Black Swan Event Under Way

Because the current dead cat bull is being driven by hope and is ignoring those fundamentals.

How do you know this? Is this a fact or are you just describing a personal hypothesis?



Nothing to do with gut feeling - the numbers are obvious. Some people take longer to figure them out. The IMF forecast assumes a return to "normality" in Q2, and nothing I've seen indicates that is even remotely likely.

OK, so... what numbers? You're saying that the IMF's numbers are wrong. So, not *those* nubmers. How do you pick and choose numbers? This is where I was going with the 'is it your gut feeling' question.



People are basing their buying on thinking we're at the peak, which ignores the example of Italy, where they're a month into extreme lockdowns and have barely managed to reduce infections & deaths.

Mm. Not necessarily. I don't buy based on anything, for example. Many investors analyze with a very long term amortization. As mentioned above, my investment timeline is 45 years at this point.



Clearly not.

It's not clear, since you literally said the idea they had 'any value' was laughable - your text is confusing.



You really do seem to be being deliberately disingenuous here, but hey, it's free to type, so be my guest.

I am not being deliberate. You said in that post that there's no point in forecasting... in a thread where you've been forecasting and defending the principle of forecasting as an investment strategy.



There's more confirmation of that idea, because it's a complete mis-representation.

I'm saying I've made my prediction and the time to worry about it being right or not is when things do return to the prior normal.

I appreciate the explanation. It makes more sense now.



Again, the proof of that will be where the market goes from here.

If it shrugs off any further effects of the downturn, I'll have been wrong and will gladly say so.

My position was not that the market will go up or down; but rather, that when predictions are fulfilled, it's chance rather than ability.

If the market performs as you expect, how would you distinguish between being correct through your analysis vs being correct by chance?


As I was saying earlier: my approach to investing was informed over the years through skepticism, and I have a lot of analogies with claims like water witching or remote viewing. The claimants are correct some of the time, just by chance. The challenge is to build an experiment to distinguish between when the hits are chance vs demonstration of ability.

How would you propose we test the hypothesis that you can guage market value?
 
Last edited:
I'm going with the "bury my head in the sand" approach, and just pretending that I don't have any investments. I'll look at them in a couple of years I suppose.
:boxedin:

I have a tendency to watch my investments much more closely in bull markets than in bear markets.
 
It's pathetic that the health of a country's economy is defined by 'GDP' and 'the share market'.

How else do you want to define it?

Number of people living in relative poverty? Number of millionaires?

Yes, there a 22 million people out of work, but this time it's different. People aren't out of work due to shenanigans in the finance industry, or lack of demand, or lazyness. They are staying at home to stop people dying. This 'unemployment' is quite different to normal, and will be a net positive in the long run.

How long is the long run?

When will the hotels & restaurants re-open? When will international air travel resume?

In the medium term - 2 years, say - the unemployment numbers in America will be mind-boggling. If you think the end of the virus will mean a quick return to the previous normal, I think you're wrong.

The alternative would be much worse.

Which alternative do you mean?

The nearest equivalent I can think of is WW2.

A much better guide is the 1929 depression, which is why IMF use it as a guide rather than WWII. Once the war ended, demand responded immediately. If the virus died out tomorrow, I'd suggest air travel would still take months to return to normal, and it doesn't show any signs of miraculous disappearance so far.

Some countries are now trying out universal basic incomes, where the unemployed are no longer treated like they have some kind of moral failing.

Sure, some countries have provided much saner responses than others.

Whether it leads to lasting, positive change, I wouldn't be betting my life on it. I suspect the recovery will be the worst thing that ever happened, as CO2 and other climate-negative emissions will skyrocket due to infrastructure spending on oil- and coal-dependent projects.
 
I have a tendency to watch my investments much more closely in bull markets than in bear markets.

I'm the opposite lately, because I participate in communities that talk about investing and early retirement, and I want to demonstrate that I practice what I preach. I provide weekly updates even though the information is all out there for people to confirm independently.

As of this morning, I'm down 5% from my absolute peak, and rolled back to January's valuation, so only a few months' growth lost. And this is with zero speculation or market timing or fancy options trading or leverage or anything like that. And I just have a boring middle class job at the phone company, no high earning IT stuff.

I'm about 2 years into the 3 year hours requirement for taking the CFP exam, which I am looking forward to doing as a side gig after taking pension at my current employer in about 2 years.
 
It's pathetic that the health of a country's economy is defined by 'GDP' and 'the share market'.

This is a misunderstanding: market performance is not strongly linked to GDP.

In fact, most of the research shows that the weak linkage is slightly negative: your share performance is slightly negatively correlated with GDP growth.
 
A much better guide is the 1929 depression, which is why IMF use it as a guide rather than WWII. Once the war ended, demand responded immediately. If the virus died out tomorrow, I'd suggest air travel would still take months to return to normal, and it doesn't show any signs of miraculous disappearance so far.

That's not the reason they chose the depression vs WWII, and the IMF explained their rationale.

Specifically, WWII destroyed capital, which needed investment to replace it. And to correct your statement above, the economy didn't bounce back immediately after WWII. The global economy was in a depression until arguably well into the maybe 1952ish because of productivity constraints. This disanalogy is why IMF thought it was a poor comparison. The factories aren't bombed to ash, they're just idle, like in the depression.

Resuming productivity will not be quick or easy, but it's not going to require a Marshall Plan.

The influence on stock prices is: what's the impact to future earnings? There's an argument that the current stock prices reflect a calculation based on available information, and they aren't over or under valued. They will probably continue to fluctuate as novel information comes available.

The keyword there is 'novel'. Bad news announcements that are expected have already been priced in. They're just validations to investors who have already made estimates that match. And sometimes bad news is a little less bad than expected, so the novel information is net positive and prices might rise after a bad announcement to accommodate.

We experienced a period of speculation and confusion with conflicting and widely ranging forecasts for awhile, and we saw a 25% plunge in US equities. Uncertainty increases the risk premium, which affects prices, but it also flushes out the people who were at too high a risk level as they panic sell. It's possible that this was too pessimistic and emotional, and now we're seeing a partial and more rational recovery and stablization as more consistent economic forecasts are emerging. ie: maybe it's only a 15% hit to forward earnings instead of 25%.

I'm not saying any of these things are true, but hopefully demonstrating that whatever happens, we can spin a story about it, like the diviners when they succeed or fail.
 
Last edited:
And to correct your statement above, the economy didn't bounce back immediately after WWII.

You're correcting a statement I didn't make.

I specifically said demand returned immediately.

The factories aren't bombed to ash, they're just idle, like in the depression.

Really? American factories were bombed to ash?

What years were American factories bombed?

Resuming productivity will not be quick or easy, but it's not going to require a Marshall Plan.

Kind of is, though, because spending on infrastructure projects is exactly the same.

I'm not saying any of these things are true...

This is why I say let's wait & see. With all of 1% of the world's population infected so far - at the highest possible estimate - we're a long way from the end of the tunnel.
 
You're correcting a statement I didn't make.

I specifically said demand returned immediately.

But it didn't. Demand is measured in dollars, there was widespread unemployment, poverty and starvation, demand plummeted. Global GDP dropped considerably, IIRC 1947 was the low point in that decade. It definitely was for Canada and Australia. I used to collect coins as a kid, and 1947s are among the rarest. The mint almost shut down, there was so little commerce, so little need for new coins, the natural shrinkage of recovering damaged coins wasn't reducing the currency fast enough to accommodate the contracting economy.




Really? American factories were bombed to ash?

What years were American factories bombed?

Of course not. The postwar recession was global, the capital investment requirements that were sponging up US resources were being spent in Europe and Asia instead of domestically.

The wealth drain was experienced without even one bombing here, but it was obviously worse outside NA. England didn't cease rationing until 1952, which is where I got my round numbers in the previous post. There is an argument that the British WWII economic slump from slow capital replacement continued into the 1970s.



Kind of is, though, because spending on infrastructure projects is exactly the same.

I don't understand what you mean. Same as what? Military occupations of defeated rivals?



In any case, it's not me you're arguing with. I'm conveying the IMF's rationale for choosing the Great Depression as a better analogy for COVID19 than WWII. Capital is idle, but not destroyed. Employing strategies for maintaining liquidity make more sense than strategies of new capital investment, is their advice.




This is why I say let's wait & see. With all of 1% of the world's population infected so far - at the highest possible estimate - we're a long way from the end of the tunnel.

For sure, there's going to be an impact felt for years, possibly forever, but I really feel we're having different conversations here.
 
This is a misunderstanding: market performance is not strongly linked to GDP.
I didn't say it was. 'Market performance' and GDP are not the same, and neither of them measure real economic health.

Problem is, people think they do. Governments make decisions based on them, and voters decide who to put in power depending on them. But when the stock market is running up it is in a bubble that will soon crash, and when it isn't we are in a recession or worse (yes, shares not going up or down is the worst possible scenario - according to share market speculators).

GDP keeps going up mainly because the population keeps going up. This 'growth' does more harm than good. All it does is burn up finite resources faster and push us closer to destruction. But 'investors' don't care. The only thing they care about is seeing their bank balance go up. They would sacrifice anything to that. Then they convince us that this is what matters.

In fact, most of the research shows that the weak linkage is slightly negative: your share performance is slightly negatively correlated with GDP growth.
Share performance should be related to business activity. But due to all the speculation it is essentially random, determined more by 'sentiment' than actual performance. This then affects business activity, creating an unstable feedback loop that causes the 'business cycle' of boom and bust - for no real reason. GDP is obviously related to this, but not directly due to delays in the feedback loop.

If GDP went down permanently it could be a good thing, because it indicates lower consumption and less destruction. Over-consumption is killing the environment and us. The lockdowns we have been forced to implement to avoid dying are doing more to improve the environment and our health than any of the pathetic plans we attempted to implement before, and yet it hasn't caused the economy to implode. I knew it wouldn't of course, because when something needs to be done it gets done.

But investors are beside themselves worrying about whether their nest eggs will go down in 'value'. Because you see, if you don't have an ever-increasing fortune tucked away (for a future you may never see) then you are ruined.
 
With all of 1% of the world's population infected so far - at the highest possible estimate - we're a long way from the end of the tunnel.
Yeah, let's wait until everybody is infected and 30% die. Then what would would we have? For the survivors, plenty of light at the end of the tunnel!

How did the Bubonic Plague make the Italian Renaissance possible?
The Black Death marked an end of an era in Italy, its impact was profound, and it resulted in wide-ranging social, economic, cultural and religious changes. These changes, directly and indirectly, led to the emergence of the Renaissance, one of the greatest epochs for art, architecture, and literature in human history.

The social consequences of the plague on society came to be profound. The high mortality rate resulted in a drastic decline in the labor force. Wages rose for both agricultural and urban workers. The survivors of the Black Death generally had a higher standard of living than before the plague. This was a phenomenon that occurred in both urban and rural areas. The crisis caused by the Black Death led to many changes in the economy, in response to the fall in the population. Because of the labor shortages, there was a move from labor-intensive farming such as cereal to livestock and increase both in industry and agriculture more labor-saving devices employed.

But we don't have to wait until millions have died to achieve our own 'Renaissance' - just a realization that there could be a better way. Perhaps when this 'black swan' event is over some real positive change will have occurred - if we were open to it.
 
GDP keeps going up mainly because the population keeps going up.

This depends on the country, which is where I was mainly going with the disengagement of GDP and stock markets. Countries with rapidly increasing standards of living see a corresponding GDP growth. In these developing regions, GDP growth does seem to genuinely represent improved quality of life.

But their stock markets don't do better than developed countries. This is the investment myth I was trying to correct.

The mechanisms are related to this covid19 situation... expanding economies have rising demand for goods. The economy responds in two ways: the companies producing goods in a sector needs to grow production, so they issue more shares to raise capital. Growth, yes, but no increase in share price. Second type of response is a new entrant into the sector that competes with the incumbants, and the overall profitability may even decline with a growing demand as competition increases, share price may even go down.



This 'growth' does more harm than good. All it does is burn up finite resources faster and push us closer to destruction. But 'investors' don't care. The only thing they care about is seeing their bank balance go up. They would sacrifice anything to that. Then they convince us that this is what matters.

Share performance should be related to business activity. But due to all the speculation it is essentially random, determined more by 'sentiment' than actual performance. This then affects business activity, creating an unstable feedback loop that causes the 'business cycle' of boom and bust - for no real reason. GDP is obviously related to this, but not directly due to delays in the feedback loop.

If GDP went down permanently it could be a good thing, because it indicates lower consumption and less destruction. Over-consumption is killing the environment and us. The lockdowns we have been forced to implement to avoid dying are doing more to improve the environment and our health than any of the pathetic plans we attempted to implement before, and yet it hasn't caused the economy to implode. I knew it wouldn't of course, because when something needs to be done it gets done.

It's hard to say re whether rising/falling GDP would be a long term plus here in 2020, given that such a significant portion of GDP in developed nations is service rather than physical goods. I'd be fine with an increase in GDP if we're all spending it on learning to play the violin &c.

I'm definitely an investor, and I don't even own a car, the hope being to reduce my ecological impact and leave a better world for my grandchildren.

It's not an us vs them situation.



But investors are beside themselves worrying about whether their nest eggs will go down in 'value'. Because you see, if you don't have an ever-increasing fortune tucked away (for a future you may never see) then you are ruined.

In their defense, most investors are pension funds or equivalent, and I think people who've laboured for half a century deserve a comfortable retirement.
 
But we don't have to wait until millions have died to achieve our own 'Renaissance' - just a realization that there could be a better way. Perhaps when this 'black swan' event is over some real positive change will have occurred - if we were open to it.

I'm being guarded but hopeful about that. My day job is at a telco, and we're working double shifts to get people set up in work from home configurations. I think a lot of them will stay this way after they're able to return to the office. 90% of these people always wanted to work from home anyway.

Especially once kids are back in school, that's the main objection I'm hearing from WFH clients at the moment. Which I get. My cats drive me nuts, I can't imagine what toddlers are doing to productivity.

Not specifically about my work, but connected via my side gig (writing fiction), I was watching a Q&A in reddit hosted by an author I follow and he was trying to do the chat while watching his daughter. He had it on speech to text, which was his first mistake.

Link: [We are Crit Faced! Ask Us Anything!]

Excerpt:
Considering my two-year-old daughter, the most useless word in the English language is the word No. A close second is the word please. And coming in third is the compound phrase oh my god oh no oh no oh no.
I usually right during Maddys naps, which she stops taking a while back, and in the late afternoon when my wife gets off of work. It’s crunchy because it’s a bug. This this is a butterfly.
No we can’t play on the table. It’s not safe. It’s not a safe place to play. As we play on the floor. Which is safe. I think my proudest moment as a writer, who is probably I don’t know Maddie we can’t play on the table. Let’s get down. Down the floor. That’s not safe. I think my proudest moment was probably I don’t know I can’t think of anything I’m proud of right now maybe I don’t know
I can’t ride without noise canceling headphones and a brown paper bag to scream into.
I would just like to finish this book
 
Yeah, let's wait until everybody is infected and 30% die. Then what would would we have? For the survivors, plenty of light at the end of the tunnel!

Best non sequitur I've seen in a while.

If you think that statement is relevant to anything in the thread, or that I've posted, do let me know.

But we don't have to wait until millions have died to achieve our own 'Renaissance' - just a realization that there could be a better way. Perhaps when this 'black swan' event is over some real positive change will have occurred - if we were open to it.

While I agree with your wish, I'm not holding my breath for it.
 
So, crude oil is now trading at $1.50 a barrel. Thats what about 3.5 cents a gallon! Lowest price before today in inflation adjusted dollars, since WW2 was around $17 a barrel!!!

Too bad there doesn't seem to be a good way for an ordinary person to invest in crude. The ETF USO is just a money loser long term.

ETA: now 80 cents a barrel!

ETA2: lol negative $20 something a barrel now.
 
Last edited:
So, crude oil is now trading at $1.50 a barrel. Thats what about 3.5 cents a gallon! Lowest price before today in inflation adjusted dollars, since WW2 was around $17 a barrel!!!

Too bad there doesn't seem to be a good way for an ordinary person to invest in crude. The ETF USO is just a money loser long term.

ETA: now 80 cents a barrel!

ETA2: lol negative $20 something a barrel now.

oh -$20 a barrel that's so 15 minutes or so ago it's now hit -$40.32:

https://www.ft.com/content/a5292644-958d-4065-92e8-ace55d766654

ETA although Brent crude is still at a heady +$25
 
Last edited:
oh -$20 a barrel that's so 15 minutes or so ago it's now hit -$40.32:

https://www.ft.com/content/a5292644-958d-4065-92e8-ace55d766654

ETA although Brent crude is still at a heady +$25

Thats only if you compare "apples to oranges".

The June contract for both Brent and WTI is trading in the $20's. Its the May contract for WTI that is below zero.

https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/CLK20/overview (May)

https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/CB*0/futures-prices (June)
https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/CLM20/futures-prices (June)

Futures markets are very different from equities. Its more like options with contracts expiring periodically usually monthly. I can't find any pricing for Brent for May, I guess its already expired. They have different cutoff dates?
 
I don't understand the commodities market.


(I have to wonder if somehow this is algorithm driven trading, and the programmers just didn't anticipate the possibility of this sort of event.)

Doesnt seem to be. Its that demand is so low that theres no place left to store crude oil. So its gone negative, IE we won't even take this stuff for free, but you can pay us to store it if you want.
 
I don't understand the commodities market.

(I have to wonder if somehow this is algorithm driven trading, and the programmers just didn't anticipate the possibility of this sort of event.)

No, it's consumption-driven added to over-production, courtesy one Mr V Putin. The appetite for oil right now is close to zero. No planes, infinitely fewer cars, shipping down...

I think MBS must have upset Vlad somewhere recently, because the high fives from last year seem to have been replaced by Vlad showing the finger to Saudi's pleas for production cuts, although he has joined them when it was too late to matter.

There must be an immense amount of oil stored around the world right now. Good business to be in for the next year or so - if you know anyone with a couple of million gallons of spare storage, let me know!

And the current price of oil is below zero for the first time in history - they are indeed paying you to take it off their hands:

https://www.ft.com/content/a5292644-958d-4065-92e8-ace55d766654

And no, I am not sorry about that at all.
 
Thats only if you compare "apples to oranges".

The June contract for both Brent and WTI is trading in the $20's. Its the May contract for WTI that is below zero.

https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/CLK20/overview (May)

https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/CB*0/futures-prices (June)
https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/CLM20/futures-prices (June)

Futures markets are very different from equities. Its more like options with contracts expiring periodically usually monthly. I can't find any pricing for Brent for May, I guess its already expired. They have different cutoff dates?

I may be wrong but I think Brent is still well in the positive due to storage capacity at least according to the FT:

https://markets.ft.com/data/commodities

Although I'll admit my understanding of the various bits of the oil market is next to zero so I may well be reading the market data wrong
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom