Bill Munns said:
Thank you for the reference to the films and videos. I'll put them on the list of items I should examine and study.
You're quite welcome. Speaking of which, you might want to pick up a copy of the "Gorilla at Large" DVD. There are some points in the film where a seeming "buttcrack" appears when the person in the costume is in certian positions. I suspect that this is unintentional and due to how the suit was constructed, so it might tie in with your anaylsis of the fur.
On the leg thing, as I understood, proponents of "real" describe a herniated bulge or something like that. For the record, I don't susbscribe to such an analysis. I see anomolies in the right leg fur patterns, but I have not formed any conclusion yet.
I vaguely remember someone at the BFF making a movie file that they claimed showed that the bulge was a film anomoly. If that is the case, I feel that it raises a big question mark on other aspects of Patty (muscles, supposed breast movement, etc.) that appear in the film. I should note that I refer to the subject as Patty since I know that costumes can be given nicknames and it provides some common ground for proponents who visit.
The water bag thing is not something I've done personally. I just know it was done pre PG Film.
Ah. I actually found the episode of the Bigfoot podcast you were on today; I wish I had heard it before I had done that post, as it made your stance on waterbags and breasts more clear to me.
The word "ventilated" can have two meanings, and thus may cause confusion. In film terms it's hand tying hairs on to a fine lace mesh, like good men's toupees are made, with a fine needle like a chrochet hook, but much smaller.
Yep! That definition is the particular definition I was referring to.
For the breast comments, I described a generalized gel or fluid pouch to create the fluidity under the foam latex skin. In 1967, water would have been the most probable fluid, and the pouch could have been a condom or a party balloon. Low tech, but would work.
Ok. Personally, I don't think the breasts move much. This is based on a .gif posted in one of the Bigfoot threads here showing a sideways "breast twitch" or "shift" from the film. There was no jiggling or movement that I would associate with real breasts moving, but would seem to match up with the movement of false breasts attached to a costume. I've seen proponents note this irregular movement and argue that this instead shows that the breasts are in fact an infant clutching/climbing the front of Patty's chest. I hope that someone reading this can repost the "breast twitch" .gif, as I have long since forgotten its location.
The ice thing I never thought of, but for a Godzilla type suit (hollow actually, held up by suspenders, I believe) pouring ice into it might have worked fine.
I'm sure the men playing Godzilla would've appreciated people cooling the suits for them. The closest to that they got (in fact, this might only apply to actors who've worn the suit from the 80's through recent times) was when they filmed in air conditioned sets. I don't know if suspenders were used for the interiors of the full Godzilla suits, but (if I recall correctly), suspenders were used for a half suit used for the first Godzilla movie, for scenes where only Godzilla's feet where seen.
Since we're on the subject of cooling systems,
here's a reference to a rather unique one I found while digging around my notes for some links to use later in this post.
But for a form fitting padded movie suit of a primate, for example, the suit is too tight to pour anything into. But a Hudsen sprayer is pressurized, so it forces the water into the suit even when it's snug, especially if you use a long tubular spray wand.
Oh...I should clarify something I meant that bags of ice would be placed in the suit while the person wasn't inside it (like prior to the actor wearing it for filming) and not that ice would be poured inside while the actor was wearing it. You're correct that using ice definitely wouldn't work while someone was in the suit.
You're not being difficult on the "Hollywood Hoax" thing. I was being colorful in my phrasing, but actually trying to say you can have an elaborate hoax involving many skilled people, or a much more modest hoax of a few people doing a hoax on a whim, or any level of sophistication between. I try to stay out of estimating how simple or complex a hoax may have occurred if it did. Seems there are simply too many options to speculate upon.
Okay, thanks for the clarification.
On my analysis, and your respectful disagreement, if I start with a presumption I'm looking at a suit and then study if the materials can do the suit, haven't I already stipulated to "if it's a suit"? And if i stipulate that, then it seems to me that I don't need to study the particulars before or other peripheral elements of the scene and event. Respectfully, you lost me here.
The intention of something is always clear to the person who created it, but may not be that way to someone observing the work because they don't have access to the creator's thought process. Based on the large amount of people who are misinterpeting your writings, I'm thinking that's what's going on here (on all "sides" of the issue). To you, your intended meanings are crystal clear, but they aren't to many others. You might think that it's obvious that you are only focusing on materials/fur, but doing notes on your thought process on arms, feet, etc. and posting comments like
"I want to understand what's in the PG film. It mystifies me and I would like an answer. That is my goal, my ambition, my intention." can make it sound like you're taking a more general approach to the issue and seemingly contradicts comments you've made about a more specific focus.
Similarly, the notes you had regarding probabilities and comments that seemingly indicate that you're leaning towards the "it's not a suit explanation (Such as how, towards the end of "Let's Talk Bigfoot", you made a comment that could be taken as you saying that only some issue with the leg was keeping you from concluding that Patty was an animal). It's fairly common here (and other forums relating to cryptozoology and "the unexplained") to have people claim to not be believers/proponents and how they're merely on the fence/trying to find "what's behind the mystery" and then later launch into discussions on why such-and-such is real, so merely saying you don't have a specific conclusion or that you're on the fence isn't going to have the same effect as it would to a group of people with no interest in the subject.
Also, not responding to certain parts of a post could be interpreted as someone ducking or ignoring an issue. I don't see it that way, but I figured you might want to know that as you seem fairly new to the wacky world of internet discussion forums.
Yes, my study is certainly open to the possiblilty the filmed subject is a real bigfoot. But isn't everything you address here arguments for "real"? For a suit, the hair length is reasonable.
I agree about the hair length being reasonable for a suit, but some might argue that length doesn't match up to the hair seen on the film. For your purposes, it could be helpful if you decide to test how certain hair lengths look when filmed under certain conditions. In my mind, making comments (that can be taken as) casting doubt on a suit being used implies that you're also considering the idea that the subject of the film is a real creature and not a disguised human. To me, this means you would need data from the witnesses to compare and contract with what's on the film. Actually, now that I think about it, that could also apply from the hoax angle, seeing as how Roger Patterson watched the film numerous times when he first played it for other Bigfoot researchers.
Why would the odd film speed affect my idea, or even the smoothness of the gait? Those seen to be arguments for "real" and I personally am not using them to say "can't be a suit". I know people are studying these issues, but I'm not, at this time. Honestly, as much as i've seen, I don't have trouble thinking a man in a suit can do the walk.
Odd film speed effects the gait of the subject when the film is adjusted. This was just an example of how something that might not be obvious to someone can have a big effect on their observations of the film if they study it "in a vacuum."
After listening to your appearance on "Let's Talk Bigfoot" and factoring that in with your comments at this forum, here's the impression that I'm now getting regarding your notes:
Recently, you became curious as to why others in your profession have said that the subject of the film is a fake, as you were not aware of any of them publicizing their analysis of the film. While trying to find pictures from the Patterson-Gimlin film to help you with this, you found the Chris Walas discussion at the BFF. Intrigued by the type of discussion going on there, you decided to lurk for awhile and eventually decided to post since you saw some comments about costumes that you thought deserved input from someone with experience in that area and since you wanted to run some of your own ideas by people. To you, the main problem area of getting the filmed results would be the nature of the fur used. This is the main focus of your look at the film and your other notes were just you trying to explain how the other aspects could be faked/displaying your musings on other aspects. This snowballed past what you had originally intended and you got more ideas, with resulted in more notes than you had originally planned and are now heading more towards hard research than just musings on the internet. You don't have any definite conclusions on whether or not Patty is a hoax or how possible it was for Patterson and Gimlin to have afforded a suit should you find a satisfactory explanation to your questions regarding fur; you could lean either way depending on what information you collect.
Is this correct? Did I miss anything? Please let me know; hopefully we can craft that attempted summary into a "Rosetta Stone" for your work.
On the Dfoot post copy, those two paragraphs are straight across from the original post. Just thought it would clear up the remark for you.
Thank you. I was able to get to the other computer and I'm now confident to say that my misquoting the location of your comment was due to my computer issues.
Anyway, I hope you stick around and read through the Bigfoot threads here after you finish clearing up the meaning of your notes. They're long, but contain a wealth on information on that matter. Also, here are some links that might interest you:
-Since I've already posted a video where Stan Winston details why he feels Patty is a man in a suit,
here is the only other instance that I know of where someone in the special effects field touches on how they reached the hoax conclusion. In it, Bob Burns recalls how Rick Baker and he analyzed a copy of the film frame by frame and saw signs of a water bag being used. If you want to compare notes with Mr. Burns, you can try contacting him thorugh
his website.
-
This site has a wonderful (but far from complete) gallery of screenshots and publicity materials from movies involving gorilla costumes.
-
This site contains summaries of some of the points discussed here in the "Screeds and Essays" section. I personally recommend checking out the "Dermal Ridges" section.
-The image shown in the middle of
this picture is the homemade suit Chris Walas referred to in his BFF thread. More specifically, the one he made for $60 (in 70's money) when he was first starting out. Sadly, this seems to be the only "archived" version of the now-missing pictures he posted there.
-Oh, and I remembered an instance in which a monster costume was split into a top half and a bottom half (You seemed to be unaware of anyone doing this in your "Let's Talk Bigfoot" appearance). Starting at about 04:16 in
this video, you will see a dinosaur-type monster called "Gigasaurus." This is from a 1990 Japanese/Australian TV series known as "Ultraman Towards the Future" in the USA (aka "Ultraman Great" in Japan). You can see the full episode
here. There used to be a behind-the-scenes video showing the man wearing the bottom half of the suit while someone lifted the top half off of him, but that was removed from Youtube. They seem to have tried to hide the seam by disguising it as a sort of armor plating around the hips, which you might notice in the videos I provided. Granted, it's a reptilian quadraped that occasionally rears up on its hind legs as opposed to a hairy, bipedal humanoid creature (so it's of no use in an analysis of the P/G film), but I thought you might find this interesting.