Bioelectromagnetics

And how would any of that enable a "talisman" to protect the body from EM radiation.

It has been demonstrated that although the talisman emits black body radiation in the IR spectrum, it would be swamped by the black body radiation produced by everything else in the environment.

You opine that the IR radiation it emits could interract with incoming EM radiation and yet again that your theories are flawed.
 
Mercutio said:
It was a glitch that happened when the entire thread got copied (if memory serves, to try to preserve a post that was reported for possible action--but with my memory, ....I'll check and see). It turns out that doing that moves the original thread and leaves a copy in its place; in this case, the copy was damaged. If memory serves (same warning), a couple of attempts were made to fix the problem, with no success. I will take a look at it, but I am certain my technical prowess is less than that of those who tried previously, so I make no promises of success.

In that case you must have stored the copy you made. That copy contains the first pages. Regardless if you can restore the pages you have a copy of the original in case somebody questions anything.

I happen to have kept a copy myself.
 
cogreslab said:
I will slip this in before resuming the issue of resonance, just in case people think these digressive debates have managed to deflect me from one of my objectives.

Unfortunately, no, I did not really expect that you were ready to be disturbed by simple things as facts. You just ignore them and ramble on. But, for the sake of the spectators, I shall continue to dismantle your arguments whenever they found to be wrong (which, I'm sorry to say, is very often).

I notice that the last few posts contain nothing but a few more pejoriatives, rather than much of scientific interest, and so I wonder who is now getting desperate.

I trust that if you read objectively, you will also find that a number of your recent long posts have been carefully refuted point for point, and it would look good if you were to address these refutations, instead of ignoring them and trying to change the subject.

So far most of the facts being offered against my hypothesis have been hopelessly inaccurate: e.g (I paraphrase because I can't be bothered to quote their rubbish word for word, but the sense is the same).

Then you should have no difficulty in countering it.

"lymphocytes are 8-9 microns in diameter, so you are obviously an ignorant fool". Total crap. But no retraction when the crap was exposed!

"Fields cannot possibly cross the lymphocytes' plasma membrane, but only go around it". Total crap. But no retraction when this rubbish was unfrocked, only a feeble attempt to defend it.

And so on.

I don't recognize any of my refutations there. Does that mean that you accept them?

Moulder Question 7:
(Powerlines and Cancer website)_

Moulder answers the question 7) How do radiofrequency radiation and microwaves cause biological effects? as follows:

"A principal mechanism by which radiofrequency radiation and microwaves cause biological effects is by heating (thermal effects). This heating can kill cells. If enough cells are killed, burns and other forms of long-term, and possibly permanent tissue damage can occur. Cells which are not killed by heating gradually return to normal after the heating ceases; permanent non-lethal cellular damage is not known to occur. At the whole-animal level, tissue injury and other thermally-induced effects can be expected when the amount of power absorbed by the animal is similar to or exceeds the amount of heat generated by normal body processes. Some of these thermal effects (also see Q9) are very subtle, and do not represent biological hazards [A4].
It is possible to produce thermal effects even with very low levels of absorbed power. One example is the "microwave hearing" phenomenon; these are auditory sensations that a person experiences when his head is exposed to pulsed microwaves such as those produced by radar. The "microwave hearing" effects is a thermal effect, but it can be observed at very low average power levels.
Since thermal effects are produced by induced currents, not by the electric or magnetic fields directly, they can be produced by fields at many different frequencies. Well-accepted safety standards exist to prevent significant thermal damage to persons exposed to radiofrequency radiation and microwaves (see Q31C), and also for persons exposed to lasers, infrared (IR) and ultraviolet (UV) light [M1]".

Astonishing! Not a single word about the major controversy raging in the scientific world regarding the adverse effects on health of radiofrequency and microwave radiation at levels far below thermal.
Even accepting this site is really only designed to discuss ELF frequencies, to omit any mention of the long history of the debate, starting with the infamous Moscow signal in the 1950s Cold War, and continuing to the present saga concerning cellphones and their associated base stations, is an inexcusable lacuna. Since this one of Moulder’s three sites aims at ELF frequencies, I shall (with difficulty) refrain from setting out the issue here, but I will retain it for the second site when I come to deal with it.

I, for one, am not dicussing Moulder's viewpoints and ideas here, I am dicussing the idead and, espcially claims of Mr. Roger Coghill.

Lucianarchy, I haven't forgotten you, and will hope to answer your legitimate and sensible question tomorrow.

Yes, that will be interesting

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Hans opined:

"Translation: "I have a definite hunch I am checkmate and out of arguments, so I'll resort to personal attacks for a while."

The French have a saying: Qui s'excuse s'accuse. If anything characterises this entire thread it is the number of unsupported personal attacks on me! The stupid challenges of the genuine ness about an evident degree or two of mine have been disproved. The puerile attempt ("We have a trap but we aren't going to tell you what it is, so there") to offer undisclosed traps have been overtaken by experimental and numerical evidence that a wide variety of organisms use EMF in many parts of the spectrum for sensing their environment, and particular examples given for far IR. This tactic fools no one, and degrades the quality of the so called science being offered in opposition to my well founded and well referenced arguments, frankly.

I have all the time in the world to place the entire story on this thread, so it might be better for all if we concenttrate on scientific matters rather than spin doctoring and rude words.
My dear Roger, surely you are the first person to recognize the justifcation of possible foul play against you. You justify putting an infant in posible danger by claiming that others do it. You justify taking honest (by your own admission) people to court, on perceived trespasses by third parties, you justify selling devices of doubtfull use to unsuspecting customers by referring to the perceived crimes of others. Surely, you understand and accept that since I perceive you as a swindler, I am justified in using foul play against you?

As for traps, I don't set traps for you. I could, but there is no need as you so so very well all by yourself.

As for time, I'm glad to hear you have plenty of time. Then I can hope that you will find time to address my refutations of your arguments?

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Thanks PJ for the link to a site describing wound healing. You pointed out some of the chemicals/molecules involved (e.g. serotonin, but perhaps you missed this from the same site:

"Many aspects of wound healing have yet to be elucidated".

No problem Roger, i think i did point out that the mechanisms were not fully understood in my post. I did not see any mention of bioelectrical control mechanisms however, and i think its quite clear that healing takes place as a result of the release of various "chemicals" from nearby cells.
 
Marian said:


If you're referring to Martin Gardner he is (last I knew) alive and well. He turned 90 in 2004.

...
Anyway I also thought perhaps it refered to Martin Gardner, so I searched on google (hoping that it did not) and could find no report of his death.

Same here. Worrying moment, there!
 
"lymphocytes are 8-9 microns in diameter, so you are obviously an ignorant fool." Total crap. But no retraction when the crap was exposed!

Roger, now lets set the record straight on this, you intially claimed that lymphocytes were of the size 4-14, and that the range of radiation emitted by the harmonizer is 4-14. A clear attempt to establish a simple connection. My point was that lymphocytes are not that size. If you care to look at the literature, the size ranges of blood cells is reasonably varied. Your initial size (lower estimate)was wrong, lympocytes are not that small, and can be much bigger (than your maximum size).

You tried to establish a simple connection that does not exist.


edited to add:

LAST CALL FOR MR COGHILL AT THE CARCINOGENESIS THREAD - ITS IN THE SCIENCE FORUM.(avoid obvious joke pj)

For interested parties, despite requesting a seperate thread to discuss carcinogenesis, Mr Coghill has not posted on the thread yet. I leave you to draw your own conclusions.
 
cogreslab said:
I dare say that some will now say OK but if you haven’t yet proved it works how can you justify offering such a device? It could at best be simply a placebo, and at worst a dangerous deception if people are putting trust in this unproven adornment. But first you must see that view against a background where the cellphone industry is constantly claiming out loud there is no hazard whatsoever from RF radiation at less than thermal levels. And they haven’t proved their case either. So even if this device was simply a placebo, in a world where there is no other solution to these non-elective unregulated exposures, the psychological value alone gives the device an advantage if only as a talisman. Doctors use placebos as a part of medical practice.


I have just read that.

Some posts earlier I told you that Roger Coghill looks down on the general public. He have us for idiots and he sees people as wallets that he must empty because somebody else will do that anyway.

Do you need more proof about that than his own confession?
It's impossible for somebody to believe seriously the last four lines from the quote above. It's just impossible for somebody to believe that. Impossible. This is one of the most cynical attitudes I have ever encountered.
 
cogreslab said:
Coming back down to earth:

you said:

"Because, an area contained within a conducting surface is like a Faraday cage, like the conducting sphere you stumbled so badly on before. The electric flux within a conducting enclosure (like a sphere) is ZERO by definition. See Gauss's Law, one of the most fundamental of the basic electrical laws".

This may apply to fully enclosed metal containers, or to Newton's bucket experiment, but cell membranes are far from equilibrium lossy materials ( i.e. leaky buckets) and your schoolboy physics no longer applies
The BODY is a faraday cage. Obviously, the effectivity of any faraday cage depends on the conductivity of the material that forms it, but by your own observation (you have even conducted tests), the body has excellent conductivity. So it follows that the body must be a good faraday cage. Consquently, electrical fields are excluded from the body.

Hans
 
That IS revealing isn't it.

I suppose the equivalent is selling special purple elephant proof trousers here in the UK.

If there is no immediate elephant menage then they are not ineffective and if there is an elephant menace then purple trousers are as effective as any other.

What he does ignore is the possiblily that some other kind of device could actually provide protection should it be proved that there is a danger.
 
cogreslab said:
The stupid challenges of the genuine ness about an evident degree or two of mine have been disproved.

Oh no they haven't! You're not getting off that easy. You obviously think we're stupid enough to fall for the kind of misdirection that works on your followers, but you are mistaken.

Let me requote your own words so that nobody is in any doubt:

Whilst writing, a little about me and the laboratory. I have a Masters from
Emmanuel College, Cambridge where I was an Open Scholar in Biology,

Which, to any reasonable person implies that you have an MA in Biology.

And you have proved exactly WHAT? You have stated that you have "an honours degree in biological sciences". Which firstly we have accepted on trust, it has not been PROVED, and secondly you refuse to tell us what the title is, i.e. BA or MA or something else. The simple fact that you are STILL resisting telling us what that qualification actually is, is clear indication to me that you are hiding something.

I may have been wrong about my opinion that "Biology" does not equal "Biological Sciences" as far as Cambridge is concerned, but that doesn't let you off the hook if you DON'T have an MA in Biological Sciences as you have led others to believe.

I have given up asking since you won't tell us. But I remind you, that the onus for a claim lies on the claimant. Since you have NOT proved you have an MA in biology, and since you have refused to even address that, then by default the claim is considered FALSE - simple rules of logic. And if it IS false, you are a liar, pure and simple.

I continue to believe that you ARE a liar unless/until you DO prove otherwise.
 
Instead of addressing the questions raised about his previous argumentation, Mr. Coghill opts to continue his train of argumentation. So be it. Now, let's see:

cogreslab said:
RESONANCE IN THE NATURAL WORLD
with particular reference to organic cells.

Resonance at an atomic level

In molecular chemistry the concept of resonance is demonstrated when a particular molecule can assume two differing states, and alternate between these. In these cases the electrons, not the atoms change locations in some regular way, and thereby achieve stability that neither of the two alternative states can do. Without necessarily re-postulating a luminiferous ether, this can give rise to detection at a distance. Thus resonances can be used to identify molecules at a distance,

Yes, quite big distances, in fact. All across the known universe, actually.

Example (taken from from http://www.cem.msu.edu website, q.v.), but since the Michigan Univ site is being moved your best bet is to find it via Google (keyword resonance):

Very helpful, indeed, "resonance" gets 1,630,000 hits on Google :con2:.

For example, sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitric acid (HNO3) may each be described by two equivalent formulas.. This averaging of electron distribution over two or more hypothetical contributing structures (canonical forms) to produce a hybrid electronic structure is called resonance. Likewise, the structure of nitric acid is best described as a resonance hybrid of two structures, a double headed arrow being the unique symbol for resonance.
The above examples represent one extreme in the application of resonance. Here, two structurally and energetically equivalent electronic structures for a stable compound can be written, but no single structure provides an accurate or even an adequate representation of the true molecule. In cases such as these, the electron delocalization described by resonance enhances the stability of the molecules, and compounds or ions composed of such molecules often show exceptional stability.

The electronic structures of most covalent compounds do not suffer the inadequacy noted above. Thus, completely satisfactory Kekulé formulas may be drawn for water (H2O), methane (CH4) and acetylene C2H2). Nevertheless, the principles of resonance are very useful in rationalizing the chemical behavior of many such compounds. For example, the carbonyl group of formaldehyde (the carbon-oxygen double bond) reacts readily to give addition products. The course of these reactions can be explained by a small contribution of a dipolar resonance contributor. Here, the first contributor (see diagram on their website) is clearly the best representation of this molecular unit, since there is no charge separation and both the carbon and oxygen atoms have achieved valence shell neon-like configurations by covalent electron sharing. If the double bond is broken heterolytically, formal charge pairs result, as shown in the other two structures. The preferred charge distribution will have the positive charge on the less electronegative atom (carbon) and the negative charge on the more electronegative atom (oxygen). Therefore the middle formula represents a more reasonable and stable structure than the one on the right. The application of resonance to this case requires a weighted averaging of these canonical structures. The double bonded structure is regarded as the major contributor, the middle structure a minor contributor and the right hand structure a non-contributor. Since the middle, charge-separated contributor has an electron deficient carbon atom, this explains the tendency of electron donors (nucleophiles) to bond at this site.

Yada, yada, yada. No need to lecture us on basic physics.

The basic principles of the resonance method may now be summarized.
For a given compound, a set of Lewis / Kekulé structures are written, keeping the relative positions of all the component atoms the same. These are the canonical forms to be considered, and all must have the same number of paired and unpaired electrons.
The following factors are important in evaluating the contribution each of these canonical structures makes to the actual molecule.
The number of covalent bonds in a structure. (The greater the bonding, the more important and stable the contributing structure.)
Formal charge separation. (Other factors aside, charge separation decreases the stability and importance of the contributing structure.)
Electronegativity of charge bearing atoms and charge density. (High charge density is destabilizing. Positive charge is best accommodated on atoms of low electronegativity, and negative charge on high electronegative atoms.)
The stability of a resonance hybrid is always greater than the stability of any canonical contributor. Consequently, if one canonical form has a much greater stability than all others, the hybrid will closely resemble it electronically and energetically. (This is the case for the carbonyl group).
All the examples on the cem webpage demonstrate an important restriction that must be remembered when using resonance. No atoms change their positions within the common structural framework. Only electrons are moved.

Yada some more.

Resonance at a cellular level.

Resonance at a cellular level is somewhat different.

Which sorta makes the lengthy lecture above somewhat irrelevant for the subject at hand. Especially since "somewhat" is an understatement. The term "entirely" would be correct.

Here the resonance is achieved when an electromagnetic wave ‘s characteristics physically match the characteristics of the object to be resonated. The effect is known as half wave resonance because the length of half the EM wave must match the diameter of, say, a globular object for the resonance to occur.

This goes for any conductive object. However, many other modes of resonance exist.

This is perhaps better understood by imagining a sphere (or circle if you looking at a diagram on a page) being sliced through the middle horizontally and the bottom semicircle moved to the right until its left limb touches the right limb of the upper semicircle. You have now constructed what looks like a sine wave on the imagined page, and the length of this "wave" is twice the diameter of the original circle (or sphere).

Definitely a layman's analogy, but OK.

If we now assume that the wave is actually composed of "crowds" of electrons moving in higher and lower gangs (to represent increased or decreased amplitude) then these will cross the midline in one direction at one time and in the opposite direction the next time.

However, we cannot assume that a wave is composed of electrons, because it is not. A current in a conductor is composed of electrons, but that is not a wave. Counting wrong premises: 14. (assuming that this post is a sequel to your earlier, and anyhow, the consequtive numbering will help you reference them when (if?) you address the problems).

Very disturbing to the surface of the sphere! It surface at that place will be subjected fortst to an upward, and then to a downward pressure.

Not at all. Neither a stream of electrons nor an electromagnetic wave will excert a physical force on a conductor, or a cell. Counting wrong premises: 15.

Only when the half wave matches the diameter will this occur however, so if the wave is smaller or larger than the object’s diameter then this "irritition" will not occur.

Since the "irritition" [sic] will not occur at all, this is wrong, too. Counting: 16.

It is easy to see that if one knows the diameter of an object one can thereby infer the wavelength which will resonate it. And since there is an inevitable relationship between wavelength and frequency, the freqwuency need to resonate an object can also be deduced. All this is very simple, really, and stands to reason.

The diameter of an object reflects the wavelength of its electrical resonance, that is correct, althoug it does not follow from your previous two statements. The relationship between wavelength and frequency is not as simple in a conductive medium as you perhaps think, but, let's not nitpick.

Nature has made use of this effect in a number of ways. We humans have receptors for waves of visible light, and so we can see the emissions of glow worms and fireflies as they communicate between themselves at light frequencies.

Uhh, in short: We can see. I am far from convinced this has anything to do with resonance, though, since the bandwidth of the color-sensitive cells in our retina is rather wide for a resonant phenomenon.

But other organisms use different wavelengths, e.g. in the far infra red, or the ultraviolet, and these we cannot normally see. In deed, there is a whole ocean out there of raditions created by the creatures of our planet for purposes as diverse as navigation, prey detecdtion, and signalling to or from a prospective mate.

The visible spectrum of a number of creatures is wider than, or different from, that of humans, correct. To call it a whole ocean is perhaps somewhat exaggarated, since it is still a quite small part of the EM spectrum.

In our case as an example, the Schumann resonances of the planet dictate our circadian rhythms, probably by a melatonin dependent mechanism.

Going off on a tangent here. This post is about cellular resonance.

The trouble is, when artificially originating electromagnetic waves appear, they can inhibit the synthesis of melatonin according to some studies, and since melatonin is known to be a powerful antioxidant and oncostatic agent, this lowered synthesis in turn increases the likelihood of cancer.

Another tangent. This is a different debate.

Resonance can also impair lymphocyte function: if one assumes a diameter of say 10 microns for an average lymphocyte then by the notion set out above a wave of length 20 microns would resonate it. This implies a wave in the far infra red region (FIR) of the electromagnetic spectrum.

And such a wave is radiated from an object with a temperature of 145 deg K. Fortunately, such an object is unlikely to be found in or near the human body. Oops! There goes the entire string of argumentation leading up to here. Too bad. Let us be nice and just count one failed premise: 17.

On the lymphocyte surface there is a veritable forest of glycoproteins (imagine them like rock candy sticks, very stiff as a result of being sugars) with an incredible variety of side rods called sialic acid residues sticking out from them, and mostly carrying a negative charge. Because opposite charges attract if any positive charges arrive near they reflect these by charge neutralisation. A good example would be the calcium ion, which carries two positive charges (or rather its outer valence shell is lacking two electrons).

Whatever the truth-value of this it is difficult to see any relevance to resonant phenomenon, so lets give it an: 18

In fact ionic calcium is known to be an important first messenger for carrying regulatory signals through the body, e.g. it plays an important role in heart beat regulation. It is also a vital second messenger, and is "allowed" into the cell interior thriough special calcumchannels too. Inside the cell there are machanisms to amplify the messenger signals and also as system to keep the cytosol clean of calcium using calmodulin as a sort of store so that the signal to noise ratio is optimised. The cell might have used magnesium instead, (also a cation) but for reasons not understood it prefers calcium.
Of course, calcium is tempted to "stick" to any place which carries negative charges, just as calcium salts might build up in your domestic waster pipes. Static magnetic fields appear to slow down that temptation, but that’s another story.

Let's just say: Yada :rolleyes:.

For the moment let us understand that objects delivering FIR signals of precisely the right frequency can therefore communicate precisely with cells in general via resonance, and with lymphocytes in particular

Sorry, but that does not follow at all. Even if the premises above were correct,
you have not explained how this alleged communication occurs: 19.
You have not explained how possible information is encoded for transmission: 20.
You have not explained how it gets directed at the cells: 21.
You have not addressed the problem of how to apply resonance to an object embedded in a conductive medium: 22.
You have not explained how a 20micron IR wave is generated in an environment where humans can exist: 23.

In short, you have not explained anything at all.


Resonance at an organic level.

I will discuss this on a separate post.

In short: :bricks:


Hans
 
Pragmatist said:
...snip...


Which, to any reasonable person implies that you have an MA in Biology.

...snip...

It might do however I expect that cogreslab is referring to something that I think is unique to Cambridge (and perhaps Oxford) and that is

http://www.quns.cam.ac.uk/Queens/Misc/jargon/CUjargon-all.html (bold by me)

Master of Arts - a degree higher than a B.A. and lower than any Doctor. In medieval times obtained after studying the Quadrivium; now obtainable by any Cambridge Bachelor of Arts six clear years after matriculation.

Sounds as if it is just something you apply for, not a "worked for" degree.

cogreslab – is the MA of your quoted qualifications the one in the above quotation, that is obtainable by any Cambridge Batchelor of Arts 6 years after leaving Cambridge?

(Edited for a few too many iss.)
 
Pragmatist said:
You have stated that you have "an honours degree in biological sciences". Which firstly we have accepted on trust, it has not been PROVED, and secondly you refuse to tell us what the title is, i.e. BA or MA or something else. The simple fact that you are STILL resisting telling us what that qualification actually is, is clear indication to me that you are hiding something.
This is an odd one. I think Cambridge gives out Bachelor's degrees, but (to quote Roger) if you stay out of jail for a few years these are automatically upgraded to MA. It may be that he only gets to claim one MA even though he has attained degree level in both Classics and Biology, but I'm really not sure.

The Biology qualification intrigues me. Roger said he was awarded second class honours, without specifying the grade. To me that implied a 2.2, because he specifically said he got a 2.1 in Classics. However, the dates he gave only covered a two-year course, and I simply don't see how you can get an honours degree in only two years unless you're counting credits from another related course. And Classics doesn't usually provide any credits applicable to Biology.

Why can't he just tell us straight? I could explain the apparent two-year duration of my honours BSc course quite easily if asked to.
The Don remarked:
If there is no immediate elephant menage then they are not ineffective and if there is an elephant menace then purple trousers are as effective as any other.
However, if there is a real elephant menace, and the only effective defence is to stay indoors, then the purple trousers may be extremely dangerous if they lull you into a false sense of security and you then go outside thinking they are protecting you.

This is so morally and intellectually bankrupt I'm surprised even Roger is prepared to commit it to print.

Rolfe.
 
cogreslab said:
Resonance at an atomic level

In molecular chemistry the concept of resonance is demonstrated when a particular molecule can assume two differing states, and alternate between these. In these cases the electrons, not the atoms change locations in some regular way, and thereby achieve stability that neither of the two alternative states can do. Without necessarily re-postulating a luminiferous ether, this can give rise to detection at a distance. Thus resonances can be used to identify molecules at a distance,

Example (taken from from http://www.cem.msu.edu website, q.v.), but since the Michigan Univ site is being moved your best bet is to find it via Google (keyword resonance):

For example, sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitric acid (HNO3) may each be described by two equivalent formulas.. This averaging of electron distribution over two or more hypothetical contributing structures (canonical forms) to produce a hybrid electronic structure is called resonance. Likewise, the structure of nitric acid is best described as a resonance hybrid of two structures, a double headed arrow being the unique symbol for resonance.
The above examples represent one extreme in the application of resonance. Here, two structurally and energetically equivalent electronic structures for a stable compound can be written, but no single structure provides an accurate or even an adequate representation of the true molecule. In cases such as these, the electron delocalization described by resonance enhances the stability of the molecules, and compounds or ions composed of such molecules often show exceptional stability.

The electronic structures of most covalent compounds do not suffer the inadequacy noted above. Thus, completely satisfactory Kekulé formulas may be drawn for water (H2O), methane (CH4) and acetylene C2H2). Nevertheless, the principles of resonance are very useful in rationalizing the chemical behavior of many such compounds. For example, the carbonyl group of formaldehyde (the carbon-oxygen double bond) reacts readily to give addition products. The course of these reactions can be explained by a small contribution of a dipolar resonance contributor. Here, the first contributor (see diagram on their website) is clearly the best representation of this molecular unit, since there is no charge separation and both the carbon and oxygen atoms have achieved valence shell neon-like configurations by covalent electron sharing. If the double bond is broken heterolytically, formal charge pairs result, as shown in the other two structures. The preferred charge distribution will have the positive charge on the less electronegative atom (carbon) and the negative charge on the more electronegative atom (oxygen). Therefore the middle formula represents a more reasonable and stable structure than the one on the right. The application of resonance to this case requires a weighted averaging of these canonical structures. The double bonded structure is regarded as the major contributor, the middle structure a minor contributor and the right hand structure a non-contributor. Since the middle, charge-separated contributor has an electron deficient carbon atom, this explains the tendency of electron donors (nucleophiles) to bond at this site.

The basic principles of the resonance method may now be summarized.
For a given compound, a set of Lewis / Kekulé structures are written, keeping the relative positions of all the component atoms the same. These are the canonical forms to be considered, and all must have the same number of paired and unpaired electrons.
The following factors are important in evaluating the contribution each of these canonical structures makes to the actual molecule.
The number of covalent bonds in a structure. (The greater the bonding, the more important and stable the contributing structure.)
Formal charge separation. (Other factors aside, charge separation decreases the stability and importance of the contributing structure.)
Electronegativity of charge bearing atoms and charge density. (High charge density is destabilizing. Positive charge is best accommodated on atoms of low electronegativity, and negative charge on high electronegative atoms.)
The stability of a resonance hybrid is always greater than the stability of any canonical contributor. Consequently, if one canonical form has a much greater stability than all others, the hybrid will closely resemble it electronically and energetically. (This is the case for the carbonyl group).


All the examples on the cem webpage demonstrate an important restriction that must be remembered when using resonance. No atoms change their positions within the common structural framework. Only electrons are moved.

Just when I think your arguments couldn't get any more lame or inane you always manage to outdo yourself!

The concept of formula "resonance" in chemistry has nothing whatsoever to do with the concept of FREQUENCY resonance which is what we were discussing! But of course, you don't know that do you? Another cherry pick of completely irrelevant information to bolster a non-argument.

The proper link for the above information you copied is:

http://www.cem.msu.edu/~reusch/VirtualText/intro3.htm

And this is a new tactic that I urge everyone to watch out for. He's copied part of some text from a web site (above) and then apparently tacked his own stuff on the end with no clear distinction between where the facts end and the BS begins. And then he gives an excuse to avoid giving the proper URL so that anyone can easily check the information themselves. And there is nothing on that site that I can see that says the site is being moved and there is no legitimate reason in any event for not giving the full URL - unless you don't want people to see the original.

So I've separated the quote so we can all see what's what here.

Jeez, Rog, you can't get much lower than this. But by now I guess I know that you will prove me wrong about that.
 
cogreslab said:
RESONANCE IN THE NATURAL WORLD
with particular reference to organic cells.

Resonance at a cellular level.

Resonance at a cellular level is somewhat different. Here the resonance is achieved when an electromagnetic wave ‘s characteristics physically match the characteristics of the object to be resonated. The effect is known as half wave resonance because the length of half the EM wave must match the diameter of, say, a globular object for the resonance to occur.

This is perhaps better understood by imagining a sphere (or circle if you looking at a diagram on a page) being sliced through the middle horizontally and the bottom semicircle moved to the right until its left limb touches the right limb of the upper semicircle. You have now constructed what looks like a sine wave on the imagined page, and the length of this "wave" is twice the diameter of the original circle (or sphere).

If we now assume that the wave is actually composed of "crowds" of electrons moving in higher and lower gangs (to represent increased or decreased amplitude) then these will cross the midline in one direction at one time and in the opposite direction the next time. Very disturbing to the surface of the sphere! It surface at that place will be subjected fortst to an upward, and then to a downward pressure. Only when the half wave matches the diameter will this occur however, so if the wave is smaller or larger than the object’s diameter then this "irritition" will not occur.

It is easy to see that if one knows the diameter of an object one can thereby infer the wavelength which will resonate it. And since there is an inevitable relationship between wavelength and frequency, the freqwuency need to resonate an object can also be deduced. All this is very simple, really, and stands to reason.

Nature has made use of this effect in a number of ways. We humans have receptors for waves of visible light, and so we can see the emissions of glow worms and fireflies as they communicate between themselves at light frequencies. But other organisms use different wavelengths, e.g. in the far infra red, or the ultraviolet, and these we cannot normally see. In deed, there is a whole ocean out there of raditions created by the creatures of our planet for purposes as diverse as navigation, prey detecdtion, and signalling to or from a prospective mate.

In our case as an example, the Schumann resonances of the planet dictate our circadian rhythms, probably by a melatonin dependent mechanism. The trouble is, when artificially originating electromagnetic waves appear, they can inhibit the synthesis of melatonin according to some studies, and since melatonin is known to be a powerful antioxidant and oncostatic agent, this lowered synthesis in turn increases the likelihood of cancer.

Resonance can also impair lymphocyte function: if one assumes a diameter of say 10 microns for an average lymphocyte then by the notion set out above a wave of length 20 microns would resonate it. This implies a wave in the far infra red region (FIR) of the electromagnetic spectrum. On the lymphocyte surface there is a veritable forest of glycoproteins (imagine them like rock candy sticks, very stiff as a result of being sugars) with an incredible variety of side rods called sialic acid residues sticking out from them, and mostly carrying a negative charge. Because opposite charges attract if any positive charges arrive near they reflect these by charge neutralisation. A good example would be the calcium ion, which carries two positive charges (or rather its outer valence shell is lacking two electrons).

In fact ionic calcium is known to be an important first messenger for carrying regulatory signals through the body, e.g. it plays an important role in heart beat regulation. It is also a vital second messenger, and is "allowed" into the cell interior thriough special calcumchannels too. Inside the cell there are machanisms to amplify the messenger signals and also as system to keep the cytosol clean of calcium using calmodulin as a sort of store so that the signal to noise ratio is optimised. The cell might have used magnesium instead, (also a cation) but for reasons not understood it prefers calcium.
Of course, calcium is tempted to "stick" to any place which carries negative charges, just as calcium salts might build up in your domestic waster pipes. Static magnetic fields appear to slow down that temptation, but that’s another story. For the moment let us understand that objects delivering FIR signals of precisely the right frequency can therefore communicate precisely with cells in general via resonance, and with lymphocytes in particular

Resonance at an organic level.

I will discuss this on a separate post.

And THIS is the text you added to the text from the chemistry site. Now what is the reference for this?

And the above is complete BS. I will address it later.
 
Pragmatist said:


*snip*
The concept of formula "resonance" in chemistry has nothing whatsoever to do with the concept of FREQUENCY resonance which is what we were discussing! But of course, you don't know that do you? Another cherry pick of completely irrelevant information to bolster a non-argument.

*snip*
Just like, as I have pointed out some time ago, the term "electrical field" when talking about signals inside the body, and around fish in water, has nothing to do with the elctromagnetic term "electrical field". But, what does a lay-man care about that?

Hans
 
Just a note on electrical resonance, for those with technical interest: For any resonant circuit, including a straight conductor, there is a factor, "Q", or "goodness" (I seem to have forgotten the proper English term). The higher the Q, the better the resonance, and consequently the more narrow the bandwidth. If we look at a conductor, an antenna, the Q gets lower, the thicker the condutor is. This is perhaps counterintuitive as a thick conductor has lower los, but this is because it allows for various other resonance modes. When the antenna gets to be as thick as it is long, which is true of a spere, the Q gets very low, I'm not sure, but I would suspect so low that real resonance is not opbtainable. I have never heard of a sperical resonant circuit, nor a sperical antenna.

Not that it matters much for Roger's train of argumentation, since it is totally moot even without this.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
Just a note on electrical resonance, for those with technical interest: For any resonant circuit, including a straight conductor, there is a factor, "Q", or "goodness" (I seem to have forgotten the proper English term).

"Quality factor" is, I believe, what you're looking for.
 
Thanks to Hans for his continued good work in responding to the "science" Roger's posts. I must admit I didn't pay too much attention (ok, actually none) to this the first time round.

cogreslab said:
Resonance at an atomic level

In molecular chemistry the concept of resonance is demonstrated when a particular molecule can assume two differing states, and alternate between these. In these cases the electrons, not the atoms change locations in some regular way, and thereby achieve stability that neither of the two alternative states can do.
As Hans as already said, this has nothing to do with the other ideas of 'resonance', but I want to comment on it anyway, because it's completely wrong.

What you are describing are resonance forms, a way of displaying molecular structure. They are entirely artificial constructs, which arise from the limitations of how molecules are normally displayed. Molecules with resonance forms do not, I repeat, do not, "alternate between" different states. The structural forms are imaginary.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom