Ok then - re-phrase it: the profitability of hedge funds proves you can.
I'm not sure how you are measuring profitability. Yes, the managers make a fortune. They are siphoning money off the fund as salaries.
If you mean the capital growth, on average, they are not profitable, which is why I think they're part of a borderline fraudulent system. Hedge fund successes are short lived and appear generally random. Like a lottery ticket. The existence of a few random winners doesn't make them a good investment. Most hedge funds fail, and almost none match the returns of S&P500 index funds.
I've put my money where my mouth is on this one, and I'm not the only one. [
Buffet bet a million dollars that nobody can pick a hedge fund that will outperform the S&P500 and won.]
One element of managed funds that skeptics will recognize from healthfraud is that they have a "file drawer problem". You can review the performance of the funds currently offered, but it's hard to examine the funds that failed. They disappear off the face of the earth. At any given time something like 95% of managed funds are underperforming the S&P500, and they only represent the ones that were able to stay solvent. Ten times that many are ghosts and researchers can only estimate.
Of the over 100 hedge funds that Protege Partners selected as the 'best' to beat the S&P500 index in the Buffet bet, only about half of them were solvent 10 years later. Probably even fewer, taking March's dismal performance into account. The managers still get their yachts, of course.
I think you're being a bit disingenuous, but now that I've clarified that there's no excuse for not seeing how investment strategies based on short-term volatility can be enormously successful.
I'm not being *deliberately* disingenuous, so if you could maybe show where I've possibly been confused explaining my investment strategy I can elaborate on it to make it clearer.
I don't think I'm making excuses for not seeing something - I think it's not there. I don't see evidence that one can intentionally make money with short term strategies that is not analogous to buying a lottery ticket. There is a lot of research that shows that laypersons don't have the tools to pick stocks and insiders are only marginally better with tools we can't access. eg: lobbyists.
I did say it would take decades to match, so thanks for proving that for me.
Well, it doesn't prove it, technically, but I am agreeing with you, yes, so used an example.
It's just me illustrating my strategy with an example: "time in the market beats timing the market" - I have an investment strategy that is unchanged in 35 years and will probably continue for another 45 if I'm lucky.