Black Swan Event Under Way

Bubbles that are going to burst.

Sports in general are in trouble but the Football/Soccer bubble has been overinflated to a ridiculous extent for years.

Excuse me while I go find some crying towels.

I see UK soccer is already 5 billion pounds down the drain.
 
2% gain. I never think about the Aussie market - it's 1/200th the size of NYSE.

Telus up 3% so far
S&P up 3% so far
AAPL up 5% so far
AMZN up 5% so far

(these are all I own)

Over my 35 years of investing, I learned a few things:
1. nobody knows what the market will do other than it will fluctuate unpredictably and generally go upward over time. anybody who says differently is either lying or self deluded
2. futures are useless
3. just make a plan based on the long run and stick to it, don't change strategies in the middle of a downturn

Having changed nothing, just dollar cost averaging every two weeks on my payday, I'm now down 8% from Feb peak, which puts me around November's valuation, or in other words, I've lost 5 months' growth.
 
With 1/12th population?

No.
Impossible.

Agreed. The US has a lot more foreign assets and a larger per capita GDP, but the proportion is not in the 200x range.

US economy: $20.58 trillion
AUS economy: $1.365 trillion

The 200x ratio could just be an illusion caused by comparison of specific indexes that have larger/smaller and otherwise arbitrary sized basket of representative stocks?
 
Having changed nothing, just dollar cost averaging every two weeks on my payday, I'm now down 8% from Feb peak, which puts me around November's valuation, or in other words, I've lost 5 months' growth.

Except that won't be the end of it.

IMF repeated today this will be the worst economic shock since the Great Depression. Almost every company will be reporting massive declines in profitability.

What's happening right now is people putting their money where their hopes are. Reality will bite shortly.

The 200x ratio could just be an illusion caused by comparison of specific indexes that have larger/smaller and otherwise arbitrary sized basket of representative stocks?

International trade, mostly. Few investors outside Australia invest in the ASX, while millions of offshore investors hit the NYSE.
 
Except that won't be the end of it.

I'm not saying whether it will or won't - just that nobody actually knows, and my investment strategy is taking that into account.

I've gone through a half dozen market kerpows, and it's served me well so far.

"time in the market beats timing the market" is the idea
 
International trade, mostly. Few investors outside Australia invest in the ASX, while millions of offshore investors hit the NYSE.

I don't see how the distribution of ownership influences the amount that's owned. Whether a guy from France and a Guy from America own AAPL, or just two guys from America, AAPL is still the same size.

We may be talking past each other? I'm comparing the US Equities market capitalization vs Australian same. I don't know if there's any metrics for total, but some indexes try to capture a majority of public equity in each country. I use:

US: USD$23.8 trillion (Russel 3000 - 98% of US equities)
Australia: USD$1.2 trillion (Ordinaries - 95% of AUS equities at A$1.9 trillion)

23.8 : 1.2 ratio is 20:1, not 200:1.
 
It strikes me that this is the way reputations are made*: somebody has a hunch, plays it and the hunch pays off spectacularly. This somebody now has the idea that they are some kind of prodigy or something. That all their analysis of the markets must be equally sound. You can make a lot of money off that kind of reputation. You can also lose a lot if you buy into it.

It’s been studied; most of these Golden Boys don’t end up doing any better than the market. You simply can’t beat the market consistently, you can only get lucky once in awhile.



*Just to be clear, I’m not saying that anyone in this thread is doing this; just musing on financial gurus in general.
 
Last edited:
It strikes me that this is the way reputations are made*: somebody has a hunch, plays it and the hunch pays off spectacularly. This somebody now has the idea that they are some kind of prodigy or something. That all their analysis of the markets must be equally sound. You can make a lot of money off that kind of reputation. You can also lose a lot if you buy into it.

It’s been studied; most of these Golden Boys don’t end up doing any better than the market. You simply can’t beat the market consistently, you can only get lucky once in awhile.



*Just to be clear, I’m not saying that anyone in this thread is doing this; just musing on financial gurus in general.

I've built my investment strategy on this very assumption. With the exception that there are financial gurus who say financial gurus can't predict the market. I think those guys have proven their case.

Skepticism helped a lot, because a lot of the literature is about our own reasoning gaps and emotional/rational conflict.

All those dowsers out there that Randi et al tested... they were confident they had a talent. They just couldn't demonstrate it on demand. And then the excuses get rolled out.

A better explanation - the Skeptical explanation - is that they were self deluded.

I feel the same way about *most* portfolio managers. The exceptions to the self delusion explanation are those who are knowingly lying, and those who are shaping special portfolios and not trying to pick stocks based on maximizing returns.




I think the most common problem is postdiction / hindsight bias / remembering the hits and forgetting the misses.

I have friends who are day traders and tell me about their big wins once in awhile. But they're all underwater over the long run, they seem to genuinely forget they lost $100/day most days. How many years does a guy sit in front of a computer losing $20k/yr and the scales don't fall from his eyes that this is gambling?

Scale this up, and you have portfolio managers who seem to sincerely believe that their 11% portfolio growth in 2019 is proof that they're geniuses. Meanwhile an unmanaged market fund did, say, 13%. How do they not appreciate they dragged the fund down 2 points (15%) with their ****** judgement? Are they just that bad at math?
 
I'm getting back into the market next month with new money. I've done some movement in my self managed IRA, but it has been almost a year since I've been in a 401K plan, where I'm dumping new money into the market.

And I will be dumping new money in, just as Blutoski's strategy dictates. It will all go into stocks. I do think that if I had to miss a year, this was a good one to miss.


It actually is possible to outperform the market. Lots of people do, and, a corollary is that it must be possible to underperform the market, and lots of people must be doing that, too. It's just not as easy as it looks, and you have to actually understand stocks.


When I was young (under 30) I didn't get into the market except a little bit in 401k, because I occasionally bought a book with a title like "How to Make Money in the Stock Market", and none of them made any sense to me. It seemed like there were these rules which were easy to learn, i.e. they could fit in the pages of an easy to read book, and if you followed those rules, people would give you money. This didn't seem very likely.

Then I bought a book on corporate finance. It was more about stocks from the companies' side of things, along with bonds and other ways to raise money. Suddenly, the stock market made sense......sort of. The day to day fluctuations made absolutely no sense, but the overall trend made much more sense, and I started playing the market. It turned out to be a good idea, because it turns out that people really will give you money for nothing, if you do it right. They just won't give you a lot of money. However, you can make a lot of money if you take some big chances, or, you can lose a lot of money if you take some big chances. That's the nature of "chance".


It today's market, you have to look at the long term value of the company and see if this really bad year coming up is going to drive them under. If not, investing may be a very good idea.
 
I'm not saying whether it will or won't - just that nobody actually knows, and my investment strategy is taking that into account.

Disagree. I think every serious broker and banker knows exactly where the market is going. You only need to be able to do maths to know with certainty this will be the worst and deepest recession since 1929.

I've gone through a half dozen market kerpows, and it's served me well so far.

For long term investors, it's easy - like property, shares will rise. Assets that pay dividends/rent/income will always appreciate. That's why gold is a dumb investment - it has no vale other than its weight.

"time in the market beats timing the market" is the idea

Not always. My single trade on TVIX returned 800% in a month. It'd take decades to make 800% in investments.

I don't see how the distribution of ownership influences the amount that's owned. Whether a guy from France and a Guy from America own AAPL, or just two guys from America, AAPL is still the same size.

The point was daily trades, not capitalisation.[/QUOTE]

I've built my investment strategy on this very assumption. With the exception that there are financial gurus who say financial gurus can't predict the market. I think those guys have proven their case.

I'd contend the existence of hedge funds proves the opposite.

Are they just that bad at math?

No, you're comparing dummies to dummies. There are loads of people who make money year after year after year. They might well be in the minority, but see above re: hedge funds. Also, search up that piece of filth Robert Mercer as a prime example.
 
I'm getting back into the market next month with new money. I've done some movement in my self managed IRA, but it has been almost a year since I've been in a 401K plan, where I'm dumping new money into the market.

And I will be dumping new money in, just as Blutoski's strategy dictates. It will all go into stocks. I do think that if I had to miss a year, this was a good one to miss.


It actually is possible to outperform the market. Lots of people do, and, a corollary is that it must be possible to underperform the market, and lots of people must be doing that, too. It's just not as easy as it looks, and you have to actually understand stocks.

I don't think a person has to understand stocks to outperform the market. I'm an example of that.

I outperformed the market, because I got flat out lucky. I had an opportunity to buy NeXT back in the mid-90s and did. Then, I literally forgot about it. (my tween was a handful, i got remarried, adopted another kid who was a handful, my parents had strokes... somehow it got lost in my paperwork). NeXT was bought by Apple. My broker emailed and asked what I wanted to do with the AAPL shares. You can guess the rest.

I suppress the temptation to pat myself on the back for what's essentially pure blind luck.
 
No, you're comparing dummies to dummies. There are loads of people who make money year after year after year. They might well be in the minority, but see above re: hedge funds. Also, search up that piece of filth Robert Mercer as a prime example.

I think there's a difference between making money investing vs making a living parting investment clients from their money. The former is what I don't think is a proven career - the latter, there's plenty of examples.
 
The point was daily trades, not capitalisation.

I have no idea what you mean, then. Can you elaborate on what you meant by:
I never think about the Aussie market - it's 1/200th the size of NYSE.

Clearly, I'm not understanding what 'it' is in the NYSE that's 200x the size of something else.

Do you mean volume?
 
I'd contend the existence of hedge funds proves the opposite.

I disagree. The existence of bigfoot museums does not prove there's a bigfoot. It *does* prove there are people out there who believe in it and are willing to part with their money for the experience.

Data point #2: churches. Proof of God?
 
Not always. My single trade on TVIX returned 800% in a month. It'd take decades to make 800% in investments.

I mean as a strategy. There's always that lottery winner who says saving is for chumps. He's failing to identify chance vs strategy.

I got lucky, too. AAPL and AMZN. Both over 800% btw. Both luck, not genius.
 
It today's market, you have to look at the long term value of the company and see if this really bad year coming up is going to drive them under. If not, investing may be a very good idea.

My thinking on that is... I don't think we can tell.

I think in 25 years we'll look back at this and be able to make some sense out of it, but right now, it's chaos.

And again, this is experience from the last half dozen times. For example, in 2008 Lehman Brothers went bankrupt. Other banks got bailouts. No difference in their business plans. Just different results from their lobbyists in Washington. My takeaway looking back at 2008 was that I *couldn't* predict which firms would give me good bounceback on recovery. My guesses were wrong.
 
I mean as a strategy. There's always that lottery winner who says saving is for chumps. He's failing to identify chance vs strategy.

I got lucky, too. AAPL and AMZN. Both over 800% btw. Both luck, not genius.

On that note, you're correct about 800% taking decades with the index fund buy and hold strategy.

S&P500 index is up 1350% since I started investing. Anybody can go that route, no analysis, just patience.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom