Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tube:

"Bill Munns:

I see on TV that a new season of Monsterquest is forthcoming. Were you involved in any of the episodes? Have you been approached by Whitewolf Entertainment?"


No, no one from that program, or any other similar program, has contacted me thus far.

Bill
 
To All:


Obviously, as I hope all here can appreciate, I do not like being accused of being a fraud, and I expect anyone else here would similarly be resentful if another person accused them of being such.

But please, let's examine this simply from the standpoint of a critical thinker, setting aside the emotionalism of the issue.

Fraud is defined (in my Random House dictionary) as "deceit or trickery used to gain unfair or dishonest advantage".


1. Where is my proven deceit? Have I lied about my resume? Have I lied about materials and their properties? People have challenged me as to my "intent" but those who do feel I am deceitful in my intent have only their "inference", their opinion that my intent is other than what I state. Inferences and opinions aren't proof. So where is the proof of deceit?

2. "Gain" What have I gained? Some say fame, but I have been famous for the Giganto figure for about 15 years. I was somewhat "famous" as a makeup artist in the 80's from my work on Swamp thing and a few other films (and famous for my being fired from Return of the Living Dead, as others here love to keep bringing up). I was famous in the world of taxidermy for my two wins as "Best in World Recreation" in 1988 ans 1992, and for years after for my published articles in Breakthrough Magazine. I was famous in a way within the digital arts community from 1998 to 2002 for my Bryce 3D digital imagery (which included my work being named a milestone in computer graphics by Computer Graphis World Magazine, in their 2002 retrospective of computer graphics achievements.

So I've been "sort of famous" four times for varied accomplishments, and whatever "fame" I may seem to be gaining now because of my notes on the PG Film, I have equally gained the anomoisity and bitter resentment of skeptical people. I have more people now actively trying to discredit me than ever before in my career, hardly the kind of gain one wants or seeks.

So where's the "gain"

3. "Unfair or dishonest advantage" What "advantage" have I obtained or received? Certainly no money, not even any talk of receiving any. I still work and if someone commissions me to do some work, any issue of fraud is between me and the person I work for, if that person found my work delivered to be something other than what I promised to accomplish, but such isn not the case.

Am I taking advantage of anyone here in this forum? Am I asking of any of you that you buy something from me? There is no advantage in a forum where ideas are exchanged, and my singular relationship with you all is simply an exchange of ideas and information.

4. Fraud generally requires a victim, someone who has lost something of value to the one perpetrating the fraud. All I have heard thus far is a vague concern for "sheeple" unnamed, unidentified, and the assumption they will lose something if they feed on my words?

So I ask, who are the victims of the fraud I am accused of? What have they lost? And if they choose to believe in bigfoot, why do you feel you must tell them what they should think? Wouldn't you resent some person simply deciding to take over your life and dictate to you what you may or may not think?


Finally, if I do accomplish some research experiemnts on the issues I talk about, and then did publish or publicly release that research information, at that time it may be evaluated by one and all, and criticized by any who find it flawed, and I could be accused of fraud if I were proven to have falsified any data or misrepresented conclusions, but none of that has happened yet.

Where is the deceit? Where is the gain? Where is the advantage? Where is the fraud?

Bill

Well Bill, you show one face to the BFF forum and another one here. Where is the true Bill?
 
tsig:

I offer the same facts and information in my comments on both sites. If I react differently as a person here compared to there, it's because people here treat me differently than there, and any human does express ideas and feelings in relation to the people they are interacting with.

Bill
 
tsig:

I offer the same facts and information in my comments on both sites. If I react differently as a person here compared to there, it's because people here treat me differently than there, and any human does express ideas and feelings in relation to the people they are interacting with.

Bill

Thank you for proving my theory.
 
Please tell me that was a parody. Something messes with the tent 6 times at 15 minute intervals and all they do is shine a light at it to scare it away??? Redneck research at its best!

Something threw pine cones at me .

Something threw rocks into the - stream, river - whatever - I heard a splash .

I smelled something awful .

I heard bipedal footfalls .

I heard an inhuman scream .

I found a broken sapling .

What on earth could it possibly have been besides a Bigfoot ?
 
Something threw pine cones at me .

Something threw rocks into the - stream, river - whatever - I heard a splash .

I smelled something awful .

I heard bipedal footfalls .

I heard an inhuman scream .

I found a broken sapling .

What on earth could it possibly have been besides a Bigfoot ?

Lets see what could it be?

Smelled something awfull-- A garbage truck
Bipedal footfalls---- T Rex
Broken sapling--- T Rex again
Inhuman scream--- Big Bird
Throwing pine cones---No brainer only human children throw pinecones
Throwing rocks--- I dunno depends where the rocks were thrown in relation
to any glass houses.
 
WP, that was a lot of good info in those last few posts. MK Davis has gone off the deep end, imo.

http://40thanniversaryofpatty.blogspot.com/2008/05/review-of-mk-davis-presentation-of-pg.html

Is it just me, or does this frame appear to show Patty much closer to the creek than I ever saw her before? I think I see Patty's legs appearing much larger than ever before.

fefbfc21.jpg
 
A wound is visible on Patty's right thigh, Davis said, and she can be seen digging a small trench by dragging a foot through the sandy soil.

Davis addressed a "bloody pool" seen in some frames. The area was frequented by logging crews, and he suggested that the pool was a hole -- pointing out apparent tool marks along one edge -- filled with an unknown red fluid. While pursuing the creature with camera in hand Patterson reportedly stepped into the hole but continued to film.

http://www.daily-jeff.com/news/article/3816121
 
http://www.cryptomundo.com/cryptozoo-news/hernia-bf/

Interesting cryptomundo coverage. Be sure to check out these links:

http://www.cryptomundo.com/cryptozoo-news/bf-massacre/

http://www.cryptomundo.com/cryptozoo-news/bf-incident/

...

Davis, myself and Scott Marlowe had almost simultaneously come to the conclusion that there had been much more than met the eye going on in the film. There was the nagging “hernia” that seemed evident on Patty’s thigh. There was also evidence of a red stain on one of her feet and some reddish tracks she left in her path. This led all of us to the conclusion that she had been shot. It is common knowledge that Gimlin sold the rifle, a 30-06, some time shortly after the encounter, and has expressed some signs of remorse telling M.K. that (paraphrased) “If I had it to do over again I would have put the gun down and tried to talk to her”.

One doesn’t attempt to talk to an ape. To further corroborate the evidence that the hernia was an exit wound, Patty appears at one point to stumble, nearly lose her balance and regain a somewhat altered gait just prior to the appearance of the leg injury. But, the evidence of possible blood in a pool of water didn’t fit with the scenario that she might have been cleansing the wound, as this occurred in the film prior to the alleged shooting.

...

According my direct conversation with M.K., the meeting with Patterson yielded new, 4×5 inch copies of certain frame transparencies that included the pool of reddish water. These had to have been made for good reason, in my opinion. Apparently, Patterson had been looking to see what, if any detail showed up in those frames, which, again in my opinion, was supportive of the newest theory Davis had formed.

...
According to the theory, the Patterson Gimlin Film, as we know it, wasn’t made on the first visit to the site. There had been another one, possibly one to several days before. On that visit, Davis theorized that Patterson and Gimlin (possibly others) had surprised a group of Patty’s clan and that the clan summarily attacked them, unprovoked. What ensued was not a massacre as it is generally thought that a massacre is a vindictive action by one group or individual against another group. His theory suggests that, if Patterson and Gimlin had not shot and killed their attackers, they themselves would have been killed…a real possibility. Self defense. But when they got up close to the bodies, they realized what they had shot were, in fact, more human like than ape like. So, the decision was to bury the bodies. It was verified by individuals that M.K. had interviewed over the years that Roger Patterson had obtained a backhoe to extricate his truck from the sand and mire of the service road leading to the site. Yet, pictures of Patterson’s vehicle show a two or three ton flatbed, outweighing a backhoe by many times. And, Patterson’s brother in law (unsure of which side of the family) allegedly owned a paving business, so he would have had access to the backhoe without rental records. I first suggested, after hearing of Patterson’s comment about the backhoe, that he and Gimlin might have killed Patty and buried her. But, after finding the evidence of the reddish water Davis took it one step further.

So, after Patterson and Gimlin had done the deed, and realized that something wasn’t kosher, they obtained the backhoe, buried the bodies and left the scene. But, in an effort to either actually capture one on film, or check the status of the alleged burial site, Patterson and Gimlin returned to Bluff Creek. Davis theorizes that what they found was Patty, bent over the burial site, trying to dig up the bodies. The ground is only so deep at the creek, allowing ground water to seep into any excavation made. So, it fits the theory that, if such an excavation was made, having been disturbed by Patty’s digging, the resulting water in the excavation would be colored by the blood coming from whatever was buried there. After being attacked by the group previously it is theorized that whoever was with Patterson that day was with him the day of the attack and opened fire on Patty, scaring her from the water and wounding her in the thigh as she fled. Let me point out that there may have been more individuals with Patterson than just Gimlin, but conjecture as to who will just lead us all down that same old path of uncertainty and speculation, one that I personally have had my fill of.

...
 
Last edited:
1. Davis could use sonar to locate the bodies, even now. Although he probably could go there based on the location of the mounds in the film, and just dig them up.

2. Note: "They were close to being human so they buried them" to support his 'Braided Indian' theory.

3. Wait, I thought no human in a costume could navigate that treacherous terrain without falling and tripping, And then I read this?
"Patty appears at one point to stumble, nearly lose her balance and regain a somewhat altered gait just prior to the appearance of the leg injury. "
WTF?
 
Maybe not.

Mountain river beds can change a bit. I would never bury a body at a river bed (at least not one like that). If the bodies were buried at a river bar, they may have been exposed and washed away. Of course, chances are someone down river (or at the eroding sand bar) could find pieces of the corpses or human-like bones.

Another possibility is that new sediment layers could be deposited over the burial site.

Aniway, the whole story stinks, and its not the stench of decomposing bigfoot bodies.

BTW, anyone knows about the reaction of Patterson's wife to this new fairy tale?
 
WP, that was a lot of good info in those last few posts. MK Davis has gone off the deep end, imo.

Is it just me, or does this frame appear to show Patty much closer to the creek than I ever saw her before? I think I see Patty's legs appearing much larger than ever before.

I agree and I even wrote a few sentences about her seeming to be closer. But I deleted that from my post because I wasn't so confident. I even thought we might be seeing more of the creek (at the bottom of the frame) than before. But that turns out to be a black photo print margin.

If this is a full frame image (rather than cropped and enlarged), then it may very well represent something not seen in the common PGF copy. It could be that Patterson removed (edited) some Patty footage that comes before what we "think" is the very first frame of the encounter.

Putting aside the ridiculousness of his new theories, Davis is very wrong to say that the flowing creek is a pool of blood. This is a fundamental error, as the Titmus map (bad as it is) does show the creek in that spot. Even if you have never seen that map, you can see that this is the flowing creek when you watch the PGF. Where does Davis think the creek is located?
 
1. There was a park ranger who was out there, I thought he stopped by the day after the filming, wouldn't he have seen teh pool of blood?
2. Why bother taking casts and calling in the BC Hounds, and calling people? If there was a Murder at Bluff Creek, wouldn't they just pack it up and leave? Or Patterson could have built a big fire and just burned them. Why go get a piece of Heavy Machinery, risk it sinking in the sand, to bury them in a Freaking flood plain? When he could just burn them?
3. Was MK Davis the guy who thought it was a 'Digger Indian' with a bone braid?
If true, wouldn't the indian know enough about getting shot at to try and high tail it out of there?

This might be an unseen still from Patty Patterson's collection.
Perhaps Roger had cut sections of the film turned into stills, and Pat has them laying around somewhere.
 
Last edited:
Remember, many bigfoot investigators do not follow conventional ways.

"Bigfoot just passed here, look at the half-eaten fruit and the bigfoot lay"
"OK, let's go home"

"Bigfoot is throwing pigs rocks and pines at our shack"
"OK, time to go home"
 
The "Davis Arrows Frame" represents a cropped and enlarged frame from the first few seconds of the PGF. This was probably done by him, rather than being provided as is from Patricia Patterson. She may have given him a full frame photo print of this, then he scanned, cropped and enlarged it.

I have no way to extract frames from clips, but I believe the Davis Arrows Frame could possibly be found in this NG clip at around 1:49. Patty appears to be in stride with her legs apart.

This clip from Green's PGF copy would show this frame at about 0:21. But guess what... it's a flipped scene!


Here is a full frame (not the same as Davis' frame, but very close) showing what I think represents the cropping that Davis did...

82d3013d.jpg

fefbfc21.jpg
 
Please look at my comparison above, Patty is standing in a hole or a creekbed, and then steps up. You are looking at it's knees not it's feet
 
Laverty and crew were there a couple days after the supposed filming date of the PGF. How that relates to the time of the "massacree" is anyone's guess.

Laverty and crew should certainly have noticed backhoe sign and dead body sign, as should Titmus.

If we can see Patty tracks in the PGF, then where are the backhoe signs?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom