Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are spot on I believe, WP.

Most people would take a footprint photo oriented L to R with the heel to the left.

However, I think that reasonable people will agree that they match without any help.

It's clear that they match. Footers know that they match too, because they invented a reason for the match. :D
Yes, footers are good at inventing reason. Patterson could be raised from the dead and come on here and tell the world he lied to us all! They still would claim Patty is real! Meldrum and Kranz would explain there reason!
 
Avindair,

Actually, for what it’s worth, there are at least two make-up artists that believe the PGF couldn’t have been hoaxed.


M


http://www.hollywood.com/celebrity/Ryan_K_Peterson/3318289

Utah voices
Bigfoot and the repugnance of truth
By Ryan Kenneth Peterson


"Like everyone, I'm guilty of not wanting to accept certain possibilities.
For instance, is it possible that Oswald shot JFK from behind, despite the exit wound being on the back of our fallen president's head? Is it possible, that on 9/11, World Trade Center Building 7 could collapse like a controlled demolition despite not being hit by a plane? Is it possible that George W. Bush was legitimately elected president in 2000?
And, finally, is it possible that the legendary Bigfoot doesn't exist? I guess anything is possible, but, I'm going to fight against this last one.
This year marks the 40th anniversary of the infamous 16mm footage shot by Roger Patterson and Bob Gimlin in Bluff Creek, Calif., on Oct. 20, 1967.
On that fateful day the two men filmed "something" walking in a wooded clearing that could be one of two things: It either shows the most successful costume ever constructed, or an actual Bigfoot was caught on celluloid.
Somewhere on these frames lies the answer to a fairly profound question: Does a primate exist that is genetically closer to homo sapiens than the chimpanzee - a missing link?
I'm not a scientist. I am an artist who has worked as a creature designer for film special effects. I've had the privilege to work for the best monster maker in Hollywood and the king of gorilla suit construction, six-time Academy
Award-winner Rick Baker.
Now, I can't speak for Rick Baker, this is my own analysis of Patterson's "star." So I'll get to the point: In my opinion, the technology and artistry were not available in 1967 to create such a convincing Bigfoot costume. Even if Roger Patterson orchestrated the whole affair and was able to hire John Chambers, the one special make-up effects man on the planet at the forefront of such technology, I would argue it wasn't enough.
Take "Planet of the Apes" for example. If a major motion picture studio like Twentieth Century Fox, during the same period, with all of its money and resources, couldn't motivate the construction of a full-body, ventilated hair suit on top of a sculpted foam musculature with arm extensions aiding an overall "man/ape" design and performance of such naturalistic nuance, how the hell could a professional rodeo rider named Roger Patterson?
Unless there was an unknown genius of such brazen pretensions, content to live in obscurity, who was willing to incorporate features into his costume design that would set itself up for potential failure - such as making it female, as well as shortening the fur where flaws would be more pronounced and allowing it to be filmed under midday sunlight in the middle of a remote wooded location with no crew or witnesses - I would say it was impossible then and I dare say even today.
Back to the big picture: Humans are a peculiar species. We demonstrate faith in technology on a daily basis - we travel by plane, go under anesthesia, genetically alter the food we eat - yet most of us don't allow technology to disrupt our illusions.
Truth, it would seem, is problematic, even repugnant, because it's perceived as scary and oh so comfortably allusive. What if it's not?
---
* RYAN KENNETH PETERSON is a self-employed fine artist in Salt Lake City and works part time in Los Angeles doing makeup effects for various studios."
 
LTC said:
Most people would take a footprint photo oriented L to R with the heel to the left.

Not always, and that's why I offered corrected Option 1 and 2. I'm not getting enough visual information from the two options to make a firm choice. Presumably, these guys were using 35mm cameras which produce a rectangular frame. Green is seen holding what appears to be a sweet Leica M-series (probably 2 or 3) rangefinder camera. Great stuff for a professional newsman. We all know that these cameras can be turned to give a vertically-oriented frame. There are photos of the BCM trackway that put the footprints into a vertical scene (toes at top or bottom of photo). This is when they photograph the trackway, but not necessarily so when they shoot an individual track. It is unfortunate and baffling why neither Patterson nor Laverty took images that show the Patty trackway with multiple footprints in a single frame. I went round and round with Huntster about that, and he said it was possibly because Laverty had the wrong lens for that. Yeah, right. I said all he had to do was tilt his camera upwards from the famous shot to capture the line of tracks that make up the trackway. Those kinds of images may have been taken by Laverty, but if so, we have not been publicly presented with them.

The famous Laverty MTB photo was certainly taken with a vertical orientation of the footprint. It is typically shown in its correct orientation. All other possible rotations of this image will make you puke on your keyboard. Try it if you dare...
018.jpg


I guess I should have mentioned why things got screwed up with wolftrax's topographic mapping and how he could possibly fix it if he tried again. It looks like he started by mapping Alderfoot, then transferring that to BCM. It should have been the reverse. Start by mapping the BCM footprint (you get an internal topography), then invert it (to show an external topography), and then transfer that to Alderfoot. The grid will need angle adjustment, and when finished you will notice that the grid does not completely cover all of the external topography of Alderfoot. That 'incompleteness' coincides fairly closely to how deeply Alderfoot was pressed into the substrate at Blue Creek Mountain. Brilliant reverse-engineering of hoaxed Bigfoot prints awaits wolftrax if he takes on this new analysis.
 
Its pretty bad when my 4 yr old doughter watches the Patterson footage for the first time and asks, "why is that guy in a gorilla suit?" Its a shame these PattyFreaks cant tell! They reject all common sense! Its obvious it is fake.

I know what you mean .. here is a repeat of a post I made a couple of years ago .. I bolded what I think is critical insight ..


I have never discussed Bigfoot or PGF with my eleven year old son..

The reasoning behind that is a whole nother' story...

He was chasing the cat by my desk , noticed I was posting on the internet, and curiously asked what I was doing.

I said I was talking about Bigfoot..
Without further comment, I said " I want you to look at this..

I rolled the LMS version of the PGF, at the default speed on a 1680 x 1250 display..

I waited till it was over, and asked: " What do you think that was ? "

His reply:

" A man in a Gorilla suit . "

I asked: " Why do you think so much of it was all shakey and blurry ?.."

He said: " Whoever had the camera was jumping around .."

I replied " Well, why do you think they didn't just hold still ? "

Reply: " He didn't want us to see what was really there.. "


He went back to playing with the cat...
 
Last edited:
I pose the question, "As 'bigfoot is a real beast' proponents, can you explain, why do the two main proponents, Green and Meldrum, put forth Wallace prints as evidence of said real beast? Why don't they recant? Is it because too much subsequent 'evidence' is based upon them being real?"

And then I realized, Meldrum's entire mid-tarsal break theory is based upon the Wallace prints being real. He can not discount their integrity or his entire idea crashes to the ground.
 
I pose the question, "As 'bigfoot is a real beast' proponents, can you explain, why do the two main proponents, Green and Meldrum, put forth Wallace prints as evidence of said real beast? Why don't they recant? Is it because too much subsequent 'evidence' is based upon them being real?"

I don't recall Meldrum saying anything about this... yet. Green isn't recanting because he is arguing that Alderfoot did not make the tracks he saw at Blue Creek Mountain Road. Rick Noll rides in that same boat.

And then I realized, Meldrum's entire mid-tarsal break theory is based upon the Wallace prints being real. He can not discount their integrity or his entire idea crashes to the ground.

This is not true. You owe it to yourself to read Meldrum's thesis (now two parts), and understand his basis for the MTB. It's really coming from the Patty tracks (faked by Patterson) and the 'Walla Walla" tracks (faked by Freeman). The Alderfoot tracks do not figure prominently (if at all) in his MTB thesis.

Read this.

And this.

His official entry to scientific papers is the second link. He obviously puts all his MTB eggs into Patty's basket for this one.
 
Parcher-
Maybe you have read this
My point is, that if you have Wallace prints as a hoax, and the prints before Pattersons were Wallace prints, then that means Patterson was drawn to Bluff Creek by hoax prints. Patterson's prints are not much different than Wallaces.

And Meldrum cites in his paper the following:
 
Of course I've read that, Drew. I also understand what you are saying to me. It doesn't make sense, or have logical conclusions with the real situation at hand. Meldrum can toss out anything made by the Alderfoots, and still be left with Patty. It would make no difference if Patterson was lured to Bluff Creek because of Alderfoot or any other faked tracks. The reason is because on October 20, 1967, Patterson encountered a genuine Bigfoot, filmed it, then filmed and cast the tracks it left behind. Laverty photographed the tracks 3 days later. Then Titmus observed the tracks and made 10 casts of consecutive footprints left by Patty.

If a Pattycake decides to toss out Alderfoot, and any other fake tracks at Bluff Creek (even to the extent of calling all previous BC tracks fakes), they are still left with genuine Bigfoot tracks left by Patty. If they think that the Patty tracks are faked - then they are not a Pattycake. Get it?

They could even make a joke that when Patty was farting around on the various sandbars near Bluff Creek, she was laughing at all the fake Bigfoot tracks she saw.

Even real Bigfoots thumb their noses at Bigfoot hoaxers! :D
 
Avindair,

Actually, for what it’s worth, there are at least two make-up artists that believe the PGF couldn’t have been hoaxed.


Mangler --

Thanks for that input. I stand corrected. I'll now say that two makeup artists think it can't be faked.

(Of course, that number is statistically insignificant, but your point is absolutely worth noting.)

Avindair
 
If a major motion picture studio like Twentieth Century Fox, during the same period, with all of its money and resources, couldn't motivate the construction of a full-body, ventilated hair suit on top of a sculpted foam musculature with arm extensions aiding an overall "man/ape" design and performance of such naturalistic nuance

Peterson should know that no arm extensions were necessary. He presumes that it was a sophisticated suit, which was not necessary either.

How does he know it was ventilated?

He thinks the suit is a great looking suit with "naturalistic nuance"...give me a break!

What version of the PGF did he watch? It must have been one I haven't seen.
 
They could even make a joke that when Patty was farting around on the various sandbars near Bluff Creek, she was laughing at all the fake Bigfoot tracks she saw.

Even real Bigfoots thumb their noses at Bigfoot hoaxers! :D

I don't even know if this attempt at a joke is funny. It uses irony aimed at a person who believes that two things exist at the same time... Bigfoot, and hoaxed Bigfoot tracks. If hoaxers are making fake Bigfoot tracks in the PNW (or anywhere Bigfoot lives) with the intention of fooling innocent people, then there is also no good reason why they couldn't be discovered by a Bigfoot first, or later.

The relation of this joke to Drew's comments is based on this. If a Bigfooter wishes to think that all found BF tracks around Bluff Creek (starting about 1958 up until Oct. 20, '67) are just fakes, and they still think Patty is real... then one could imagine Patty herself seeing some of these faked tracks over the years. What would a real Bigfoot do when they see human-hoaxed Bigfoot tracks? Laugh! If anyone should be able to recognize a hoaxed BF track it should be Patty. But her days of laughing stopped on the afternoon of October 20, 1967 when Roger and Bob startled her next to Bluff Creek. She wasn't looking at any fake tracks out there that day. Instead, this poor cowboy recovers from a horse crushing and starts running at her with a camera. Damn, I've been had! No laughing now. She turns to look and you just know she hates being seen, let alone being documented on film. It's a Bigfoot's worst nightmare. Very serious look. Very unhappy.

She loses them and circles around to sit in some ferns. She is watching them, but now it's on her terms. Bastards! Both of you are bastards and so are your stupid horses. I don't like your camera one bit. What? Now you are pouring plaster into my footprints? Bastards! I hate plaster. Don't you guys know that I am supposed to never allow confirmatory pictures of me? You are not allowed to make confirmatory castings of my footprints either. Do you not respect The Boss Of The Woods?! Well, I have a joke on you now. Nobody with any brains is gonna believe you anyway. Hah!

OK, not funny.
 
How does he know it was ventilated?
He's referring to the process of hand knotting hair into a suit. In the US it's called 'ventilation' It's not air conditioning.

I posted over on *BFF about this as it sounds very technical (although it no doubt is a very skilled practice).

LINK

ETA Linky

ETA *HERE as well.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom