RESONANCE IN THE NATURAL WORLD
with particular reference to organic cells.
Resonance at an atomic level
In molecular chemistry the concept of resonance is demonstrated when a particular molecule can assume two differing states, and alternate between these. In these cases the electrons, not the atoms change locations in some regular way, and thereby achieve stability that neither of the two alternative states can do. Without necessarily re-postulating a luminiferous ether, this can give rise to detection at a distance. Thus resonances can be used to identify molecules at a distance,
Yes, quite big distances, in fact. All across the known universe, actually.
Example (taken from from
http://www.cem.msu.edu website, q.v.), but since the Michigan Univ site is being moved your best bet is to find it via Google (keyword resonance):
Very helpful, indeed, "resonance" gets 1,630,000 hits on Google
.
For example, sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitric acid (HNO3) may each be described by two equivalent formulas.. This averaging of electron distribution over two or more hypothetical contributing structures (canonical forms) to produce a hybrid electronic structure is called resonance. Likewise, the structure of nitric acid is best described as a resonance hybrid of two structures, a double headed arrow being the unique symbol for resonance.
The above examples represent one extreme in the application of resonance. Here, two structurally and energetically equivalent electronic structures for a stable compound can be written, but no single structure provides an accurate or even an adequate representation of the true molecule. In cases such as these, the electron delocalization described by resonance enhances the stability of the molecules, and compounds or ions composed of such molecules often show exceptional stability.
The electronic structures of most covalent compounds do not suffer the inadequacy noted above. Thus, completely satisfactory Kekulé formulas may be drawn for water (H2O), methane (CH4) and acetylene C2H2). Nevertheless, the principles of resonance are very useful in rationalizing the chemical behavior of many such compounds. For example, the carbonyl group of formaldehyde (the carbon-oxygen double bond) reacts readily to give addition products. The course of these reactions can be explained by a small contribution of a dipolar resonance contributor. Here, the first contributor (see diagram on their website) is clearly the best representation of this molecular unit, since there is no charge separation and both the carbon and oxygen atoms have achieved valence shell neon-like configurations by covalent electron sharing. If the double bond is broken heterolytically, formal charge pairs result, as shown in the other two structures. The preferred charge distribution will have the positive charge on the less electronegative atom (carbon) and the negative charge on the more electronegative atom (oxygen). Therefore the middle formula represents a more reasonable and stable structure than the one on the right. The application of resonance to this case requires a weighted averaging of these canonical structures. The double bonded structure is regarded as the major contributor, the middle structure a minor contributor and the right hand structure a non-contributor. Since the middle, charge-separated contributor has an electron deficient carbon atom, this explains the tendency of electron donors (nucleophiles) to bond at this site.
Yada, yada, yada. No need to lecture us on basic physics.
The basic principles of the resonance method may now be summarized.
For a given compound, a set of Lewis / Kekulé structures are written, keeping the relative positions of all the component atoms the same. These are the canonical forms to be considered, and all must have the same number of paired and unpaired electrons.
The following factors are important in evaluating the contribution each of these canonical structures makes to the actual molecule.
The number of covalent bonds in a structure. (The greater the bonding, the more important and stable the contributing structure.)
Formal charge separation. (Other factors aside, charge separation decreases the stability and importance of the contributing structure.)
Electronegativity of charge bearing atoms and charge density. (High charge density is destabilizing. Positive charge is best accommodated on atoms of low electronegativity, and negative charge on high electronegative atoms.)
The stability of a resonance hybrid is always greater than the stability of any canonical contributor. Consequently, if one canonical form has a much greater stability than all others, the hybrid will closely resemble it electronically and energetically. (This is the case for the carbonyl group).
All the examples on the cem webpage demonstrate an important restriction that must be remembered when using resonance. No atoms change their positions within the common structural framework. Only electrons are moved.
Yada some more.
Resonance at a cellular level.
Resonance at a cellular level is somewhat different.
Which sorta makes the lengthy lecture above somewhat irrelevant for the subject at hand. Especially since "somewhat" is an understatement. The term "entirely" would be correct.
Here the resonance is achieved when an electromagnetic wave ‘s characteristics physically match the characteristics of the object to be resonated. The effect is known as half wave resonance because the length of half the EM wave must match the diameter of, say, a globular object for the resonance to occur.
This goes for any conductive object. However, many other modes of resonance exist.
This is perhaps better understood by imagining a sphere (or circle if you looking at a diagram on a page) being sliced through the middle horizontally and the bottom semicircle moved to the right until its left limb touches the right limb of the upper semicircle. You have now constructed what looks like a sine wave on the imagined page, and the length of this "wave" is twice the diameter of the original circle (or sphere).
Definitely a layman's analogy, but OK.
If we now assume that the wave is actually composed of "crowds" of electrons moving in higher and lower gangs (to represent increased or decreased amplitude) then these will cross the midline in one direction at one time and in the opposite direction the next time.
However, we cannot assume that a wave is composed of electrons, because it is not. A current in a conductor is composed of electrons, but that is not a wave. Counting wrong premises: 14. (assuming that this post is a sequel to your earlier, and anyhow, the consequtive numbering will help you reference them when (if?) you address the problems).
Very disturbing to the surface of the sphere! It surface at that place will be subjected fortst to an upward, and then to a downward pressure.
Not at all. Neither a stream of electrons nor an electromagnetic wave will excert a physical force on a conductor, or a cell. Counting wrong premises: 15.
Only when the half wave matches the diameter will this occur however, so if the wave is smaller or larger than the object’s diameter then this "irritition" will not occur.
Since the "irritition" [sic] will not occur at all, this is wrong, too. Counting: 16.
It is easy to see that if one knows the diameter of an object one can thereby infer the wavelength which will resonate it. And since there is an inevitable relationship between wavelength and frequency, the freqwuency need to resonate an object can also be deduced. All this is very simple, really, and stands to reason.
The diameter of an object reflects the wavelength of its electrical resonance, that is correct, althoug it does not follow from your previous two statements. The relationship between wavelength and frequency is not as simple in a conductive medium as you perhaps think, but, let's not nitpick.
Nature has made use of this effect in a number of ways. We humans have receptors for waves of visible light, and so we can see the emissions of glow worms and fireflies as they communicate between themselves at light frequencies.
Uhh, in short: We can see. I am far from convinced this has anything to do with resonance, though, since the bandwidth of the color-sensitive cells in our retina is rather wide for a resonant phenomenon.
But other organisms use different wavelengths, e.g. in the far infra red, or the ultraviolet, and these we cannot normally see. In deed, there is a whole ocean out there of raditions created by the creatures of our planet for purposes as diverse as navigation, prey detecdtion, and signalling to or from a prospective mate.
The visible spectrum of a number of creatures is wider than, or different from, that of humans, correct. To call it a whole ocean is perhaps somewhat exaggarated, since it is still a quite small part of the EM spectrum.
In our case as an example, the Schumann resonances of the planet dictate our circadian rhythms, probably by a melatonin dependent mechanism.
Going off on a tangent here. This post is about cellular resonance.
The trouble is, when artificially originating electromagnetic waves appear, they can inhibit the synthesis of melatonin according to some studies, and since melatonin is known to be a powerful antioxidant and oncostatic agent, this lowered synthesis in turn increases the likelihood of cancer.
Another tangent. This is a different debate.
Resonance can also impair lymphocyte function: if one assumes a diameter of say 10 microns for an average lymphocyte then by the notion set out above a wave of length 20 microns would resonate it. This implies a wave in the far infra red region (FIR) of the electromagnetic spectrum.
And such a wave is radiated from an object with a temperature of 145 deg K. Fortunately, such an object is unlikely to be found in or near the human body. Oops! There goes the entire string of argumentation leading up to here. Too bad. Let us be nice and just count one failed premise: 17.
On the lymphocyte surface there is a veritable forest of glycoproteins (imagine them like rock candy sticks, very stiff as a result of being sugars) with an incredible variety of side rods called sialic acid residues sticking out from them, and mostly carrying a negative charge. Because opposite charges attract if any positive charges arrive near they reflect these by charge neutralisation. A good example would be the calcium ion, which carries two positive charges (or rather its outer valence shell is lacking two electrons).
Whatever the truth-value of this it is difficult to see any relevance to resonant phenomenon, so lets give it an: 18
In fact ionic calcium is known to be an important first messenger for carrying regulatory signals through the body, e.g. it plays an important role in heart beat regulation. It is also a vital second messenger, and is "allowed" into the cell interior thriough special calcumchannels too. Inside the cell there are machanisms to amplify the messenger signals and also as system to keep the cytosol clean of calcium using calmodulin as a sort of store so that the signal to noise ratio is optimised. The cell might have used magnesium instead, (also a cation) but for reasons not understood it prefers calcium.
Of course, calcium is tempted to "stick" to any place which carries negative charges, just as calcium salts might build up in your domestic waster pipes. Static magnetic fields appear to slow down that temptation, but that’s another story.
Let's just say: Yada
.
For the moment let us understand that objects delivering FIR signals of precisely the right frequency can therefore communicate precisely with cells in general via resonance, and with lymphocytes in particular
Sorry, but that does not follow at all. Even if the premises above were correct,
you have not explained how this alleged communication occurs: 19.
You have not explained how possible information is encoded for transmission: 20.
You have not explained how it gets directed at the cells: 21.
You have not addressed the problem of how to apply resonance to an object embedded in a conductive medium: 22.
You have not explained how a 20micron IR wave is generated in an environment where humans can exist: 23.
In short, you have not explained anything at all.
Resonance at an organic level.
I will discuss this on a separate post.