Bioelectromagnetics

Pragmatist said:
Here's a question for you Roger:

Let assume for the sake of argument that a device external to the body somehow radiates coherent information coded into radiation at say 9 microns (or anywhere between 4 and 14 if you want). And let's further assume that somehow this radiation makes it all the way to a lymphocyte inside the body (ignoring all the other factors already mentioned) and that the "information" is not corrupted in any way. Let's further assume that the lymphocyte has a diameter of 9 microns (or if you don't like 9 microns, let's simply say that the lymphocyte size is EXACTLY identical to the wavelength of the external radiation). Is it your contention that there will be some specific interaction with the lymphocyte because the sizes of the lymphocyte and the radiation are the same? That the lymphocyte somehow acts as an antenna because it's the same size? Yes or no will do.

And I ask everyone else to keep quiet on this point until I get an answer from Roger.

Congratulations on asking a straight scientific question! Maybe we'll make a research scientist out of you yet!

I can almost answer in yes or no format, but maybe you do not know that lymphocytes change their diameter quite substantially depending on what they are doing, and an activated lymphocyte is quite different size from a resting one. (and so do mitochondria behave similarly). My answer is yes, in a nutshell, but remember that half wave resonance has to be taken into account.
 
cogreslab said:
My point is that insects can be regarded as flying IR spectrophotometers,

Hey, look, kids! I've got this thin little glass tube here that I filled with mercury. Voila! Spectrophotometer!

:dl:

Roger, do they put you in a corner at IoB meetings and only let you out for milk and cookies?
 
Thanks PJ for the link to a site describing wound healing. You pointed out some of the chemicals/molecules involved (e.g. serotonin, but perhaps you missed this from the same site:

"Many aspects of wound healing have yet to be elucidated".
 
Oh Dear, we can always rely on Bouncer Bill to lower the tone of any discussion. More animated gifs by way of scientific exposition!
 
MRC_Hans said:
Uhh, Roger: Do you possibly have a few references on cancer and such that are less than about 40 years old? You know, a few things have happened in science since then :rolleyes:.

Hans

Considering we were just discussing Henry Lai and NP's paper in the May 2004 Env Health Perspectives, that seems a somewhat harsh judgement, Hans: For my part I would love to read any references at all from you guys, rather than continual lazy web links, most of which do not support your arguments (note I am charitable enough to say they are arguments, rather than simply pejoratives).
 
cogreslab said:
Oh Dear, we can always rely on Bouncer Bill to lower the tone of any discussion. More animated gifs by way of scientific exposition!

Insect spectrophotometer, you dunderhead?
:dl:

You're a dunce. An ignoramous. A boor and a delusional clown.

You are not worth my time, sir. Spectrophotometer, you bozo? Which one of your expert lab clowns fed you that one? Adjust his tricycle so he can ride off to the pub for another few pints.

And you can shove your attitude up your nether regions. Don't tell me I'm lowering the tone of the discussion when you sit there writing this pseudo-scientific drivel. You really put the cock on the poppy, don't you? That light-headedness you feel is the result of walking around with an empty cranium.
 
cogreslab said:
My point is that insects can be regarded as flying IR spectrophotometers...

commentary.gif
 
cogreslab said:
My point is that insects can be regarded as flying IR spectrophotometers,

What's the accuracy of that moth? How about the resolution? Please post a graph of its ouput over the range 1-1000 micron. Does it cover the whole range, or just part? How does it produce a graph? You do know what spectrophotometer actually is, don't you?

Quick, catch that arsehole with the big nose riding out your lab on a tricycle. Surely, he'll know.
commentary.gif
 
cogreslab said:
Congratulations on asking a straight scientific question! Maybe we'll make a research scientist out of you yet!

If you mean, "a research scientist like YOU", then all I have to say is that I don't respond well to threats! :)


cogreslab said:
I can almost answer in yes or no format, but maybe you do not know that lymphocytes change their diameter quite substantially depending on what they are doing, and an activated lymphocyte is quite different size from a resting one. (and so do mitochondria behave similarly). My answer is yes, in a nutshell, but remember that half wave resonance has to be taken inton account.

I allowed you the luxury of changing the lymphocyte size and/or the wavelength, so that is irrelevant.

Well now, consider this: Let's just concentrate on one fixed size for the moment. It doesn't matter what that size is, it can be any size you like within the quoted ranges. I will choose 10 microns to make it easier.

Roger, what happens to an electromagnetic wave when it moves from one medium to another? Particularly a less dense medium to a higher density one? Do you know? I gather you know that the speed changes since you mentioned that before. But did you also know that there is an equation which relates the speed of a wave to it's wavelength and frequency? It's one of the simplest equations in electromagnetics:

v = f * lambda

Where f is the frequency and lambda is the wavelength and v is the speed of the wave.

So what happens if the speed of the wave changes as it enters the body from the outside air. The harmonizer isn't embedded in the body is it? Surely f and/or lambda have to change as well don't they?

Without going to the bother of proving what is again high school physics I shall simply assert that the frequency CAN'T change and therefore, if the speed changes when a wave enters a different medium, then it must be the WAVELENGTH of the wave that changes as well.

So we have a lymphocyte that is 10 microns. The harmonizer emits a wave (in the air) of 10 microns, so this 10 micron wave must reach the lymphocyte surely? NO! Because by the time the wave reaches the lymphocyte it will be traveling at a different speed! The wave is NO LONGER 10 microns when it reaches the lymphocyte! Now, off the top of my head, I don't know what the dispersion of blood plasma is, I'll have to look it up, so I can''t say what the actual speed or wavelength will be, all I can say is that it will be LONGER than 10 microns by a significant amount.

This also brings in another point about wave penetration. Each interface (each change of medium) is a change in the impedance of the path of the wave. Therefore a wave of any given impedance will have to pass through a series of impedance changes along the way on the path to the lymphocyte. And what happens when a wave meets an impedance change? It REFLECTS! That is how mirrors work! That is also why we see colours in materials. In fact, it's why we even see at all. So any wave that originates outside the body will be partially reflected many times before it ever gets to a lymphocyte. The proportion of radiation getting through, and that is ignoring ALL the factors I have previously mentioned will be attenuated considerably.

But let's be even more generous, let's set aside the above scientific facts. Let's assume that our wave does get through and that its wavelength change is not an issue. The question is, will it "resonate" with a lymphocyte with the same diameter?

Simple answer, unlikely in the extreme! Because the situation is nowhere near as simplistic as having matching diameters. Why should a wave have to match the DIAMETER of a lymphocyte? What's so special about the diameter? Perhaps what's so special to YOU is it's the only figure you KNOW!

If we look at a typical cell, like a lymphocyte, we discover that it is basically like a bag consisting of a lipid bilayer membrane with some internal fluids/cytoplasm etc. Now, one thing we can say about a liipid bilayer is this: it's a darned good insulator! And insulators don't act like antennas! And in addition, antennas have significant changes in what they resonate with depending on their geometry. A circular antenna would tend to resonate with wavelengths near to its circumference in size. It's DIAMETER is irrelevant except that it affects the circumference.

Something needs to conduct to be an antenna. Therefore if there is any conduction at the surface of a lymphocyte then it would tend to conduct AROUND the lymphocyte and not THROUGH it (because of surface ion adsorption on the insulating lipid bilayer). Because, an area contained within a conducting surface is like a Faraday cage, like the conducting sphere you stumbled so badly on before. The electric flux within a conducting enclosure (like a sphere) is ZERO by definition. See Gauss's Law, one of the most fundamental of the basic electrical laws.

Therefore, if your lymphocyte is to be an antenna, it will NOT be sensitive to radiation comparable to its DIAMETER but rather its CIRCUMFERENCE (if at ALL that is). Now that might seem to imply that all we do is multiply by PI to get the circumference. But it's not as simple as that. Firstly the lymphocyte is unlikely to be perfectly spherical, and it's also unlikely that the ions adsorbed on its surface form a perfectly smooth surface themselves. So the best we can do is say that it's likely that the resonant wavelength is likely to be MUCH longer than 10 microns, and also that it is not likely to have any integral relationship to the figure of 10 microns, which it would need to have if it was to be an efficient antenna in relation to radiation of 10 microns. And NO, this will NOT be compensated for by the change in wavelength due to speed, the magnitudes are of different orders.

Finally, if a lymphocyte WAS an efficient antenna at these wavelengths then it would automatically be picking up and absorbing energy from all the background thermal radiation in the same range. Yes, Roger, antennas RECEIVE as well as transmit! So how do lymphocytes deal with a constant flood of incoming thermal radiation without heating up and exploding, if they are such good "antennas"?!

Your theory has more holes in it than a sieve!
 
Schumann resonances, (a prelude to the idea of organic resonance).

I haven’t had time before now to address the previous comments about these, but I refer readers to Neil Cherry’s excellent review in Natural Hazards 26: 279-331 (2002). (yes Hans it really is less than 40 years old) titled "Schumann Resonances: a plausible biopohysical mechanism for the human health effects of Solar/Geomagnetic activity".

I quote first from his abstract:

"The cell membrane has an electric field of the order of 10^5 V/cm [who was it said on this thread there were none in the human body?] The ELF brain waves operate at about 10^-1 V/cm. Fish, birds and animals and people have been shown to respond to ELF signals that produce tissue electric gradients of ULF/ELF oscillating signals at a threshold of 10^-7 to 10^-8 V/cm. This involves resonant non-linear absorption of ULF/ELF systems that use natural ion oscillation signals in the same frequency range. [The facts of Schumann resonance] …provide strong support for identifying the Schumann resonance signals as the solar and geomagnetic activity biophysical mechanism, primarily through a melatonin mechanism".

In the text:

"The brain operates successfully using oscillating signals a million times smaller than the membrane potential. …It was shown that environmental electromagnetic fields in this frequency range significantly altered the calcium ion fluxes and EMR waves in brain tissue (Bawin et al, 1973; Bawin and Adey, 1976; Adey 1980). The field strength was 10^-7 V/cm. Since that time the calcium ion efflux /influx effect has been observed in many independent laboratories. The effect is taken as established by overwhelming evidence in a review (Blackman, 1990) [ This is the very same Carl Blackman from the EPA mentioned earlier in this thread; and for those who believe I am an isolationist, a man with whom I have had many breakfasts coffees etc with over the years discussing such matters].

In a way I am sad to write this post, since Ross Adey died only last week, and Neil Cherry the year before, both exceptionally good scientists, and hugely respected in the bioelectromagnetics community, - far better scientists I reckon than I could ever be. (Time for your hyena gif, Bouncer!).

Neil’s beautiful and elegant paper continues and eventually:

"The brain is a very sensitive electromagnetic organ. The model and hypothesis proposes a direct mechanism for SR signals to interact with the brain, altering brain waves and neurohormonal responses…It has been shown that exogenous ELF signals affect melatonin/serotonin, dopamine and opiate systems (Frey, 1995). This effect is plausible through interference with endogenous ELF systems and the vital role of calcium ion signalling".

OK, so I don’t know a lot of physics. Nor biochemistry, nor microbiology, anatomy, physiology, radio engineering, physical chemistry, epidemiology, statistics, or the myriad specialities of modern science needed to conduct research in a multidisciplinary and largely uncharted region like bioelectromagnetics. But taking a lateral view, many like me have reached the sort of consensus expressed by the late Drs Cherry and Adey. Now, standing on the shoulders of these fallen giants, we need to hone these hypotheses and to make them watertight in order to change the present environmental situation for the better, a process to which you guys, despite your lack of charm and unjustifiable rough manners, are making a valuable contribution. Thanks.
 
Pragmatist said:



If we look at a typical cell, like a lymphocyte, we discover that it is basically like a bag consisting of a lipid bilayer membrane with some internal fluids/cytoplasm etc. Now, one thing we can say about a liipid bilayer is this: it's a darned good insulator! And insulators don't act like antennas! And in addition, antennas have significant changes in what they resonate with depending on their geometry. A circular antenna would tend to resonate with wavelengths near to its circumference in size. It's DIAMETER is irrelevant except that it affects the circumference.

Something needs to conduct to be an antenna. Therefore if there is any conduction at the surface of a lymphocyte then it would tend to conduct AROUND the lymphocyte and not THROUGH it (because of surface ion adsorption on the insulating lipid bilayer). Because, an area contained within a conducting surface is like a Faraday cage, like the conducting sphere you stumbled so badly on before. The electric flux within a conducting enclosure (like a sphere) is ZERO by definition. See Gauss's Law, one of the most fundamental of the basic electrical laws.

Therefore, if your lymphocyte is to be an antenna, it will NOT be sensitive to radiation comparable to its DIAMETER but rather its CIRCUMFERENCE (if at ALL that is). Now that might seem to imply that all we do is multiply by PI to get the circumference. But it's not as simple as that. Firstly the lymphocyte is unlikely to be perfectly spherical, and it's also unlikely that the ions adsorbed on its surface form a perfectly smooth surface themselves. So the best we can do is say that it's likely that the resonant wavelength is likely to be MUCH longer than 10 microns, and also that it is not likely to have any integral relationship to the figure of 10 microns, which it would need to have if it was to be an efficient antenna in relation to radiation of 10 microns. And NO, this will NOT be compensated for by the change in wavelength due to speed, the magnitudes are of different orders.

Finally, if a lymphocyte WAS an efficient antenna at these wavelengths then it would automatically be picking up and absorbing energy from all the background thermal radiation in the same range. Yes, Roger, antennas RECEIVE as well as transmit! So how do lymphocytes deal with a constant flood of incoming thermal radiation without heating up and exploding, if they are such good "antennas"?!

Your theory has more holes in it than a sieve!

Oh dear, more shocking ignorance! You obviously regard a cow as a box on four legs too, being a typical physicist.

The plasma membrane is full of things like ion-gated channels specifically designed to allow calcium signals and other ions in and out. There is an elaborate cascading signal transduction mechanism to take signals arriving at the surface of the cell into the cytosol. You will find it described in many text books, including Alberts, Bray et al (1993 and other editions of that work).

The pioin is that organic cells have clearly defined mechanisms for recption and amplification of incoming (and often calcium-related) signals, ninny.
 
Pragmatist said:




If we look at a typical cell, like a lymphocyte, we discover that it is basically like a bag consisting of a lipid bilayer membrane with some internal fluids/cytoplasm etc. Now, one thing we can say about a liipid bilayer is this: it's a darned good insulator! And insulators don't act like antennas! And in addition, antennas have significant changes in what they resonate with depending on their geometry. A circular antenna would tend to resonate with wavelengths near to its circumference in size. It's DIAMETER is irrelevant except that it affects the circumference.

Something needs to conduct to be an antenna. Therefore if there is any conduction at the surface of a lymphocyte then it would tend to conduct AROUND the lymphocyte and not THROUGH it (because of surface ion adsorption on the insulating lipid bilayer). Because, an area contained within a conducting surface is like a Faraday cage, like the conducting sphere you stumbled so badly on before. The electric flux within a conducting enclosure (like a sphere) is ZERO by definition. See Gauss's Law, one of the most fundamental of the basic electrical laws.

Therefore, if your lymphocyte is to be an antenna, it will NOT be sensitive to radiation comparable to its DIAMETER but rather its CIRCUMFERENCE (if at ALL that is). Now that might seem to imply that all we do is multiply by PI to get the circumference. But it's not as simple as that. Firstly the lymphocyte is unlikely to be perfectly spherical, and it's also unlikely that the ions adsorbed on its surface form a perfectly smooth surface themselves. So the best we can do is say that it's likely that the resonant wavelength is likely to be MUCH longer than 10 microns, and also that it is not likely to have any integral relationship to the figure of 10 microns, which it would need to have if it was to be an efficient antenna in relation to radiation of 10 microns. And NO, this will NOT be compensated for by the change in wavelength due to speed, the magnitudes are of different orders.

Finally, if a lymphocyte WAS an efficient antenna at these wavelengths then it would automatically be picking up and absorbing energy from all the background thermal radiation in the same range. Yes, Roger, antennas RECEIVE as well as transmit! So how do lymphocytes deal with a constant flood of incoming thermal radiation without heating up and exploding, if they are such good "antennas"?!

Your theory has more holes in it than a sieve!

Oh dear, more ignorance! The plasma membrane has ion-gated channels all around it specifically designed to receive incoming (and often calcium related) signals and another cascading amplification system in the cytosol, well understood and to be found in most text books, e.g. Alberts, Bray (1993 and other editions). Any ELF signals arriving on the plasma membrane surface are immediately reported to the cell interior and initiate well mapped cell responses, including mitosis.

When you lok at a cow, do you see it as a box on four legs, or something like that. Get aware of life, physicist!
 
cogreslab said:


The plasma membrane is full of things like ion-gated channels specifically designed to allow calcium signals and other ions in and out. There is an elaborate cascading signal transduction mechanism to take signals arriving at the surface of the cell into the cytosol. You will find it described in many text books, including Alberts, Bray et al (1993 and other editions of that work).

The pioin is that organic cells have clearly defined mechanisms for recption and amplification of incoming (and often calcium-related) signals, ninny.


Calcium ions, glucose , all sorts of gates, yes, but you're not talking about movement of ions, you're talking about EM radiation.
 
cogreslab said:


Oh dear, more shocking ignorance! You obviously regard a cow as a box on four legs too, being a typical physicist.

The plasma membrane is full of things like ion-gated channels specifically designed to allow calcium signals and other ions in and out. There is an elaborate cascading signal transduction mechanism to take signals arriving at the surface of the cell into the cytosol. You will find it described in many text books, including Alberts, Bray et al (1993 and other editions of that work).

The pioin is that organic cells have clearly defined mechanisms for recption and amplification of incoming (and often calcium-related) signals, ninny.

Roger I am overwhelmed by the sheer scientific quality of your argument!

:dl:

Calcium signals in and out (which are carried by err....calcium!). Have nothing whatsoever to do with whether a lymphocyte is an antenna to FIR. Caught out again - usual response: desperate ad hoc hypothesizing!

And it's just possible that I might know something you don't about ion channels and the like, but I'll leave THAT fun for later.

In the meantime, why don't you tell us about the Trypan Blue Exclusion test.
 
cogreslab said:
The plasma membrane is full of things like ion-gated channels specifically designed to allow calcium signals and other ions in and out. There is an elaborate cascading signal transduction mechanism to take signals arriving at the surface of the cell into the cytosol. You will find it described in many text books, including Alberts, Bray et al (1993 and other editions of that work).

The pioin is that organic cells have clearly defined mechanisms for recption and amplification of incoming (and often calcium-related) signals, ninny.

Roger Dodger,

Oh, dear, still dodging questions and deflecting are we? Still trafficking on your arrogant assumption of the general readers' ignorance?

First, sir, tell us, please, all about your moth spectrophotometers. Show us their graphs and tell us how they make them. Give us their accuracy, wavelength range and resolution over said range.

Second, in this post, you wish to dance around an equivocation about "reception" and wish to move from ion channels to antenna action. This is a dodge, sir, and you know it. You are dodging the issue of receiving the signal and burying the dodge in a first-year-level discussion of physiology.
 
cogreslab said:
The pioin is that organic cells have clearly defined mechanisms for recption and amplification of incoming (and often calcium-related) signals, ninny.


cogreslab said:
When you lok at a cow, do you see it as a box on four legs, or something like that. Get aware of life, physicist!

Wow! Ad hoc hypotheses AND post hoc editing! What a combination! :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom