Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Pointing out flaws in your thinking is not intended to get you to switch teams, but to realize how un-critically you've been approaching the subject.
You know what, Drewbot? I think he does realize that. I think he realizes it very well but is just unwilling to admit it out of pride. When your more interested in scoring points on the damn dirty skeptics who peed on your bigfoot play, you're going to be loathe to concede any error in your judgement.

ETA: W00t! I got the first post on the 300th page of our beast that Diogenes hatched. Yay! I'm in cahoots with the bad muthas at the JREF and was allowed that as a special NSA priviledge, of course.
 
Last edited:
devnull wrote:
Still getting this wrong Sweaty? The whole *every possible imagined scenario, no matter how convoluted or ridiculous, is as valid as any other* point of view?


You have it wrong, Devnull.

You misrepresented what I said...to the tune of 180 degrees.....upside down. You have it backwards, my skeptical friend.
Perhaps your reading comprehension skills are simply.....not there.

This is what I actually said...

So, think whatever you like....but your opinion, or assumption, concerning Patty is worth no more than anyone else's...including mine... just 2 cents.

and...

...but that 'position' is nothing more than a "peferential belief"...a meaningless thought...on the part of whoever takes it...unless it can be supported by evidence which proves the position to be factual.


Explanation....for the "hard of thinking" ;).....I said that default positions....such as "Patty IS a human", or "Patty IS a Bigfoot" are meaningless, and worthless.

Worthless is the exact OPPOSITE of valid.


Again...as I said in my previous post....

Like I said in my previous post....help yourself to whatever thoughts you want to have! You're free to assume and think that Patty is a man....but that 'position' is nothing more than a "peferential belief"...a meaningless thought...on the part of whoever takes it...unless it can be supported by evidence which proves the position to be factual.


I applaud a skeptic's freedom of thought. By all means....go ahead and think whatever you want about what Patty is!
All I'm saying is that until Patty is proven to be one or the other, what someone says they think she is.....is simply a worthless opinion...and nothing more. :)
It carries no weight....unless it is supported by evidence.

As for why proof is needed for those positions (Patty IS ...whatever..) to have validity..it's because it's ambiguous as to what Patty is...man or beast.
Even some skeptics here have admitted they think she may be a real Bigfoot.

This is why LTC said this:
Well, since you have attempted to hijack something I wrote by truncating it and applying it to something else, I don't think I'll answer that.


....in response to my question...

One option is that the Patterson subject may be a real Bigfoot.
Is this not true?"

LTC evaded and refused to answer a simple question...because his answer, either way, would cause a problem for him, due to his default position that "Patty IS a man-in-a-suit, until proven otherwise".
 
Last edited:
Question:
If someone says "Patty is a man in a suit, until proven otherwise"....why should that mean anything to me...or to anyone else?
 
LTC evaded and refused to answer a simple question...because his answer, either way, would cause a problem for him, due to his default position that "Patty IS a man-in-a-suit, until proven otherwise".

Which is a correct answer. Because for all we know Bigfoot could be a kangaroo-in-a-suit. Or an alien having shortly landed on the planet. Or an abominable snowman having gotten a sunburn, or a shape-shifted pink unicorn, or even, as historian claim, a beast from the 5th dimension.

Those are claim which have to be proven by the claimant. Until then the default position of a claim should be the most acceptable or accepted position : this is a man in a suit.

Until you provide evidence this is a real animal (or an alien, or a ....) then it is not up to the skeptic to PROVE that it cannot be anything but a man in a suit. Although skeptic might indulge in poking wide hole in your shaky arguments.

Thus you request for LTC to admit that this could be a real animal is about as sensible as the request of some other to admit that this could be a shape shifting unicorn, or even a monster from the 5th dimension.

By the way I believe this is a kangaroo in a costume. Are you ready to admit this could be the case ?
 
Last edited:
By your own words, Astro....your default position is simply a "will to believe", on your part.

Sorry, but my/the skeptic position is based on FACTS (Things that can not be disputed). A man can put on a suit that can be constructed to look like bigfoot. Since these things can happen then it is probable (no matter how much you argue that it can not be so). However, your position is that it can not be a hoax and that it shows a true bigfoot. Without any evidence for bigfoot to exist, then your option is based on belief and not a fact.
 
Question:
If someone says "Patty is a man in a suit, until proven otherwise"....why should that mean anything to me...or to anyone else?

If you are not doing science, but doing theology (in other word, you BELIEVE as in FAITH this is a real animal) then such question should not matter. But then again you are not trying to provide evidence , you just recite a gospel.

On the other hand if you want people to think Bigfoot as a real animal, in a way which is roughly scientific, and not a theological one, then you will need to provide evidence. And in such case, the ONLY valid stance, is NOT to take the figure in the film as an animal, but to take the most likely explanation as the most valid "a man in a suit" and then work up all evidence against that standard. If some evidence don#t pass to that "man in a suit" then the hypothese needs to be reworked. (some skeptic might want to start as "it is unknown" but this would come back to our discussion of orange/green skeptic).

Up to now there has been no evidence whatsoever that invalidate/falsify "this is a man in a suit". Thus the stance of LTC is acceptable.
 
Question:
If someone says "Patty is a man in a suit, until proven otherwise"....why should that mean anything to me...or to anyone else?
A simple answer for the chronic dodger's simple question.

1) Nobody here cares if it means anything to you, we're just showing the erroneous nature of your reasoning.

2) Patty is far, far more likely to be a man in a suit than a living bigfoot for all the reasons already explained to you many times over. Whether you accept this fact is up to you and you are free to continue rolling in the joy that there is a miniscule possibility that Patty is a living bigfoot.
 
LTC evaded and refused to answer a simple question...because his answer, either way, would cause a problem for him, due to his default position that "Patty IS a man-in-a-suit, until proven otherwise".

I've already answered the question many times. In fact, I answered it recently. Also, that default position is not my default position, but the default position.

It's the dafault position of Sweaty as well. If it weren't, he would not be looking for evidence, he'd be declaring bigfoot real and backing up that declaration.
 
Last edited:
Drewbot wrote:
I am simply wondering how you can look at things like MDF, and PGF, and conclude that that is an Unclassified, Hairy, Bipedal, Swimming, Primate.


Where did I say that I concluded those subjects are real Bigfoot creatures?
 
LTC8K6 wrote:
I've already answered the question many times. In fact, I answered it recently.

When did you answer this question?...

One option is that the Patterson subject may be a real Bigfoot.
Is this not true?"


Can you provide a post number?

The truth of the matter is...you refused to answer it...

I don't think I'll answer that.
 
I haven't eliminated the possibility that Patty is a man in a suit yet, and iirc, no one else has either.

I'm actually more certain now than I was that the PGF is a hoax, although I was pretty certain already.

I have learned a lot in this thread and the other threads that have firmed up my opinions about the PGF.

Posted by me on 2/22/08.
 
kitakaze wrote:
Nobody here cares if it means anything to you, we're just showing the erroneous nature of your reasoning.


I asked.....

If someone says "Patty is a man in a suit, until proven otherwise"....why should that mean anything to me... or to anyone else?

Can you answer the question, kitty?
 
If someone says "Patty is a man in a suit, until proven otherwise"....why should that mean anything to me... or to anyone else?

It should be how you are approaching the issue, Sweaty. It should be how any objective person approaches the issue.

The idea that Patty is a new primate is farfetched.

It cannot be given the same standing as the idea that Patty is a hoax without some very strong evidence in support of it, evidence which has not shown up to date.

The hoax idea is the most likely, and needs little support.

When support for Patty being a new primate comes in, the hoax idea will become less likely.

So far, there is zero evidence that Patty is a real new primate. There is no more evidence today than there was when the film became public.

The film is what it is. It doesn't prove anything at all.
 
Last edited:
No, the truth is I refused to answer it that time in the context in which you presented it, and I have answered it numerous times here and in other threads.


You have not answered the question, LTC.

Those quotes of yours you provided are not an answer to the question I asked you.

My guess is that you are simply afraid to answer.


Yes....skeptics refuse to answer questions. :)
Probably because they're more interested in playing "word games" than they are in carrying on honest discussions. There is simply no good, or real, reason to refuse to to answer a simple "yes or no" question.
 
LTC8K6 wrote:
It should be how you are approaching the issue, Sweaty.


So, you're saying that I should think that "Patty IS a human" because...as you just stated...."it should be how I approach the issue". :boggled:

(That is circular reasoning.)


But, nobody has provided proof that Patty is a human.
So, again, why should I think that Patty is definitely a human?
 
Last edited:
Sweaty, just for clarification, are you talking about Patty specifically, or bigfoot in general? I notice you used the term "Patterson subject" and not "Patty" or "bigfoot".

Is the Patterson subject bigfoot? Personally, I don't know. I haven't seen one and the descriptions from those who have tend to vary a bit.
 
Nor were they intended to be. My position on bigfoot is quite well known to you and anyone who follows these threads.


Your answer to this question....

One option is that the Patterson subject may be a real Bigfoot.
Is this not true?"


...is NOT known, LTC.

You apparantly are afraid to answer it.

You said that skeptics consider ALL options.
Is "Patty may be a real Bigfoot" an option??

Don't be scared....it's an easy question to answer. :)
 
So, again, why should I think that Patty is definitely a human?

Hmmmm....you added a word and changed the sentence. Oh well, I guess people are used to you doing that by now. I'll just act as if you didn't do that with my answer.

You can think whatever you want to think, of course.

However, when you are trying to examine the issue of bigfoot objectively to learn the truth, then you need to start with the most likely idea, and eliminate it first. It is most likely a hoax. Same when examining the PGF.

Unless you eliminate the most likely explanations, you will forever be confronted by them when you try to tell objective people about the other possible explanations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom