Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Define "credible." Because if you mean "considered to be real by Bigfoot enthusiasts," then there are a bunch of them (Memorial Day, Redwoods, Freeman...)

None of what you mention is any good IMO. I consider the PGF as a gold standard of a fake film that has enough going for it to invite exactly what the PGF has inspired for the past 40years. Wittness the 371 pages of posts here and it needs no further explaination. Freeman IMO is dreadful, Memorial Day a blurry mess seen at a distance, Redwoods looks as bad a the BBC suit. On and on. But lets not stop there lets include Morris recreation as an illustration of a professional job that doesn't look real even though its not intended to be real. It still looks fake. The PGF is a fake a great fake they got it right.

So we're left with the problem of the supposed ease that the PGF hoax was created with yet no contender to actually challenge its rank. If it was quick and easy and cheap then we'd have excellent fakes galore. We don't we have one great hoax the likes of which only happens when professionals ply their craft. As good as the PGF, sure but you'll be spending real money and real time.

That said DFoot may eventually come forward with a serious suit and Bill Munns will too. But what's the operative word between them? Professionals with professional connections. None of the quick and easy mavens stand a chance of making this thing. If it could be done by nobody's it would have been done by now. But go ahead give it a try see if you can.
 
Last edited:
Complaining about skeptics not attempting something is a standard ploy used to deflect attention away from the fact that proponents can not prove their case that bigfoot is an honest to goodness real creature and not the just another myth.

I dont reallylike or care for the titles and their connotations slung around on various boards but I have to acknowledge one thing I see time and time again. ( especially since by the definitions proffered, I would be a "believer" who just applies real science to the situation)

I never see "skeptics" always claiming to have the suit or various components ( such as this mystery evidence examined in secret Russian labs or endless claims "verified" by various "unnamed" experts whose reports and datasets never seem to materialize)

I never see skeptics asking for people to void the tenets and canon of science and bend all the rules for "their" suit claims.

Just an observation
 
Last edited:
I never see "skeptics" always claiming to have the suit or various components ( such as this mystery evidence examined in secret Russian labs or endless claims "verified" by various "unnamed" experts whose reports and datasets never seem to materialize)
I never see skeptics asking for people to void the tenets and canon of science and bend all the rules for "their" suit claims.
Just an observation

I doubt any recreation with a comparable suit will ever satisfy bigfoot proponents. There will always be complaints that it doesn't look exactly right. That is because the proponents will know it is a suit. Recreating the effort is a waste of time IMO.

Additionally, asking for the suit 40 years later is a ridiculous request in itself. You might as well ask for the holy grail or the golden fleece. The suit is long since gone and nobody knows what happened to it. If it does materialize, proponents will claim it is not the suit and somebody created a comparable suit to make it look like Patty/Bunny.

In both cases, the proponents will not be happy. There is one way to completely solve this and that would be to produce a body or a living bigfoot. That would end the discussion. Until that body or living bigfoot is produced, then skeptics will always state it looks like a guy in a suit and there is no evidence to suggest otherwise.

Just an observation.
 
@Astrophotographer you could simply summarize it that proponent are simply acting on faith. That certainly explain why due to lack of any biological evidence they still purport BF to exists and always will.
 
I am not sure if anybody has even really tried there Sweaty. But as long as we are on the "failed attempts" idea. How many years since PGF? Something like 40 and counting? Yet, this is the best evidence that proponents can produce to show there are real bigfeet in the northwest? With all the advances in technology and the expansion of civilization towards the NW, nobody has yet to get anything better. Why is that? Where are the bodies?


Nice diversion attempt, Astro....but the skeptics have the much easier task. Just stuff a little padding inside a pant-leg, and show us all exactly how it was done.


Complaining about skeptics not attempting something is a standard ploy used to deflect attention away from the fact that proponents can not prove their case that bigfoot is an honest to goodness real creature and not the just another myth.


I highlighted 2 key words in your statement, Astro.


First....who's complaining? :) I'm laughing at the "skeptics" on this board!

Greg can say with 100% certainty (read my signature line for his quote...the 'evidence' carries a 0% probability of Bigfoot being real, according to Greg's weighing of it.) that the bulging on the back of Patty's leg, and on her thigh, is the result of padding inside of a suit......yet he CANNOT seem to reproduce it. (I challenged Greg a couple of years ago to reproduce the 'thigh bulge'....nothing from him yet.)

So, I find it extremely humorous :D :D :D that someone can "know" that those bulges on Patty are simply padding.....and yet, at the same time, be completely incapable of reproducing it.

Don't you think that's funny?



Secondly.....it's not a 'ploy' at all.

It's a request....a challenge. There's nothing wrong with asking someone who says they know something to show that they actually do know it.

Does that seem unreasonable to you?

I'm not going to try to reproduce the apparant muscle bulging on Patty, using padding, when I don't think that it is padding....and I don't know how to reproduce the effect with padding.

I'll leave that up the experts on padding.......like Greg, and you. ;)


Tick tock....the world waits....and laughs.......forever. :)
 
Last edited:
Here's a comparison of the back of the legs of a couple of cheap suits...with Patty's left leg...


HaHaHaHaHaHa1.jpg



gorilla6.jpg



The suits pull away from the back of the leg in the loose-fitting suits, but Patty's "suit" is, somehow, tightly attached to the back of the leg...despite the bulging mass (muscle ;))....


PattyLLEGgif33.gif
 
It's a request....a challenge. There's nothing wrong with asking someone who says they know something to show that they actually do know it.

I doubt there is any comparable suit that will satisfy bigfoot proponents. However, the reverse challenge is there. No body for over 40 years says a lot. Not one body or living bigfoot indicates the PGF is a fake. If you want to believe it is a real bigfoot, feel free to do so. However, there is no proof it is a real bigfoot and plenty to indicate it could be a fake. The easiest method to prove it is a real bigfoot is to produce a body. So far, bigfoot mania is big on promise but short on results.


I'll leave that up the experts on padding.......like Greg, and you.
Tick tock....the world waits....and laughs.......forever.

Never said I was an expert in recreating a suit. However, looking at the images there is nothing in the PGF that indicates we are seeing a real bigfoot no matter how much you complain. Everything in the film can be reproduced by a guy in a suit. BTW, it is "the world wonders". However, the world does laugh. They laugh at people who believe in things that don't exist like ghosts, fairies, elves, loch ness monsters, bigfeet, etc...
 
Last edited:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dI9wPqk5Kgo

The 12 to 20 second mark of this video, has several thigh bulges in the same area as Patty, and look at the funny calf bulge right at the 14 second mark.

Also, Does anyone have any DVDs of the Gargantua movies. Those costumes look ripe for bulges. Green and Brown Gargantua and even Baby gargantua would be good if someone could look at those for similar bulges.
 
If the suit was as bad as Dfoot claims it was. If it easy to make and film with the effect the PGF achieved
Bad costume? Yes, for our current standards and when compared with some vintage costumes.

Define easy. If by "easy" you define pulling a well-planned hoax at the right time with the right target, using the right costume and with some lucky strikes, then it was easy.

we'd be knee deep in enigmatic Sasquatach films. But we're not and its not because there isn't a reasonable degree of interest in trying to make a Sasquatch film. A quick trim to You Tube is enough put an end to that cozy notion.
This, I think, is doubtfull. One thing is a hoax being possible and easy to be made; however that's not all. There must be a "market" for the hoax. I don't think there is a market for a hoax like PGF nowadays. Think about the bigfoot film/pictures hoax story. P&G were relatively successfull but still recognized as a fraud. In their tracks came Marx, Freeman, Biscardi, the snow walker, etc. All of them received smaller attention and had less success. P&G had previously occupied the niche. To pull a PGF-like hoax nowadays it would be much harder, I think. The story would be subjected to a much deeper scrutiny. Youtube can only produce more amateurish bigfoot as well as UFO, ghost, sea serpent, whatever. But I think they all will be only the products of a couple of people who decided to have a laugh at the believers without spending too much time and money. Different goals. Some youtube hoaxes are far worse than Marx's ridiculous costume. There are gorilla costumes which can be bought or rented which would perform much better. But no one bothers making a second PGF because nowadays its not worth the effort.

Note that we are not also knee-deep in good UFO, ghost, sea serpent, etc. footage, despite all the tech currently available. The olds stuff remains, mostly due to a number of tenacious defenders, because detailed investigation is no longer possible and because most people do not care. Its a new time, with new investigation standards.

The suit was good, the mime in the suit was good, it wasn't cheap it wasn't easy. Yet still we wait. Man there just aren't any credible fake Sasquataches why? why oh why is that?
Correa do you have the answer why?
Define good. Good like the kaiju yeti costume? Good like the kaiju king kong costume? Good like one of the vintage gorilla costumes we posted pics of?

Why there are no credible bigfoot fakes? There are two main reasons, I think.
No market for them is the main cause. Actually I think there are several gorilla (and other hominid) costumes which would be as good as and even better than Patty. Again, no one bothers making a second PGF because nowadays its not worth the effort.

The second part of the equation is the iconic level that Patty reached among some people. Nothing will, in their minds, be better than Patty. Not even Patty itself, as Dfoot's photoshop job indicated. Not even a state-of-the-art costume, as one can see from the statements from many a footer when they declare that certain post- (as well as sin- and pre-) PGF costumes are not as realistic as Patty.

I don't call what I wrote above "answers". They are educated guesses.
 
Last edited:
Just addressing some misinformation...

Now we are getting somewhere Crow. ( I know things tend to get lost in a blog, especially when the information is posted over 2 of them in multiple threads)

The key is as you wrote- usable information. As I said originally, one CAN get a degree of relative accuracy ( which cannot be defined) but not exact. ( and in this case the range is but a few inches)
How do you know the range is a few inches?

Heres the next problem ( in addition to not being able to independantly measure each object to bring them in sync) The objects are 3 D ( they have height,width and depth)
The objects are 3D that have been projected onto a 2D surface. No different than the back of your retina.

a picture is 2 D- thus its been "flattened" ( distorted) so in addition to lacking information to scale the objects to measure them- the objects themselves are distorted and not a true representation of what they actually are. ( depending on their relative angles to the lense)
Huh? A 2D pic hasn't been flattened or distorted (with a decent lens). Rendering an object in 2D does NOT create distortion. What principle of optics are you referring to?

Its like making a map. A map ( flat paper) is a representation of a 3 D globe ( with elevations, depressions and such). So when you "iron" the globe flat to put on the paper- its automatically distorted. Thats why maps have conversion angles on them to account for the distortion when using GPS or a compass. ( or why some people say a picture makes them "look" fat- it actually does to a point)
This is flat out wrong! 2D images don't get flattened out in a photo. There is no difference or distortion than looking at an object with 1 eye.

So this effect can, depending on the angle to the lens of the object, can compress ( make smaller by pushing it into itself) or make it wider ( like a fun house mirror)
Where are you getting this stuff? The only effect that the angle to the lens creates is foreshortening. No different from the 3D world. Are you referring to the depth of field "compression effect" between background and foreground caused by lens magnification?

This effect becomes greater ( more pronounced) as distance between the object and the lens increases. ( same angle but from the apex out- the tangent lines move further apart)
Angular foreshortening effects are EXACTLY the same regardless of distance from the observer. The actual scaling distortion of an object LESSENS farther from the camera. Macro views are the most distortive because the distances from the front and back of an object are relatively large with respect to the distance from the camera.

So, in addition to the inability to dimension the objects independantly, you are dealing with 2 different levels of individual distortion that must be accounted for if one wants to compare the 2.

For example-( just pulling figures out of the air because actual measurements are unknown) if BH was 10 feet from the lens, his distortion factor might be 1%- if patty was 100feet, her distortion would be about 10% so you are still comparing an apple to a plum in terms of an orange. ( unlike your polo pictures where the players were reasonably close so their distortion would be almost insignificant and equal amongst the group)
Wrong! Your expertise obviously doesn't extend to optics.

See, what I'm telling you isnt my "opinion" ( as if one persons opinion regarding a guess means more than any others)- its a stone cold fact of physics and planar math and cant simply be "ignored" in favor of visual acquity( the eyes will play tricks on one- a yardstick never does)
It sure IS your opinion and it's faulty. My criticism has nothing to do with whether or not the PGF can be measured reliably. This is all about misrepresenting the science of image metrology and in particular optics and geomatics.
 
Last edited:
I dont reallylike or care for the titles and their connotations slung around on various boards but I have to acknowledge one thing I see time and time again. ( especially since by the definitions proffered, I would be a "believer" who just applies real science to the situation)

I never see "skeptics" always claiming to have the suit or various components ( such as this mystery evidence examined in secret Russian labs or endless claims "verified" by various "unnamed" experts whose reports and datasets never seem to materialize)

I never see skeptics asking for people to void the tenets and canon of science and bend all the rules for "their" suit claims.

Just an observation
LT, the biggest complaint we have regarding some footers are the constant attempts to decrease evidence quality levels (to the point of trying to sell crap as gold) and the almost complete lack of good research methodology. Judging from what I saw, there's very little (if any) science in bigfootery. And no amounts of ad homs against skeptics or endless repetition of old unsubstantiated claims/evidence from the part of some proponents can change this. One has the right to believe on something based on weak or unverifiable evidence -such as personal experiences- but one must also keep in mind the limitations of such a position.

Frankly, in the end, I (and I think many posters here) actually do not care if a poster believes or not in bigfoot; I do not actually try to convince people that bigfeet (or UFOs, Atlantis, etc.) are not real. What I try to do is to show that the bar regarding evidence quality and methodology must be raised if they want their claims to be taken seriously. They must dump the bad data and start from scratch after building a set of good methodological guidelines. Yes, it may hurt to let go things with a large amount of emotional attachment, but good science is primarily constructed with reason. The emotion and the commitment goes in to dedicating oneself to do a good work. Emotional attachment to hypothesis (I don’t think there are actual theories regarding bigfoot – there are work hypothesis at best) and datasets will cloud the reasoning and ruin the proponents’ works.

There’s no point complaining about the lack of support from the part of “close-minded mainstream skeptical scientists isolated within their ivory towers”. The lack of support comes solely from the lack of evidence and poor methodology. Skeptics are not the main reason why bigfoot is not taken seriously; the main cause lies within the very behavior of many of its supporters. As long as they keep spreading misinformation, making false claims, using lousy methodology and displaying excess of credibility (not to mention the scam attempts), they will keep shooting their own feet.

To say the methodology is poor and the evidence is unreliable because the people who investigate bigfoot are amateurs is a lame excuse. All it takes is to look at the level of some work made by amateur astronomers and paleontologists, for example, to see how weak such an excuse is.

Hopefully, reading a similar argument from a person who labels himself as a “believer” some people will at last get it…
 
Crowlogic:

None of what you mention is any good IMO. I consider the PGF as a gold standard of a fake film that has enough going for it to invite exactly what the PGF has inspired for the past 40years. Wittness the 371 pages of posts here and it needs no further explaination.

Correa Neto is dead-on about the PGF (and other old "evidence") being touted as a mystery for so long due to tenacious believers. I think that if the internet existed back then, the PGF would've been ripped apart pretty quickly. And let's not forget that "Surgeon's Photograph" example I gave awhile back about a hoax "being a mystery for decades." As for the page count, let's not forget that a good chunk of that was devoted to off-topic subjects and repetitions of the same arguments.

So we're left with the problem of the supposed ease that the PGF hoax was created with yet no contender to actually challenge its rank. If it was quick and easy and cheap then we'd have excellent fakes galore. We don't we have one great hoax the likes of which only happens when professionals ply their craft. As good as the PGF, sure but you'll be spending real money and real time.

I think it all depends on a person's personal definition of cheapness and ease. If Dfoot's theory about it being mostly made of repurposed Star Trek costume parts is correct, then there's a very good reason why nobody else has made another Patty.

Drewbot:

I'm afraid that War of the Gargantuas won't be out on DVD in the USA until September. Now if someone had a copy of the Japanese release...
 
How the *bleeep* Patty was actually like?

OK, after thinking a bit about Munns' Patty reconstruction, I remembered an older one. After some searching, I found this pic sunken somewhere in the depths of my HD:
whomadethisbigfoot.jpg

I have no idea regarding who made it, and if there's some copyright violation, mods and admins, please edit this post and delete the link.

Now, lets check its details (if its still there).
The position is clearly derived from a PGF frame; the face has what I also interpret as beard-like hairs. I think the headcrest is too pointed. However, three things stand up:
-The color. Its roughly the same tone used by Munns. I just can't figure out how such light color can be derived from PGF frames.
-The feet. They look more like gorilla's feet (more consistent with the presence of a mid-tarsal break) but they do not look like Patty's feet as shown at PGF and/or the fooprints claimed to be from its feet.
-The wrists. I can't see them like that. They either look more like a gorilla's wrists (adated to knuckle-walking) or like that weird joint we can see at some gorilla costumes with arm extensions.
-The breasts seem smaller and at a higher (and more correct) position in the chest.

My point is that even if it is the rendering of a male bigfoot based on PGF images, its quite problematic, assuming accuracy was intended. What brings us back to the methodology issue...
 
Just addressing some misinformation...


How do you know the range is a few inches?


The objects are 3D that have been projected onto a 2D surface. No different than the back of your retina.


Huh? A 2D pic hasn't been flattened or distorted (with a decent lens). Rendering an object in 2D does NOT create distortion. What principle of optics are you referring to?


This is flat out wrong! 2D images don't get flattened out in a photo. There is no difference or distortion than looking at an object with 1 eye.


Where are you getting this stuff? The only effect that the angle to the lens creates is foreshortening. No different from the 3D world. Are you referring to the depth of field "compression effect" between background and foreground caused by lens magnification?


Angular foreshortening effects are EXACTLY the same regardless of distance from the observer. The actual scaling distortion of an object LESSENS farther from the camera. Macro views are the most distortive because the distances from the front and back of an object are relatively large with respect to the distance from the camera.


Wrong! Your expertise obviously doesn't extend to optics.


It sure IS your opinion and it's faulty. My criticism has nothing to do with whether or not the PGF can be measured reliably. This is all about misrepresenting the science of image metrology and in particular optics and geomatics.


Oh Boy, a challenge- I like them

>>>Just addressing some misinformation...

No, thats what I'm doing now to your post

>>>How do you know the range is a few inches?

DECADES of actually doing it, along with training and accreditation/certification to accepted Global Standards- your pedigree is?

>>>The objects are 3D that have been projected onto a 2D surface. No different than the back of your retina.

Not how it works

>>>Huh? A 2D pic hasn't been flattened or distorted (with a decent lens). Rendering an object in 2D does NOT create distortion. What principle of optics are you referring to?

You're done at this point- its clear you have no subject matter knowledge of what you speak

>>>This is flat out wrong! 2D images don't get flattened out in a photo. There is no difference or distortion than looking at an object with 1 eye.

No

>>>Where are you getting this stuff? The only effect that the angle to the lens creates is foreshortening. No different from the 3D world. Are you referring to the depth of field "compression effect" between background and foreground caused by lens magnification?

I posted my reference- where is yours coming from is the question

>>>Angular foreshortening effects are EXACTLY the same regardless of distance from the observer. The actual scaling distortion of an object LESSENS farther from the camera. Macro views are the most distortive because the distances from the front and back of an object are relatively large with respect to the distance from the camera.

No

>>>Wrong! Your expertise obviously doesn't extend to optics.

Yours doesnt extend to anything- thats obvious. You blather and say nothing. Heres your "acid test"- DIMENSION the picture ( its put up or shut up time now)

>>>It sure IS your opinion and it's faulty. My criticism has nothing to do with whether or not the PGF can be measured reliably. This is all about misrepresenting the science of image metrology and in particular optics and geomatics

No, its a FACT and all your whining wont change that. Heres the test. Stop whining and start DIMENSIONING. And dont forget to post exactly what each dimension is and how you derived it ( the date will be reviewed)

There are 2 choices now- the line is in the sand

1) you will and face the critique that I can GUARANTEE is coming and will be blown out of the water

2) you will remain suspiciously silent in the woodwork talking in circles yet never producing anything which will speak for itself.

Your move- I'm here and waiting
 
LT, the biggest complaint we have regarding some footers are the constant attempts to decrease evidence quality levels (to the point of trying to sell crap as gold) and the almost complete lack of good research methodology. Judging from what I saw, there's very little (if any) science in bigfootery. And no amounts of ad homs against skeptics or endless repetition of old unsubstantiated claims/evidence from the part of some proponents can change this. One has the right to believe on something based on weak or unverifiable evidence -such as personal experiences- but one must also keep in mind the limitations of such a position.

Frankly, in the end, I (and I think many posters here) actually do not care if a poster believes or not in bigfoot; I do not actually try to convince people that bigfeet (or UFOs, Atlantis, etc.) are not real. What I try to do is to show that the bar regarding evidence quality and methodology must be raised if they want their claims to be taken seriously. They must dump the bad data and start from scratch after building a set of good methodological guidelines. Yes, it may hurt to let go things with a large amount of emotional attachment, but good science is primarily constructed with reason. The emotion and the commitment goes in to dedicating oneself to do a good work. Emotional attachment to hypothesis (I don’t think there are actual theories regarding bigfoot – there are work hypothesis at best) and datasets will cloud the reasoning and ruin the proponents’ works.

There’s no point complaining about the lack of support from the part of “close-minded mainstream skeptical scientists isolated within their ivory towers”. The lack of support comes solely from the lack of evidence and poor methodology. Skeptics are not the main reason why bigfoot is not taken seriously; the main cause lies within the very behavior of many of its supporters. As long as they keep spreading misinformation, making false claims, using lousy methodology and displaying excess of credibility (not to mention the scam attempts), they will keep shooting their own feet.

To say the methodology is poor and the evidence is unreliable because the people who investigate bigfoot are amateurs is a lame excuse. All it takes is to look at the level of some work made by amateur astronomers and paleontologists, for example, to see how weak such an excuse is.

Hopefully, reading a similar argument from a person who labels himself as a “believer” some people will at last get it…


>>>the constant attempts to decrease evidence quality levels (to the point of trying to sell crap as gold) and the almost complete lack of good research methodology.

No question,argument or discussion from me- it is the truth ( however, there are many I have come to know and respect who do put forth 100% effort in just that)

>>>Judging from what I saw, there's very little (if any) science in bigfootery.

See above but on the whole ( with the most publicized ones) thats correct

>>>What I try to do is to show that the bar regarding evidence quality and methodology must be raised if they want their claims to be taken seriously. They must dump the bad data and start from scratch after building a set of good methodological guidelines.

You are preaching to the choir- I have stated before thats what I'm doing as well

>>>There’s no point complaining about the lack of support from the part of “close-minded mainstream skeptical scientists isolated within their ivory towers”. ........As long as they keep spreading misinformation, making false claims, using lousy methodology and displaying excess of credibility (not to mention the scam attempts), they will keep shooting their own feet.


agreed

>>>To say the methodology is poor and the evidence is unreliable because the people who investigate bigfoot are amateurs is a lame excuse. All it takes is to look at the level of some work made by amateur astronomers and paleontologists, for example, to see how weak such an excuse is.

There are many of those out there. Those are the ones who have my complete and total support in their efforts.

>>>Hopefully, reading a similar argument from a person who labels himself as a “believer” some people will at last get it

I cannot qualify or quantify my 2 experiences and after thousands of times reviewing them in my mind- the most probable solution if a Bigfoot ( still,I never got a positive ID). That said, thats fine for "me" personally but I know that theres no way possible for me to go further than that. When I put on my professional garment- I have to state what the facts and data show and subject every piece of evidence to the acid test of science. So far, nothing has survived.

Please dont call my hand because there are fanatics in every field but I try to exercise professional restraint with those who are really putting forth the legitimate effort. ( which is most of them) They are worthy of respect.
 
Bad costume? Yes, for our current standards and when compared with some vintage costumes.

Define easy. If by "easy" you define pulling a well-planned hoax at the right time with the right target, using the right costume and with some lucky strikes, then it was easy.


This, I think, is doubtfull. One thing is a hoax being possible and easy to be made; however that's not all. There must be a "market" for the hoax. I don't think there is a market for a hoax like PGF nowadays. Think about the bigfoot film/pictures hoax story. P&G were relatively successfull but still recognized as a fraud. In their tracks came Marx, Freeman, Biscardi, the snow walker, etc. All of them received smaller attention and had less success. P&G had previously occupied the niche. To pull a PGF-like hoax nowadays it would be much harder, I think. The story would be subjected to a much deeper scrutiny. Youtube can only produce more amateurish bigfoot as well as UFO, ghost, sea serpent, whatever. But I think they all will be only the products of a couple of people who decided to have a laugh at the believers without spending too much time and money. Different goals. Some youtube hoaxes are far worse than Marx's ridiculous costume. There are gorilla costumes which can be bought or rented which would perform much better. But no one bothers making a second PGF because nowadays its not worth the effort.

Note that we are not also knee-deep in good UFO, ghost, sea serpent, etc. footage, despite all the tech currently available. The olds stuff remains, mostly due to a number of tenacious defenders, because detailed investigation is no longer possible and because most people do not care. Its a new time, with new investigation standards.


Define good. Good like the kaiju yeti costume? Good like the kaiju king kong costume? Good like one of the vintage gorilla costumes we posted pics of?

Why there are no credible bigfoot fakes? There are two main reasons, I think.
No market for them is the main cause. Actually I think there are several gorilla (and other hominid) costumes which would be as good as and even better than Patty. Again, no one bothers making a second PGF because nowadays its not worth the effort.

The second part of the equation is the iconic level that Patty reached among some people. Nothing will, in their minds, be better than Patty. Not even Patty itself, as Dfoot's photoshop job indicated. Not even a state-of-the-art costume, as one can see from the statements from many a footer when they declare that certain post- (as well as sin- and pre-) PGF costumes are not as realistic as Patty.
I don't call what I wrote above "answers". They are educated guesses.



Fast and easy? A couple of weeks worth of evenings and weekends. 6 months I don't consider fast and easy.

Good? Apes in 2001, PGF itself, Good would be a suit that could be photographed in good lighting, natural daylight in an unobstructed view for a period at least the PGF. For example the Messin With Bigfoot/Saquatach commercials are a reasonable quality although because of the spoof nature of the commercials the Sasquatach may be something of a characertized image.

By knee deep I mean within the confines of the overall community that pays attention to the issue, including pro and con. Obviously non interested parties aren't going to make a hoax since most uninterested don't even know what Sasquatach is anymore.

No good hoaxes because its not worth the effort to make a good hoax implys that it does then take time, money and effort to make a great or even good hoax. If great hoaxes could be cranked out we'd have guys like Butchie The Kid from Youtube making good hoaxes instead of the dribble he does.

In this day and age when a person's 15 minutes of fame can be a lucrative 15 minutes a great hoax could reward the hoaxer better than Patterson manged. There's always a market anything can be marketed if youknow how to market it.
 
Crowlogic:



Correa Neto is dead-on about the PGF (and other old "evidence") being touted as a mystery for so long due to tenacious believers. I think that if the internet existed back then, the PGF would've been ripped apart pretty quickly. And let's not forget that "Surgeon's Photograph" example I gave awhile back about a hoax "being a mystery for decades." As for the page count, let's not forget that a good chunk of that was devoted to off-topic subjects and repetitions of the same arguments.



I think it all depends on a person's personal definition of cheapness and ease. If Dfoot's theory about it being mostly made of repurposed Star Trek costume parts is correct, then there's a very good reason why nobody else has made another Patty.

...


The "Surgeon's Photograph" took a confession to put it to bed once and for all. Dfoot's Star Trek costume parts is not out of the question which lends the professional touch to the PGF suit. The Star Trek stuff was made before the PGF. We never saw Patty again because lightning striking twice may have left Patterson burned.
 
Crowlogic said:
Fast and easy? A couple of weeks worth of evenings and weekends. 6 months I don't consider fast and easy.
What you consider as hard may not be hard for others. Spending a couple of weekends and evenings through six months or more, for example, is easy for me. What else, in terms of time, would P&G need? Buy or rent the costume, modify it personally or on demand. No big deal; not much time is spent. While awaiting the costume to be finished, you can plan the hoax while drinking beer at a local pub. A couple of weekends or evenings will later be spent making test runs at someones backyard after the costume arrived. Then its time to go to the final film location, shoot several sequences (of the costume in action as well as some extra material such as riding horses) - four days should do it- and develop the film. Now, choose the sequence with the best bigfoot performance, return to the field, plant additional evidence (footprints) and call the suckers target audience.

Crowlogic said:
Good? Apes in 2001, PGF itself, Good would be a suit that could be photographed in good lighting, natural daylight in an unobstructed view for a period at least the PGF. For example the Messin With Bigfoot/Saquatach commercials are a reasonable quality although because of the spoof nature of the commercials the Sasquatach may be something of a characertized image.
Most costumes we presented here were filmed at better conditions and for longer time than PGF. That's one of the reasons why people see their flaws and don't see flaws in Patty. I think that if the Patty costume, filmed under the same conditions (and during the same time interval) of the movies we talked about, it would really suck. Suck at least as much as the kaiju King Kong and probably even more.
Now, I agree regarding the "characterized image"; this makes the fakery being easier to spot. A big mistake is made by many a PGF defender when they compare Harry with Patty. Harry was designed to be a funny figure. But I suspect that even Harry, under PGF circumstances, would perform better than Patty.

Crowlogic said:
By knee deep I mean within the confines of the overall community that pays attention to the issue, including pro and con. Obviously non interested parties aren't going to make a hoax since most uninterested don't even know what Sasquatach is anymore.
Actually, within the bigfoot community (skeptics included) there are hoaxes being performed every now and then. Biscardi is an example of what I would call a professional hoaxer; I suspect many "sightings" at BFRO expedition$ are also hoaxes. Let’s not forget the people who keep claiming to have astounding pics (creekfreak comes to mind) and those who claim to have "habituated" bigfeet. With so much competition (even if lousy ones) and with such a small target audience… No wonder there are no PGFs around.

Crowlogic said:
No good hoaxes because its not worth the effort to make a good hoax implys that it does then take time, money and effort to make a great or even good hoax. If great hoaxes could be cranked out we'd have guys like Butchie The Kid from Youtube making good hoaxes instead of the dribble he does.
Everything requires a certain ammount of investment. I think the reason why there are no more good bigfoot hoaxes (as well as UFOs, for example) is that the cost/benefit ratio is unfavorable. Nowadays it’s easier to investigate and the audience is more demanding, less naïve, specially after all the hoaxes that were previously made. Back in the 60s there was more room for bigfoot; today, the gap where bigfeet could live is just too small. A PGF-like hoax nowadays would be exposed very quickly. To accomplish what PGF accomplished nowadays would require much more investment.

Crowlogic said:
In this day and age when a person's 15 minutes of fame can be a lucrative 15 minutes a great hoax could reward the hoaxer better than Patterson manged. There's always a market anything can be marketed if youknow how to market it.
But there are people looking for these 15 minutes. The problem is that most of these people know that the pieces of evidence they can present will be subject to close scrutiny- that's the reason for the "pay first see later" conditions. They also know that there will always be someone eager to give them attention, hoping that at last the day of the revelation has come. A few may be just deluded people, who actually believe in their fairy tales of bigfoot habituation or blobfoots caught on pics. At youtube, most of the people you'll get will be those who make very cheap pranks just for fun.
Attention whores, scammers and deluded people that's what you'll find at the other end of the sort of "evidence pieces" we are talking about... Higher level scammers will target better audiences, with more money to drain and less chances of being caught. They will become tele evangelists or Sylvia Browne-like mediums, for example.
 
Kudos to Bill for making his website more cut and paste friendly!

http://www.billmunnscreaturegallery.com/bmcgsite_068.htm
Bill Munns said:
A Classic Example of Flawed Skeptical Logic

As I have noted here, some people who consider themselves skeptical of the PG Film have polarized against me because I have not offered any conclusion that fits their foregone conclusion arguing the film was hoaxed. And I noted in another commentary that one of my primary reasons for doubting the skeptical reasoning for their analysis of the hoax idea is that I have seen first hand their flawed reasoning about me and my intentions and actions. So I know with certainty that they fail to see clearly or fairly what I'm doing, and so I must consider that their flawed logic, driven by a forgone suspicious conclusion, may render their "hoax" theories equally flawed and potentially false.

The reaction of some skeptical people to elements of my website has essentially proven their failure to think critically and fairly, and shown they will choose a suspicious conclusion that satisfies their forgone preferred conclusion even if it is not true.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom