Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

the lying, gold digging bitch defense.

Gold digging? No. Dickinson is wealthy in her own right. But she DOES revel in publicity. Whether she is lying about Cosby, I don't know, but when she teamed up with Gloria Allred for a well-attended press conference to make her claim against him, my cynical side did wonder.
 
Last edited:
....
Money is a powerful incentive for all manner of bad behaviour. Just ask anyone who has had a wealthy relative die.

Who is demanding money? The statutes of limitations for criminal and civil action ended decades ago for almost all of these cases. Constand is an unusual exception.
 
Who is demanding money? The statutes of limitations for criminal and civil action ended decades ago for almost all of these cases. Constand is an unusual exception.

Judy Huth for one and the attorney for others has demanded that Cosbyput $100 million into an account and allow a retired judge to decide if the women's individual cases have merit.
 
Rightly so if that's correct. Agreements made by authorized state agents are binding (or should be) on the state, even after the officeholder retires. I can't see a judge ruling any other way.


Was the guy speaking for the state? Or only about what he personally would or wouldn't do? The story quotes the current DA:
The current district attorney, Kevin Steele, who was elected in November after serving as Ferman's longtime top deputy, told CNN on Friday: "There is a specific legal method to grant immunity. That was not done in 2005."

And he's not being prosecuted for what he said in the deposition, but for what he did, as alleged by Constand. His deposition helps support her claims, but she can still get on the stand and testify herself, as can other witnesses. It's a little early for Coz to be celebrating.
 
And he's not being prosecuted for what he said in the deposition, but for what he did, as alleged by Constand. His deposition helps support her claims, but she can still get on the stand and testify herself, as can other witnesses. It's a little early for Coz to be celebrating.

I think the idea is that the prosecutor (the one retired now) agreed not to file criminal charges so Cosby wouldn't be able to claim his fifth amendment rights in the civil case, allowing them to depose him without that protection.

Breaking that agreement would then entail winding the clock back and re-doing the civil suit (for which I think she got a settlement). I don't think that's possible at this point.

But it's not just a matter of not using Cosby's civil trial testimony in a 'new' criminal trial, it's about the consequences of getting it for the civil trial back when the agreement was made. One could claim (with justification) that the agreement not to prosecute then was critical in obtaining a settlement for the victim.

If they prosecute Cosby for the same event now, the whole thing looks like a sneaky way to remove fifth amendment protections from a defendant. I don't think that's gonna fly with a judge. Especially when the tool is so commonly used by prosecutors to get bad guys to "flip" on other bad guys. You can compel them to testify if you grant them immunity, since their right to self incrimination is not invoked with immunity.

The other path - available back then, but not now - would be to prosecute criminally before the deposition in the civil trial takes place. Cosby gets to invoke his right not to self-incriminate during the criminal phase, but once that's over (with either outcome), he loses it for the civil trial.
 
Last edited:
I think the idea is that the prosecutor (the one retired now) agreed not to file criminal charges so Cosby wouldn't be able to claim his fifth amendment rights in the civil case, allowing them to depose him without that protection.
....


But even if his deposition is excluded entirely, how does that preclude Constand from testifying about what happened to her, supported by whatever witnesses she presents? When a defendant's confession is thrown out because it was obtained illegally, the prosecution can still go forward with witnesses, other evidence, forensics, even other statements he may have made. The deposition might be the reason the new DA believes Constand, but he could have chosen to believe her without it. He doesn't need it to make the case to a jury.
 
But even if his deposition is excluded entirely, how does that preclude Constand from testifying about what happened to her, supported by whatever witnesses she presents? When a defendant's confession is thrown out because it was obtained illegally, the prosecution can still go forward with witnesses, other evidence, forensics, even other statements he may have made. The deposition might be the reason the new DA believes Constand, but he could have chosen to believe her without it. He doesn't need it to make the case to a jury.

That's all true, but how can we go back in time to the civil case and give Cosby his fifth amendment rights back? That ship has already sailed.

The complaint is about more than the criminal trial, it's about what Cosby would have done back then if he didn't have immunity.
 
That's all true, but how can we go back in time to the civil case and give Cosby his fifth amendment rights back? That ship has already sailed.

The complaint is about more than the criminal trial, it's about what Cosby would have done back then if he didn't have immunity.

Did he have immunity from prosecution for his crimes? Or just immunity (if even that) from having his deposition used against him? Assume Cosby had never given his deposition. The DA would still have been able to revisit the case today -- just before the statute of limitations expired -- based on Constand's allegations in 2005 and now, supported by accounts from dozens of women about similar events that a different DA didn't have in 2005. It's possible - but not certain -- that a judge might prohibit using Cosby's deposition, but just as when a flawed confession is excluded from evidence, the prosecution can pursue the case with other tools. Ultimately the jury has to decide whether Constand or Cosby is telling the truth about consent to what they both agree was a sexual encounter.
 
This is a wider question, but why should a serious crime be subject to a statute of limitations?

Not an American example, but Berlusconi has got away with much because of this.
 
This is a wider question, but why should a serious crime be subject to a statute of limitations?

Not an American example, but Berlusconi has got away with much because of this.
The statute of limitations is designed to prevent prosecutorial abuse. Citizens shouldn't have to live their whole lives in fear of the state changing its mind when it comes to whether or not to prosecute them for a crime. Murder is the exception because it's considered the worst crime that can be committed. There may be other crimes for which the same exception should be made (I'd be cool with rape and attempted murder having no statute of limitations) but, speaking generally, it's a good thing.
 
Did he have immunity from prosecution for his crimes? Or just immunity (if even that) from having his deposition used against him?

I think it's the former, reading what the old prosecutor had to say about it.

Assume Cosby had never given his deposition. The DA would still have been able to revisit the case today -- just before the statute of limitations expired -- based on Constand's allegations in 2005 and now, supported by accounts from dozens of women about similar events that a different DA didn't have in 2005. It's possible - but not certain -- that a judge might prohibit using Cosby's deposition, but just as when a flawed confession is excluded from evidence, the prosecution can pursue the case with other tools. Ultimately the jury has to decide whether Constand or Cosby is telling the truth about consent to what they both agree was a sexual encounter.

It's true that Cosby would still be chargeable without the deal and they could charge without the deposition. As to the new witnesses, we have to wonder if they would have come forward, had the lawsuit not been settled - I forget how much her story and judgement fanned the negative publicity claims.

The decision made at the time by the prosecutor seems reasonable to me: "I can't convict with what I have, but if I agree not to charge, Cosby is vulnerable to a civil judgement." From the victim's (and justice's) point of view, it's better to get something rather than nothing.
 
The defense of Cosby gives me hope to see people finally putting blame where it belongs in the supposed abuse by catholic priests. On those extorting money from the church.
 
And what suave seductive ladies man like Cosby doesn't drug their women? It is all part of the game. His own testimony shows that.

Making unsupported claims won't get him charged, it just makes his claim that the women are lying more believable.
 
The defense of Cosby gives me hope to see people finally putting blame where it belongs in the supposed abuse by catholic priests. On those extorting money from the church.

As a skeptic you should follow the evidence, and as police investigators have shown, everytime there is a verifiable claim made against Cosby it turns out to be false or is contradicted by stronger evidence.

For instance, Cosby was not at the Playboy mansion nor does the accuser's own witness corroborate the claim of the accuser. Nor was he on the tonight show set on the occasion his accuser says. He was in New York.

Dickinson's claim about the events in Cosby's room are directly contradicted by her earlier unsolicited version of events told on several occasions to several independent people.

The "sheer numbers means he's guilty" isn't evidence. It's wishful thinking
 
As a skeptic you should follow the evidence, and as police investigators have shown, everytime there is a verifiable claim made against Cosby it turns out to be false or is contradicted by stronger evidence.

Every time? Surely some of the times they've just decided that there's not enough evidence to pursue a prosecution with a reasonable prospect of success - not necessarily that the claim is false?

(I don't know, which is why this post is a question.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom