Marian said:
I recently bought "Fads & Fallacies In the Name of Science" by Martin Gardner, and I read a section I thought applied rather well to this thread. Unfortunately it was a little long, and I didn't want to type it up, but I found that someone else had typed it up on another board. So I've copied that and am posting it here. Source is Martin Gardner's book.
I would actually take issue with Gardner's description of a pseudoscientist. Whilst it is undoubtedly true in part I don't think it reflects many that I have encountered. And it also partially fits one or two true geniuses. I think he is addressing more the very deluded crank believers. Here are some observations of my own about typical characteristics of pseudoscientists.
1. They thrive on publicity. They have a lot in common with cult leaders. The typical pseudoscientist seeks to impress the ignorant and to attract followers. The way they do this is by simply spouting incomprehensible garbage in front of ignorant people. Those people get impressed by what SOUNDS like a high level of learning, but typically lack the skill, knowledge or experience to evaluate whether the information is true. Many such people like to associate themselves with somebody they believe is more credible, so they tend to compliment and encourage the pseudoscientist. In turn the pseudoscientist (PS for short) thrives on this attention and adulation, it bolsters their ego. Most PS's have some sort of ego problem. This is where I agree with Gardner. The PS's think they are geniuses, whereas REAL geniuses are often extremely humble. Although in reality, it's usually low self esteem, that makes the PS's so arrogant.
Spurred by this attention the PS gains confidence and tends to become more strident and outgoing. Also they feel emboldened to stray further from the accepted limits of science. They are so wrapped up in the adulation of their followers that they don't care about true scientific acceptance any more.
2. Pseudoscientists like to back up every argument with endless legitimate scientific references. However, they don't really understand these references and at best they cherry pick something which appears superficially to support their latest idea. A true scientist by comparison tends to make detailed, cogent logical arguments which stand on their own merits and only cites references as further information/support. When confronted with a contradiction in their theories or error in their references, true scientists usually admit they are wrong and go off to re-examine their assumptions. PS's on the other hand will usually ignore the contradiction. They will not address it head on. Instead they will go looking for another, more amenable reference, or they will attack the questioner, or they will attempt to bolster their argument by changing their claim or adding ad hoc hypotheses to counter specific objections. very often, the PS will present a scientific reference in place of any argument. When asked to explain something they will simply quote some complicated reference, with an attitude of, "This is too trivial for me to address, read this and it should be self evident that I am right"". Of course, they know that most people will never bother to actually check or READ the reference.
3. Pseudoscientists will never admit they are wrong about anything. YOU, the questioner are always wrong. They will try to make you believe that you have missed something obvious and they will act in a condenscending, pitying way, hoping that you will back off by believing that maybe you are making a fool of yourself. Because this tactic always works on ignorant true believers - their main audience.
4. Pseudoscientists like to be associated wherever possible with REAL scientists, especially famous or highly qualified ones. They will attend all the conferences. They will try to become friendly with real scientists. They will always "name drop", for example. "Oh, yes I just happened to mention that to Albert (Einstein) the other day." The idea is that you are to be impressed that:
a) They actually KNOW Einstein.
b) That they are on a first name basis with him.
c) There will usually be some implication that the named scientist supports the theories of the PS.
Wherever possible they will seek to give talks and lectures, they will be prominent at gatherings where scientists are present. If a famous scientist is giving a lecture they will want to be seen.They will inevitably stand up, introduce themselves and ask a question in an authoritative sounding manner.
If a famous scientist attends a social gathering, and someone takes a photo, they will usually sidle up to them and make sure THEY are prominently in the picture, as close as possible. If they can get away with it, they will do things like put their arm around the shoulders of the more famous person and smile broadly to give the impression they are great friends. And of course they will NEVER refer to "Professor Einstein", it will always be, "My DEAR friend (or "my esteemed colleague") Albert"".
5. Pseudoscientists will ignore an issue they have been proven wrong on. It will not be mentioned (by them) again, unless someone else brings it up. The usual tactic then is pure bluff. They will pretend that they were proven RIGHT and attempt to dismiss it: "I proved my case on this before, its a closed issue". Or they will simply go silent and change the subject. If any of their believers notice this they draw them aside and tell them in private, "I don't want to argue with that fanatic, the poor man is deluded, just ignore him". They will often try to resurrect a disputed argument after some time (when everyone has forgotten about the earlier rebuttal) and they will blithely present the same faulty theory to a new group of believers.
6. Pseudoscientists nearly always have some grand theory of their own. They insist that they have made some new and great original discovery. They will work that into everything. In fact, they usually have little else than that. This is often a precursor to all the rest. It is the conviction that they have made some fabulous new discovery that leads them down this path in the first place.
7. Pseudoscientists nearly always have something to sell, and they nearly always endorse the products of their supporters. It's a kind of loyalty scheme. They will subscribe to, and endorse the claims of other pseudoscientists and expect the same in return, because there is more strength in numbers.
8. Pseudoscientists go out of their way to discredit the opposition. Opponents are always labelled and wherever possible associated with a derogatory class. "Dogmatic", "convention bound", "stupid"", "a fanatical skeptic", "part of the Establishment" or whatever.
9. Pseudoscientists are nearly always paranoid. They have to pretend that they are the victims of a conspiracy for two main reasons:
a) It makes them feel self important. People don't conspire against nobodies.
b) It gives an excuse for their believers why their ideas are not generally accepted. (the others are part of the conspiracy)
Now I just wrote that off the top of my head based on my experience with many pseudoscientists I have met. I did NOT specifically cull it from this thread. But I'll let everyone draw their own conclusions about whether any of these criteria are specifically met by anyone here.