Bioelectromagnetics

Since Roger has now posted his theory of how the harmonizer "works" (and I am too worked up to address that directly at this moment), I'm going to take a time out and clarify something from the earlier discussion.

Some may be wondering why I denied Roger's earlier assertion that the radiation from the device was in the range 4 to 14 microns and why I asked him for a spectrogram.

The reasoning is this: ALL objects, and I mean ALL that exist within a normal temperature range on earth (and just about anywhere else that we know of) emit radiation in the far infra red range. It's a perfectly natural phenomenon. When something is "warm" (that's a relative term as I will explain) it naturally emits some of that heat as infra red.

Now, as Hans pointed out earlier, and even Roger himself, at body temperature, 37 degrees celsius, the peak (i.e. the MAJORITY) of the radiation is emitted at around 9 microns, which is well within the above range. What Roger didn't know was just how wide that range really is.

For example, let's take the lowest energy state (that's the longest wavelength) which is 14 microns. The temperature required to cause natural thermal radiation to peak at 14 microns is -67 degrees C. Yes, that's MINUS! Conversely, the highest energy state, 4 microns corresponds to a temperature of 437 degrees C. What this means therefore is that ANY object at all, almost without exception, will radiate strongly in the range 4 to 14 microns EVEN if it is outside the above range of temperatures (because these are not sharp cut off points), but that the maximum radiation of any object will be in the range of 4 to 14 microns provided that object is anywhere in the temperature range -67 to +437 degrees C!

And to make this even clearer, nearly all temperatures within "normal" environmental range of around 0 to 40 degrees C will cause objects to radiate with a peak close to 9 microns. It doesn't matter if that object is a "personal harmonizer", a pebble on the beach, the clothes you are wearing, your body itself, your cat, your neighbour's car or whatever. EVERYTHING!

So why did I deny it? Simple. I wanted to see if Roger would actually try to measure the emission! Because it's virtually impossible to do so. The measuring instrument itself would be radiating in that range, as would whatever environment it was placed in. The simple fact that he didn't immediately challenge my assertion is proof of the level of "science" he is bringing to this debate.

Hans sprang my trap when he mentioned the radiation law. No matter. But this is BASIC physics again, high school stuff! There is no normal object in the universe that does NOT emit at 4 to 14 microns when it's in our normal environmental temperature range!

The claim that the "personal harmonizer", somehow specially or uniquely radiates in this range is complete and utter BS. If that IS it's alleged mode of action it is PROVED to be a complete fraud.

There are other aspects to this as well. All objects that radiate also absorb. So if an object radiates in this range it also absorbs in this range as well.

And a black object radiates much better than a shiny metallic object (like the personal harmonizer). So if a person were simply to wear a black shirt, that shirt would emit MILLIONS of times more radiation in the range 4 to 14 microns than any personal harmonizer! AND, it would also ABSORB that much better too. So if the harmonizer was emitting weakly in that range, then you could guarantee with almost absolute certainty that ALL it's radiations would be absorbed by your clothes (regardless of colour) BEFORE THEY EVER REACHED THE SKIN! The only way one could avoid that would be to insert the harmonizer into....well let's just say "a body orifice" to be polite! I haven't seen the instructions, but I'll bet it doesn't tell you to do that! :)

To get a picture of this: our bodies are FLOODED with this radiation from everything around us, 24 hours per day. No "harmonizer" is going to have any effect in this range because any small amount of radiation it produces will be overwhelmed and flooded by the environment. And also that environmental radiation will interfere with and change the output of the harmonizer, its output will automatically get scrambled no matter how coherent it is to begin with. It's like somebody whispering at a rock concert!

The question about tissue penetration by radiation in this range is irrelevant, and meaningless. The tissue itself radiates in this range as do all natural objects. So it will naturally absorb and pass this radiation. An atom will absorb the radiation and release it again. In this way, 4 to 14 microns will pass through almost ANY object.

Finally, I caught on the moment Roger mentioned 4 to 14 microns. Why? Because there is a whole industry of quack devices which claim to emit special radiation in EXACTLY this range. If you search the web you will find hundreds of people advertizing special "FIR emitters" which radiate in this range. Along with all kinds of claims about how this range is uniquely produced by THEIR device etc. It's a con, and an old one at that! Of COURSE they emit in this range - EVERYTHING does!

I'll discuss the OTHER problems separately.
 
I recently bought "Fads & Fallacies In the Name of Science" by Martin Gardner, and I read a section I thought applied rather well to this thread. Unfortunately it was a little long, and I didn't want to type it up, but I found that someone else had typed it up on another board. So I've copied that and am posting it here. Source is Martin Gardner's book.
________________________
"[M]ost pseudo-scientists have a number of characteristics in
common.

"First and most important of these traits is that cranks work
in almost total isolation . . . in the sense of having no fruitful
contacts with fellow researchers. . . . The modern crank insists
that his isolation is not desired on his part. It is due, he claims,
to the prejudice of established scientific groups against new
ideas. . . .

"The modern pseudo-scientist . . . stands entirely outside
the closely integrated channels through which new ideas are
introduced and evaluated. He works in isolation. He does not
send his findings to the recognized journals, or if he does, they
are rejected for reasons which in the vast majority of cases
are excellent. In most cases, the crank is not well enough
informed to write a paper with even a surface resemblance
to a significant study. As a consequence, he finds himself
excluded the journals and societies, and almost universally
ignored by the competent workers in his field. In fact, the
reputable scientist does not even know of the crank's
existence unless his work is given widespread publicity through
non-academic channels, or unless the scientist makes a hobby
of collecting crank literature. The eccentric is forced, therefore,
to tread a lonely way. He speaks before organizations he
himself has founded, contributes to journals he himself may
edit, and -- until recently -- publishes books only when he
or his followers can raise sufficient funds to have them printed
privately.

"A second characteristic of the pseudo scientist, which
greatly strengthens his isolation, is a tendency toward
paranoia. . . .

"There are five ways in which the sincere pseudo-
scientist's paranoid tendencies are likely to be exhibited.

"(1) He considers himself a genius.

"(2) He regards his colleagues, without exception, as
ignorant blockheads. Everyone is out of step except himself.
Frequently he insults his opponents by accusing them of
stupidity, dishonesty, or other base motives. If they ignore
him, he takes this to mean his arguments are unanswerable.
If they retaliate in kind, this strengthens his delusion that he
is battling scoundrels. . . .

"(3) He believes himself unjustly persecuted and discriminated
against. . . .

"(4) He has a strong compulsion to focus his attacks on the
greatest scientists and the best established theories. When
Newton was the outstanding name in physics, eccentric works
in that science were violently anti Newton. Today, with
Einstein the father symbol of authority, a crank theory of
physics is likely to attack Einstein in the name of Newton. . . .

"(5) He often has a tendency to write in a complex
jargon, in many cases making use of terms and phrases he
himself has coined. . . ."
__________________________
 
If anyone is in any doubt about the level of "science" that Roger is bringing to this discussion I have a suggestion. Below is a direct quote from Roger's theory, in the context of conducting tissues:

One point to make as well is that charges on the surface of a large sphere will equal the charges on a sphere inside it. Since the surface area of the interior sphere is inevitably smaller than the sphere encompassing it, this leads to a concentration of charge density on the interior surface. Tis is an example of organic "amplification", but there are others.

What I suggest to anyone who is in any doubt that they are being fed meaningless pseudoscientific technobabble is to simply look up Michael Faraday's work on electrostatics, and in particular his numerous experiments with charged conducting spheres.

It will open your eyes.
 
cogreslab said:
Don't want to deflect now, nor derail my own thread but I picked this uipm from the Bioelectromagnetics group posts (from Bill Curry, PhD, physicist) and felt it was too important to ignore.

So, I will not ignore it:

"Hi folks,
I have to say that I don't know what was being measured by Charles, but I want to mention two other things that you might be interested in. Dr. Martin Graham, an Emeritus Professor of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science at the University of California, developed a circuit that enables one to separate the RF induced on powerlines from the 60 (in the US) or 50 (in Europe) Hz current in order to measure the extent to which the powerline current has been contaminated by nearby RF sources, such as cell towers, radio stations, etc. One plugs this filter circuit into a wall socket and attaches the leads from the other end of the printed circuit to a Fluke RMS meter and reads the voltage (in mV) that corresponds to the RF component of current. With this device, one finds that voltages much above about 30 mV constitute significant RF contamination of the powerline. Items such as light dimmers et between off and on positions also contribute significant RF contamination; I have measured 100 mV or so. This is a consequence of the clipping of the normal sine wave that is done by these devices.

Well, my dear Watson, this is rather old hat. Yes, the mains can carry various signals, noise and otherwise. In fact, back when intercoms were fashionable, some intercom systems worked by sending applying a carrier wave to the mains. Saved you the trouble of extra wiring. Problem was that the neighboors could often listen in ;). A Fluke RMS meter is not a suitable instrument to measure this type of noise, however, because its effective frequency range is too small.

"The consequence of all this, of course, is RF radiation from the powerline inside a residence or an office. Usually, when I have found this contamination, it has been accompanied by similar induced RF components on telephone lines, as shown by low level RF radiation measured at the phone jack (with an RF field meter) or from the telephone line or from a fax machine attached to the phone line.

Yes and no. The reason it is carried by the power line is exactly that it is a poor radiator, and the reason is as much that RF radiates INTO the power lines as the other way round. But anyhoo, sure, it contributes to the general electrosmog.

"The second thing I wanted to mention is that some bioelectromagnetic scientists have found that living cells have the ability to demodulate modulated RF carriers. I do not know the details of the mechanism nor the extent to which this is true, but it has been observed in laboratory experiments, according to Dr. Carl Blackman of the EPA Laboratory in North Carolina, USA. It might be worthwhile to search on the website of the publisher of Bioelectromagnetics. You can find this by going to www.bioelectromagnteics.org and clicking on the publications link and then clicking on the link for the journal. You can search the issues of bioelectromagnetics for the desired subject. if you want to see the abstract or buy the journal article, you have to register, but registration is free".

If anyone has the time while I am working on the lie and swindle issue, we have most of the BEMS journals back issues from its inception in 1989 in our library, so don't go spending money on them.

OK so I seem to have bolden the text of interest (see below), but how do you get it just to be boldened in the text above, without reduplication?


"The second thing I wanted to mention is that some bioelectromagnetic scientists have found that living cells have the ability to demodulate modulated RF carriers. [/B]

You type in the [ b] and [ /b] tags (without the space).

Well, since the conductivity of cell walls is not linear, yes it is possible that demodulation (and intermodulation) might occur under certain circumstances. And?

Hans
 
Hans- side issue-I have recently seen two ads for home PC networking , using existing domestic wiring to avoid the need for LAN cables and the leakage associated with WiFi. Would such systems also be tappable by neighbours?(eg in an apartment building).
 
Whether the repair is simply locally controlled by neighbouring cells or directed by a central source is moot, but I believe it is the latter.

The wound healing process whilst not known in entirity, is reasonably well understood. Its also chemically mediated:

Following incision of the skin, a 5- to 10-minute period of vasoconstriction ensues, mediated by epinephrine, norepinephrine, prostaglandins, serotonin, and thromboxane.

it carries on

http://www.emedicine.com/ent/topic13.htm

and something about platelets, just coz they're important:


http://www.perfusion.com/perfusion/articles/general/9905-platelet-anatomy/
 
Yuck! This is worse than I thought. Well, I guess I asked for it, so here goes:

cogreslab said:
Harmoniser

Let me begin by defining the word health, for that is what this is all about. Health comes from an Anglo Saxon word " hele" and is the same root as hale, heal, or whole, meaning entire. In multicellular organisms this is when the organism is entire, i.e. it has all its cells. Every day many millions of cells die though events such as surface wounds, etc and these are replaced by directed mitosis. Whether the repair is simply locally controlled by neighbouring cells or directed by a central source is moot, but I believe it is the latter.

Yada, yada, yada. If it is moot, why use space for it here?

This regulatory control process is almost certainly electrical not chemical, as has been shown in examples such as measured currents of injury around surface wounds (see Becker’s work on amputated limbs: if the injury current is reversed the limb does not regenerate).

What is you basis for claiming that it is almost certainly not chemical? Who says it needs to be either chemical or electrical, mostlikely it is both. Our body is teeming with electrochemical processes.

Again one could discuss whether it is the current or the fields they give rise to which is the causal factor, and again I believe it is the latter.

There are no fields inside the body (faraday cage effect), so you are wrong. Counting wrong premises: 1.

Since the human body is transparent to magnetic fields, I do not believe that any organic regulatory mechanism uses magnetic fields, and though they are seen in Squid sensors I regard these as a by product not a controlling signal.

The human body is partly transparant to magnetic fields (AC fields), but they do interact with the body. Counting wrong premises: 2.

Btw, if you believe this, how come you sell so many magnetic devices?


I also think that the negatively charged sialic acid residues on glycoproteins collect very small electrical signals and are differentiated specifically to do that, then by signal transduction processes (this bit is in the text books) carry those signals to the nucleus for action by DNA to open up at precisely the right place and organise the synthesis of required proteins via the correct gene expression. Again I expect there could be huge debate over that view, but again I want to move on for the moment. For now let me just say this is consistent with the fact that such glycoproteins are sparse on cancer cells, which clearly do not obey regulatory growth control instructions.

In short, by your own admission, this is loose speculation on your part.

If one allows that external fields and radiations can interfere with that continuous delicate electrical process of cell repair, and that my friends with lymphomas are an example of this, how on earth can a small bit of copper tubing act as a protection against such events?

Yes, get to the point, please.

Indeed, given the four accepted facts of previous posts, there is still the yawning chasm of explaining how this "protection" occurs.

I would call this a serious understatement.

And first it must be necessary to see if there is any evidence of protection at all, which is why we did the in vitro study.

That is a funny (and expensive) way to do science. You have an entirely speculative effect and you want to do experiments. Do youpropose to make experiments for every speculative idea around? How ca nyou design a useful experiment when you have no idea abit the mechanism you are looking for.

That study did I think provide evidence of some kind of protective process at work, though I expect there will also be criticisms of the study too.

Like: We have no idea what it shows.

Obviously one needs more evidence of such a protective, from a case control study for example, which I concede we have not ourselves completed (see below).

I see our contributary role rather as trying to understand what might be the mechanism of interaction here, and that is what you have asked me to address.

Yes, because if we can not point to a plausible mechanism, we do not really have a theory, do we?

How does this putative protective effect get amplified so that it can compete effectively with a signal (e.g. the cellphone emissions) many orders of magnitude stronger in power density? I believe I found at least part of the answer by seeing what happens in the brain during an infant’s response to ELF interference.

Where and how have you seen that? Do you experiment with infants?

The brain is already designed to increase its amplitude when necessary in the face of such challenges:

I have NEVER heard of such a mechanism. Could you provide a reference for that claim?

you see this increase during REM sleep too, for example, when most of cell division takes place. We sleep, perchance to dream, but more likely to create optimal signal to noise conditions (no electrical activity from muscular movement, no competition from solar radiation) for the brain’s regulatory control transmissions to the cells, instruction them to divide. These are so powerful as to cause involuntary movement of the eye muscles, hence REM (rapid eye movement) under the lids.

The brainwaves during REM sleep are no more powerful that those when we are awake. Counting wrong premises: 3.

Once inside the body the high conductivity of physiological saline solutions and the array-like nature of many tissues serves to carry these endogenous currents throughout the body.

What do you mean: "Once inside the body"? They are gnerated in there.

One point to make as well is that charges on the surface of a large sphere will equal the charges on a sphere inside it.

Whaaaat? That is complete nonsense. Where did you get that idea??

Since the surface area of the interior sphere is inevitably smaller than the sphere encompassing it, this leads to a concentration of charge density on the interior surface.

More nonsense.

Tis is an example of organic "amplification", but there are others.

Counting wrong premises: 4.


Similarly the electrical signals from the sino atrial node in the heart are carried throughout the vasculature, resulting in a concerted rhythm of contractions to assist the blood ‘s circulation. (The heart by itself could never exert the pressure needed to pump a viscous solution through several miles of conduit), another example of amplification of endogenous fields.

More nonsense. The signals from the sinus node act as a trigger and time-keeper for the heart. The direction and sequence of how the signal propagates through the heart musculature ensures an effective pump function, but it is the mechanical work of the muscles that move the blood. Counting wrong premises: 5.

With a conductive rod made of copper the electrons find an easier path than through the surrounding air,

Electrons do not move at all in air (under normal conditions). Counting wrong premises: 6

and will therefore move along it in both directions in response to any existing forces

They certainly will not. They will move in one direction dependent of the force. Counting wrong premises: 7.

but more so, since the conductivity of skin and near surface tissues is lower.

How did we get from the copper to under the skin, all of a sudden. Anyhow, the skin is not very conductive, and the conductiviety of tissue is not lower than copper. Counting wrong premises: 8.

Encouraged by thermal energy I think the patterns of electron movements, exactly mimicking those from the body ,

How could that happen? Where does thermal energy come into the question. You can't just convert thermal energy into current. Counting wrong premises: 10.

are established within the copper tubing and that this then acts as a radiator of those endogenous signals,

They just got in there, man, if they are radieted back out, what difference does the device make? Counting etc.: 11.

and more efficiently than the organic tissues with their lower conductivity. If the copper rod is constructed to optimise those endogenous signals, then a fair degree of amplification might be achieved.

No. amplification requires a power source. Counting: 12. And a copper rod, regardless of its shape is a passive component, it cannot amplifiy anything. Counting. 13.


In the early days of radio (see BBC Handbook 1928) radio stations did exactly that: to compete against another station broadcasting on similar frequencies one station upped the amplitude of its transmissions, and the poor listener’s radio reception was mightily perturbed by the interference of both. In the end it became such a farce that a European Regulatory Authority was set up to allocate frequencies (which since then are now entirely used, so that radio astronomers complain about even their reception being perturbed).

Irrelevant.

In principle then it seems plausible to regard the lie and swindle device as an amplifier of endogenous signal in order to combat other competing signals from the RF frequency range.

No, all your premises have failed. Actually, your "early days of radio" shows that amplification is NOT the solution to intereference, but since your thesis of amplification has failed, that is also moot.

This would still not be a strong argument if power density was the only issue, but it isn’t. the information content is more important than the amplitude of the signal. As a metaphor, even if the radio station emissions were only a block away its powerful emissions would not matter to the radio listener if they were at a non-relevant frequency. I imagine organic cells as being radio listeners too.

Imagine all you will, but you have failed to provide a radio signal.

So much for the initial outline of the mechanism I hypothesise. You will notice I have not quoted any studies yet, because the next stage is to show that this hypothesis (some kind one dignified it with the term theory, but is only my hypothesis at present, and as it is still at that stage there is room for modification no doubt).

My summary is below this quotation box.

Non-scientific intermissive side comment:
(I know you like to rummage through this sort of thing)

I dare say that some will now say OK but if you haven’t yet proved it works how can you justify offering such a device? It could at best be simply a placebo, and at worst a dangerous deception if people are putting trust in this unproven adornment.

Exactly.

But first you must see that view against a background where the cellphone industry is constantly claiming out loud there is no hazard whatsoever from RF radiation at less than thermal levels. And they haven’t proved their case either. So even if this device was simply a placebo, in a world where there is no other solution to these non-elective unregulated exposures, the psychological value alone gives the device an advantage if only as a talisman. Doctors use placebos as a part of medical practice.

So, you claim that since you perceive others to act unethically, this justifies you to act unethically too? This puts you in a nice company: Osama Bin Laden, Hitler, Pol Pot, just to mention a few.

This thing costs the customer around £15 , and we buy the few we sell at £14. (I don’t know, because we don’t make it, but I guess it might cost £3 to make including packaging, but excluding any marketing costs). This actually gives us a loss, since the invoicing cost exceeds a pound - believe me this exercise is not designed to make us a fast buck!.

If you pay 14£ for a wound copper tube, you are an idiot. Next time you need some, contact me, I'll make them for 5. Wait, make that 10 (no reason to let a sucker get off too easily ;)) Anyhow, I think this is bad: Selling fraud to make money is after all understandable. As you say it hardly hurts anybody, and a fool and his money are soon parted anyway, but now you tell us you don't even make money?? Then you cheat other people simply for the kicks? This is worse than I thought :(.

But it does give us an opportunity for building a cohort of users and gathering more scientific data, from which a better understanding of any putative effects can be gained. This is of course a non-invasive experiment of sorts.

So now you tell us that you don't experiment on animals (except worms), for ethical reasons, but you DO experiment on people, wthout their knowledge and consent, and you even charge them money for it :eek:? I begin to see why you feel a relationship with worms.

But so, on that criterion, and on a global scale, is the sale for far greater profit of cellphones by the mobile telecommunications industry. They don’t know if their products are safe, and there is strong evidence they are not.

Uhh, perhaps. But cell-phones serve a purpose. Cars are dangerous, too, but we accept the danger, because of the benefits. YOUR device, however, is entirely useless.

The difference is that once a cell phone user has signed a contract it is binding and expensive, whereas we offer the user a trial period of at least 30 days (it may be 60, or 90, I cannot remember for that particular product right now), so if the buyer finds no effect it will tell us something more about our hypothesis and be costless to the customer. In fact we sell very few and we get very few returns, ( the company selling these claims the same) so we are still building the database for future study. We look at the exercise as an information gathering exercise, not a commercial one, and it is so subsidiary to our activities that to cease selling this little device would be no hardship to us at all. I fear that we would lose knowledge by doing so, however, so we have left it in our sales list for now.

Database?? Are you registering your costumer's data for research, presumably again without their knowledge and consent?? The plot thickens. This is illegal on most countries.

Next I want to address the more important task of a review of the supporting scientific evidence about the lie and swindle device, so would be grateful if you withhold overall judgement until I have competed the presentation.

Withold judgement? After you have just shot your own thesis to pieces by faulty reasoning? Are you mad?

Mr. Roger Coghill, this is worse than I had imagined. You have made 13 wrong premises to build your conclusion (plus a lot of general nonsense). A scientist should be open-minded and allow for the unknown, but even if we give your 13 premises a VERY generous 10% posibility to be true, the resultant probability of yout thesis is submicroscopic (10E-13). And you admit now that you make definite advertizing claims based on a personal thesis, that you sell your device knowing it is probably worthless simple to gather experimental data.

Sir, I will no longer call you a swindler. You are a bandit.

Hans
 
Marian said:
I recently bought "Fads & Fallacies In the Name of Science" by Martin Gardner, and I read a section I thought applied rather well to this thread. Unfortunately it was a little long, and I didn't want to type it up, but I found that someone else had typed it up on another board. So I've copied that and am posting it here. Source is Martin Gardner's book.


I read this book a couple of months ago and this passage came to my mind also.

Michael Shermer makes similar comparisons in 'Borderlands of Science' (well worth a read).
 
Oleron, I know which bit you mean. The piece about the difference between science and pseudoscience.

It's extremely relevant to Mr Coghills methods.

Edit: *sorry just read Marian's post. That's exactly the bit I meant.
 
cogreslab said:
I dare say that some will now say OK but if you haven’t yet proved it works how can you justify offering such a device? It could at best be simply a placebo, and at worst a dangerous deception if people are putting trust in this unproven adornment. .... So even if this device was simply a placebo, in a world where there is no other solution to these non-elective unregulated exposures, the psychological value alone gives the device an advantage if only as a talisman.
I couldn't come close to Hans' masterly demolition of that entire post, but this bit is worthy of more specific comment.

Roger admits he hasn't proved that this lie and swindle works. He seems at first to understand that it may therefore be dangerous, because people might put trust in it. But then he completely ignores this vital point, and goes on to justify marketing it as a "talisman".

Let us suppose that mobile phones do indeed emit dangerous radiation. In that case, failing a proven effective shield, the sensible solution is to use the things less, as Roger himself has advocated. However, sell people a "talisman", claiming that it is an effective shield, and are they then going to minimise phone use? I think not. This "talisman" is in this scenario extremely dangerous, in that it is likely to lull phone users into a false sense of security and stop them taking the obvious, sensible precaution of minimising usage.

This has got precisely nothing to do with a placebo effect, which by the way doctors aren't supposed to use anyway.

And then Roger goes on to justify marketing the things as a way of "gathering data" - in other words experimenting on his customers. Do these people know they are part of an experiment, Roger? Do you have a structured system for gathering the experimental data from them?

This is just sickening.

Rolfe.
 
Soapy Sam said:
Hans- side issue-I have recently seen two ads for home PC networking , using existing domestic wiring to avoid the need for LAN cables and the leakage associated with WiFi. Would such systems also be tappable by neighbours?(eg in an apartment building).
Yes, this makes for a local network with undefined limits. However, presumably some coding scheme is added to ensure privacy.

Hans
 
Was that it? You disappoint me, gentlemen. Before I move on to the next part let me then next clad the outline I gave with more substantive evidence, and answer the sometimes ludicrous comments made above. This should be here by tonight since today is a busy day.
 
Pragmatist said:


Congratulations Roger, you've just about managed to shut me up! I am literally speechless! I am frankly more than outraged, and I am making a real conscious effort to keep calm.

I can't discuss this sensibly right now.

This initial response adds nothing to the debate, except to invite a response (were I responding in the tradtions I find in this group) that you can#'t ever discuss it sensibly!
 
Pragmatist said:
Since Roger has now posted his theory of how the harmonizer "works" (and I am too worked up to address that directly at this moment), I'm going to take a time out and clarify something from the earlier discussion.

Some may be wondering why I denied Roger's earlier assertion that the radiation from the device was in the range 4 to 14 microns and why I asked him for a spectrogram.

The reasoning is this: ALL objects, and I mean ALL that exist within a normal temperature range on earth (and just about anywhere else that we know of) emit radiation in the far infra red range. It's a perfectly natural phenomenon. When something is "warm" (that's a relative term as I will explain) it naturally emits some of that heat as infra red.

Now, as Hans pointed out earlier, and even Roger himself, at body temperature, 37 degrees celsius, the peak (i.e. the MAJORITY) of the radiation is emitted at around 9 microns, which is well within the above range. What Roger didn't know was just how wide that range really is.


I want to comment on this by adding some data, but so as not to lose the quote I am posting it now since i seem to have got the hang of the quote system.

Prag, you are talking rubbish and using pseudoscience to present your self as a knowledgable expert.

Since some of the readers are laypersons, and some of them might have camcorders with infra red (zero lux) capability, they will be curious to know, if all objects radiate IR in such a way (i.e. only at around 9 microns) that no resolution could be possible, they can still get an acceptable image from a completely dark room. Of course, even our present technology can distinguish between IR radiations of only slightly different temperatures sufficiently to provide meaningful information. This was the point I made and you have not overturned it.

It is a well known physical phenomenon that IR radiation is generated by vibration and rotation of atoms and molecules in any temperature above absolute zero. IR is often misdescribed as thermal, but it actually demonstrates many of the characteristics of visible light and radar waves. It may be focused, , transmitted like radio or radar through materials that block visible light, and it can be used to deliver information with the same precision.


As for your stupid comments about the great temperature range exhibited between 4 and 14 microns wavelength, let me givwe ione example from nature to show how IR can be used with great precision to convey information at a distance. Dorsett (1962) used a thermocouple to measure the increase in temperature generated by various species of sphingids during wing vibrations and observed an increase about the resting /ambient temperature of upto 18 degrees C. Callahan later proved that the corn ear moth could regulate its IR emissions extremely precisely by changing its wing beat rate, thereby varying thorax temperature.

If we consider the heated earworm moth as a black body (unity) , then for every degree of temperature we can calculate, using Wein’s displacement law, a specific radiation wavelength where:

Lamda m x T = b,

Lamda m being the wavelength of maximum radiation intensity in centimeters, T the temperature in Kelvin of the source object, a nd b the Wein displacement constant (=2897 m K° if landa m is calculated in microns).

Therefore lamda m = 2897/absolute temperture of a flying earworm moth

= 2897/273 + 24 C° = 9.7 microns at 76 F° and at 1800 wing beats/minute.

As the moth’s wing frequency rises towards its peak and as the temperature rises above ambient, the wavelength in microns for peak radition (lamda m) decreases. Callahan then showed by accurate measurements of inflight temperature that every species of moth used a characteristic wing beat rate and thereby an identifiable wavelength of IR radiation.

I will not bother to address the issue of whether the minute changes in radiation energy are detectable by the except to say that the antennae sensory pits of certain species of ants, grasshoppers, bees, and chafers could be considered as dielectric wave guides. Callahan sets out the radiation emitted per steradian and comes up with about 0.009 watts/steradian. It is further evident that only a few degrees change in K can shift the spectral distribution in langleys radiated between 9.5 microns and 10 microns sufficiently for easy detection by the moth ( e.g. 9.66 microns at 300 K (80.6 F), 10.0 microns at 289 K (60.8 F).

So your claim that IR radiation is too diffuse for use as an information delivery medium in organic life is complete crap.
Continued.


,
 
cogreslab said:
Was that it? You disappoint me, gentlemen. Before I move on to the next part let me then next clad the outline I gave with more substantive evidence, and answer the sometimes ludicrous comments made above. This should be here by tonight since today is a busy day.
"Was that it" is what we are asking. You have presented a totally whacky thesis, in fact way beyond my imaginations. I had at least expected you to show some logical consistency, but you just pile one wild speculation upon another, glued together by ignorance of the subject at hand, and you are disappointed. May I ask, disappointed of what? Did you think you could enter a forum of qualified people and get away with waving some foggy notions around? Perhaps you thought that by padding them with enough words, we would not read carefully?

Sorry, sir, but yes then I must disappoint you. Expect your every inconsistency and self-contradiction to be noted and called. Much earlier in this thread, somebody gave you the good advice: When in a hole, stop digging. I'm wondering, isn't it beginning to get hot down there?

But, by all means, do go on. Write another piece of fiction, and we'll tear that to shreds, too. We aim to please ;).

Hans
 
You have presented no evidence, simply assertions based on you own dubious science.

You failed to spot that everything at body temperatures radiates in the range your little gizmo radiates. You then attempt to distract by posting a notice about an electrophysiology conference that has nothing to do with your case.

Your explanation talks complete rubbish about immunology and haemodynamics.

You practically admit that the 'Harmonizer' is nothing more than a talisman.

I assume that arrogance is a compulsory part of the a degree at Cambridge, since you’re far from the only case that I’ve come across. You seem to regard yourself as the ‘crème de la crème’ forgetting that this is the thick bit at the top.
 
cogreslab said:


I want to comment on this by adding some data, but so as not to lose the quote I am posting it now since i seem to have got the hang of the quote system.
Mmm, just friendly advice, Roger: Since you want to pass for an academic, I suggest you try to avoid drawing attention to the fact that it took you several weeks (and the help of several other posters) to learn how to click the "quote" button :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
Timble said:
I assume that arrogance is a compulsory part of the a degree at Cambridge,
You assume correctly :D. Mr Coghill is by Fen Poly standards not very arrogant at all.
 
This thread never ceases to astonish.

I would very much like to know who the physical chemists are that consult with Mr Coghill, and what their expertise is, but I don't want to pile up yet another diversion.
 
cogreslab said:


This initial response adds nothing to the debate, except to invite a response (were I responding in the tradtions I find in this group) that you can#'t ever discuss it sensibly!

It adds to the debate my expression of outrage at the bankruptcy of your morals and ethics. And if you can't see WHY I am outraged at your admission that you justify immoral and unethical behavior yourself on the grounds that someone else does it (in your opinion at that, because the alleged immoral behavior of others is not by any means proved), then you are sick, very very sick indeed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom