Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
And now just when I thought it was safe to not think about his master work any more this evening sgoodman72 draws attention that the unfurred parts of the face match the color of the unfurred skin of the hand. Excellent observation!

Yeah? Look at the right hand. The thing that people are calling a film grain artifact or background is the same color as the face.

Now check out the left hand. WTF is that supposed to be? Did she stick it in a meat grinder?

5af5d4f7.jpg
 
Yeah? Look at the right hand. The thing that people are calling a film grain artifact or background is the same color as the face.

Now check out the left hand. WTF is that supposed to be? Did she stick it in a meat grinder?


We already discussed the left hand, I think it very convincingly shows a large thumb in sort of a top view, tilted slightly upwards. The fingers are also curled in a semi-fist underneath.

LTC: Now if the .gif file that was just displayed between 350 and 352 really does show an open hand and the closed semi-fist, then that's a whole 'nother angle and frame of the hand opening and closing, just like the little snippet we've seen so many times that Sweaty linked to earlier today. I STILL am torn over why everyone is hell-bent on the hands not opening, it doesn't legitimize squat if they do. The only thing I can puzzle out is that you or WP claimed that they definitely didn't open in some previous post and are backing those claims.
 
I see what looks like a grid pattern superimposed on her mouth area to look like teeth. Or maybe I'm nuts. :D


Haha, okay that's the second time I've laughed aloud in the span of about 5 minutes, definitely getting time for me to go to bed!!

The first was when Crow said the film was sure to have inspired more than it's fair share of barfights, lol. We shall resume this in the morn' (I will rejoin the convo. then I mean).


Hmm, maybe I'll make the barfight line my signature, or maybe this one as well LTC.
 
sgoodman72, the film just isn't good enough, imo. People see all sorts of things that may or may not actually be there. It's not unusual with such a film. I've gone back and forth on things I thought I saw in the PGF.

One man's thumb is another man's artifact. It's impossible to say who is correct most of the time.

Mangler's expose of the lobster claw animation still holds for me though. I thought it became very obvious that it was not Patty's hand opening and closing.

It's why I often lament the lack of the original film for study.
 
Bill, thanks once again, for addressing my questions. Sorry for not being able to respond as fast as I would like to. It's being a rather busy time for me. Oh, BTW, sorry for the typos, no time for spell checking in the previous post... Please also be aware that this thread is growing faster than I can follow these frozen and busy days. So, I certainly missed certain recent developments.

Correa Neto Your new post today #12292:

"I must stand by my statements; basically I feel that a person, especially if used to hard work, could perform as Patty, especially because he (whoever he was) would have two helpers. Or at the very least, one. Not to mention that the "Patty performance" was not very long.

Now, do you agree or not? If not, why?"

Agree.
OK, thanks.
So, this issue is settled, I guess. Assuming a Patty suit could be built, performing as Patty would not be a big issue for a group composed of two or three people, especially if they are used to hard works. Please take my word that this is not some sort of baiting. I just want to be sure we're talking the same "language".

"I partially agree with you, and my posts on the issue shows why. Of course the building and filming techniques are different. The true question is: Considering seams can be hidden in miniatures filmed at close range (by a number of means) would the seams of a full-sized costume be visible at PGF's resolution?

My opinion is no or barely."

Depends on the seam, where it is, how it was designed. Seams on costumes are far more varied in design that in stop motion models, especially closure seams (to get a person into and out of the costume. I have doubts about how well the film can resolve seams, and would like to test that more reliably, taking actual seamed fur structures, photographing them at similar resolution, and seeing exactly what does show and what doesn't. with knowledge of the original seam placement as the callibration data.
So, have we reached a partial agreement on this?
I mean, depending on how the suit was built and filmed they may or not be shown? Or perhaps depending on how the suit was built and filmed, the expressions on film of the seam lines would be open to interpretation? What some may interpret as a seam line others may interpret as something else?

Now, this is an important issue, it’s directly related to PGF’s resolution, it has to do with the amount of detail one can extract from the footage. It also has to do with the ways bias seep in to our evaluation.


seams running parallel to the hair lay are harder to hide than seams running perpendicular to the hair lay. Zig Zag seams running overall parallel to the hair lay help better than straight seams running parallel, but are a lot more work tailoring. And seamed sections are stiffer than fur unseamed areas, so the difference in rigidity makes curious motion artifcats in the seam locations that may magnify the effect (when the suit person moves on camera), and so magnify the prospect of being seen.
At this point I must consider how the effects you described would look like if filmed under PGF conditions (of course some “calibration” data would be nice to have). I would suppose that (most of) the seams would be perpendicular to hair "flow". A head piece, a "shirt", gloves (maybe with some sort of arms extensions) and "pants" (with some sort of "boots"). This, I think, under PGF shooting conditions could, in my opinion, be very effective, especially when I compare PGF with many segments of creature effects in movies.


Back to the breasts now:

"Bill, here's the problem:
"I didn't see"
It’s the very same issue we've been dealing with for a long time. Personal impressions. As you just said, you did not see anything particularly unnatural. Well, I see. In this particular issues, saying "it looks real for me" is just not enough. You certainly are familiar with Monty Python's "The meaning of life". Well, there's a scene of several bare breasted women running. No silicone. Please point me to a single one whose breasts move like Patty's breasts. "

You seem to fail to grasp that I simply don't think the whole breast thing is an issue, because I know anything on the screen can be faked with the 1960's technology, and I've said so repeatedly.
Bill, what I consider to be an issue is not your statement that Patty's breasts could be recreated by the 60's costume tech - I agree, vintage FX tech can make Patty's breasts. I have, however, a problem with the "looks real for me" line. Why? Because it does not looks OK for me... Now, either we agree to disagree or we can show each other argument backing our positions.

Seems like now, you're trying to prove a negative, that it's "impossible" for breasts of a living creature to move as you see them in the PG film. A skeptic would say, no matter how many human female breasts you look at running topless in a movie, there are still some human females who have not done so and thus you haven't seen the full range of potential human female breast motion or lack of same, so you've proven nothing. And the film shows a walk (maybe brisk, but a walk, not a run).
OK, lets move ahead on this path.
Lets suppose some human females could have such natural hard breasts. How many of them? What would be the percentage? Would bigfeet females have a similar distribution? What would be the odds of Patterson filming such a specimen?

What would be more likely? An unusual condition or a fakery?
Well, you already know my position.

See? We've been left with little but a (baseless) speculation or an argument on ignorance...

I'm frankly amused at why you want to keep returning to the breast thing, trying to prove an impossible, while others here suggest I can't or shouldn't try to prove an impossible (that it's not a suit). Those “can’t prove an impossible” cuts both ways.

Can we agree with this?
Why I keep returning to the breast thing?
Well... Hmmm... Breasts!
OK, I just lost some points for not being PC.

Now, seriously, I try to avoid the "can't prove a negative" line as hard as I can. Why? Because in some cases, you can! Unless, of course, you wan to enter in some obscure philosophical considerations. I suggest we leave that line of reasoning to the philosophy forum...

Your opinion: The breasts in the film do not move as you expect or have observed any real human female breasts moving.

My opinion: The apparent subtle motion (or lack of more motion) simply suggests, if the figure is real (qualified here), than the subcutenious connective fibers in the skin around the breast are particularly well connected, a condition many a woman would envy. And if it's a suit, everything I see in the breasts could be replicated with 1967 technology, no sweat.
Lets keep following the same path I started to wade in to a few lines above.
How likely would it be for a woman to have her breast’ subcutaneous connective fibers in such a nice shape, especially if her breasts are hanging so low in the torso?

Very small, I would say.

See? Its not just a matter of vintage costume tech being able to make it. Its more, its an anatomy question.

"Bill, I think I was clear from my posts. I see I wasn't. So, I will try to be more clear.

I think that regardless of your qualifications, personal bias have seeped in your analysis of Patty's breasts. Please understand that qualifications apart, what impress me and can make me change my mind are evidence and arguments. So far, the reasons you exposed to back your positions on how hard it would be to build a Patty costume, specially the parts I have outlined, have failed to convince me, regradless of your CV. These are two things apart."

You are not convinced. I respect that.

I will be most happy to set aside CVs and resumes, and allow each person's opinion to have real consideration, if you (all collectively) will drop that dumb "incredulaity" word from these discussions. Fair trade?
Bill, believe me or not, every single word written by proponents was considered (well, at least to a certain point – “invisiable” bigfeet claims are a breed apart, for example). If I had no consideration by your opinions, I would not be discussing them. “Argument from personal incredibility” is nothing but a designation for a logical fallacy, a trap many people (including myself) fall in to when discussing a subject.

Correa Neto #10082 Jan. 4

"Anyway, he's pretty dead on spot when he says Gimlim must have been a part of the hoax."

I never said Bob Gimlin was in on a hoax. I said if it was a hoax, I could not imagine it being done without Gimlin being part of it - Means I did not imagine a way to hoax Gimlin himself. Does not conclude there was one.
I only meant that, in your opinion, if it were a hoax, Gimlim must have been an active part of it. You must remember that every now and then speculations are made that Patterson may have fooled Gimlim. I do think it was a hoax and I do think Gimlim had an active role on it.

Correa Neto #10135

"Oh, Munns' ideas.

So far, he exposed arguments on why he thinks its unlikely that the patterns seen on Patty's hair or fur could have been made by Patterson and eventual colaborators."

I never made any appraisal of the skill or lack of same for Patterson to make a fur hair pattern, other than to apprease what I felt were professional skills an amateur would not likely posses.
Wait a minute…
I wrote “why he thinks its unlikely that the patterns seen on Patty's hair or fur could have been made by Patterson and eventual colaborators." Is this so different from “I felt were professional skills an amateur would not likely posses”?

Unless you are considering Patterson and his eventual collaborators were not amateurs…

Anyway, I think we should never underestimate the skill levels of amateurs, especially when they have time and energy to carry on with their projects.
 
Correa Neto said:
How likely would it be for a woman to have her breast’ subcutaneous connective fibers in such a nice shape, especially if her breasts are hanging so low in the torso?


Okay I had to wake back up and post because I just had a mini-brainstorm about Patty's melons...

Up until now everyone just says they're hanging low with no dimensions that I've seen or read. If you compared them relative to where Patty's elbow joints are, could it be determined if they're in fact too low, or in the right spot? As a reference I suggest just taking any kind of female primate and seeing where the breasts fall in relation to the elbow, and see where Patty's fall in relation to her elbows. I understand it's quite rudimentary without full analysis, but it'd be interesting. Bill, LTC, Crow, WP, anyone!?

Also if this has been mentioned or brought up before, I sincerely apologize and will meander slowly back to my bed and pretend I never posted this in the morning.
 
Okay I had to wake back up and post because I just had a mini-brainstorm about Patty's melons...

Up until now everyone just says they're hanging low with no dimensions that I've seen or read. If you compared them relative to where Patty's elbow joints are, could it be determined if they're in fact too low, or in the right spot? As a reference I suggest just taking any kind of female primate and seeing where the breasts fall in relation to the elbow, and see where Patty's fall in relation to her elbows. I understand it's quite rudimentary without full analysis, but it'd be interesting. Bill, LTC, Crow, WP, anyone!?



Also if this has been mentioned or brought up before, I sincerely apologize and will meander slowly back to my bed and pretend I never posted this in the morning.

If I understand this correctly the fact that Patty has a very long arm and if put into the shape with which to cradle a newborn to suckle would put the position of the newborn/infant at a point much lower on the abdomen than in a human. It most certainly would better to have the breasts low.
 
Correa:

"Assuming a Patty suit could be built, performing as Patty would not be a big issue for a group composed of two or three people, especially if they are used to hard works."

There are issues of "degree of difficulty" but not issues of "posible/impossible", as long as you allow somebody to assist the person in the suit, dressing the wearer into and out of it. Training, skill, practice and talent do raise the odds for possible. Dumb luck leans more to "impossible".

"I mean, depending on how the suit was built and filmed they may or not be shown? Or perhaps depending on how the suit was built and filmed, the expressions on film of the seam lines would be open to interpretation? What some may interpret as a seam line others may interpret as something else?"

There would be tailoring seams on the suit any way you look at it, but tailoring seams can be blended reasonably well. Closure seams (used to get the person into or out of the suit, are harder to hide, but if the suit were custom designed to be filmed exactly as seen, you could put seams in the front, thus hiding them. It's very rare, but possible.

You are correct in that lines on the figure that some people call seams are highly subject to intrepretation, and the graininess of the film raises questions of whether lines are seams, shadows, or film artifiacts. All highly interpretitive.

"At this point I must consider how the effects you described would look like if filmed under PGF conditions (of course some “calibration” data would be nice to have). I would suppose that (most of) the seams would be perpendicular to hair "flow". A head piece, a "shirt", gloves (maybe with some sort of arms extensions) and "pants" (with some sort of "boots"). This, I think, under PGF shooting conditions could, in my opinion, be very effective, especially when I compare PGF with many segments of creature effects in movies."

A head/neck seam would be perpendicular to hair lay, as would a waist seam (if the shirt and pants split), while a traditional "zipper up the back" would be a parallel seam, and would be vastly better if a zig-zag type instead of straight. This hypothetical back zipper is what the Disney people are reported to have looked for back in the time the film was first brought to Hollywood for appraisal.

There should also be a tailoring seam down the inside of each leg, but only the left leg shows the inside surface. That would need to be extremely well hidden, because the walking motion ruffles hair in the inside leg surfaces, and ruffled hair tends to expose seams.

The ideal way to try to find out how easy or hard it is to find a seam is to make a suit, and film it under the PG Film conditions of figure to frame size, same sunlight angle, same prime lens, perhaps hand held, duped twice and scanned, and look for the seams you know for a fact are in the suit you filmed. if you can't see any evidence of them in your test, you may assume there can be seams on Patty and you just can't see them because of the film grain, duping, etc. That's the kind of callibration test I mean, as one example.

On to the breasts:

We agree to disagree on "looks real to me."

Now you take the human model as a direct comparison. But does Patty have a normal human skull or a bit of a sagital crest? Does she have a head/neck posture, hunched over, unlike a normal human. And of course, does a normal human have fur over it's body? If we say "she's not quite human", than the breasts could also be "not quite human" and still be real. So I see a little more range on "normal" than you do, because of this.

But let's go back to basics. Mammals have mammary glands in bilateral placement on the torso, generally, and always on primates, one pair on the upper torso, which is above the diaphram midline at the base of the lungs. So far, Patty is "normal." Human's tend to have the breast higher, but that is a tendancy moreso than an absolute, and it's specific to humans, not something like a human (which may have more variance). So my perspective is, based on these specifications, I do not see anything I call "unnatural" to the point I'd conclude "unreal". But this only pertains to form, the basic shape. Motion is a seperate element.

Breasts are soft tissue, not muscle, so they have no capacity to tense up rigidly as tensed muscles can. So they tend to move as a female walks, runs, etc. And large breasts do tend to move quite a bit. For the size of breasts in the film, I think more movement would generally be expected. Some people say they see a lot of movement, some say little, some say none. But the breast movement is in part an occillation, a responsive wave-like reaction to an action, and so how smooth the walk, keeping the torso steady, may impact on "bounce".

There are also issues of the strength of breast skin connective tissue, and the prospect of a lactating female having the breasts slightly fuller than usual for the skin covering them, and expanding the skin may cause it to firm up as it's stretched, restricting motion. These are all theoreticals a person would need to factor into an analysis trying to find the breasts "unnatural" to the point they must not be real (proof of a hoax)

I personally am not trying to prove they are not real. I know everything in the film can be faked, if need be, for the breasts. So you are welcome to use any of the anatomical studies and physiological aspects to argue for "not real", but as other's have said of me, "you can't prove a negative". So you have a formitable task to prove, if you use the breast as your object of proof.

A skeptic can simply say, have you studied every woman's breasts in the world to say none can have that shape and exhibit that movement (or lack of, as you prefer to word it)? If you say "no", because if you embark on this noble cause, at least one woman will surely say "no", then the skeptic can say you haven't arrived at "absolutely no women have such breasts." So you go to probability, and then you open the door for your opponent to use probability against you as well.

You say "How likely would it be for a woman to have her breast’ subcutaneous connective fibers in such a nice shape, especially if her breasts are hanging so low in the torso?

Very small, I would say."


And I would agree. Small odds. My opinion, just for the record, the breasts will never settle it eaither way. Other parts of the body will, if it is settled. This becomes a research judgmental call, something like "fight the wars you can win". Put your research effort into the issues and arguments you think you really have a good chance to prove, and direct less research resource to the issues that may be the hardst to win. That's why I tend to keep saying things don't matter to me. I have a limited amount of time and resource and want to put it to best use, by setting aside the things I feel just don't impact strongly on my hypothesis.

On Gimlin hoaxed, I don't want to accuse the man, because I know nothing about him. I will just say, with all I know about suits and what it takes to film them, if a suit was filmed, I cannot imagine anybody on the scene who would be unaware of a hoax being filmed.

"Anyway, I think we should never underestimate the skill levels of amateurs, especially when they have time and energy to carry on with their projects."

I emphatically agree. I happen to admire people who simply choose to educate themselves, learn all they can, try things, and develop fine skills, even when they are classified as "amateurs". Some of the most masterful people in the world are "amateurs".

The "professional vs amateur" is a generalization, all presumption the pro knows more. Every so often, an amateur comes along and defies the presumption. I applaud them when they do.

Bill
 
Bill Munns said:
Thank you for the reference to the films and videos. I'll put them on the list of items I should examine and study.

You're quite welcome. Speaking of which, you might want to pick up a copy of the "Gorilla at Large" DVD. There are some points in the film where a seeming "buttcrack" appears when the person in the costume is in certian positions. I suspect that this is unintentional and due to how the suit was constructed, so it might tie in with your anaylsis of the fur.

On the leg thing, as I understood, proponents of "real" describe a herniated bulge or something like that. For the record, I don't susbscribe to such an analysis. I see anomolies in the right leg fur patterns, but I have not formed any conclusion yet.

I vaguely remember someone at the BFF making a movie file that they claimed showed that the bulge was a film anomoly. If that is the case, I feel that it raises a big question mark on other aspects of Patty (muscles, supposed breast movement, etc.) that appear in the film. I should note that I refer to the subject as Patty since I know that costumes can be given nicknames and it provides some common ground for proponents who visit.

The water bag thing is not something I've done personally. I just know it was done pre PG Film.

Ah. I actually found the episode of the Bigfoot podcast you were on today; I wish I had heard it before I had done that post, as it made your stance on waterbags and breasts more clear to me.

The word "ventilated" can have two meanings, and thus may cause confusion. In film terms it's hand tying hairs on to a fine lace mesh, like good men's toupees are made, with a fine needle like a chrochet hook, but much smaller.

Yep! That definition is the particular definition I was referring to.

For the breast comments, I described a generalized gel or fluid pouch to create the fluidity under the foam latex skin. In 1967, water would have been the most probable fluid, and the pouch could have been a condom or a party balloon. Low tech, but would work.

Ok. Personally, I don't think the breasts move much. This is based on a .gif posted in one of the Bigfoot threads here showing a sideways "breast twitch" or "shift" from the film. There was no jiggling or movement that I would associate with real breasts moving, but would seem to match up with the movement of false breasts attached to a costume. I've seen proponents note this irregular movement and argue that this instead shows that the breasts are in fact an infant clutching/climbing the front of Patty's chest. I hope that someone reading this can repost the "breast twitch" .gif, as I have long since forgotten its location.

The ice thing I never thought of, but for a Godzilla type suit (hollow actually, held up by suspenders, I believe) pouring ice into it might have worked fine.

I'm sure the men playing Godzilla would've appreciated people cooling the suits for them. The closest to that they got (in fact, this might only apply to actors who've worn the suit from the 80's through recent times) was when they filmed in air conditioned sets. I don't know if suspenders were used for the interiors of the full Godzilla suits, but (if I recall correctly), suspenders were used for a half suit used for the first Godzilla movie, for scenes where only Godzilla's feet where seen.

Since we're on the subject of cooling systems, here's a reference to a rather unique one I found while digging around my notes for some links to use later in this post.

But for a form fitting padded movie suit of a primate, for example, the suit is too tight to pour anything into. But a Hudsen sprayer is pressurized, so it forces the water into the suit even when it's snug, especially if you use a long tubular spray wand.

Oh...I should clarify something I meant that bags of ice would be placed in the suit while the person wasn't inside it (like prior to the actor wearing it for filming) and not that ice would be poured inside while the actor was wearing it. You're correct that using ice definitely wouldn't work while someone was in the suit.

You're not being difficult on the "Hollywood Hoax" thing. I was being colorful in my phrasing, but actually trying to say you can have an elaborate hoax involving many skilled people, or a much more modest hoax of a few people doing a hoax on a whim, or any level of sophistication between. I try to stay out of estimating how simple or complex a hoax may have occurred if it did. Seems there are simply too many options to speculate upon.

Okay, thanks for the clarification.

On my analysis, and your respectful disagreement, if I start with a presumption I'm looking at a suit and then study if the materials can do the suit, haven't I already stipulated to "if it's a suit"? And if i stipulate that, then it seems to me that I don't need to study the particulars before or other peripheral elements of the scene and event. Respectfully, you lost me here.

The intention of something is always clear to the person who created it, but may not be that way to someone observing the work because they don't have access to the creator's thought process. Based on the large amount of people who are misinterpeting your writings, I'm thinking that's what's going on here (on all "sides" of the issue). To you, your intended meanings are crystal clear, but they aren't to many others. You might think that it's obvious that you are only focusing on materials/fur, but doing notes on your thought process on arms, feet, etc. and posting comments like "I want to understand what's in the PG film. It mystifies me and I would like an answer. That is my goal, my ambition, my intention." can make it sound like you're taking a more general approach to the issue and seemingly contradicts comments you've made about a more specific focus.

Similarly, the notes you had regarding probabilities and comments that seemingly indicate that you're leaning towards the "it's not a suit explanation (Such as how, towards the end of "Let's Talk Bigfoot", you made a comment that could be taken as you saying that only some issue with the leg was keeping you from concluding that Patty was an animal). It's fairly common here (and other forums relating to cryptozoology and "the unexplained") to have people claim to not be believers/proponents and how they're merely on the fence/trying to find "what's behind the mystery" and then later launch into discussions on why such-and-such is real, so merely saying you don't have a specific conclusion or that you're on the fence isn't going to have the same effect as it would to a group of people with no interest in the subject.

Also, not responding to certain parts of a post could be interpreted as someone ducking or ignoring an issue. I don't see it that way, but I figured you might want to know that as you seem fairly new to the wacky world of internet discussion forums.

Yes, my study is certainly open to the possiblilty the filmed subject is a real bigfoot. But isn't everything you address here arguments for "real"? For a suit, the hair length is reasonable.

I agree about the hair length being reasonable for a suit, but some might argue that length doesn't match up to the hair seen on the film. For your purposes, it could be helpful if you decide to test how certain hair lengths look when filmed under certain conditions. In my mind, making comments (that can be taken as) casting doubt on a suit being used implies that you're also considering the idea that the subject of the film is a real creature and not a disguised human. To me, this means you would need data from the witnesses to compare and contract with what's on the film. Actually, now that I think about it, that could also apply from the hoax angle, seeing as how Roger Patterson watched the film numerous times when he first played it for other Bigfoot researchers.

Why would the odd film speed affect my idea, or even the smoothness of the gait? Those seen to be arguments for "real" and I personally am not using them to say "can't be a suit". I know people are studying these issues, but I'm not, at this time. Honestly, as much as i've seen, I don't have trouble thinking a man in a suit can do the walk.

Odd film speed effects the gait of the subject when the film is adjusted. This was just an example of how something that might not be obvious to someone can have a big effect on their observations of the film if they study it "in a vacuum."

After listening to your appearance on "Let's Talk Bigfoot" and factoring that in with your comments at this forum, here's the impression that I'm now getting regarding your notes:

Recently, you became curious as to why others in your profession have said that the subject of the film is a fake, as you were not aware of any of them publicizing their analysis of the film. While trying to find pictures from the Patterson-Gimlin film to help you with this, you found the Chris Walas discussion at the BFF. Intrigued by the type of discussion going on there, you decided to lurk for awhile and eventually decided to post since you saw some comments about costumes that you thought deserved input from someone with experience in that area and since you wanted to run some of your own ideas by people. To you, the main problem area of getting the filmed results would be the nature of the fur used. This is the main focus of your look at the film and your other notes were just you trying to explain how the other aspects could be faked/displaying your musings on other aspects. This snowballed past what you had originally intended and you got more ideas, with resulted in more notes than you had originally planned and are now heading more towards hard research than just musings on the internet. You don't have any definite conclusions on whether or not Patty is a hoax or how possible it was for Patterson and Gimlin to have afforded a suit should you find a satisfactory explanation to your questions regarding fur; you could lean either way depending on what information you collect.

Is this correct? Did I miss anything? Please let me know; hopefully we can craft that attempted summary into a "Rosetta Stone" for your work.

On the Dfoot post copy, those two paragraphs are straight across from the original post. Just thought it would clear up the remark for you.

Thank you. I was able to get to the other computer and I'm now confident to say that my misquoting the location of your comment was due to my computer issues.

Anyway, I hope you stick around and read through the Bigfoot threads here after you finish clearing up the meaning of your notes. They're long, but contain a wealth on information on that matter. Also, here are some links that might interest you:

-Since I've already posted a video where Stan Winston details why he feels Patty is a man in a suit, here is the only other instance that I know of where someone in the special effects field touches on how they reached the hoax conclusion. In it, Bob Burns recalls how Rick Baker and he analyzed a copy of the film frame by frame and saw signs of a water bag being used. If you want to compare notes with Mr. Burns, you can try contacting him thorugh his website.

-This site has a wonderful (but far from complete) gallery of screenshots and publicity materials from movies involving gorilla costumes.

-This site contains summaries of some of the points discussed here in the "Screeds and Essays" section. I personally recommend checking out the "Dermal Ridges" section.

-The image shown in the middle of this picture is the homemade suit Chris Walas referred to in his BFF thread. More specifically, the one he made for $60 (in 70's money) when he was first starting out. Sadly, this seems to be the only "archived" version of the now-missing pictures he posted there.

-Oh, and I remembered an instance in which a monster costume was split into a top half and a bottom half (You seemed to be unaware of anyone doing this in your "Let's Talk Bigfoot" appearance). Starting at about 04:16 in this video, you will see a dinosaur-type monster called "Gigasaurus." This is from a 1990 Japanese/Australian TV series known as "Ultraman Towards the Future" in the USA (aka "Ultraman Great" in Japan). You can see the full episode here. There used to be a behind-the-scenes video showing the man wearing the bottom half of the suit while someone lifted the top half off of him, but that was removed from Youtube. They seem to have tried to hide the seam by disguising it as a sort of armor plating around the hips, which you might notice in the videos I provided. Granted, it's a reptilian quadraped that occasionally rears up on its hind legs as opposed to a hairy, bipedal humanoid creature (so it's of no use in an analysis of the P/G film), but I thought you might find this interesting.
 
Last edited:
AtomicMysteryMonster:

"Is this correct? Did I miss anything? Please let me know; hopefully we can craft that attempted summary into a "Rosetta Stone" for your work."

If i had a budget, I'd hire you to do my PR. You have provided the closest understanding of who I really am and what I'm doing, as well as how it sort of happened unplanned, I could hope to read from another person.

I really was beginning to wonder why I couldn't get anybody to see what I was saying. You give me hope.

Thank you.

Bill
 
Bill Munn said:
Now to Aepervius Post #12318

I ask you, "so your contention is 'process of elimination' is not a scientific method" Fascinating" and you reply "No it is not. It allows you to form an hypothese at best. But that is it. The scientific method involve far more "

So, if process of elimination only allows you to form a hypothesis and is not a part of the scientific method (Your exact words, "no it is not!"), than forming a hypothesis is not part of the scientific method. Your reasoning is truly fascinating.

Anybody can form an hypothesis. You can also do that in theology. In philosophy. What you seem to ignore , whether intentionally or not, is that an hypothesis ALONE does not make a method. ONLY the combination of data gathering, hypothesis making, falsification is the scientific method. Your reasoning is truly fascinating as you think that making hypothesis alone is enough. no it is not. An hypothesis alone is worthless. At most it is entertaining. But science it is not. NOT until falsification comes in. Until then it is a rambling between people on the internet, or as I usually say, AN OPINION.

I am forming a hypothesis. I've said that repeatedly. I still have experiments and studies to do, I've said that repeatedly. Falsification of the hypothesis will be factored into the study. I have not offered any final conclusion yet, I have said that repeatedly. My notes are a work in progress, I've made that clear. And I've stated repeatedly that I am studying material physical properties and dynamics, as my principle emphasis.

If you are studying something specific made of plastic, for example, you study what that plastic compound can or cannot do, in physical property terms. You do not need to study every specific item made of that plastic.

Similarly, IF it can be shown that furcloth materials of the time do not have some physical properties necessary to do what is seen on the film, and it is the inherent physical character of the material that is causing the lack of capacity, than any costume fabricated with such material is included, and does not need to be tested seperately.

And I repeat, which you clearly fail to grasp, I'm not trying to prove a real criptid exists. I even offered an option of a real human that might satisfy the "real" and not involve a cryptid, if the suit were (hypothetically) not possible.

I can offer conclusions to specific questions in the larger matrix of study. If you ask me if standard furcloth can stretch like new spandex based furcloths, I can say categorically (conclude) they do not. They lack the physical dynamic to do so.

Let me repeat. My notes are a work in progress.

I do not care if you want to prove a real cryptid exists, or if this is a 5th dimension teleporting aliens. The fact is, non-withstanding the lack of data due to the film copying/quality/dot-per-inch you cannot prove you eliminated all costume making method. You can only say you eliminated all method *you are aware of*. Which is why an elimination method such as the one you propose cannot ever eliminate the pgf=costume guy proposal. It cannot even make it less likely than it is now. And this is the salient point you are missing. You cannot come to a conclusion with your premise. Because you cannot falsify your hypothesis.
 
SG or anyone, do your remember a thread somewhere about the Cibachromes being possibly intentionally altered or etched to achieve some effect? I seem to remember it during a discussion about LMS, I think Noll was in on the discussion as well. I can't locate the thread though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom