Pragmatist
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- May 12, 2004
- Messages
- 1,529
Since Roger has now posted his theory of how the harmonizer "works" (and I am too worked up to address that directly at this moment), I'm going to take a time out and clarify something from the earlier discussion.
Some may be wondering why I denied Roger's earlier assertion that the radiation from the device was in the range 4 to 14 microns and why I asked him for a spectrogram.
The reasoning is this: ALL objects, and I mean ALL that exist within a normal temperature range on earth (and just about anywhere else that we know of) emit radiation in the far infra red range. It's a perfectly natural phenomenon. When something is "warm" (that's a relative term as I will explain) it naturally emits some of that heat as infra red.
Now, as Hans pointed out earlier, and even Roger himself, at body temperature, 37 degrees celsius, the peak (i.e. the MAJORITY) of the radiation is emitted at around 9 microns, which is well within the above range. What Roger didn't know was just how wide that range really is.
For example, let's take the lowest energy state (that's the longest wavelength) which is 14 microns. The temperature required to cause natural thermal radiation to peak at 14 microns is -67 degrees C. Yes, that's MINUS! Conversely, the highest energy state, 4 microns corresponds to a temperature of 437 degrees C. What this means therefore is that ANY object at all, almost without exception, will radiate strongly in the range 4 to 14 microns EVEN if it is outside the above range of temperatures (because these are not sharp cut off points), but that the maximum radiation of any object will be in the range of 4 to 14 microns provided that object is anywhere in the temperature range -67 to +437 degrees C!
And to make this even clearer, nearly all temperatures within "normal" environmental range of around 0 to 40 degrees C will cause objects to radiate with a peak close to 9 microns. It doesn't matter if that object is a "personal harmonizer", a pebble on the beach, the clothes you are wearing, your body itself, your cat, your neighbour's car or whatever. EVERYTHING!
So why did I deny it? Simple. I wanted to see if Roger would actually try to measure the emission! Because it's virtually impossible to do so. The measuring instrument itself would be radiating in that range, as would whatever environment it was placed in. The simple fact that he didn't immediately challenge my assertion is proof of the level of "science" he is bringing to this debate.
Hans sprang my trap when he mentioned the radiation law. No matter. But this is BASIC physics again, high school stuff! There is no normal object in the universe that does NOT emit at 4 to 14 microns when it's in our normal environmental temperature range!
The claim that the "personal harmonizer", somehow specially or uniquely radiates in this range is complete and utter BS. If that IS it's alleged mode of action it is PROVED to be a complete fraud.
There are other aspects to this as well. All objects that radiate also absorb. So if an object radiates in this range it also absorbs in this range as well.
And a black object radiates much better than a shiny metallic object (like the personal harmonizer). So if a person were simply to wear a black shirt, that shirt would emit MILLIONS of times more radiation in the range 4 to 14 microns than any personal harmonizer! AND, it would also ABSORB that much better too. So if the harmonizer was emitting weakly in that range, then you could guarantee with almost absolute certainty that ALL it's radiations would be absorbed by your clothes (regardless of colour) BEFORE THEY EVER REACHED THE SKIN! The only way one could avoid that would be to insert the harmonizer into....well let's just say "a body orifice" to be polite! I haven't seen the instructions, but I'll bet it doesn't tell you to do that!
To get a picture of this: our bodies are FLOODED with this radiation from everything around us, 24 hours per day. No "harmonizer" is going to have any effect in this range because any small amount of radiation it produces will be overwhelmed and flooded by the environment. And also that environmental radiation will interfere with and change the output of the harmonizer, its output will automatically get scrambled no matter how coherent it is to begin with. It's like somebody whispering at a rock concert!
The question about tissue penetration by radiation in this range is irrelevant, and meaningless. The tissue itself radiates in this range as do all natural objects. So it will naturally absorb and pass this radiation. An atom will absorb the radiation and release it again. In this way, 4 to 14 microns will pass through almost ANY object.
Finally, I caught on the moment Roger mentioned 4 to 14 microns. Why? Because there is a whole industry of quack devices which claim to emit special radiation in EXACTLY this range. If you search the web you will find hundreds of people advertizing special "FIR emitters" which radiate in this range. Along with all kinds of claims about how this range is uniquely produced by THEIR device etc. It's a con, and an old one at that! Of COURSE they emit in this range - EVERYTHING does!
I'll discuss the OTHER problems separately.
Some may be wondering why I denied Roger's earlier assertion that the radiation from the device was in the range 4 to 14 microns and why I asked him for a spectrogram.
The reasoning is this: ALL objects, and I mean ALL that exist within a normal temperature range on earth (and just about anywhere else that we know of) emit radiation in the far infra red range. It's a perfectly natural phenomenon. When something is "warm" (that's a relative term as I will explain) it naturally emits some of that heat as infra red.
Now, as Hans pointed out earlier, and even Roger himself, at body temperature, 37 degrees celsius, the peak (i.e. the MAJORITY) of the radiation is emitted at around 9 microns, which is well within the above range. What Roger didn't know was just how wide that range really is.
For example, let's take the lowest energy state (that's the longest wavelength) which is 14 microns. The temperature required to cause natural thermal radiation to peak at 14 microns is -67 degrees C. Yes, that's MINUS! Conversely, the highest energy state, 4 microns corresponds to a temperature of 437 degrees C. What this means therefore is that ANY object at all, almost without exception, will radiate strongly in the range 4 to 14 microns EVEN if it is outside the above range of temperatures (because these are not sharp cut off points), but that the maximum radiation of any object will be in the range of 4 to 14 microns provided that object is anywhere in the temperature range -67 to +437 degrees C!
And to make this even clearer, nearly all temperatures within "normal" environmental range of around 0 to 40 degrees C will cause objects to radiate with a peak close to 9 microns. It doesn't matter if that object is a "personal harmonizer", a pebble on the beach, the clothes you are wearing, your body itself, your cat, your neighbour's car or whatever. EVERYTHING!
So why did I deny it? Simple. I wanted to see if Roger would actually try to measure the emission! Because it's virtually impossible to do so. The measuring instrument itself would be radiating in that range, as would whatever environment it was placed in. The simple fact that he didn't immediately challenge my assertion is proof of the level of "science" he is bringing to this debate.
Hans sprang my trap when he mentioned the radiation law. No matter. But this is BASIC physics again, high school stuff! There is no normal object in the universe that does NOT emit at 4 to 14 microns when it's in our normal environmental temperature range!
The claim that the "personal harmonizer", somehow specially or uniquely radiates in this range is complete and utter BS. If that IS it's alleged mode of action it is PROVED to be a complete fraud.
There are other aspects to this as well. All objects that radiate also absorb. So if an object radiates in this range it also absorbs in this range as well.
And a black object radiates much better than a shiny metallic object (like the personal harmonizer). So if a person were simply to wear a black shirt, that shirt would emit MILLIONS of times more radiation in the range 4 to 14 microns than any personal harmonizer! AND, it would also ABSORB that much better too. So if the harmonizer was emitting weakly in that range, then you could guarantee with almost absolute certainty that ALL it's radiations would be absorbed by your clothes (regardless of colour) BEFORE THEY EVER REACHED THE SKIN! The only way one could avoid that would be to insert the harmonizer into....well let's just say "a body orifice" to be polite! I haven't seen the instructions, but I'll bet it doesn't tell you to do that!
To get a picture of this: our bodies are FLOODED with this radiation from everything around us, 24 hours per day. No "harmonizer" is going to have any effect in this range because any small amount of radiation it produces will be overwhelmed and flooded by the environment. And also that environmental radiation will interfere with and change the output of the harmonizer, its output will automatically get scrambled no matter how coherent it is to begin with. It's like somebody whispering at a rock concert!
The question about tissue penetration by radiation in this range is irrelevant, and meaningless. The tissue itself radiates in this range as do all natural objects. So it will naturally absorb and pass this radiation. An atom will absorb the radiation and release it again. In this way, 4 to 14 microns will pass through almost ANY object.
Finally, I caught on the moment Roger mentioned 4 to 14 microns. Why? Because there is a whole industry of quack devices which claim to emit special radiation in EXACTLY this range. If you search the web you will find hundreds of people advertizing special "FIR emitters" which radiate in this range. Along with all kinds of claims about how this range is uniquely produced by THEIR device etc. It's a con, and an old one at that! Of COURSE they emit in this range - EVERYTHING does!
I'll discuss the OTHER problems separately.