Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Texas Bigfoot
View Member Profile Today, 01:55 PM Post #266


Five toes - Saskets


Group: Members
Posts: 582
Joined: 10-May 07
From: Dallas, Texas
Member No.: 6,029



So now the beast that RP and BG filmed was Ray Wallace? I'm officially confused.

Yes, yes. That is our argument. Now shoot it down.

Good grief!
 
Bob Titmus speaking of his first viewing of the PGF at UBC Vancouver: None of these individuals witnessed more than one showing, I believe. (Titmus watches the film only once. His statement is technically false, as some scientists are said to view it multiple times in private upon their request.)

BT: By the end of the day it became apparent that a few of the viewers felt that there was a possibility the whole thing was a very elaborate and expensive hoax. I felt that this possibility was so extremely remote as to be almost non-existent. (Titmus was a devoted Bigfooter, and had previously been on Tom Slick's payroll to find it.)

BT: However, I did have to take into consideration the fact that I believe that I viewed the film through somewhat different eyes than most of the persons present. Firstly I think that a taxidermist will see and retain far more detail, while watching an animal, and is probably far more qualified to recognize anything unnatural, than the average person. (There were university scientists Don Abbott and Frank Beebe present. From Chris Murphy: "The university scientists were under strict orders not to comment one way or the other on the authenticity of the film. To this day, there has been no official comment from this group. The museum people, Frank Beebe and Don Abbott, however, were not restrained. Frank Beebe, although impressed with the film, implied the strong likelihood of a hoax. Don Abbott did not give a personal opinion at this time.")

BT: ...so the following day I went on to California to have a look at the tracks.

BT: My first full day up near the end of Bluff Creek, I missed the tracks completely. I walked some 14 to 16 miles on Bluff Creek and the many feeder creeks coming into it and found nothing of any particular interest other than the fact that Roger and Bob's horse tracks were everywhere I went. I found the place where the pictures had been taken and the tracks of Bigfoot the following morning. (14-16 miles on foot.)

BT: It was not difficult to find the exact spot where Roger was standing when he was taking his pictures and he was in an excellent position. (How could he know this without seeing Roger's tracks?)

BT: Roger and Bob had covered a few of them with slabs of bark etc., and these were in excellent condition. (Only Bob said he did this.)

BT: The tracks appeared perfectly natural and normal. (Nice.)

BT: Nothing whatever here indicated that these tracks could have been faked in some manner. In fact all of the evidence pointed in the opposite direction. And no amount of thinking and imagining on my part could conceive of a method by which these tracks could have been made fictitiously. (Pure Bigfooter Gold :D)

BT: Harry made several tests and observations, one of which was walking briskly beside the tracks to try to match their depth of up to an inch and a quarter and more in places. Harry is a 200 pounder and the best he could do was an imprint of about 1/2 of an inch on the rear portion of his shoe heel and one-eighth of an inch and less on the rest of his shoe imprint. We both agreed, considering the depth of the two imprints and the difference in the amount of bearing surface, that the creature that made these tracks would have to weigh at least 600 to 700 pounds. (The front part of Laverty's work boot print might be deeper than 1/8".)

Was Bob Titmus on Roger Patterson's payroll?
 
Last edited:
Dfoot, could you share any details on what Paul is talking about here?:

Was there name calling and if so, what was it?

Thanks for asking. No, there was no "name-calling" on my part. I invite anyone here to click over to the BFF and actually read the posts I made rather than go by what Paul is pushing.

There was no ban regarding the mention of Scientology as far as I knew. That was something they came up with AFTER I compared the kinds of attacks anyone who brings up evidence that the film is a fraud might have to endure to that particular cult. (*Again, go and read for yourself)

Once I was told in threatening emails from Paul NOT to mention Scientology again, I simply explained to him why I made the comparison and I never mentioned it again on the BFF. So "religion" cannot be the reason for the banning.

I did get a couple of concerned BFF members emails warning me that because I was beginning to get too many people to question Bob Gimlin's version of events the "powers that be" over there were trying to figure out a way to ban me. Since I was not breaking any rules that seemed unlikely, but I never-the-less expected it would happen so I tried to leave as much skeptical info for others to view later as I could before that day came.

I noticed that someone had actually changed what I had written to read something entirely different. I could understand arguing, but that was ridiculous and very transparent. So I pointed out that I didn't write those words at all - though my name was next to them.

When I mentioned this I got yet another threatening email from someone I didn't even know was connected to the BFF. He told me that because I'd responded to a moderator (although I thought the person was just another erratic Patty poster) by informing him that my words had been changed to read something else I never said, this was considered talking back to a mod.

I was told that questioning any action by any moderator was forbidden by their rules. I was warned that my daring to mention someone had taken the time to re-write what I'd said was a violation and that any further statement by me informing anyone that my posts had been changed would result in (*shudder*) banishment.

The last private email I got from Paul was yet another threat about banishment. I basically told him that he needed to allow real discussion from both sides of the PG film question to go on without censorship. After that my ability to post was stopped and he went online to give his excuse.

Here's the funny part of all this --- Some of the quotes he's using are not based on what I wrote on the BFF thread I created. He's quoting from private conversations and JREF posts.

The idea that a "mod" can erase what you've posted and write something different in your name so that it will say what they want it to say is bad enough. The idea that someone from one forum can then use what you say elsewhere on a totally different forum that does allow one to mention Scientology and group-think behavior against you as if it were posted on his forum is just insane - to put it mildly.

He apparently lost it when I posted here at JREF words to the effect of; "If you can find a more cult-like behavior - you buy it." This AFTER he'd ordered me not to say such things. Apparently he was speaking to me as if I were Tom Cruise and he was David Miscavige.:rolleyes:

I'm used to seeing things written by fans of the television shows I"ve worked on that are completely untrue. In fact, Paul found one such untrue fan tale about me and posted it on the BFF on my skeptical thread. What that had to do with a faked bigfoot film I can't see, but what it has to do with handling "SP's" I'm very familiar with.

So... I'll post my info here from time to time and perhaps it'll help prevent some Bigfooters from being scammed. I've heard from a few of them at the BFF that my thread helped them and they do appreciate it. Those would be the actual researchers rather than those caught up in some special club that's based on imagination and fantasy instead of real analysis.

However, cardboard fairies are real. I don't care about confessions. I just like their skirts. I proclaim them real. Say otherwise and you'll be banned. You have been warned.:catfight:
 
Last edited:
Greg, the optical illusions vanish when the photo is displayed with the same orientation that the camera was held.


Optical illusion (foot impression looks raised, and strangely-tilted or squeezed), wrong orientation...
ab071a00.jpg


Optical illusion (foot impression looks strangely-tilted or squeezed), wrong orientation...
walfoot.gif


No optical illusion, correct orientation of original photograph...
d290110a.jpg
 
Greg, the optical illusions vanish when the photo is displayed with the same orientation that the camera was held.


Optical illusion (foot impression looks raised, and strangely-tilted or squeezed), wrong orientation...
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/ab071a00.jpg[/qimg]

Optical illusion (foot impression looks strangely-tilted or squeezed), wrong orientation...
[qimg]http://www.gatzstuff.com/images/Bigfoot/walfoot.gif[/qimg]

No optical illusion, correct orientation of original photograph...
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/d290110a.jpg[/qimg]

William what are these photos from? I've never seen them before.
 
No, there was no "name-calling" on my part. I invite anyone here to click over to the BFF and actually read the posts I made rather than go by what Paul is pushing.

Sorry, I'd have to disagree with you Dfoot. Your last post contained remarks that I would not have made when discussing bigfoot with proponents no matter how much I disagreed with them. I refer specifically to your "geniuses among us", and "totally deluded desperate people" remarks.

I did get a couple of concerned BFF members emails warning me that because I was beginning to get too many people to question Bob Gimlin's version of events the "powers that be" over there were trying to figure out a way to ban me.
Like it or not, it seems your attitude as much as anything is what got you banned.

Since I was not breaking any rules that seemed unlikely, but I never-the-less expected it would happen so I tried to leave as much skeptical info for others to view later as I could before that day came.
Had you done so in a non-abrasive manner, you'd likely still be able to post there. Attacking the argument and not the person is the path to take.

I noticed that someone had actually changed what I had written to read something entirely different. I could understand arguing, but that was ridiculous and very transparent. So I pointed out that I didn't write those words at all - though my name was next to them.
Pointing it out was all that was required. I didn't find it a big deal and still don't.

So... I'll post my info here from time to time and perhaps it'll help prevent some Bigfooters from being scammed. I've heard from a few of them at the BFF that my thread helped them and they do appreciate it. Those would be the actual researchers rather than those caught up in some special club that's based on imagination and fantasy instead of real analysis.
I appreciate factual information, but if someone didn't applaud your actions they were culties? Gee, nice of you to paint all of us with the same broad brush.

Dfoot, when you first started posting over there I read all of it. In the beginning it was interesting, though I'm not sure how much was factual. Having an opinion about something is great, but I eventually quit reading the vast majority of your 'suit-making info' because most of it seemed to be nothing more than speculation on your part. If you find the actual suit that was used, then you'll definitely have my attention, but at present I don't find your opinion any more valid than the next suit 'expert' to trot out an opinion.

RayG
 
Another photo with a funky raised illusion. The reason this is happening is because Bigfooters seem to want to orient footprint photos with a vertical bias, and with the toes at the top. It may not be the correct orientation relative to how the shot was originally taken.

Optical illusion (foot impression looks raised, and strangely-tilted or squeezed), wrong orientation...
index.php


Option 1) No optical illusion, possible correct orientation of original photograph...
aac942a8.jpg


Option 2) No optical illusion, possible correct orientation of original photograph...
1c3c009d.jpg


Either of those could be correct. I believe that the only way to determine which is correct - would be to know if the camera was held horizontally or vertically. The corrected orientation in my previous post can be determined to be correct because it shows bold shadowing. Photos with obvious bold shadows will only appear without optical illusion when the orientation is correct.
 
With the number of people potentially involved with the PGF conspiracy perhaps Roger Patterson was on the payoll of the real mastermind behind the hoax.
 
They look raised to me .. The Boot and the Bigfoot print.. The one with the toes down looks correct to me ..

Nah. Pretend you are the cameraman looking through the viewfinder.

You are (probably) crouched down alongside and above these prints. Everything is normal for this shot...
d290110a.jpg



Now you are standing almost directly above the prints shooting downwards, but you have tilted the camera in a bizarre way (rotated your head and camera clockwise). That ain't right at all...
walfoot.gif
 
Last edited:
Avindair wrote:

And not ONE compares with Patty....as far as "realism" goes.

Bunk.

Save one and only one makeup and VFX artist over at the BFF, every industry professional who has looked at the PGF has seen a hoax. Remember, Stan Winston is reported to have said he would have fired anyone who would have made anything that looked like that.

The "1967 technology" argument has been demonstrated to be yet another steaming pile of woo. That's been done time and again.

Unfortunately, as long as Pattyphiles keep jamming their thumbs in their ears (since the aural canal has been widened by years of fingers being slipped inside) and saying "Lalalalalalalanotlisteninglalalalaalal!" it will still be a "fact' in their personal mythology.

The character and motivations of the individual who "obtained" (staged) the footage were at best questionable, at worst outright deceitful. (Long's research into Patterson's character in The Making of Bigfoot is quite damning.)

All evidence -- which, in our case, means something repeatable and testable-- points to the subject being a man in a suit.

Wanna prove me wrong?

1. Bring me new footage of a Patty-like creature.
2. Bring me a body.

No?

Didn't think so.

Suit.

That is the significant point that I made.

No, it's an opinion and a belief.

The opinion that the PGF is a suit "beyond the knowledge of man" and one that is not shared by professionals trained and skilled in fooling others with images on film or video.

There are many other examples of creature effects from the era that look not only as good but better than the PGF. Many on this board have shared them here, and elsewhere. Unfortunately, since the footage is often in focus and steadied (to say nothing of being fairly large in frame, and not overexposed) the general look of the examples differs from the suit in the PGF.

Not one other comparable video or photo of a man-in-a-suit has caused people, with reputations at stake, to say that think it may actually be a real Bigfoot.

...because, to date, none of the faked footage had someone like DeAtley pushing it through a film distributor arguably before it was even created.

The closest we've had that I can recall was the infamous Snow Walker footage from the mid-nineties. Even though the footage had all of the hallmarks of a fake (anonymous donor, inability to verify claims) until it was exposed as a hoax from the producer, many compared the movement of the creature to Patty. And all of this from a blobsquatch.

As I recall, lots of people were honked off when it was exposed.

Ironically enough, it's still listed on some sites as being a peice of genuine footage. There's a lesson there...

The LMS dvd only analysed the subject of the Patterson film.

Adding a 3D skeleton to a piece of blown-up, stabilized film isn't "analysis"; it's conjecture.

Observing a bubble in fabric-like "skin" and identifying a "hernia" and not even discussing the possibility of an underpad poking through to a costume isn't analysis, it's sensationalism.

Heck, not even asking any makeup and FX houses of their opinions of the PGF isn't analysis, it's stacking the bloody deck.

They didn't analyse the subjects of any other videos or photos.
There is a good reason for that.....Patty is outside of the ordinary... as far as her "realism" is concerned...hence, Patty's so-called "suit" is "extra-ordinary". ;)

The suit is very ordinary, for reasons that have been stated repeatedly.

The only thing extraordinary is the zealotry surrounding its "reality".

BTW, has anybody ever traced the money changing hands during the creation of the LMS video?

It's easy for anybody to type into their computer..."Patty looks like a guy-in-a-suit".......but it's extremely difficult to create, or find, a video which can cause people to analyse the subject of the video for years on end, and still consider it to be most likely the real thing. :)

Yet more Woo.

There have been many, many, many examples -- which required genuine research -- providing examples of exactly why Patterson's hoax suit isn't that remarkable. Unfortunately, Pattyphiles perform Olympic-worthy mental gymnastics in order to justify their belief in this piece of footage.

For the record, even though I was never impressed by the PGF (the head always looked phony to me, even as a kid), I held out hope that it was real. In particular, the shine and wear pattern of the hair looked pretty interesting, as did the taper of the leg.

Then I worked on a TV set with an actress in a gorilla (which, for the record, buffed up a 5'1" petite gal into a bulky 5'4" ape) and was surprised to see wear on the fake fur, a nice, healthy "shine", and tightly-tapered calves.

I discussed the PGF with the person who modified the standard suit for the show. I played the LMS DVD for him. His laughter was raucous.

For the record, nearly every major costuming point that Dfoot and others have made he brought up in one viewing of the LMS. One.

(Was he an Oscar winning costumer? Nope. But to this day he doesn't want his name associated with "bigfoot" because it would hurt him in his job.)

My point: It's easy to sit at a computer and poo-poo the others who have made this determination. It's a lot harder to actually work on a set with professionals and see how these things are done, only to be told "No, that's not true!" by people who wouldn't know a grip arm from a boom operator.

Dfoot is showing us all just how difficult it truly is!


Ah, yes, the ridiculous "Dfoot hasn't made a suit!" straw man.

Does it matter that he's stated that making a suit wasn't his intention? Nope. All that matters is that, if Pattyphiles keep repeating the charge, it will enter the mythology.

That being said, if you honestly believe, looking at the work he -- and others -- have done just to provide you with an example of how the suit could be made then nothing short of Gimlin sitting down, holding your hand, looking earnestly in the eye, and saying "We faked this!" will make a difference.


Avindair
 
Last edited:
Nah. Pretend you are the cameraman looking through the viewfinder.

You are (probably) crouched down alongside and above these prints. Everything is normal for this shot...
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/d290110a.jpg[/qimg]


Now you are standing almost directly above the prints shooting downwards, but you have tilted the camera in a bizarre way (rotated your head and camera clockwise). That ain't right at all...
[qimg]http://www.gatzstuff.com/images/Bigfoot/walfoot.gif[/qimg]

Whether you see bumps or dips has to do with how your brain interprets the light source..

Check it out .. ( an extreme example , but the principle is the same )..

http://www.qualitytrading.com/illusions/crater.html
 
This is a critique of a heated dispute going on right now at BFF between wolftrax and damndirtyape (Rick Noll). We've already broached this subject recently in this thread. Here is pretty much where this thing starts on BFF.

The focus of interest are the Blue Creek Mountain (Onion Mountain) "Bigfoot" prints that constituted an extensive trackway. John Green and Rene Dahinden were there to examine and photo-document the scene. The contention is that these prints were made by the now famous Ray Wallace wooden feet. These Bigfoot print-making tools and the resultant fake footprints are now commonly known as "Alderfoot" because of the wood that the fake feet were carved from.

Rick Noll, John Green, and others are saying that the BCM prints were not made by the Alderfoots. Wolftrax is trying to argue that they were, and that they are virtually a match. They are a match, but Noll cannot "see" it because analytical mistakes have been made by him and wolftrax. Noll goes on to make the bold accusation that wolftrax actually manipulated the photos and his computer analysis. He did not, but you will soon see why Noll thinks this.

The problem with the analysis (by both parties) starts with an incorrectly oriented photo of the original footprint - and only gets worse from there. It's something like a 'garbage in - garbage out' situation. The original photo with incorrect orientation is the first bit of garbage, then the computer analysis adds its own garbage. The result is an argument that would seem to have no resolution.

Here is the photo used for this analysis. It is incorrectly oriented as you see it...
index.php


I believe that this is its correct orientation (I chose Option #1 from my previous post)...
aac942a8.jpg


Here is a photo of John Green looking at these tracks. This shot is significant because it probably shows Green's position when he took the above photo. I think this was taken by Dahinden...
wallacetracks.gif


Here is wolftrax's animation that shows his analysis using computer software which creates a 3-dimensional model of the Alderfoot (using a good photo of the fake foot held by Dale Wallace). The software creates a series of lines (grid) that are essentially a topographic map of the surface of the Alderfoot. It can also create what looks like a solid replica of the Alderfoot using shadows and shading. These can then be manipulated into various rotations and angles and still retain their integrity and 3-dimensional expression. You can see this in action with the animation. Unfortunately, the animation proceeds so rapidly that it is difficult to focus on any single component of it. Also shown is the shot of Dale holding the Alderfoots...
index.php

post-2-1107477084.gif


Now we will see some of the components individually. You already saw the original photo of the BCM footprint in its incorrect and corrected orientation.

Here is the mapping of the actual Alderfoot...
index.php


Here is the mapping of the BCM footprint with incorrect orientation...
index.php


Noll is essentially arguing that the Alderfoot does not match the BCM print; because Alderfoot is too wide, the toes are a different shape, and the bizarre double-balls look different. He is right in a literal sense, but not in a 'real world' sense.

1) Alderfoot is wider than the BCM print: When you see the correct orientation of BCM you immediately understand why it looks narrowed. The camera was positioned and held at an angle that caused this appearance. Alderfoot was photographed nearly 'straight-on'. That alone removes this from an apples-to-apples comparison. When you photograph a dollar bill staright-on it looks like a perfect rectangle. As you change the position of the camera, it can become "narrower" and eventually becomes a single straight line (only the edge of the bill is seen).

2) The toes and double-balls don't match up: This is true, but for a good reason. When Alderfoot was used at Blue Creek Mountain (this specific photo of this specific BCM footprint), it did not sink deeply into the substrate. Alderfoot has a high-relief surface with bold contours at the toes and balls. A shallow application will look quite different compared to a deep one. The software analysis is flawed because it mapped the full surface topography that is visible in the Dale photo. The software mapping has 'no idea' that you are only interested in a portion of the surface topography. That mapping was then transferred in full to the BCM footprint. It tricks your eyes/mind into thinking that you should see the full topography map when you look at BCM. This probably would match if only Alderfoot had been jammed deeply into the substrate at Blue Creek Mountain. Because it wasn't, we only get to see the beginnings of the full potential of the Alderfoot contours at the toes and balls. If you took Alderfoot into your hand, you could lightly press it into a compliant substrate. The resultant impression would look quite different than what Alderfoot would be capable of producing with a deep impression. With a light pressure application, the toes and balls won't match what you see when you simply look at Alderfoot. You 'want to', or 'expect to', see the full expression of these bizarre features carved into Alderfoot.

Conclusions:

1) BCM looks narrow because of how the original photo was taken.

2) The toes don't match because Alderfoot did not sink deeply into the Blue Creek Mountain substrate.

3) The double-balls don't match because Alderfoot did not sink deeply into the Blue Creek Mountain substrate.

The distinctive crack near the heel? Oh, it's there, just as plain as the nose on Rick Noll's face.

PS: This post took about 2 hours to put together. A labor of love. I love the Bigfoot myth!
 
You are spot on I believe, WP.

Most people would take a footprint photo oriented L to R with the heel to the left.

However, I think that reasonable people will agree that they match without any help.

It's clear that they match. Footers know that they match too, because they invented a reason for the match. :D
 
Last edited:
Its pretty bad when my 4 yr old doughter watches the Patterson footage for the first time and asks, "why is that guy in a gorilla suit?" Its a shame these PattyFreaks cant tell! They reject all common sense! Its obvious it is fake. The heels to me are the biggest proof there is. Its a small detail but its the most damning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom