Black Swan Event Under Way

Do you mean volume?

Yes.

I disagree. The existence of bigfoot museums does not prove there's a bigfoot. It *does* prove there are people out there who believe in it and are willing to part with their money for the experience.

Ok then - re-phrase it: the profitability of hedge funds proves you can.

I think you're being a bit disingenuous, but now that I've clarified that there's no excuse for not seeing how investment strategies based on short-term volatility can be enormously successful.

I got lucky, too. AAPL and AMZN. Both over 800% btw. Both luck, not genius.

I did say it would take decades to match, so thanks for proving that for me.
 
Telus up 3% so far
S&P up 3% so far
AAPL up 5% so far
AMZN up 5% so far

(these are all I own)

Over my 35 years of investing, I learned a few things:
1. nobody knows what the market will do other than it will fluctuate unpredictably and generally go upward over time. anybody who says differently is either lying or self deluded
2. futures are useless
3. just make a plan based on the long run and stick to it, don't change strategies in the middle of a downturn

Having changed nothing, just dollar cost averaging every two weeks on my payday, I'm now down 8% from Feb peak, which puts me around November's valuation, or in other words, I've lost 5 months' growth.

So, your advice is . . . don't panic. Makes sense to me.
 
It strikes me that this is the way reputations are made*: somebody has a hunch, plays it and the hunch pays off spectacularly. This somebody now has the idea that they are some kind of prodigy or something. That all their analysis of the markets must be equally sound. You can make a lot of money off that kind of reputation. You can also lose a lot if you buy into it.

It’s been studied; most of these Golden Boys don’t end up doing any better than the market. You simply can’t beat the market consistently, you can only get lucky once in awhile.

Well, Keynes was a spectacularly succesful investor and even though initially suffered in 1929-30 went on to make profits year after year in very turbulent times. One of the very few economists that I know of that has managed that feat.
 
Ok then - re-phrase it: the profitability of hedge funds proves you can.

Hedge funds are indeed very profitable for those who run them, but not necessarily for those who invest in them.

Then again, they're not really designed to outperform the market on a regular basis. The clue is in the name, they're there to provide a hedge against failure in regular investments.

This article highlights that 2019 was the first year in which hedge funds on average beat the market for 5 years. Of course individual funds can beat the market, sometimes for long periods of time but they tend to revert to the mean in the long term.

https://www.barrons.com/articles/he...-for-the-first-time-in-five-years-51553284144
 
Ok then - re-phrase it: the profitability of hedge funds proves you can.

I'm not sure how you are measuring profitability. Yes, the managers make a fortune. They are siphoning money off the fund as salaries.

If you mean the capital growth, on average, they are not profitable, which is why I think they're part of a borderline fraudulent system. Hedge fund successes are short lived and appear generally random. Like a lottery ticket. The existence of a few random winners doesn't make them a good investment. Most hedge funds fail, and almost none match the returns of S&P500 index funds.

I've put my money where my mouth is on this one, and I'm not the only one. [Buffet bet a million dollars that nobody can pick a hedge fund that will outperform the S&P500 and won.]

One element of managed funds that skeptics will recognize from healthfraud is that they have a "file drawer problem". You can review the performance of the funds currently offered, but it's hard to examine the funds that failed. They disappear off the face of the earth. At any given time something like 95% of managed funds are underperforming the S&P500, and they only represent the ones that were able to stay solvent. Ten times that many are ghosts and researchers can only estimate.

Of the over 100 hedge funds that Protege Partners selected as the 'best' to beat the S&P500 index in the Buffet bet, only about half of them were solvent 10 years later. Probably even fewer, taking March's dismal performance into account. The managers still get their yachts, of course.



I think you're being a bit disingenuous, but now that I've clarified that there's no excuse for not seeing how investment strategies based on short-term volatility can be enormously successful.

I'm not being *deliberately* disingenuous, so if you could maybe show where I've possibly been confused explaining my investment strategy I can elaborate on it to make it clearer.

I don't think I'm making excuses for not seeing something - I think it's not there. I don't see evidence that one can intentionally make money with short term strategies that is not analogous to buying a lottery ticket. There is a lot of research that shows that laypersons don't have the tools to pick stocks and insiders are only marginally better with tools we can't access. eg: lobbyists.



I did say it would take decades to match, so thanks for proving that for me.

Well, it doesn't prove it, technically, but I am agreeing with you, yes, so used an example.

It's just me illustrating my strategy with an example: "time in the market beats timing the market" - I have an investment strategy that is unchanged in 35 years and will probably continue for another 45 if I'm lucky.
 
Hedge funds are indeed very profitable for those who run them, but not necessarily for those who invest in them.

Then again, they're not really designed to outperform the market on a regular basis. The clue is in the name, they're there to provide a hedge against failure in regular investments.

I categorize hedge funds as a subclass of managed funds, and their scope is getting blurrier. A lot of hedge funds start with a mandate, they lose money consistently, and they just start trying to cherry pick off mandate stocks to make up the difference.



This article highlights that 2019 was the first year in which hedge funds on average beat the market for 5 years. Of course individual funds can beat the market, sometimes for long periods of time but they tend to revert to the mean in the long term.

Worth pointing out that the mean for managed funds is not the S&P500, it's actually a mean average of no returns, with some losing money and some making money.
 
Well, Keynes was a spectacularly succesful investor and even though initially suffered in 1929-30 went on to make profits year after year in very turbulent times. One of the very few economists that I know of that has managed that feat.

Keynes was the guy I quoted above. He told some reporters back in the 60s 30s that he knew exactly what the market would do: fluctuate unpredictably but generally go up in the long run.

But it's not about Keynes or any specific pundit. There's research out there.

And again, it's skepticism that got me here. The science is out there. Unfortunately, there is also a profitable industry that wants to cultivate a belief that they are worth their salaries and the science showing they're not is... inconvenient and needs to be countered. The misinformation has a lot of incentive behind it.
 
Last edited:
Keynes was the guy I quoted above. He told some reporters back in the 60s that he knew exactly what the market would do: fluctuate unpredictably but generally go up in the long run.

But it's not about Keynes or any specific pundit. There's research out there.

And again, it's skepticism that got me here. The science is out there. Unfortunately, there is also a profitable industry that wants to cultivate a belief that they are worth their salaries and the science showing they're not is... inconvenient and needs to be countered. The misinformation has a lot of incentive behind it.

It's true. If you are sufficiently good at stock picking that you can beat the markets, you don't need other people's money to be rich, and those clients would be just a liability.

People can beat the market, and not just by dumb luck. However, "the market" is average. If someone is beating the market, someone else is trailing the market.

The most common way that amateurs underperform the market is that they look at a market that is down and say, "Oh, no. The market is down. I had better sell in order to avoid losing more." Then, when the market is up, they say, "Wow! I can make a lot of money if I get into stocks." It's the "Buy high, sell low" strategy.

People would be better off doing what you do. Buy high, buy low, buy average, and don't sell until you need to. On average, you will win.
 
People can beat the market, and not just by dumb luck. However, "the market" is average. If someone is beating the market, someone else is trailing the market.

I don't think that's true... indexes just measure the market valuation. It reflects the economy mostly. So it's possible for everybody to make money at the same time; it's not an equal balance of winners and losers.

Indexes outperform stock pickers most of the time; indexes are not average, they're above average.



The most common way that amateurs underperform the market is that they look at a market that is down and say, "Oh, no. The market is down. I had better sell in order to avoid losing more." Then, when the market is up, they say, "Wow! I can make a lot of money if I get into stocks." It's the "Buy high, sell low" strategy.

After all this reading on personal finance, I'm not sure there's a single dominant type of mistake. It's really just a categorization problem. For example, arguably the biggest mistake is not participating in equities at all, but is that a category of investment error? Another example would be somebody who picked what looked like a good stock but it stank and he eventually sold it. Was the error picking the wrong stock? Was it that he didn't sell it soon enough? Was it further complicated by not timing it to take advantage of Tax Loss Harvesting?


People would be better off doing what you do. Buy high, buy low, buy average, and don't sell until you need to. On average, you will win.

Compared to stock picking, it's beyond on average. Index funds and dollar cost averaging beat managed stock pickers something like 99.9% of the time.
 
I don't think that's true... indexes just measure the market valuation. It reflects the economy mostly. So it's possible for everybody to make money at the same time; it's not an equal balance of winners and losers.

True. On average, most people are winners. In other words, if you go at market level, neither beating the market or trailing the market, you will make money in the long run. (At least, that has been true for the history of modern stock markets.)

What I was talking about was people who "beat the market", i.e. who do better than average. They not only make money, they make more money than average. Well, if someone is making more money than average, someone else must be making less money than average. (That's why there's an "average").

Some people consistently do better than average. Those people become rich. However, if one guy is doing better than average, somewhere, there must be someone doing worse than average, either making less than market averages or actually losing money.
 
Some people consistently do better than average. Those people become rich. However, if one guy is doing better than average, somewhere, there must be someone doing worse than average, either making less than market averages or actually losing money.

Got it. Thinking it through it does seem like the index represents a mean average of its component corporations. The index goes up 10% because some stocks went up 9% and some went up 11%.

In this example, all participants make gains, but the 11% stock pickers beat the index and the 9% pickers did not. Their deltas on capital gains vs the index' capital gains should be equal and opposite. Makes sense.


Worth mentioning that even people doing worse than average still can get rich, as long as the returns beat inflation, and they have enough time.
 
And reality maybe finally starting to sink in - Dow down another 400 today, giving up almost all of the month "gain".

Just wait till the next unemployment figures come out.
 
And reality maybe finally starting to sink in - Dow down another 400 today, giving up almost all of the month "gain".

Just wait till the next unemployment figures come out.

The first wave of unemployment was all the laid off workers whose jobs were now forbidden, such as restaurant workers, non-essential retail and manufacturing, etc.

It turns out, though, that all those people bought stuff, and had loans, so the next round is going to be a whole bunch of people who work for companies that aren't bringing in cash, and so they are laying off people. Lots and lots of corporations not making money, and not paying back loans. Big time problems that will drag down corporate profits in a big way.

So, will that drag down stock prices? This is where Blutoski's conversations come in. Typical, lower corporate earnings mean lower stock prices, but should they? There's nothing fundamentally wrong with the companies that are about to start losing huge sums of money this year. Most of them will come back. So, should stock prices plummet now, and rebound later? That would be typical, but unless you can pick the bottom of the fall, you may as well just keep the stocks.

A couple of weeks ago during the super fast bear market, I bought a couple of companies whose earnings are just going to be hammered this year. Planet Fitness isn't going to make any money this year. They are going to take huge losses. However, they won't go bankrupt, but some of their competition will. That means that when people start going back to the gym next year, they have potential for growth. I bought.

Will that investment pay off? If I knew that, I would be rich.
 
The first wave of unemployment was all the laid off workers whose jobs were now forbidden, such as restaurant workers, non-essential retail and manufacturing, etc.

It turns out, though, that all those people bought stuff, and had loans, so the next round is going to be a whole bunch of people who work for companies that aren't bringing in cash, and so they are laying off people. Lots and lots of corporations not making money, and not paying back loans. Big time problems that will drag down corporate profits in a big way.

So, will that drag down stock prices? This is where Blutoski's conversations come in. Typical, lower corporate earnings mean lower stock prices, but should they? There's nothing fundamentally wrong with the companies that are about to start losing huge sums of money this year. Most of them will come back. So, should stock prices plummet now, and rebound later? That would be typical, but unless you can pick the bottom of the fall, you may as well just keep the stocks.

The other unknown about, any particular day's stock prices and upcoming bad news, is whether the bad news is already priced in. I know I don't have a clue.
 
It turns out, though, that all those people bought stuff, and had loans, so the next round is going to be a whole bunch of people who work for companies that aren't bringing in cash, and so they are laying off people. Lots and lots of corporations not making money, and not paying back loans. Big time problems that will drag down corporate profits in a big way.

The problem is the downstream effects, which aren't obvious.

An example is a client of mine whose entire business is based on making food-grade stainless fitouts for restaurants, hotels, bars, etc.

That business will die off and there are thousands like it.

Another factor is commercial construction. In NZ, most of it has been around new hotels. In the past two weeks, three major hotels have decided to cease the projects at the outer skin stage - they will leave new hotels sitting with the entire interior and infrastructure not even started. That has a huge flow-on to electricians, engineers, plumbers, painters, etc, etc.

And yes, there will be immense numbers of bankruptcies and repossessions.

So, will that drag down stock prices?

You bet. There will be very few companies that escape with all their business intact.
 
It strikes me that this is the way reputations are made*: somebody has a hunch, plays it and the hunch pays off spectacularly. This somebody now has the idea that they are some kind of prodigy or something. That all their analysis of the markets must be equally sound. You can make a lot of money off that kind of reputation. You can also lose a lot if you buy into it.

It’s been studied; most of these Golden Boys don’t end up doing any better than the market. You simply can’t beat the market consistently, you can only get lucky once in awhile.



*Just to be clear, I’m not saying that anyone in this thread is doing this; just musing on financial gurus in general.
Let me be quite clear. You are engaging in a thought experiment and have got a false result.
 
The problem is the downstream effects, which aren't obvious.

An example is a client of mine whose entire business is based on making food-grade stainless fitouts for restaurants, hotels, bars, etc.

That business will die off and there are thousands like it.

Another factor is commercial construction. In NZ, most of it has been around new hotels. In the past two weeks, three major hotels have decided to cease the projects at the outer skin stage - they will leave new hotels sitting with the entire interior and infrastructure not even started. That has a huge flow-on to electricians, engineers, plumbers, painters, etc, etc.

And yes, there will be immense numbers of bankruptcies and repossessions.



You bet. There will be very few companies that escape with all their business intact.
I phoned a plumber yesterday to have a wc cistern replaced and he was available immediately.
 
I phoned a plumber yesterday to have a wc cistern replaced and he was available immediately.

They will be for some time to come.

Plumbers have been on a pig's back for years, along with electricians and chippies, building McMansions at exorbitant markups, along with an ever-increasing number of malls selling cheap crap.

All the commercial and most of the residential work will dry up and they'll be grateful for every broken dunny they can find. Commercial property will fall through the floor for years to come. That's why BK took the receivership option, I'm quite sure.

Put me in the "not even slightly sorry" about those industries being among the worst-hit. (Outside of tourism & hospitality, which are dead and embalmed)
 
Nasdaq closed just 10% of all time high.
SP500 trading 15.6% off high in after market.

I find these numbers surprising, yet the upward momentum looks powerful.

The black swan is using peroxide.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom