...
Davis, myself and Scott Marlowe had almost simultaneously come to the conclusion that there had been much more than met the eye going on in the film. There was the nagging “hernia” that seemed evident on Patty’s thigh. There was also evidence of a red stain on one of her feet and some reddish tracks she left in her path. This led all of us to the conclusion that she had been shot. It is common knowledge that Gimlin sold the rifle, a 30-06, some time shortly after the encounter, and has expressed some signs of remorse telling M.K. that (paraphrased) “If I had it to do over again I would have put the gun down and tried to talk to her”.
One doesn’t attempt to talk to an ape. To further corroborate the evidence that the hernia was an exit wound, Patty appears at one point to stumble, nearly lose her balance and regain a somewhat altered gait just prior to the appearance of the leg injury. But, the evidence of possible blood in a pool of water didn’t fit with the scenario that she might have been cleansing the wound, as this occurred in the film prior to the alleged shooting.
...
According my direct conversation with M.K., the meeting with Patterson yielded new, 4×5 inch copies of certain frame transparencies that included the pool of reddish water. These had to have been made for good reason, in my opinion. Apparently, Patterson had been looking to see what, if any detail showed up in those frames, which, again in my opinion, was supportive of the newest theory Davis had formed.
...
According to the theory, the Patterson Gimlin Film, as we know it, wasn’t made on the first visit to the site. There had been another one, possibly one to several days before. On that visit, Davis theorized that Patterson and Gimlin (possibly others) had surprised a group of Patty’s clan and that the clan summarily attacked them, unprovoked. What ensued was not a massacre as it is generally thought that a massacre is a vindictive action by one group or individual against another group. His theory suggests that, if Patterson and Gimlin had not shot and killed their attackers, they themselves would have been killed…a real possibility. Self defense. But when they got up close to the bodies, they realized what they had shot were, in fact, more human like than ape like. So, the decision was to bury the bodies. It was verified by individuals that M.K. had interviewed over the years that Roger Patterson had obtained a backhoe to extricate his truck from the sand and mire of the service road leading to the site. Yet, pictures of Patterson’s vehicle show a two or three ton flatbed, outweighing a backhoe by many times. And, Patterson’s brother in law (unsure of which side of the family) allegedly owned a paving business, so he would have had access to the backhoe without rental records. I first suggested, after hearing of Patterson’s comment about the backhoe, that he and Gimlin might have killed Patty and buried her. But, after finding the evidence of the reddish water Davis took it one step further.
So, after Patterson and Gimlin had done the deed, and realized that something wasn’t kosher, they obtained the backhoe, buried the bodies and left the scene. But, in an effort to either actually capture one on film, or check the status of the alleged burial site, Patterson and Gimlin returned to Bluff Creek. Davis theorizes that what they found was Patty, bent over the burial site, trying to dig up the bodies. The ground is only so deep at the creek, allowing ground water to seep into any excavation made. So, it fits the theory that, if such an excavation was made, having been disturbed by Patty’s digging, the resulting water in the excavation would be colored by the blood coming from whatever was buried there. After being attacked by the group previously it is theorized that whoever was with Patterson that day was with him the day of the attack and opened fire on Patty, scaring her from the water and wounding her in the thigh as she fled. Let me point out that there may have been more individuals with Patterson than just Gimlin, but conjecture as to who will just lead us all down that same old path of uncertainty and speculation, one that I personally have had my fill of.
...