Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Whenever I think I can see the hands they look like they are formed into a slight cupping. I don't think I have ever seen distinct fingers or thumbs.

Like this...

b921b3c0.jpg
 
Are we talking about the PGF !?

No we were talking about Gone With The Wind. And nobody in Gone With The Wind said "It stunk. Roger skinned out a dead red horse". But when it comes to the PGF that quote has risen its dead red head often. Have you proven yet that Bob H. never said it?
 
William Parcher said:
So your 'work' is to be strictly limited to the external material or skin/hair of Patty? If so, then please quit with the arm length ratio, hands-in-gloves, and feet stuff pronto, ok? Better tell the folks on BFF that everything else (other than external material) you talked about is just your ancillary musings.

Stop making rules for what I can say, to whom, or how.

Sounds like you are making rules for me.

You follow no rules.

Thunderdome is simple. Get to the weapons. Use them any way you can. I know you won't break the rules. There aren't any.
 
Yes, my study is certainly open to the possiblilty the filmed subject is a real bigfoot. But isn't everything you address here arguments for "real"? For a suit, the hair length is reasonable. Why would the odd film speed affect my idea, or even the smoothness of the gait? Those seen to be arguments for "real" and I personally am not using them to say "can't be a suit". I know people are studying these issues, but I'm not, at this time. Honestly, as much as i've seen, I don't have trouble thinking a man in a suit can do the walk.

Just for fun. Here is a random Yakima guy walking with Patty. It's crude and dodgy, but fun is sometimes like that.

a22efd90.gif
 
I f****in HATE the Thunderdome connotations in this forum! Now here this all you enlightened critical thinkers out there if you were to invite legitmate cricical thinkers and scientists into this forum to engage in critical thinking and said oh by the way our method of critical thinking around here is we treat it like Thunderdome you'd be laughed out of town!
 
I f****in HATE the Thunderdome connotations in this forum!

Membership Agreement - Rule #10: You will not swear in your posts. This includes using swear words in a disguised form, for example, by replacing certain letters in the word with another letter, character, or image.

I won't report your post, because there are no rules in Thunderdome. The mods may disagree and act accordingly.

Now here this all you enlightened critical thinkers out there if you were to invite legitmate cricical thinkers and scientists into this forum to engage in critical thinking and said oh by the way our method of critical thinking around here is we treat it like Thunderdome you'd be laughed out of town!

Those folks are too busy to come here because they are working on trying to solve the mystery of chupacabras. Busy, busy, busy. You must understand.

Welcome to another edition of Thunderdome! We control the cheap a simp.
 
I HATE the Thunderdome connotations in this forum! Now here this all you enlightened critical thinkers out there if you were to invite legitmate cricical thinkers and scientists into this forum to engage in critical thinking and said oh by the way our method of critical thinking around here is we treat it like Thunderdome you'd be laughed out of town!

Lighten up, Francis!
 
I f****in HATE the Thunderdome connotations in this forum! Now here this all you enlightened critical thinkers out there if you were to invite legitmate cricical thinkers and scientists into this forum to engage in critical thinking and said oh by the way our method of critical thinking around here is we treat it like Thunderdome you'd be laughed out of town!

We are already being laughed out of town by scientists and anyone else who is actually paid to think ..

What makes you think anyone in that category, would spend any more time on this, than the 60 seconds it takes to watch the film ?
 
Aepervius your post #12517

"is that an hypothesis ALONE does not make a method. ONLY the combination of data gathering, hypothesis making, falsification is the scientific method. "

Did you miss the parts about my goal of a research study? Did I say I'm going to stop with my hypothesis? Here it is, hopefully one final time. I have formed my hypothesis. Stage one. I am planning a program or further research to gather data and test materials and processes, Stage two (not complete yet). Then, I will move on to the additional stages of the scientific method.

Got it?

"And this is the salient point you are missing. You cannot come to a conclusion with your premise. Because you cannot falsify your hypothesis."

So I shouldn't even try, because you predict I will not succeed? Or are you so wise you know the outcome of my studies before I even conduct them?

I will try to bring new data to the subject, and we will see where that new data leads, what it may or may not conclude or resolve. New data is a contribution. Your negativism is an obstruction.

Is that all you want to accomplist, to obstruct others from trying to bring new data to the issue?

Bill
 
Last edited:
Bill, the last paragraph from part 1 over at BFF ..

And that would be one of the strongest arguments Patty isn't a suit. If you can't find a Hollywood suit of the time or earlier, where the fur was very short and dense as on Patty's back, form-fitting a apelike, humanoid, or even bear-like anatomy, then it speaks volumes for the fact of how hard it is, and maybe it simply couldn't be done.

If Patty is not a Hollwood suit, made by Hollywood suit makers, why would you expect to find a Hollywood suit that looks like it ?

That said, did I miss where you ruled out real fur, like an old beaver coat or some such,
as part of the suit; particularly the back ?

Patty's pelt is by no means congruous ..
The back looks nice and smooth, but the texture of the butt, thighs and legs all looks different..
Not something you would expect to see on a real animal ...

P.S.

Bill, I see where you listed ..

A. Real fur, like the bear skins used on the 1976 Kong Suit A "Maybe", in terms of being used for Patty. Price: a few hunderd per good pelt or bear skin rug, and you'd need 4-6 to make a full suit (with color matches and getting hair lay correct from piece to piece).


But like I said, it doesn't match and it doesn't lay correct from head to toe..

You didn't rule real fur out, but you implied as much ..
 
Last edited:
Diogenes:

"If Patty is not a Hollwood suit, made by Hollywood suit makers, why would you expect to find a Hollywood suit that looks like it ?"

I would simply use Hollywood Suits as a standard of the highest proficiency, the best that could be done. But a fair appraisal would be, in any study of existing suits, to look beyond Hollywood and find what may have been done outside of it as well, like the Morris stuff.

I didn't rule out real fur. But it has the same general physical capacity in that it does not stretch any more than standard fake fur. So in that sense, it behaves the same (from a material dynamic position). It bends, it folds, it twists, but it doesn't stretch.

Real fur, if you could tailor it right, would probably look more real for Patty, but the tailoring work would be harder. But it still would have potential problems with the motion of the person wearing it, as far as looking like a suit. But to clarify for you, neither real fur or artificial fur is clonclusively ruled out yet. Further study awaits.

In my quote, didn't I say "maybe". It's still "maybe".

Bill
 
"Its head was very human, though considerably more slanted, and with a large forehead and wide nostrils. Its arms hung almost to its knees when it walked. Its hair was two to four inches long, brown underneath, lighter at the top, and covering the entire body except for the face. And it was a female; it had big, pendulous breasts."

Roger reiterates the 2 to 4 inches in 1969.

Now for Argosy in 1968, he said she was covered with short, shiny, black hair.

2 to 4 inches must have been "short" to Roger.

At any rate, he saw the creature live, and had much better resolution than we have looking at old films.
 
LTC

"Just a few hours after he filmed Patty, Roger told a reporter that her hair was 2 to 4 inches long, Bill. Where'd you get the idea that Patty's hair was short?"

I appraise the hair length relative to most good suits where the hair is "longer"

Best I can do, for now, based on film quality.

afterthought

The lay of hair or fur can strongly influence it's apparent length. 2 inch fur can actually look far shorter if it's laying down smoothly. The same fur, bristled up, may look longer.

But appraisals of hair length can also be determined by how much the hair obstructs the appearance of the underlying anatomy. If you see anything resembling musculature or soft tissue deposits, the fur in those areas tends to be shorter, and longer fur tends to obscure such contours of anatomy.
 
Last edited:
Bill:
I didn't rule out real fur. But it has the same general physical capacity in that it does not stretch any more than standard fake fur. So in that sense, it behaves the same (from a material dynamic position). It bends, it folds, it twists, but it doesn't stretch.
I'm confused.
You have a problem with a real animal pelt as a covering for a real animal ?
 
But appraisals of hair length can also be determined by how much the hair obstructs the appearance of the underlying anatomy. If you see anything resembling musculature or soft tissue deposits, the fur in those areas tends to be shorter, and longer fur tends to obscure such contours of anatomy.

I's funny how that works..

When I have pointed problems with the musculature on the subject, the argument was it must be long hair giving an unnatural look .

Where do you think the musculature looks normal; showing through what must be short hair ?

Perhaps we can discuss it...
 
Last edited:
Bill, the last paragraph from part 1 over at BFF ..



Patty's pelt is by no means congruous ..
The back looks nice and smooth, but the texture of the butt, thighs and legs all looks different..
Not something you would expect to see on a real animal ...


You need to get out and see more real animals! A few friendly Gorillas may be helpful.







 
Well, if a claim is going to be made that Patty's hair is too short, too short to hide seams and zippers for example, there must be a way of determining this with some accuracy for the claim to be valid.

I see no way to determine this from the film.

Claims of seeing muscle movement are dubious at best, and even if we allow that, you can see muscle movement on animals with hair long enough to hide a zipper or a seam.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom