Avindair wrote:
And not ONE compares with Patty....as far as "realism" goes.
Bunk.
Save one and
only one makeup and VFX artist over at the BFF, every industry professional who has looked at the PGF has seen a hoax. Remember, Stan Winston is reported to have said he would have fired anyone who would have made anything that looked like that.
The "1967 technology" argument has been demonstrated to be yet another steaming pile of woo. That's been done time and again.
Unfortunately, as long as Pattyphiles keep jamming their thumbs in their ears (since the aural canal has been widened by years of fingers being slipped inside) and saying "Lalalalalalalanotlisteninglalalalaalal!" it will still be a "fact' in their personal mythology.
The character and motivations of the individual who "obtained" (staged) the footage were at best questionable, at worst outright deceitful. (Long's research into Patterson's character in
The Making of Bigfoot is quite damning.)
All
evidence -- which, in our case, means something
repeatable and
testable-- points to the subject being a man in a suit.
Wanna prove me wrong?
1. Bring me new footage of a Patty-like creature.
2. Bring me a body.
No?
Didn't think so.
Suit.
That is the significant point that I made.
No, it's an
opinion and a
belief.
The opinion that the PGF is a suit "beyond the knowledge of man" and one that is not shared by professionals trained and skilled in fooling others with images on film or video.
There are many other examples of creature effects from the era that look not only as good but
better than the PGF. Many on this board have shared them here, and elsewhere. Unfortunately, since the footage is often
in focus and
steadied (to say nothing of being fairly large in frame, and not overexposed) the general look of the examples differs from the suit in the PGF.
Not one other comparable video or photo of a man-in-a-suit has caused people, with reputations at stake, to say that think it may actually be a real Bigfoot.
...because, to date, none of the faked footage had someone like DeAtley pushing it through a film distributor arguably before it was even
created.
The closest we've had that I can recall was the infamous
Snow Walker footage from the mid-nineties. Even though the footage had all of the hallmarks of a fake (anonymous donor, inability to verify claims) until it was exposed as a hoax from the producer, many compared the movement of the creature to Patty. And all of this from a blobsquatch.
As I recall, lots of people were honked off when it was exposed.
Ironically enough, it's still listed on some sites as being a peice of genuine footage. There's a lesson there...
The LMS dvd only analysed the subject of the Patterson film.
Adding a 3D skeleton to a piece of blown-up, stabilized film isn't "analysis"; it's
conjecture.
Observing a bubble in fabric-like "skin" and identifying a "hernia" and not even discussing the possibility of an underpad poking through to a costume isn't analysis, it's
sensationalism.
Heck, not even
asking any makeup and FX houses of their opinions of the PGF isn't analysis, it's stacking the bloody deck.
They didn't analyse the subjects of any other videos or photos.
There is a good reason for that.....Patty is outside of the
ordinary... as far as her "realism" is concerned
...hence, Patty's so-called "suit" is "extra-ordinary".
The suit is very ordinary, for reasons that have been stated repeatedly.
The only thing extraordinary is the zealotry surrounding its "reality".
BTW, has anybody ever traced the money changing hands during the creation of the LMS video?
It's easy for anybody to type into their computer..."Patty looks like a guy-in-a-suit".......but it's extremely difficult to create, or find, a video which can cause people to analyse the subject of the video for years on end, and still consider it to be
most likely the real thing.
Yet more Woo.
There have been many, many,
many examples -- which required genuine research -- providing examples of exactly why Patterson's hoax suit isn't that remarkable. Unfortunately, Pattyphiles perform Olympic-worthy mental gymnastics in order to justify their belief in this piece of footage.
For the record, even though I was never impressed by the PGF (the head always looked phony to me, even as a kid), I held out hope that it was real. In particular, the shine and wear pattern of the hair looked pretty interesting, as did the taper of the leg.
Then I worked on a TV set with an actress in a gorilla (which, for the record, buffed up a 5'1" petite gal into a bulky 5'4" ape) and was surprised to see wear on the fake fur, a nice, healthy "shine", and tightly-tapered calves.
I discussed the PGF with the person who modified the standard suit for the show. I played the LMS DVD for him. His laughter was raucous.
For the record, nearly every major costuming point that Dfoot and others have made he brought up in one viewing of the LMS. One.
(Was he an Oscar winning costumer? Nope. But
to this day he doesn't want his name associated with "bigfoot" because it would hurt him in his job.)
My point: It's easy to sit at a computer and poo-poo the others who have made this determination. It's a lot harder to actually
work on a set with professionals and see how these things are done, only to be told
"No, that's not true!" by people who wouldn't know a grip arm from a boom operator.
Dfoot is showing us all just how difficult it truly is!
Ah, yes, the ridiculous
"Dfoot hasn't made a suit!" straw man.
Does it matter that he's stated that making a suit wasn't his intention? Nope. All that matters is that, if Pattyphiles keep
repeating the charge, it will enter the mythology.
That being said, if you honestly believe, looking at the work he -- and
others -- have done just to provide you with an example of how the suit could be made then nothing short of Gimlin sitting down, holding your hand, looking earnestly in the eye, and saying "We faked this!" will make a difference.
Avindair