Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Diogenes:

"I'm confused.
You have a problem with a real animal pelt as a covering for a real animal ?"


Not at all. I am referring to a tanned hide of a former real animal that is no longer living tissue and used a fur for something a person fabricates. When it was living tissue on the real animal, it had splendid elasticity.

"I's funny how that works.. When I have pointed problems with the musculature on the subject, the argument was it must be long hair giving an unnatural look . Where do you think the musculature looks normal; showing through what must be short hair ?"

I personally have not said or thought "it must be long hair giving it an unnatural look". So i can only suggest you approach whoever offered that argument. I certainly wouldn't agree with the quote. I don't see what I would classify "long hair"

Remember I said "musculature or soft tissue deposits" and I tend to see what I feel is more of the second, less of the first. But it can be simplified as seeing "flesh tissue" (which would include both muscle and soft tissue) as opposed to fur and light artifacts caused by light reflected off the hair.

Bill
 
Well, if a claim is going to be made that Patty's hair is too short, too short to hide seams and zippers for example, there must be a way of determining this with some accuracy for the claim to be valid.

I see no way to determine this from the film.

Claims of seeing muscle movement are dubious at best, and even if we allow that, you can see muscle movement on animals with hair long enough to hide a zipper or a seam.

LTC it's not my Gorilla my Condo won't allow pets that big. But that's a photo of a Silverback Male. I personally think Patty looks too well groomed too even.
 
I personally think Patty looks too well groomed too even.

Well, bigfoot is almost human, maybe they brush their hair. :D

Speaking of hair, what a great opportunity the PGF encounter was to gather some of Patty's hair. 3-3.5 miles of following her through heavy woods, and no effort to collect any of the hairs she certainly left behind.
 
Diogenes:

"I'm confused.
You have a problem with a real animal pelt as a covering for a real animal ?"


Not at all. I am referring to a tanned hide of a former real animal that is no longer living tissue and used a fur for something a person fabricates. When it was living tissue on the real animal, it had splendid elasticity.
I don't believe you can show that live skin stretches . It has creases and folds where it needs to expand and contract.
A well tanned pelt can be more pliable than it ever was on a live animal ..

I personally have not said or thought "it must be long hair giving it an unnatural look". So i can only suggest you approach whoever offered that argument. I certainly wouldn't agree with the quote. I don't see what I would classify "long hair"

Remember I said "musculature or soft tissue deposits" and I tend to see what I feel is more of the second, less of the first. But it can be simplified as seeing "flesh tissue" (which would include both muscle and soft tissue) as opposed to fur and light artifacts caused by light reflected off the hair.

Bill
" Less of the first.." Means you see some..

Could you point some out to me ?
 
If i had a budget, I'd hire you to do my PR. You have provided the closest understanding of who I really am and what I'm doing, as well as how it sort of happened unplanned, I could hope to read from another person.

I really was beginning to wonder why I couldn't get anybody to see what I was saying. You give me hope.

You're quite welcome; thanks for the clarification. Please feel free to repost that summary on any other forums where you feel your notes/views are being misunderstood (although giving me some credit for the summarizing would be nice).

Also, I think I misspoke when I used the term "seam" in reference to the Gigasaurus costume. Since I'm not sure if the halves of the costume were actually connected, it's just as likely for the seperation between the two to have been an unconnected gap.
 
Diogenes

"I don't believe you can show that live skin stretches . It has creases and folds where it needs to expand and contract.
A well tanned pelt can be more pliable than it ever was on a live animal .."


You don't believe live skin stretches? Well, then I'll never convince you.

On the soft tissue thing, I know you're on the board where my notes are, and the Part 10 "Flab" has the illustrations where I think it indicates such. No need to repeat it here, without the images.

Bill
 
Last edited:
I don't believe you can show that live skin stretches . It has creases and folds where it needs to expand and contract.
A well tanned pelt can be more pliable than it ever was on a live animal ..


" Less of the first.." Means you see some..

Could you point some out to me ?

Grab the side of your cheek with your thumb and forefinger and pull. Skin strecthes and bounces back. Living skin is quite elastic.
 
Note: This was a post I was planning on doing before our recent explosion of posts. This has nothing to do with Bill Munns' work.

Back in this post by William Parcher, I was alerted to how Patty's feet looked rather fakey in a section of a Youtube video. After checking it out for myself, I was struck by how similar they looked to the feet used for the Morris suit. Since my ability to make images that don't look like complete crap is limited, I've decided to post some notes here in case others would like to have a crack at it. However, although I feel that they look very similar, there are factors (distance of subject from camera, what type of film was used, the amount of magnification done to each, Youtube compression, etc.) that could mean that the match isn't as close as I think it is.

First, here's the Patty video. The feet-related features I'm referring to show up at 01:30 - 01:33. Personally, I chose to hit pause at 01:32.

Here's a video (well, more of a looped series of semi-animated pictures) called "Bob Heironimus walking in a bigfoot suit." I chose to pause the video at 00:01.

Similarly, check out 00:02 in this video.

This video shows a TV news segment on the "recreation" that Philip Morris and Bob H. were involved in. You can see good views of how the costume feet look and the nature of their design at 00:40 and 01:31 of the video.

On an unrelated note, here's an interesting "arm demo" by Dfoot that I found. I've noticed a similar effect while testing those movements for myself in front of a large mirror.
 
Diogenes

"I don't believe you can show that live skin stretches . It has creases and folds where it needs to expand and contract.
A well tanned pelt can be more pliable than it ever was on a live animal .."


You don't believe live skin stretches? Well, then I'll never convince you.

On the soft tissue thing, I know you're on the board where my notes are, and the Part 10 "Flab" has the illustrations where I think it indicates such. No need to repeat it here, without the images.

Bill

I'm not asking about flab .

I'm asking about how real primate muscle structure appears when under skin.

I pointed out some problems in that thread, and you dodged it their also.
 
Diogenes:

"I pointed out some problems in that thread, and you dodged it their also."

I have tried to answer your questions as best I can. If my answers aren't to your satisfaction, maybe you should ask somebody else the question.

Now ask yourself, are you really just trying to get an answer, knowledge, because if so, you should go to others with your same questions and see if they can do better than I. But if you are simply testing my knowledge, I've given it my best shot, taken your test, so to speak, and you may grade the exam in your mind as you like.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Diogenes try this. Put you right hand down on a good hard table and with a hammer in your left hand give the thumb of your right hand a good stiff wack with the hammer. Then as you're jumping around screaming in pain take a look at you thumb. If you've done the deed correctly you'll notice that your thump is swelling up. As it swells the skin on the surface of your thumb is stretching to allow the injury process and body response to happen (fluids and all that). Now as your thumb heals you'll notice that the swelling goes down and eventually your thumb returns to normal. So your skin had to stretch during injury and retracts again. Skin is elastic.
 
Mr Munns, Bob Heironimus said that the suit he wore had three pieces, one, the legs and butt that he put on like a pair of pants, two the body that was one piece that had to be put over his head like a sweater and three the head that he thought was like a football helmet. Would this be consistent with suits made by Hollywood in the 60's?
 
Geno:

"Mr Munns, Bob Heironimus said that the suit he wore had three pieces, one, the legs and butt that he put on like a pair of pants, two the body that was one piece that had to be put over his head like a sweater and three the head that he thought was like a football helmet. Would this be consistent with suits made by Hollywood in the 60's?"

None that I am aware of. I have never heard of such a method, not ever seen such used, even outside Hollywood.
 
Geno:

"Mr Munns, Bob Heironimus said that the suit he wore had three pieces, one, the legs and butt that he put on like a pair of pants, two the body that was one piece that had to be put over his head like a sweater and three the head that he thought was like a football helmet. Would this be consistent with suits made by Hollywood in the 60's?"

None that I am aware of. I have never heard of such a method, not ever seen such used, even outside Hollywood.

Bill I think the idea of making suits that good should come with the warning "Kids don't try this at home".
 
I've taken the liberty of reading the first page of this thread and its interesting to see how the opinion of the early fence sitters has shifted into the negative now that its at page 314. But there are some good points brought up in that first page. One of which is the amount of film in the camera and the crummy camera work by Patterson. Here we have 3 guys out in the boonies lots of grub some good horses and a killer of a good monkey suit that's just itching to get some wear and tear. So what are you going to do? Are you going to dress up monkey man and have him strut his stuff one time while you do your best to make the camera look as if it was strapped around the neck of a St Banard that was shaking itself dry after a dip in the creek (Bluff Creek lol). In my opinon you'll make monkey man earn the money you've promised (even if you really aren't going to pay him) and you're going to try as many takes and locations as you can. A better film and more of it just may have gotten the official attention that Patterson was hoping to get. Had I bankrolled those boys and this is what they brought back I would have sent them back out to do a better job. That is assuming this is a hoax and could have been done over and over.
 
"Its head was very human, though considerably more slanted, and with a large forehead and wide nostrils. Its arms hung almost to its knees when it walked. Its hair was two to four inches long, brown underneath, lighter at the top, and covering the entire body except for the face. And it was a female; it had big, pendulous breasts."

Roger reiterates the 2 to 4 inches in 1969.

Now for Argosy in 1968, he said she was covered with short, shiny, black hair.

2 to 4 inches must have been "short" to Roger.

At any rate, he saw the creature live, and had much better resolution than we have looking at old films.


I'm not sure which frames I am about to reference, but they are your typical classic PGF shots. Some recently showing as .gifs as well I think? Anyway, in these frames as Patty stomps down with her right leg you can see the hair bounce up from the upper thigh. I watched it over and over, endlessly for a while.

Given how high you can see it bounce, I would say it definitely looks about 2-4 inches in length, no shorter.
 
I've taken the liberty of reading the first page of this thread and its interesting to see how the opinion of the early fence sitters has shifted into the negative now that its at page 314. But there are some good points brought up in that first page. One of which is the amount of film in the camera and the crummy camera work by Patterson. Here we have 3 guys out in the boonies lots of grub some good horses and a killer of a good monkey suit that's just itching to get some wear and tear. So what are you going to do? Are you going to dress up monkey man and have him strut his stuff one time while you do your best to make the camera look as if it was strapped around the neck of a St Banard that was shaking itself dry after a dip in the creek (Bluff Creek lol). In my opinon you'll make monkey man earn the money you've promised (even if you really aren't going to pay him) and you're going to try as many takes and locations as you can. A better film and more of it just may have gotten the official attention that Patterson was hoping to get. Had I bankrolled those boys and this is what they brought back I would have sent them back out to do a better job. That is assuming this is a hoax and could have been done over and over.

Unless Roger shot 200 feet of Bob clomping around in that silly suit and the ~60 seconds we see were the only bits that didn't look [even more] completely fake. That might even be why the rest of the footage was "lost."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom