Bjarne
Philosopher
- Joined
- Oct 6, 2009
- Messages
- 5,087
Except cowsWe're all going to look pretty silly then
Except cowsWe're all going to look pretty silly then
You are showing your ignorance again, Bjarne: Jupiter does not have the same atmosphere as the EarthDid you notice the word; “huge”?
Yes, - Jupiter has more heat in its atmosphere as expected (coming from an unknown source) but not something you can compare to the huge heat convection in the Earth atmosphere.
!So what?Off course we have far from a full overview of what causes the many storms / hurricane created on Jupiter or other gas planets; - so long we even have not the full overview of what causing (etc) hurricanes on Earth.
No: "central gravity" is a fantasy in your head.Off course heat release on the gas planets also are ingredients of hurricane, but since many of these hurricanes are hundreds of times larger than on earth, central gravity is also proportional larger.
! Another astounding bit of ignorqance from you Bjarne.Of course the mass of the Red Spot is involved but mass of Jupiter dominates. Any mass that is 1000 times the mass of another mass has 1000 times the gravity....snipped cow logic and more ignorance...
If the weight of Jupiter’s big hurricane is 1000 times the mass of a hurricane at earth, then also gravity are 1000 times stronger involved? – And off course also the heat release from Jupiter is involved.
To make a long history short.Bjarne
Did you notice the word; “huge”?
Yes, - Jupiter has more heat in its atmosphere as expected (coming from an unknown source) but not something you can compare to the huge heat convection in the Earth atmosphere.
RC
You are showing your ignorance again, Bjarne: Jupiter does not have the same atmosphere as the Earth
Ohhh RC, - and you have been at a university in 17 years.We have a good "overview" of what causes the many storms / hurricane created on Jupiter or other gas planets and on Earth.
You are so prejudiced my dear, - tell me now the true, - are your anti-crackpot glasses really more dark inside as inside black hole?You are talking like those crackpots who say that we have no perfect knowledge of anything and so all science is wrong. What these cranks do not realize is that
- Science is the process of getting closer and closer to perfect knowledge. No sane person expects science to have perfect knowledge.
- The fantasies that they come up with are imperfect and so wrong according to their definition!
Professor RCReal gravity that actually exists and has been measured for centuries has a factor to play in all hurricanes.
The gas-giant hurricanes are larger than on Earth because gas-giants are bigger than Earth ! Another astounding bit of ignorance from you Bjarne.
The formation of tropical cyclones is the topic of extensive ongoing research and is still not fully understood........
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tropical_cyclone
Meteorology is a relatively young science and the study of tornadoes is newer still. Although researched for about 140 years and intensively for around 60 years, there are still aspects of tornadoes which remain a mystery.[104]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tornado
We agree there because it is obvious: hurricanes are not fully understood.To make a long history short.
- I think everybody agrees that hurricanes at gas planet are bigger mysteries, or (at least) less understood as hurricanes on Earth.
- The formation of hurricanes on Earth are, (as also you agree) not fully understood.
Ohhh Bjarne, And you are so full of 17 years of ignorance! Have the cows not taught you to think before you write? It is simple to do.Ohhh RC, - and you have been at a university in 17 years.
Have they really not learn you to check blab blab la –
It is so simple to do it
For exsample this > http://www.astronomy-education.com/index.php?page=76 –
A completely brain damage cow that still can either read or hear will understand that hurricane on Jupiter not is understood, and that we even have failed to understand which thesis to support.
Youu are so ignorant my dear, - tell me now the true, - are your crackpot glasses really more dark inside as inside black hole?You are so prejudiced my dear, - tell me now the true, - are your anti-crackpot glasses really more dark inside as inside black hole?
Kindergarten student,BjarneProfessor RC
Tell me know honestly do you know what Wikipedia is:
Here you can read :
So Bjarne...snipped delustional "central gravity" and Bjarne's crackpost obsession with things not being "fully understood"...
So RC
Now when you (hopefully know what Wikipedia is, you can also read this).
But I think it will not give more than 0.0000000000000000000000000000000002% sense to you, you know also because of the anti crackpot glasses.
We agree: hurricanes are not fully understood.
Fallstreak holes (punch hole clouds) are a very strange weather phenomenon that is not understood.
http://www.xearththeory.com/fallstreakholes_cloudarcstructures_crabclouds.html
these are not fully understood by meteorologists or scientists yet. All/both have their own theories.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dltbluefrog/4413731658/
The formation of tropical cyclones is the topic of extensive ongoing research and is still not fully understood........
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/tropical_cyclone
scientific understanding of atmospheric processes, though highly advanced, is incomplete and imperfect.
While much is known about hurricanes, far more remains to be discovered.
Scientists don't fully understand, for example, the process of tropical cyclogenesis (genesis of tropical cyclones).
They don't know precisely how it occurs, or why some tropical disturbances generate into hurricanes, while others, which may meet all the known requirements for hurricane formation, fail to develop
http://www.hurrnet.com/tutorial/expectations/limitations.html
eyewall: The eyewall is a circular band of intense convection and winds immediately surrounding the eye. It is home to the most severe conditions in a tropical cyclone. Intense cyclones show eye-wall replacement cycles, in which outer eye walls form to replace inner ones. The mechanisms which make this occur are still not fully understood.
http://www.armageddononline.org/tropical-storm.html
observations made during the historic 2005 hurricane season document a case of "eyewall replacement."
clouds outside the hurricane eyewall coalesce to form a new eyewall at a greater radius from the storm center, and the old eyewall dies.
The winds in the new eyewall are initially weaker than those in the original eyewall, but as the new eyewall contracts, the storm reintensifies. Understanding this replacement mechanism is vital to forecasting variations in hurricane intensity.
Processes in the "moat" region between the new and old eyewall have been particularly unclear.
Aircraft data now show that the moat becomes dynamically similar to the eye and thus is converted into a region inimical to survival of the inner eyewall.
We suggest that targeting aircraft to key parts of the storm to gain crucial input to high-resolution numerical models can lead to improvements in forecasting hurricane intensity.
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/315/5816/1235
the general mechanisms by which the eye and eyewall are formed are not fully understood, although observations have shed some light on the problem. The calm eye of the tropical cyclone shares many qualitative characteristics with other vortical systems such as tornadoes, waterspouts, dust devils and whirlpools.
http://www.cppj.net/index.aspx?page=140
what finally produces a tornado? By some mechanism not fully understood, the circulation in the storm's lower levels may tighten into a narrow cylinder, elongate, and speed up, much as figure skaters spin faster by pulling in their arms.
http://www.ucar.edu/communications/factsheets/tornadoes.html
exactly how tornadoes form is complex and not fully understood.
http://www.experts123.com/q/how-does-a-tornado-form.html
I have always stated that hurricanse are not fully understood - you have just not been able to comprehend that this means nothing.A little step for Mandkind
A big step for RC
In simple terms, I know that we can conclude that that scientists do not understand (mainly) the central area of all kind of low pressures.So in general, simple and short, - I think we easy can conclude, that scientist do not understand (mainly) the central area of all kind of low pressures.
What about central gravity > http://www.science27.com - much stronger as we thought?
I mean just an "idea" right?
Apparently you can conclude that; other people can read the links and actually see the word fully.Hole in the clouds
cyclones
hurricanes
tornadoes
So in general, simple and short, - I think we easy can conclude, that scientist do not understand (mainly) the central area of all kind of low pressures.
Again with the we.What about central gravity ... much stronger as we thought?
Yep, and apparently not a very good one.I mean just an "idea" right?
So, Bjarne: If your 'Kolding Effect' (remember, 'Central Gravity' is already taken) causes hurricanes, tell us, how does the column of air involved in a hurricane "know" that it must have a unified gravity? Why aren't the columns next to it involved?
Can Bill Gates stop hurricanes? http://edition.cnn.com/2009/TECH/science/08/28/hurricanes.gates.gray
Could Powder Kill A Hurricane?
Florida Man Thinks His Powder Could 'Absorb' A Hurricane
http://www.wesh.com/news/3963137/detail.html
Let's imaging a low pressure area of 500 km2, carrying an average of 100 kg water per m2 (total 5 * 1013 kg ).
This is a pretty heavy mass.
Near the centre of a such low pressure we should (according to this theory) expect acceleration due to gravity about 0,00002 m/s2.
Even though this is not much, we must remember that wind blowing towards the centre of a low pressure will keep accelerating (second by second / day by day) due to the force of gravity.
After one day/night (86400 seconds) a water molecule blowing in the direction of the center can have reach a velocity about 1.73 m/s2.
After 10 days 17,3 m/s2. (62 km/h) etc, only caused by gravity.
This is off course provided that the air also can escape, - which mean there is or can be established a high pressure nearby. (and no resistance for exsample from Earth gravity)
That's some bad maths, Bjarne. You're 1000x out.
The mass of water is 5 * 1010 kg, which gives you 0.0173m/s (not m/s2!), or 0.063 km/h after 10 whole days!
And you say this causes hurricanes?
I do (far from) fully understand you question.
Let me answer based on the incompletely understanding I got..
Let's imaging a low pressure area of 500 km2, carrying an average of 100 kg water per m2 (total 5 * 1013 kg ).
This is a pretty heavy mass.
Near the centre of a such low pressure we should (according to this theory) expect acceleration due to gravity about 0,00002 m/s2.
Even though this is not much, we must remember that wind blowing towards the centre of a low pressure will keep accelerating (second by second / day by day) due to the force of gravity.
This is off course provided that the air also can escape, - which mean there is or can be established a high pressure nearby. (and no resistance for exsample from Earth gravity)
First when rain will begin to fall, (billion of ton water), - THEN – HUGE amount of mass will fall THEN the hurricane will die.
I mean 500 km in radius or diameter
If the shape was a square and radius 500 km
500000 meter * 500000 meter * 100Kg/m2 = 5*1013 Kg.
Round radius 250 km.
Radius 250000 meter * 250000 meter * 3,14 * 100Kg/m2 = 1.96*1013 Kg.
How much water per sqaure meter does a hurricane carry ?

NoThe air inside a hurricane, or a thunderstorm, of even a normal cloud, is lighter than the surrounding air.
Warm water vapors is only lighter only until it condensate (and finally) falls as cold heavy rain.Also, water vapor is lighter than air.
Have you ever hear about heavy clouds?Your pull of gravity would be away from the center, because the surrounding, denser air has a greater gravitational pull.
The pressure is lower when the warm air is rising (measured from Earth) It is the temperature + the upwards buoyancy that causing low-pressure under the heavy clouds.And the reason the air inside the cloud/thunderstorm/hurricane is lighter is, of course, that the pressure is lower.
Nonsense like the rest of your load.The rain increases the energy of the storm, because as water condenses, it releases heat energy. The more it rains, the more it storms.
I do not say everybody are stupid, - but only that there are too stupid many prejudiced and too stupid many reserved, and too stupid many authoritarian believers, and too stupid many lazy, and too stupid many orthodox believers, and too stupid too much brainwash, and too stupid too many inflexibilities, and too stupid too little Openness.Bjarne, don't you find it a little bit odd that you think you are wiser than the rest of us, but you still have to ask about all sorts of things?
No I don’t think so
Really Hans it is not my problem.So with this starter help your homework is as follows:
1) Find the volume of your hurricane (not just the area). So you must find the hight.
2) Find the density of air.
3) Find the weight of the air in the hurricane.
4) Take 3% of that and you have the mass of the water in it.
No
This is because of the heat buoyancy and warm air is lighter than cold air.
But air reaching a hurricanes clouds is longer moving upward, and no longer warm, its energy have already been used, and the vapor begins to condensate.
Cold air falling from higher altitude (high pressure) is colder and also heavier.
Warm water vapors is only lighter only until it condensate (and finally) falls as cold heavy rain.
Have you ever hear about heavy clouds?
Why do you believe hailstones can be huge? -Let me tell you, because of strong upwards wind prevent these to fall down?
Or do you also believe hailstones and billion of ton raindrops (that really want to fall to the Earth) are lighter than air?
The pressure is lower when the warm air is rising (measured from Earth) It is the temperature + the upwards buoyancy that causing low-pressure under the heavy clouds.
Why do you believe it gets colder after a thunder storm, have released its heavy cold load ?
The barometer is really ONLY a weight measuring how much stronger the weight of warm air is, + how much upwards motion there is under the heavy clouds, - exactly like you are lighter (measured from earth) when a elevator pulls you upwards doesn’t matter if there is a heavy thundercloud above you head or not.
The upwards heat carries the energy for keeping a storm strong.
When it have reach it target the energy is already lost.
I do not say everybody are stupid, - but only that there are too stupid many prejudiced and too stupid many reserved, and too stupid many authoritarian believers, and too stupid many lazy, and too stupid many orthodox believers, and too stupid too much brainwash, and too stupid too many inflexibilities, and too stupid too little Openness.
Really Hans it is not my problem.
I do not get a hurricane in my head every second week comrade, and even if I calculated it all, 898 % exactly, - I am afraid that only cows would clap their hoofs , and the jalousie would grove even bigger between humans..
Because according to Karl Marx and the dear Jantelov

