way of trying to overcome that fear is to be optimistic. It's exactly the same as buying 500 rolls of toilet paper.
 
Yes, I'm talking about the sharemarket, and with unemployment and contraction of GDP across the world, the maths is dead easy - the market can only go down.

What you're seeing is the result of a massive funds injection into Americans' pockets combined with blind optimism and a total lack of understanding of the maths.

What "math" are you talking about? You haven't provided any.

And there is no math that says the market can only go down.
 
My mom's portfolio manager called yesterday. My portfolio too. This bank has a lot of very wealthy clients; we're just middle-class investors. So we're not super-important clients. I decided at least a month ago, probably six weeks, to stay the course, not because I was particularly hopeful but because the alternative to equities didn't seem all that great either. I didn't want cash, real estate, gold, or guns, ammo and canned goods. (Except for maybe the canned goods).

She seemed relieved at my laidback attitude. I appreciated her call, which seemed almost totally social. I thought when Mom died (she's 95) her stuff all had to be liquidated, but it doesn't. I'm underemployed but still hope to avoid raiding my IRA. My "good" job disappeared in the last recession and I don't think I'll save a whole lot more money, but with no pressing need to sell things off in the next year or two I'm riding it out just because I'm not sure what else to do.
 
My mom's portfolio manager called yesterday. My portfolio too. This bank has a lot of very wealthy clients; we're just middle-class investors. So we're not super-important clients. I decided at least a month ago, probably six weeks, to stay the course, not because I was particularly hopeful but because the alternative to equities didn't seem all that great either. I didn't want cash, real estate, gold, or guns, ammo and canned goods. (Except for maybe the canned goods).

She seemed relieved at my laidback attitude. I appreciated her call, which seemed almost totally social. I thought when Mom died (she's 95) her stuff all had to be liquidated, but it doesn't. I'm underemployed but still hope to avoid raiding my IRA. My "good" job disappeared in the last recession and I don't think I'll save a whole lot more money, but with no pressing need to sell things off in the next year or two I'm riding it out just because I'm not sure what else to do.

My wife's an MD, so her account manager / investment advisor is calling weekly. I'm guessing some of his clients are freaking out. Not us, we're like you.

Also: gold bugs have been knocking door to door here, trying to sell us their worthless mine stocks.
 
Hedge funds are indeed very profitable for those who run them, but not necessarily for those who invest in them.

Then again, they're not really designed to outperform the market on a regular basis. The clue is in the name, they're there to provide a hedge against failure in regular investments.

This article highlights that 2019 was the first year in which hedge funds on average beat the market for 5 years. Of course individual funds can beat the market, sometimes for long periods of time but they tend to revert to the mean in the long term.

https://www.barrons.com/articles/he...-for-the-first-time-in-five-years-51553284144

One interesting exercise that was cancelled a couple of years ago was the Canadian newspaper called the Financial Post, they did a running experiment annually where they got a wind up santa toy, laid out their stock list pages from their paper on the floor, wound it up a bit, and bought the stock it finally settled on when the spring wound down.

The toy consistently outperformed managed funds, and on average, matched the TSX performance. However, the gag was shelved when funds organized and threatened to pull their advertising. Notably, they didn't threat to sue for libel. They probably knew the facts were true, just not helpful.
 
Yes, I'm talking about the sharemarket, and with unemployment and contraction of GDP across the world, the maths is dead easy - the market can only go down.


No in this case, you are wrong. There's no maths that determine short term market prices. It's psychology.


One of the things I took away from that book on corporate finance that I read was how to value securities, and there is indeed math, or maths, that dictate that. The fair value of a security is equal to the net present value of all future cash flows generated by that security. That's the math. The problem is that with stocks, it's impossible to know the future cash flows that the stock will generate, so you can't actually do any better than estimate the price based on what you think the future cash flows will be. However, one thing is fairly certain, those cash flows will be generated over 10, or 50, or 100 years, not over the next six months.

Profits will go down over the next six months. That much is clear. However, what they will do over the next five years is not so predictable.
 
Hedge funds are indeed very profitable for those who run them, but not necessarily for those who invest in them.

Then again, they're not really designed to outperform the market on a regular basis. The clue is in the name, they're there to provide a hedge against failure in regular investments.

This article highlights that 2019 was the first year in which hedge funds on average beat the market for 5 years. Of course individual funds can beat the market, sometimes for long periods of time but they tend to revert to the mean in the long term.

https://www.barrons.com/articles/he...-for-the-first-time-in-five-years-51553284144

Hedge funds are mostly profitable for their managers due to the two and twenty fee structures. They started back in the 40s using market neutral techniques which is where they got the name, but most of them haven't been hedged or market neutral for a long time and they're really just best seen as alternative (and usually bad) investments. There may be some diversification benefit in some of them, but...
 
Last edited:
No in this case, you are wrong. There's no maths that determine short term market prices. It's psychology.


One of the things I took away from that book on corporate finance that I read was how to value securities, and there is indeed math, or maths, that dictate that. The fair value of a security is equal to the net present value of all future cash flows generated by that security. That's the math. The problem is that with stocks, it's impossible to know the future cash flows that the stock will generate, so you can't actually do any better than estimate the price based on what you think the future cash flows will be. However, one thing is fairly certain, those cash flows will be generated over 10, or 50, or 100 years, not over the next six months.

Profits will go down over the next six months. That much is clear. However, what they will do over the next five years is not so predictable.

This is why - and I don't want to come across as singling you out on this, it's just that you were obliging enough to present a strategy and its rationale earlier - this is why I don't think this is the time to value search.

Specifically, I'm referring to the idea that this would be a time to sort out the companies that might bounce back earlier from those that might languish longer, or fail outright. The problems are psychological here too. You're not the only one thinking this, for one thing. The disproportionate demand will neutralize the discount, they will be fairly priced or overpriced.

Secondly, the market as a whole already has a baked in future discounting. This means that there's *already* a bias toward overvaluing nearer term earnings vs long recoveries, further overpricing those stocks that are going to recover earlier.

This doesn't mean I think you're making a mistake - just that stock valuations involve too many recursive game theory scenarios, and ultimately I think this just means performance is unpredictable and lean toward broad index funds as the best way to mitigate this.
 
What "math" are you talking about? You haven't provided any.

I most certainly did.

The IMF is predicting a decline in GDP, to the tune of nine trillion dollars: https://blogs.imf.org/2020/04/14/th...economic-downturn-since-the-great-depression/

USA already has unemployment at never before seen levels, with 22 million already out of work, and that number will climb considerably.

That means far reduced earnings, and that means less value in shares.

No in this case, you are wrong. There's no maths that determine short term market prices. It's psychology.

Nope - the psychology is driving it up, reality says it goes down.

The fair value of a security is equal to the net present value of all future cash flows generated by that security.

If you think earnings will only be impacted for six months, I'd say you're well short. I think the IMF's prediction is overly optimistic as well. I've already stated the world economy's hit will be more like $20T and I'll stick with that.

This is only the very start - even if you allow for 100 times as many cases as currently showing, that is a mere 3% of the world's population, and I don't think the factor is anywhere close to 100 times. Based on current evidence, it's 5-10 times more, so probably as little as 0.3% of the population has been infected so far.

The idea that there's any value in shares in the Dow while America isn't even close to having the epidemic under control is laughable.

Give it time. I'll be happy to revisit these numbers in a year. Much like arguments over the number of people Covid's killing, I see no point arguing about it when we'll have the proof of what actually happened.
 
I most certainly did.

The IMF is predicting a decline in GDP, to the tune of nine trillion dollars: https://blogs.imf.org/2020/04/14/th...economic-downturn-since-the-great-depression/

USA already has unemployment at never before seen levels, with 22 million already out of work, and that number will climb considerably.

That means far reduced earnings, and that means less value in shares.

Which we see already. Why would it go down further?



Nope - the psychology is driving it up, reality says it goes down.

Why?



If you think earnings will only be impacted for six months, I'd say you're well short. I think the IMF's prediction is overly optimistic as well. I've already stated the world economy's hit will be more like $20T and I'll stick with that.

OK, so it's not 'the' numbers - it's your gut feeling?

...The idea that there's any value in shares in the Dow while America isn't even close to having the epidemic under control is laughable.

Do you mean, the valuation should be $0?



Give it time. I'll be happy to revisit these numbers in a year. Much like arguments over the number of people Covid's killing, I see no point arguing about it when we'll have the proof of what actually happened.

Hm. That seems to contradict what you've been doing in the thread, which is forecasting.
 
I was asking for the math being talked about here:

Yes, I'm talking about the sharemarket, and with unemployment and contraction of GDP across the world, the maths is dead easy - the market can only go down.

I was expecting actual math, like equations and stuff showing that the market can only go down.

Also in the same comment above you said that the recent market gains were due to "blind optimism and a total lack of understanding of the maths." Do your math equations not account for blind optimism and other investors not understanding math? If so, they're probably not going to be very effective at predicting the movements of the markets, let alone showing that the market can only go down!
 
The IMF is predicting a decline in GDP, to the tune of nine trillion dollars: https://blogs.imf.org/2020/04/14/th...economic-downturn-since-the-great-depression/

USA already has unemployment at never before seen levels, with 22 million already out of work, and that number will climb considerably.

That means far reduced earnings, and that means less value in shares.
It's pathetic that the health of a country's economy is defined by 'GDP' and 'the share market'.

Yes, there a 22 million people out of work, but this time it's different. People aren't out of work due to shenanigans in the finance industry, or lack of demand, or lazyness. They are staying at home to stop people dying. This 'unemployment' is quite different to normal, and will be a net positive in the long run. The alternative would be much worse.

The nearest equivalent I can think of is WW2. We took an enormous hit as resources were diverted to fighting off the axis powers, but afterwards achieved long periods of economic expansion, increased employment and improved living standards. The same thing will happen when this is all over (assuming we don't screw it up and lose the fight).

There's a big shakeup going on right now. When we get through it a lot of things will have changed. Some industries will be gutted, while others find new ways to expand. But in the end we still have everything we need for a solid economy - plenty of natural resources, advanced technology, a healthy population, and sufficient demand to bring it all together. As people are now having to live on less they may continue to do so, and that may also be a good thing. Money spent on over-consumption is wasted, and hurts us more than we know.

If GDP is a bit lower than it was or speculators don't make as much on the stock market it might even be for the best. The virus has shown that we can survive without these 'indicators', and we might even look towards a future where we aren't slaves to them. Governments around the World have stepped in to control the supply of goods and services because private enterprise could not, proving that the 'invisible hand' is a myth. Some countries are now trying out universal basic incomes, where the unemployed are no longer treated like they have some kind of moral failing.

These are changes that we will need to implement in the future anyway when robots take over our jobs etc., only the virus has made it acutely necessary. Just a pity so many people have to die to show us the way.
 
Last edited:
Not my site, but people I've interacted with through a shared intersection of skepticism and personal finance.
(and they're also Canadian)... are the Rational Reminder podcasters.

Link: [Rational Reminder podcast]

Episode 90, "Bear markets: always different, always the same" seems on topic.
 
Which we see already. Why would it go down further?

Because the current dead cat bull is being driven by hope and is ignoring those fundamentals.

OK, so it's not 'the' numbers - it's your gut feeling?

Nothing to do with gut feeling - the numbers are obvious. Some people take longer to figure them out. The IMF forecast assumes a return to "normality" in Q2, and nothing I've seen indicates that is even remotely likely.

People are basing their buying on thinking we're at the peak, which ignores the example of Italy, where they're a month into extreme lockdowns and have barely managed to reduce infections & deaths.

Do you mean, the valuation should be $0?

Clearly not.

You really do seem to be being deliberately disingenuous here, but hey, it's free to type, so be my guest.

Hm. That seems to contradict what you've been doing in the thread, which is forecasting.

There's more confirmation of that idea, because it's a complete mis-representation.

I'm saying I've made my prediction and the time to worry about it being right or not is when things do return to the prior normal.

Also in the same comment above you said that the recent market gains were due to "blind optimism and a total lack of understanding of the maths."

Again, the proof of that will be where the market goes from here.

If it shrugs off any further effects of the downturn, I'll have been wrong and will gladly say so.
 
Again, the proof of that will be where the market goes from here.

If it shrugs off any further effects of the downturn, I'll have been wrong and will gladly say so.

No, where the market goes from here won't prove anything. We're not disagreeing about the direction the market is going to go, but on whether or not there is any math according to which it "can only go down". I maintain there isn't, and your mathless posts are starting so suggest I'm right.

ETA: In fact, it looks like the market has gone up since your statement. Using the Wilshire 5K as a proxy for "the market".
 
Last edited:
Reminds me of John Bogle's Investment advice of "don't do something, just stand there!"

I'm taking a similar approach and being pretty passive with my investments.

I'm going with the "bury my head in the sand" approach, and just pretending that I don't have any investments. I'll look at them in a couple of years I suppose.
:boxedin:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom