Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, I've been following the slow decent of MK Davis' theories into abject madness...

At this point I suspect that Davis has "crossed the line" even with die-hard Patty believers, as he committed the Mortal Sin of calling Bob Gimlin's character into question. Looks like Davis got the boot from the line-up of a forthcoming Bigfoot conference. I think Davis has a few die-hard sycophants who believe his nonsense, but at this point I think his social status in Bigfootery falls somewhere between Matt Moneymaker and Eric Beckjord.

Davis took his "fan fiction" just a little too far...
 
From the link:

Just when you thought the “Bigfoot Massacre” theory was getting rather wild, now comes word that Florida’s Scott Marlowe has sent a letter to the District Attorney in Humboldt County, California, “pursuant to an investigation of M. K. Davis’ ‘revelations’ about the Patterson-Gimlin ‘Bigfoot’ film.”
Marlowe writes:

I would suggest that it would be prudent for your office to initiate an investigation into this matter in order to ascertain the actual facts surrounding this event and determine if criminal prosecution proceedings should be initiated.
We'll get right on that.

And for the Gimlin defense team...

 
Cryptomundo & Bill Munns

FYI,

Our buddy Bill is mentioned on a June 17 posting on Cryptomundo in a thread titled "What is Bigfoot?".

According to Loren Coleman Bill rules out Giganto and states:

Munns has written: “If we were to apply Ockham’s Razor to the question of Patty’s fossil heritage, the solution with the least complicated conditions would actually be Zinj.”

And I thought Bill was objectively reviewing the PGF and had an open mind on if it was a real critter or BH in a suit? :D
 
Clayflingythingy:

"According to Loren Coleman Bill rules out Giganto and states:

Munns has written: “If we were to apply Ockham’s Razor to the question of Patty’s fossil heritage, the solution with the least complicated conditions would actually be Zinj.”

And I thought Bill was objectively reviewing the PGF and had an open mind on if it was a real critter or BH in a suit?"


Actually, what Cryptomundo reported is taken from something I prepared over three months ago for a radio interview, speculating A. "If Patty's a suit" and B "If patty's real", and the chart comparing potential fossil ancestors is part of the "B If Patty's real" option.

I am still objectively reviewing the PG Film, and still have not offered any conclusion if it's real or a suit. But just as people are entitled to speculate that if it's a suit, is Bob H. wearing it, people can speculate that if Patty's real, what known fossil primate may be a likely ancestor. Both are speculation in one form or another.

We can speculate about both alternate ideas.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Noticed recently that PGF skeptics are no longer at the APEX of Pattyphile's Scorn pyramid. Starting from the top and going down 5 levels of scorn.

APEX being highest level of Scorn
5th Level being lowest level of Scorn

APEX- Those who believe Patty was part of a Massacre
2nd Level- Those who believe Patty is an Interdimensional Traveller
3rd Level- Those who Belive Patty is a guy in a suit and Bigfoot is not a real creature
4th Level- Those who Believe Patty is a guy in a suit and Believe Bigfoot is a real creature
5th Level- Those who Believe Patty and Bigfoot are real creatures

 
Last edited:
Clayflingythingy:

"According to Loren Coleman Bill rules out Giganto and states:

Munns has written: “If we were to apply Ockham’s Razor to the question of Patty’s fossil heritage, the solution with the least complicated conditions would actually be Zinj.”

And I thought Bill was objectively reviewing the PGF and had an open mind on if it was a real critter or BH in a suit?"


Actually, what Cryptomundo reported is taken from something I prepared over three months ago for a radio interview, speculating A. "If Patty's a suit" and B "If patty's real", and the chart comparing potential fossil ancestors is part of the "B If Patty's real" option.

I am still objectively reviewing the PG Film, and still have not offered any conclusion if it's real or a suit.

I think that posting what you just said in the comments for that Cryptomundo entry would decrease the liklihood of this sort of confusion from happening again. If you ask, you might be able to get Loren Coleman to post that into the body of the article itself so that it would be more likely to be seen by readers than it would in the comments section.
 
News for the Bigfooter Nation: One Hollywood costume guy has spent over six months examining and evaluating the PGF and still hasn't arrived at any sort of conclusion on whether it shows somebody in a costume or an unclassified wild primate.

Boredom has set in. I predict that Bill will never come to any conclusion other than "undetermined". That will work out just fine for the Patty believers.
 
Bill Munns on Cryptomundo said:
Something to keep in mind: Aside from the fact that my reconstructions are quite speculative in the soft tissue aspects (as any reconstruction is), they represent figures that existed over a million years ago, and if any is in fact related to something alive today, that million years (plus) time gap would be expected to cause them to have evolved into a different form today. So the real comparison was more to say, how much evolution might be needed to get from one of them to what people see and report today? Then see which evolutionary path seems the least complicated (invoking Ockams’s Razor).

Really, if Bigfoot is not a mythical creature then proposing that it is closely related to Homo is less complicated than any other prehistoric hominoid ancestry. Why? Because it is already an established fact that Homo made it to North America.

Why is Paranthropus boisei (Zinj) a favored ancestor choice, instead of simply picking one of the Australopithecus or Homo spp.?
 
WP:

"Why is Paranthropus boisei (Zinj) a favored ancestor choice, instead of simply picking one of the Australopithecus or Homo spp.? "

My though was simply that the enlarged and dome-shaped (rounded) braincase of the later Homo species wasn't as consistant with the head shape I perceived in the PG Film as the Zinj head and braincase.

:)

As for my remaining "undecided" or my analysis still "undetermined", yes, that's the current status. But good science is patient, and sometimes resolving a mystery or controversy takes more time than we wish. And rushing to a false or unsupported conclusion just to appease others is not good science.


So I'm just working it through, as my resources permit, and we'll see where it goes.

Bill
 
Last edited:
It's too bad that the coelacanth doesn't have a domed head as that would make it a nice and simple choice for you to designate it a likely ancestor of Paranthropus.

Do any hominoid fossils from Asia strike your fancy as being of the Bigfoot lineage? Or, is P. boisei the only physical evidence for Bigfoot?
 
WP:

"It's too bad that the coelacanth doesn't have a domed head as that would make it a nice and simple choice for you to designate it a likely ancestor of Paranthropus. "

?

"Do any hominoid fossils from Asia strike your fancy as being of the Bigfoot lineage? Or, is P. boisei the only physical evidence for Bigfoot?"

None of the known fossil hominids are physical evidence for bigfoot, as far as I know. They are physical evidence for themselves. Ancestral links to Bigfoot are purely speculative, which is okay as long as labeled as such.

As pure speculation, no, none of the asian hominid fossils strike my fancy.

Bill
 
News for the Bigfooter Nation: One Hollywood costume guy has spent over six months examining and evaluating the PGF and still hasn't arrived at any sort of conclusion on whether it shows somebody in a costume or an unclassified wild primate.

Boredom has set in. I predict that Bill will never come to any conclusion other than "undetermined". That will work out just fine for the Patty believers.

Bill seems to be experiencing the problem of all new prophets, how to keep the followers interested.
 
TSIG:

"Bill seems to be experiencing the problem of all new prophets, how to keep the followers interested. "


Actually I've been trying to figure out how to get the skeptics less interested, but it's apparently not working.
 
TSIG:

"Bill seems to be experiencing the problem of all new prophets, how to keep the followers interested. "


Actually I've been trying to figure out how to get the skeptics less interested, but it's apparently not working.

Why do you want the skeptics less interested?

If you are interested in discovering the truth don't you want to hear opinions from all concerned?:boggled:
 
GT/CS:

"Why do you want the skeptics less interested?"

Because too many of them are delusional and have no sense of humor. They keep obcessing about "prophets", "Sheeple" and the like and fail to see that my work is in material substances, plain old boring things like furcloth, latex masks, and foam padding.



"If you are interested in discovering the truth don't you want to hear opinions from all concerned?"


Gotta seperate the wheat from the chaff, intellectually.

:)

Bill
 
GT/CS:

"Why do you want the skeptics less interested?"

Because too many of them are delusional and have no sense of humor. They keep obcessing about "prophets", "Sheeple" and the like and fail to see that my work is in material substances, plain old boring things like furcloth, latex masks, and foam padding.



"If you are interested in discovering the truth don't you want to hear opinions from all concerned?"


Gotta seperate the wheat from the chaff, intellectually.

:)

Bill

Thank you for those revealing responses.
 
To All:

It seems like every time this forum thread starts to get its focus back on the PG Film and the issues specific to that topic, somebody gets concerned about the fact that I exist and somebody wrote something about me.

So I'm going to give it one more shot, hopefully appealing to anyone in this forum who is actually interested in discussions that lead to a mutual and better understanding of the issues and situation.

First, this is what I believe:

1. I do believe there are species of wildlife existing that we have not yet found or documented scientifically, and that continuing searches for such unknown species is a valid endeavor, a respectful avenue of scientific exploration.

2. I acknowledge that finding larger unknown species (such as a large cryptid North American Primate) is far less likely than finding species like new frogs, birds, and sea life, but however remote the possiblilty, we should not close our minds to the possiblilty.

3. I have looked at the Patterson Gimlin film now for 6 months and listened to the arguments for it's authenticity and against same, arguments that the figure seen in the film (and known as "Patty") is a real creature and arguments that the figure in the film is a human in a fur costume. I have applied my knowledge and experience in making fur suits and costumes from the film industry to that analysis. My position, my appraisal of this film's subject figure, is that I am truly mystified by this film and its figure. I cannot simply dismiss it as a "cheap suit" as some people in the film industry do, yet I cannot say with conclusive confidence that it is a real creature. I do not believe that any explanation so far offered by other people explains this figure to my satisfaction, and most explanations of it as a fur suit worn by a human I find lacking in credability based on my experience with the subject (fur suits and costumes).

4. I also believe research needs to be done on the issue of how much detail can, in fact, be extracted from the film's resolution, and that research, if done, I believe would bring new data to the discussion for everyone's benefit.

That's the truth, and about as plain as I can say it. If anybody thinks those are the words of a "prophet", or a rallying cry to inspire groupies, you seriously need a reality check.

I will be pleased to discuss the topic (the film), with any rational people, and I am very interested in different, even opposing opinions, if you can simply keep the focus on the ideas, and construct a logical argument.

The ball's in your court, fellow forum members. Can we have an intelligent discussion of the film and the issues related to it? I'm willing to try if you are.

ps: The above four items are part of a statement of intent I will be putting up on a website that opens in a week or two, a gallery of my experience as an artist making creatures for Hollywood, museums, scientific displays, and wildlife art. My recent studies of Patty will be mentioned.

Bill Munns
 
1 and 2 do not relate to 3 and 4. And I really think 4 is useless. "What is the goal" you have to ask yourself.

Is the goal proving that there is an unknown hominid roaming in remote corner of the US ? Then a film analysis is the wrong way to go. What is needed is real evidence, like blood, corpse, skeleton, etc... Which all require somebody to roam where Bigfoot is seen and search for the aforementioned (I won't go into the debate that BF believer never seem to do that, and seem to shy away from doing a real search for BF).

Is the goal to prove that the film is not one of a costume ? You will never ever be able to prove that. There is not enough information simply to what we have available to draw a 100% conclusion. And I don't see anyway the interest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom