Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:
Since some of the readers are laypersons, and some of them might have camcorders with infra red (zero lux) capability, they will be curious to know, if all objects radiate IR in such a way (i.e. only at around 9 microns) that no resolution could be possible, they can still get an acceptable image from a completely dark room.

That's not what he wrote, roger, and you bloody well know it. This post of yours is yet another strawman blatherfest. Here, roger, is what he wrote:

Now, as Hans pointed out earlier, and even Roger himself, at body temperature, 37 degrees celsius, the peak (i.e. the MAJORITY) of the radiation is emitted at around 9 microns, which is well within the above range. What Roger didn't know was just how wide that range really is.

Do you see the difference, sir? Do you see that he was discussing living bodies at 37 degrees celsius, sir, and not "all objects"?
 
MRC_Hans said:
Well, since the conductivity of cell walls is not linear, yes it is possible that demodulation (and intermodulation) might occur under certain circumstances. And?

Hans

More than that. Cell membranes have a significant potential difference across them, it's not exactly rocket science to realise that they will rectify and therefore demodulate. What bothers me is that someone needed to do a STUDY to work this out? I sincerely hope that these people are not being paid from public funds!

I wonder how many other people are doing studies to test stunning new scientific insights, for example, studies to determine if the sea is wet!
 
cogreslab said:


Snip....

So your claim that IR radiation is too diffuse for use as an information delivery medium in organic life is complete crap.
Continued.



Nobody's claimed that it's too diffuse for an information delivery system, but because moth's can effectively 'see' into the infrared doesn't mean that lymphocytes do the same and you've zero evidence to show that that this is the case.

This what was said that in trying to put any IR energy into the body by your little gizmo would be utterly swamped by IR radiation from every other source that's around the same temperature.


I'm not sure if you're a fraud or deluded, I'm coming to the conclusion it's the latter.
 
Marian said:
I recently bought "Fads & Fallacies In the Name of Science" by Martin Gardner, and I read a section I thought applied rather well to this thread. Unfortunately it was a little long, and I didn't want to type it up, but I found that someone else had typed it up on another board. So I've copied that and am posting it here. Source is Martin Gardner's book.
________________________
"[M]ost pseudo-scientists have a number of characteristics in
common.

"First and most important of these traits is that cranks work
in almost total isolation . . . in the sense of having no fruitful
contacts with fellow researchers. . . . The modern crank insists
that his isolation is not desired on his part. It is due, he claims,
to the prejudice of established scientific groups against new
ideas. . . .

"The modern pseudo-scientist . . . stands entirely outside
the closely integrated channels through which new ideas are
introduced and evaluated. He works in isolation. He does not
send his findings to the recognized journals, or if he does, they
are rejected for reasons which in the vast majority of cases
are excellent. In most cases, the crank is not well enough
informed to write a paper with even a surface resemblance
to a significant study. As a consequence, he finds himself
excluded the journals and societies, and almost universally
ignored by the competent workers in his field. In fact, the
reputable scientist does not even know of the crank's
existence unless his work is given widespread publicity through
non-academic channels, or unless the scientist makes a hobby
of collecting crank literature. The eccentric is forced, therefore,
to tread a lonely way. He speaks before organizations he
himself has founded, contributes to journals he himself may
edit, and -- until recently -- publishes books only when he
or his followers can raise sufficient funds to have them printed
privately.

"A second characteristic of the pseudo scientist, which
greatly strengthens his isolation, is a tendency toward
paranoia. . . .

"There are five ways in which the sincere pseudo-
scientist's paranoid tendencies are likely to be exhibited.

"(1) He considers himself a genius.

"(2) He regards his colleagues, without exception, as
ignorant blockheads. Everyone is out of step except himself.
Frequently he insults his opponents by accusing them of
stupidity, dishonesty, or other base motives. If they ignore
him, he takes this to mean his arguments are unanswerable.
If they retaliate in kind, this strengthens his delusion that he
is battling scoundrels. . . .

"(3) He believes himself unjustly persecuted and discriminated
against. . . .

"(4) He has a strong compulsion to focus his attacks on the
greatest scientists and the best established theories. When
Newton was the outstanding name in physics, eccentric works
in that science were violently anti Newton. Today, with
Einstein the father symbol of authority, a crank theory of
physics is likely to attack Einstein in the name of Newton. . . .

"(5) He often has a tendency to write in a complex
jargon, in many cases making use of terms and phrases he
himself has coined. . . ."
__________________________

From what you say this quote is trotted out by Randarians more than on one occasionj, and the inference here is that it applies to me.

let's see if this cap fits:

1. "First and most important of these traits is that cranks work
in almost total isolation . . . in the sense of having no fruitful
contacts with fellow researchers".

Apart from those colleagues in the lab itself, the members of the Welsh biotech conmmunity and the Iob members, in the next few weeks I am going to Istanbul for the WHO meeting and then to Washington for the BEMS meeting where I shall get together with biolelectromagnetics colleagues I have known for many nyears. Then in July to the Gordon Conference in CT. I could welcome some isolation! This is to keep in tiouch with new science as it emerges.

2. "A second characteristic of the pseudo scientist, which
greatly strengthens his isolation, is a tendency toward
paranoia. . . .

1. No way do I think I am in the genius class! I have said so a few times on thus thread and pointed instead to many famous scientists whose work I admire and congratulate. Also my work is peer review puiblished. If I call others stupid occasionally, it is a habit I learned here.

As for persecution, if that is the case I haven't noticed it! Nor have the thousands of other scientists who share my views about PELs.

Sorry but to cut a long storyu short, your description is more fitting to certain other posters on this thread, and not to me!
 
cogreslab said:



As for persecution, if that is the case I haven't noticed it! Nor have the thousands of other scientists who share my views about PELs.


This from the person who claims that the NRPB is hiding something, that drugs companies are concealing data on effective treatments for cancer, that people have had their grants stopped for daring to research in to the deleterious effects of electrical fields.........
 
Pragmatist said:



Finally, I caught on the moment Roger mentioned 4 to 14 microns. Why? Because there is a whole industry of quack devices which claim to emit special radiation in EXACTLY this range. If you search the web you will find hundreds of people advertizing special "FIR emitters" which radiate in this range. Along with all kinds of claims about how this range is uniquely produced by THEIR device etc. It's a con, and an old one at that! Of COURSE they emit in this range - EVERYTHING does!

I'll discuss the OTHER problems separately.

If you look at the IR absorption band windows and atmospheric scattering from 1 - 16 microns, you see a large window of relatively low absorption between 4 and 14 microns punctuated only by water (5-7 microns) and oxygen (c. 9.5 microns). Kruse et al, 1963 related trransmission of IR through the atmosphere to measureable absolute humidity. An IR signal must provide a detectable difference between itself and any spurious background radiation.

Since all objects radiate (not disputed) it is obvious that the background noise might override the detectable signal. Clouds produce variations but these have the greatest effect at wavelengths below 3 microns, which is another example of why Nature has selected IR wavelengths for organic information transfer at a distance above that wavelength region. .
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*

Prag, you are talking rubbish and using pseudoscience to present your self as a knowledgable expert.

The irony of this sentence coming from you is too deep for words.

Since some of the readers are laypersons, and some of them might have camcorders with infra red (zero lux) capability, they will be curious to know, if all objects radiate IR in such a way (i.e. only at around 9 microns) that no resolution could be possible, they can still get an acceptable image from a completely dark room.

That was not what Pragmaic said. You, Roger, are the one who is talking about some tuning of wavelengths to certain cells, and what Pragmaitic correctly points out is that a "receiver" tuned to IR in the band 4-14 microns will be flooded with input from all parts of an indoor ambience, because while the peak radiation is dependent on the temperature, the radiated band is very wide, so the radiation fom any object with a temperature between freezing and scalding will contain lots of radiation in the 4-14 band.

As for IR sensitive camaras of any kind, they are not able to distinguish wavelenght at all. They record only intensity, which also varies with temperature.


Of course, even our present technology can distinguish between IR radiations of only slightly different temperatures sufficiently to provide meaningful information. This was the point I made and you have not overturned it.

Beacuse it is irrelevant to your claims. Modern IR temperature probes do not detect wavelength. They use intensity, just like camaras.

It is a well known physical phenomenon that IR radiation is generated by vibration and rotation of atoms and molecules in any temperature above absolute zero. IR is often misdescribed as thermal, but it actually demonstrates many of the characteristics of visible light and radar waves. It may be focused, , transmitted like radio or radar through materials that block visible light, and it can be used to deliver information with the same precision.

Not only does it behave like electromagnetic waves, it IS electromagnetic waves. There is nothing wrong with the term "thermal", it simply denotes this particular part of the EM spectum, just like "light" denotes another.

As for your stupid comments about the great temperature range exhibited between 4 and 14 microns wavelength, let me givwe ione example from nature to show how IR can be used with great precision to convey information at a distance. Dorsett (1962) used a thermocouple to measure the increase in temperature generated by various species of sphingids during wing vibrations and observed an increase about the resting /ambient temperature of upto 18 degrees C.

Roger, a thermocouple does not detect wavelenght, it detects intensity :rolleyes:. Do you know at all what a thermocouple is and how it works?

Callahan later proved that the corn ear moth could regulate its IR emissions extremely precisely by changing its wing beat rate, thereby varying thorax temperature.

If we consider the heated earworm moth as a black body (unity) , then for every degree of temperature we can calculate, using Wein’s displacement law, a specific radiation wavelength where:

Lamda m x T = b,

Lamda m being the wavelength of maximum radiation intensity in centimeters, T the temperature in Kelvin of the source object, a nd b the Wein displacement constant (=2897 m K° if landa m is calculated in microns).

Cool, Roger, you ARE quick on the take-up. That was the formula I posted a couple of pages back, and used to calculate the emission peak of your harmonizer.

Therefore lamda m = 2897/absolute temperture of a flying earworm moth

= 2897/273 + 24 C° = 9.7 microns at 76 F° and at 1800 wing beats/minute.

As the moth’s wing frequency rises towards its peak and as the temperature rises above ambient, the wavelength in microns for peak radition (lamda m) decreases. Callahan then showed by accurate measurements of inflight temperature that every species of moth used a characteristic wing beat rate and thereby an identifiable wavelength of IR radiation.

Yes, and like everybody else, he used the intensity. While the spectrum of an IR radiation can be measured, this is much too complicated for normal temperature measurements.

I will not bother to address the issue of whether the minute changes in radiation energy are detectable by the except to say that the antennae sensory pits of certain species of ants, grasshoppers, bees, and chafers could be considered as dielectric wave guides. Callahan sets out the radiation emitted per steradian and comes up with about 0.009 watts/steradian. It is further evident that only a few degrees change in K can shift the spectral distribution in langleys radiated between 9.5 microns and 10 microns sufficiently for easy detection by the moth ( e.g. 9.66 microns at 300 K (80.6 F), 10.0 microns at 289 K (60.8 F).

See above :rolleyes:

So your claim that IR radiation is too diffuse for use as an information delivery medium in organic life is complete crap.
Continued.

As demonstrated, it is a perfectly valid refutation of YOUR claim that a particilar radiation is somehow tuned to cells.
Again, your are caught by your lack of homework, Roger. But it gets worse: In you later, very long, post trying to explain the Harmonizer, you base your thesis on the shape of the device being somehow tuned to certain waves and acting like an amplifier (or perhaps concentrator, since amplification is out of the question), but wavelegths where such a function might be postulated are nowhere near the 4-14 micron range. Since the size of your device is (I assume from the pictures, but you might give us the exact dimensions) some six centimetres long, its resonance frequencies will be found somewhere in the 5-10GHz band.

Logical inconsistency, Roger. Again.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:


If you look at the IR absorption band windows and atmospheric scattering from 1 - 16 microns, you see a large window of relatively low absorption between 4 and 14 microns punctuated only by water (5-7 microns) and oxygen (c. 9.5 microns). Kruse et al, 1963 related trransmission of IR through the atmosphere to measureable absolute humidity. An IR signal must provide a detectable difference between itself and any spurious background radiation.
Yes, and especially at 10 microns, there is a particularly transparant window. All very interesting, but how exactly is it relevant to the matter at hand?

Oh, and before you mention IR remote controls, they are not frequency selected, either, they are intensity modulated. (Just thought I'd nip that one in the bud ;)).

Hans
 
cogreslab said:


*snip*
Since all objects radiate (not disputed) it is obvious that the background noise might override the detectable signal. Clouds produce variations but these have the greatest effect at wavelengths below 3 microns, which is another example of why Nature has selected IR wavelengths for organic information transfer at a distance above that wavelength region. .
Well, if you keep editing your posts, you must put up with multiple replies...

Only problem is that the idea that Nature signals anything by IR is entirely speculative.

Hans
 
Timble said:


This from the person who claims that the NRPB is hiding something, that drugs companies are concealing data on effective treatments for cancer, that people have had their grants stopped for daring to research in to the deleterious effects of electrical fields.........

How are all these truths supposed to persecute me? My concerns about the problem (with which thousands of others agree, as you saw not from me but from a British MP the other day) are more likely to persecute the NRPB than the other way round. I am an inconvenient thorn in their side, and quite rightly so since this problem needs to be addressed.

Addressed in two ways:

first to give the publ;ic the proper advice

and secondfly

to develop means of exposure mitigation.

That is one aim of our lab.
 
How do you suggest to make research, not to mention have your research taken seriously, if anybody with some knowledge can easily see how sketchy your understanding of the subject is? How do you suggest people should consider you credible when the homepage of your lab is also a shop-front for bogus devices?

Hans
 
cogreslab said:


I want to comment on this by adding some data, but so as not to lose the quote I am posting it now since i seem to have got the hang of the quote system.

Prag, you are talking rubbish and using pseudoscience to present your self as a knowledgable expert.

Lame Roger, lame! There are some extremely smart and well informed people on here. Do you honestly think that ANYONE could get away with spouting pseudoscience on here! Oh, I just realised....YOU think YOU can! Guess that was a bad example wasn't it? :)

cogreslab said:
Since some of the readers are laypersons, and some of them might have camcorders with infra red (zero lux) capability, they will be curious to know, if all objects radiate IR in such a way (i.e. only at around 9 microns) that no resolution could be possible, they can still get an acceptable image from a completely dark room. Of course, even our present technology can distinguish between IR radiations of only slightly different temperatures sufficiently to provide meaningful information. This was the point I made and you have not overturned it.

You never know when to stop digging do you? Oh, well, so be it. Firstly I never said that all objects only radiate around 9 microns. I said that the PEAK of radiation intensity is around 9 microns at normal environmental temperatures, and I also quite clearly said that the range is not a sharp cut off, but is very diffusely spread out around that.

As for camcorders. Camcorders don't work on the ambient thermal background radiation! They have infra-red emitters built in. And did it ever occur to you that there might be...wait for it...different ranges of infra-red?. No, of course it didn't, because you don't really know ANYTHING do you? The output range of typical modern IR emitters is typically in the range from 780 to 940 nanometers. But of course you won't believe that, you know everything don't you? The whole world is wrong, only you are right. For the benefit of laypeople:

From: http://www.dealtime.com/xPR-Sony_CCD_TRV308~RD-81212771972

0 Lux:

The 0 Lux (or Zero Lux...in case you thought it was an "o".) technology is very useful for that time when you happen to spot Big Foot or something in the dark wilderness...j/k. When sliding the nightshot option to the "On" position a little infrared LED turns on inside the tinted plastic window below the camera lens to cover a small area (up to 6-8 feet out..though you may see much more too because stars and such emit infrared waves.). The infrared then bounces back and the lens picks up the light.


From: http://www.bigbyte.co.nz/guides/guide001.html

Night Shot enables you to record in low light conditions without a separate video light. Zero-Lux models use an infrared light built in to the camcorder so you can record quality footage in complete darkness.

cogreslab said:
It is a well known physical phenomenon that IR radiation is generated by vibration and rotation of atoms and molecules in any temperature above absolute zero. IR is often misdescribed as thermal, but it actually demonstrates many of the characteristics of visible light and radar waves. It may be focused, , transmitted like radio or radar through materials that block visible light, and it can be used to deliver information with the same precision.

I've got news for you Rog, this will come as a shock, so sit down. IR, radio and radar are ALL the same, they are electromagnetic waves. It doesn't "demonstrate many of the characteristics" of the latter, it has IDENTICAL properties to the latter!

cogreslab said:
As for your stupid comments about the great temperature range exhibited between 4 and 14 microns wavelength, let me givwe ione example from nature to show how IR can be used with great precision to convey information at a distance. Dorsett (1962) used a thermocouple to measure the increase in temperature generated by various species of sphingids during wing vibrations and observed an increase about the resting /ambient temperature of upto 18 degrees C. Callahan later proved that the corn ear moth could regulate its IR emissions extremely precisely by changing its wing beat rate, thereby varying thorax temperature.

This will also come as a shock to you. I don't need it to be demonstrated, I have a TV remote control! :)

As for my "stupid" comments about the temperature range, if anyone wants to check, here is a link to a graphical thermal radiation calculator:

http://guymcarthur.com/resources/java/applets/planck/

If anyone wants to check, the temperatures need to be entered in Kelvin. -67 degrees celcius is 206 Kelvin, and +437 degrees C is 710 Kelvin.

cogreslab said:
If we consider the heated earworm moth as a black body (unity) , then for every degree of temperature we can calculate, using Wein’s displacement law, a specific radiation wavelength where:

Lamda m x T = b,

Lamda m being the wavelength of maximum radiation intensity in centimeters, T the temperature in Kelvin of the source object, a nd b the Wein displacement constant (=2897 m K° if landa m is calculated in microns).

Therefore lamda m = 2897/absolute temperture of a flying earworm moth

= 2897/273 + 24 C° = 9.7 microns at 76 F° and at 1800 wing beats/minute.

As the moth’s wing frequency rises towards its peak and as the temperature rises above ambient, the wavelength in microns for peak radition (lamda m) decreases. Callahan then showed by accurate measurements of inflight temperature that every species of moth used a characteristic wing beat rate and thereby an identifiable wavelength of IR radiation.

And the point of all this is? Oh, silly me, of course, it's to make laypeople think you actually know what you're talking about.....

cogreslab said:
I will not bother to address the issue of whether the minute changes in radiation energy are detectable by the except to say that the antennae sensory pits of certain species of ants, grasshoppers, bees, and chafers could be considered as dielectric wave guides. Callahan sets out the radiation emitted per steradian and comes up with about 0.009 watts/steradian. It is further evident that only a few degrees change in K can shift the spectral distribution in langleys radiated between 9.5 microns and 10 microns sufficiently for easy detection by the moth ( e.g. 9.66 microns at 300 K (80.6 F), 10.0 microns at 289 K (60.8 F).

So the personal harmonizer actually works by sending signals to moths, ants, grasshoppers and bees does it?

ANY specific range of radiation can be isolated from background by a highly tuned and filtered sensor. But lymphocytes are NOT highly tuned and filtered IR sensors. Furthermore, the radiation from insects is focussed and coherent, and finally, insects would have great difficulty communicating through the jacket of a suit, a tie, a shirt, maybe a vest, several layers of skin and fat, possibly bone, intracellular fluid.....and so on, ALL of which is absorbing and radiating in the same range!

cogreslab said:
So your claim that IR radiation is too diffuse for use as an information delivery medium in organic life is complete crap.

I made absolutely NO such claim. I claimed that the alleged "output" of a personal harmonizer would be virtually indistinguishable from background, especially after it had passed through the above materials. Your dishonesty is obvious sir, you cannot make any coherent argument without misrepresenting those of others. It is a tactic you use time and time again. Then again, in the absence of any tenable or credible argument of your own, I guess you don't have much else to rely on, do you?
 
cogreslab said:


If you look at the IR absorption band windows and atmospheric scattering from 1 - 16 microns, you see a large window of relatively low absorption between 4 and 14 microns punctuated only by water (5-7 microns) and oxygen (c. 9.5 microns). Kruse et al, 1963 related trransmission of IR through the atmosphere to measureable absolute humidity. An IR signal must provide a detectable difference between itself and any spurious background radiation.


Lymphocytes are found swimming in blood plasma, which is mainly water so it's going to be absorbed.

And your gimzo won't be the only emitter at that wavelength close to the skin. You're spitting in a tropical monsoon.
 
Thank you for the explanation of the Harmoniser, Roger. That has certainly cleared up the issue of whether you are a liar and a swindler for me.
 
Here's a question for you Roger:

Let assume for the sake of argument that a device external to the body somehow radiates coherent information coded into radiation at say 9 microns (or anywhere between 4 and 14 if you want). And let's further assume that somehow this radiation makes it all the way to a lymphocyte inside the body (ignoring all the other factors already mentioned) and that the "information" is not corrupted in any way. Let's further assume that the lymphocyte has a diameter of 9 microns (or if you don't like 9 microns, let's simply say that the lymphocyte size is EXACTLY identical to the wavelength of the external radiation). Is it your contention that there will be some specific interaction with the lymphocyte because the sizes of the lymphocyte and the radiation are the same? That the lymphocyte somehow acts as an antenna because it's the same size? Yes or no will do.

And I ask everyone else to keep quiet on this point until I get an answer from Roger.
 
JamesM said:
This thread never ceases to astonish.

I would very much like to know who the physical chemists are that consult with Mr Coghill, and what their expertise is, but I don't want to pile up yet another diversion.

He mentioned the name of the person concerned before somewhere, either on this thread or on his web site.

Given the size of this thread I don't want to go looking for it. Maybe Bill can search for it, he has some way of searching the thread. When he finishes munching his sandwich that is! :)
 
Mr Coghill / Cogreslab,

I know you're busy answering 'Lists' right now, and the thread does keep changing, but have you got a quick reference for my question about the coasters and contraindiction with drugs/therapies. Since i intend to use them, I'd like to be sure. I can't find anything myself, but you seem to know the field inside out. Thanks.
 
Yes I know how a thermocouple works. This was what Dorsett used, but Callahan used a different method. An extremely sensitive thermistor probe (such as we have used for years here, supplied by another Welsh company Skye Instruments, - but we don’t use them on moths) and reported this method in his 1964 paper: A hypodermic probe was embedded ventrally in the thorax of the moth and the probe with the impaled moth placed in front of a stroboscope. The strobe light was then synchronised to the wing beat and the wing amplitude was viewed against a black card with degree lines marked on the card. Time was measured with an electric counter. From this he could establish the relation between wing beat rate and temperature.

My point is that insects can be regarded as flying IR spectrophotometers, and as an example of the exquisite sensitivity of organisms to electromagnetic radiation. There are many examples of this sensitivity e.g. Kalmijn ‘s work at the Scripps on elasmobranch fishes senstivity to electric fields at ELF frequencies, and De Geer’s work on Melanophila acuminata beetles, which are remarkably sensitive to smoke. These beetles seek out forest fires at great distances, and this had been presumed due to olfactory sense. But their sensory pits responded through resonance to IR in the 0.8 to 2.7 micron band and as high as 6 microns. No chemicals were involved in this process.

What makes you think that human beings or rather the cells and organs of which they are composed, should not be equally sensitive? I have now given several examples o to disprove the idea that organisms cannot detect IR though the surrounding noise. Want some more?
 
Pragmatist said:
Here's a question for you Roger:

Let assume for the sake of argument that a device external to the body somehow radiates coherent information coded into radiation at say 9 microns (or anywhere between 4 and 14 if you want). And let's further assume that somehow this radiation makes it all the way to a lymphocyte inside the body (ignoring all the other factors already mentioned) and that the "information" is not corrupted in any way. Let's further assume that the lymphocyte has a diameter of 9 microns (or if you don't like 9 microns, let's simply say that the lymphocyte size is EXACTLY identical to the wavelength of the external radiation). Is it your contention that there will be some specific interaction with the lymphocyte because the sizes of the lymphocyte and the radiation are the same? That the lymphocyte somehow acts as an antenna because it's the same size? Yes or no will do.

And I ask everyone else to keep quiet on this point until I get an answer from Roger.

Just yes or no Roger. What are you afriad of?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom