blutoski
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2006
- Messages
- 12,454
Because the current dead cat bull is being driven by hope and is ignoring those fundamentals.
How do you know this? Is this a fact or are you just describing a personal hypothesis?
Nothing to do with gut feeling - the numbers are obvious. Some people take longer to figure them out. The IMF forecast assumes a return to "normality" in Q2, and nothing I've seen indicates that is even remotely likely.
OK, so... what numbers? You're saying that the IMF's numbers are wrong. So, not *those* nubmers. How do you pick and choose numbers? This is where I was going with the 'is it your gut feeling' question.
People are basing their buying on thinking we're at the peak, which ignores the example of Italy, where they're a month into extreme lockdowns and have barely managed to reduce infections & deaths.
Mm. Not necessarily. I don't buy based on anything, for example. Many investors analyze with a very long term amortization. As mentioned above, my investment timeline is 45 years at this point.
Clearly not.
It's not clear, since you literally said the idea they had 'any value' was laughable - your text is confusing.
You really do seem to be being deliberately disingenuous here, but hey, it's free to type, so be my guest.
I am not being deliberate. You said in that post that there's no point in forecasting... in a thread where you've been forecasting and defending the principle of forecasting as an investment strategy.
There's more confirmation of that idea, because it's a complete mis-representation.
I'm saying I've made my prediction and the time to worry about it being right or not is when things do return to the prior normal.
I appreciate the explanation. It makes more sense now.
Again, the proof of that will be where the market goes from here.
If it shrugs off any further effects of the downturn, I'll have been wrong and will gladly say so.
My position was not that the market will go up or down; but rather, that when predictions are fulfilled, it's chance rather than ability.
If the market performs as you expect, how would you distinguish between being correct through your analysis vs being correct by chance?
As I was saying earlier: my approach to investing was informed over the years through skepticism, and I have a lot of analogies with claims like water witching or remote viewing. The claimants are correct some of the time, just by chance. The challenge is to build an experiment to distinguish between when the hits are chance vs demonstration of ability.
How would you propose we test the hypothesis that you can guage market value?
Last edited: