Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
75k$. To be so expansive it must be Unicorn leather. Or maybe specially treated Sasquash leather (dunked 20 times in water under a full moon)...

$75,000 ??? Oh... sorry. I was thinking of the NASI study in which they spent $75,000 and said they were unable to locate a zipper or anything that appeared like it might be a guy in a suit.

The gloves actually cost $7. (*Note to self: Never attempt to type while wearing gorilla gloves):boggled:
 
Final confirmation that "Binocular Man" (with dog) is Roger Patterson.

attachment.php


I was hung up because I couldn't place Roger in that jacket with white collar in any other scene. We still settled for it being him.

Done. Grubby hat and an uncomfortable look. Somebody has a tape recorder going (or sharing a chocolate bar)? I wish it was me. :D
 
Now look at the toes of the 63’ or 64’ (depending on who you believe) Laird Meadow cast compared to the 67’ Bluff Creek cast. One is 16 or 17 inches long (depending on who you believe) and the other is 14.5. I find this overlay quite interesting.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/826447a7d0f70c101.gif[/qimg]

Nice!

Scroll down to Figure 3. Those are the ten Patty tracks that were cast by Bob Titmus - nine days after the filmed encounter. Bigfooters say they show evidence of toe movement. Really? It looks like prints from different sources. The toes aren't moving around, they are arranged entirely different from each other. Some look similar. Top left looks like a big human foot, while top right looks like a gorilla suit foot or some other fake thing.

Scientific paper by Meldrum. Bleh!
 
See, Patterson had Titmus in his back pocket. He only needed to say that the Patty tracks didn't look faked. This was just more of the same thing that was happening around Bluff Creek. Bigfooter makes fake Bigfoot tracks. Another Bigfooter finds them and validates their authenticity. Circle jerk. It was a Code of Honor among the Classic Era Bigfooters. Never accuse your fellow Bigfooter of hoaxery.

Titmus never mentioned seeing work boot impressions around the Patty tracks. He should have seen that because Lyle Laverty and crew were all over looking and photographing those tracks. We have a work boot print (from Laverty himself or crew) right next to the famous photo of the MTB. Titmus mentions (cowboy) boot and hoof prints that were attributed to P&G. No word from him about seeing logging crew boot prints alongside of Patty's. Seeing those should have raised a red flag for Titmus who was supposed to be critiquing them for possible hoaxery.

What may have happened is that Titmus never knew that Laverty had showed up 3 days after the Patty walk date (Oct. 20). He sees these tracks going around Patty's that aren't cowboy boots. Better to just not talk about them.

Here is Titmus' letter to John Green about his visit to see Patty's tracks:

No true investigation of the film was undertaken at the time (or shortly after) the film was taken. The only person who did any sort of investigation was Bob Titmus who went to California and went over the evidence there. Here is a letter to John Green regarding the showing of the film at the University of B.C., and what he found at Bluff Creek:

By the end of the day it became apparent that a few of the viewers felt that there was a possibility the whole thing was a very elaborate and expensive hoax. I felt that this possibility was so extremely remote as to be almost non-existent. (None of these individuals witnessed more than one showing, I believe). However, I did have to take into consideration the fact that I believe that I viewed the film through somewhat different eyes than most of the persons present.

Firstly I think that a taxidermist will see and retain far more detail, while watching an animal, and is probably far more qualified to recognize anything unnatural, than the average person.

Secondly, evidence I witnessed in the mountains of Northern California about ten years ago changed me from a non-believer to a believer and since that time I have spent a major portion of those years, as you know, interviewing witnesses, investigating reports, collecting evidence, casting many, many different tracks, setting up camera and live traps, tracking the creatures dozens of times, etc., all of this was in an effort to capture one of the creatures. All of this experience only strengthened the case of the existence of the creature Bigfoot/Sasquatch.

Thirdly, many years ago I saw one of these creatures at fairly close range and watched it for about ninety seconds before it walked off into the timber.

Almost none of the persons present at the showing of the film had a background of experience like this so it is not surprising that there was some variance in the conclusions arrived at.

Since I know more about tracks than film and generally feel that they will tell me a more accurate story than film, I had a very strong urge to see the tracks that were being made during the time that Roger was shooting his film. I felt that the tracks could very well prove or disprove the authenticity of the pictures. No one else present seemed inclined or able so the following day I went on to California to have a look at the tracks.

My first full day up near the end of Bluff Creek, I missed the tracks completely. I walked some 14 to 16 miles on Bluff Creek and the many feeder creeks coming into it and found nothing of any particular interest other than the fact that Roger and Bob's horse tracks were everywhere I went. I found the place where the pictures had been taken and the tracks of Bigfoot the following morning. The tracks traversed a little more than 300 feet of a rather high sand, silt and gravel bar which had a light scattering of trees growing on it, no underbrush whatever but a considerable amount of drift debris here and there. The tracks then crossed Bluff Creek and an old logging road and continued up a steep mountainside.

This is heavily timbered with some underbrush and a deep carpet of ferns. About 80 or 90 feet above the creek and logging road there was very plain evidence where Bigfoot had sat down for some time among the ferns. He was apparently watching the two men below and across the creek from him. The distance would have been approximately 125-150 yards. His position was shadowed and well screened from observation from below. His tracks continued on up the mountain but I did not follow them far. I also spent little time in trying to backtrack Bigfoot from where his tracks appeared on the sandbar since it was soon obvious that he did not come up the creek but most probably came down the mountain, up the hard road a ways and then crossed the creek onto the sandbar. It was not difficult to find the exact spot where Roger was standing when he was taking his pictures and he was in an excellent position.

I spent hours that day examining the tracks, which, for the most part, were still in very good condition considering that they were 9 or 10 days old. Roger and Bob had covered a few of them with slabs of bark etc., and these were in excellent condition. The tracks appeared perfectly natural and normal. The same as the many others that we have tracked and become so familiar with over the years, but of a slightly different size. Most of the tracks showed a great deal of foot movement, some showed a little and a few indicated almost no movement whatever. I took plaster casts of ten consecutive imprints and the casts show a vast difference in each imprint, such as toe placement, toe gripping force, pressure ridges and breaks, weight shifts, weight distribution, depth, etc. Nothing whatever here indicated that these tracks could have been faked in some manner. In fact all of the evidence pointed in the opposite direction. And no amount of thinking and imagining on my part could conceive of a method by which these tracks could have been made fictitiously.

While passing through Weaverville I had phoned my sister and brother-in-law in San Diego and invited them up to Bluff Creek for a visit after my several years away and also to see the tracks. They arrived at my camp this particular evening shortly before I was preparing to leave. We stayed over another day. Allene was a skeptic and Harry a hard-headed non-believer. Both of them left there believing in the existence of this creature. I didn't try to convince them of anything. I simply took them to where the tracks were and let them examine them to their own satisfaction and draw their own conclusions. Harry has hunted big game all of his life. He has been all over Africa, Alaska, Yukon Territory, Canada, Mexico and the U.S. and stated that this impressed him more than anything he had ever seen in the bush in all of his travels. Harry made several tests and observations, one of which was walking briskly beside the tracks to try to match their depth of up to an inch and a quarter and more in places. Harry is a 200 pounder and the best he could do was an imprint of about 1/2 of an inch on the rear portion of his shoe heel and one-eighth of an inch and less on the rest of his shoe imprint. We both agreed, considering the depth of the two imprints and the difference in the amount of bearing surface, that the creature that made these tracks would have to weigh at least 600 to 700 pounds.
 
Every now and again, something comes down the pike that is really extraordinary.

The whole "inhuman IM index" of the Patterson film subject is predicated on what appear to be unusually long arms. This is clearly one of the core belief systems of the major Bigfoot proponents. I've had Rick Noll tell me personally about the "bending fingers".

Well, just like the "inhuman lower level leg lift" being demonstrated to be well within human capability, we see today the most effective debunking of the "inhumanly long arms with moving fingers" yet:

776647aa1fe2955be.gif


Sadly, I'm sure this will not stop one-note fanatics from continuing to post images of "Patty's inhumanly long arms with moving fingers".

Very well done, Dfoot
 
.but what I'm saying is that that statement doesn't really have any meaning...or carry any weight...if it isn't supported by actual evidence.
And what Im saying is that that position is complete bunk. It is not anyone's job to prove that Patty is a human based on the flawed PGF. The default position is that Patty is a human being, and is up to believers to prove otherwise.

Consider the logic of what you're saying - its like me taking a photo of mars an d then claiming its a UFO. It would be up to me to prove that it was a UFO and bring the evidence. It would not be anyone's job to prove to me it was Mars based on my own flawed evidence.

It's NO different than someone saying "I think Patty is a man". It's simply one person's opinion, which is pretty much worthless, if it can't be supported with evidence.
Nope. Im sure you really wish it were like that, but it really isnt :)

It is true that "Patty is a man" and "Patty is a bigfoot" are indeed 2 different opinions. However, this does not afford them equal rankings in terms of likelihood. I could now claim that "Patty is a mutant carrot". Is it equally as likely? Should you now have to provide evidence that I am wrong?

The word "is" in that default statement, is used in a "definite" sense....as if it is a known. But if someone cannot provide proof that Patty is a man....then they don't really know that Patty is a man.
The world is full of gray areas, but sometimes there are just 2 shades - black and white.

As for what Patty is most likely to be....that depends solely on the true weight of the evidence....for and against her being a real Bigfoot.

Again, no. We dont need evidence that Patty is a human. Believers need to provide solid evidence that patty is a BF.

This is the same logic that creationists use when they consistently ask eminent biologists to debate the topic. They think that the debate will add weight to their own position, and in some ways they are right. It still doesnt negate the fact that theyre talking absolute lunacy.

"Patty being a guy in a suit" is an extraordinary claim....because Patty looks so much like a real creature.
Oh come now. Maybe its what you want to see. To me, Patty looks like some dude in a really bad gorilla suit. Dodgy footage and someone saying "I think it looks real" does not constitute evidence.

You can believe it all you want, but it still doesnt advance your theory to be as equally likely as the simpler explanation that its a guy in a suit.

The fact that nobody has ever been able to reproduce such a realisitic "man-in-a-suit...IN MOTION" speaks volumes about Patty's realism.

I could produce an infinite number of short film segments you would be unable to reproduce fully.

To be honest, I dont really care a shred about the evidence - BF and PGF was case closed for me about 2.5 milliseconds after viewing the film. What I am interested in is your approach to arguing your case.

The "chance" or "degree of probability" that Bigfoot exists depends on the weight of the sighting reports, the footprint evidence, and other types of evidence.

Nope. Given no real evidence either way, the default position wins out, until you bring something real (a corpse?). Until then, you're pissing in the wind.
 
Devnull wrote:
Originally Posted by SweatyYeti
As for what Patty is most likely to be....that depends solely on the true weight of the evidence....for and against her being a real Bigfoot.


Again, no. We dont need evidence that Patty is a human. Believers need to provide solid evidence that patty is a BF.

Why does anybody need to provide solid evidence, or proof, that Patty is a real-live Bigfoot?

I don't understand exactly what you mean by that, Devnull.
 
They really screwed Bob when they made him his new suit lol! Worse yet is the animation footage that's apparantly so bad they don't actually show it as a true movie. Its kind of like an old Warners Bros. cartoon the way of Bugs and Daffy might zip from one place to another. Bob's arm does seem to have done some serious shrinking. In any event they didn't get it right which brings up the question of why they didn't get it right. If the new suit was made to emulate Bob's description then they did good but without arm extensions a longer armed mime is needed to get the arms in scale. Also it could just be me but while Bob's arms are too short his nose seems too long.
 
Last edited:
They really screwed Bob when they made him his new suit lol! Worse yet is the animation footage that's apparantly so bad they don't actually show it as a true movie. Its kind of like an old Warners Bros. cartoon the way of Bugs and Daffy might zip from one place to another. Bob's arm does seem to have done some serious shrinking. In any event they didn't get it right which brings up the question of why they didn't get it right. If the new suit was made to emulate Bob's description then they did good but without arm extensions a longer armed mime is needed to get the arms in scale. Also it could just be me but while Bob's arms are too short his nose seems too long.

The attempted recreation is really a distraction - it doesnt lend any credibility to the PGF at all.
 
I'm new to this, but based on those right hand pictures, the arm doesn't seem to be out of proportion for a normal man. I mean, the fingers extend to about where you'd expect based on the fact that the guy in the suit is hunched.

Also, how many primates besides humans swing their arms when they walk?
 
Last edited:
Perhaps Titmus mentioned the Boot Prints that were all around the BF prints, and Roger said, "Aww don't worry about those, a logging crew came through here and they were looking at them." So he didn't mention it again.

NICE TRY DFOOT, but we can't see your shoulders, you damn dirty hoaxer. :)


Also, there is a hint of what was talked about at the Washington museum last week. I thought the jaw moving was debunked within a week of the Monsterquest episode. http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?s=&showtopic=21820&view=findpost&p=443156
Bill, my father got a chance to listen to Bob Gimlin and Owen Caddy speak last month in Washington. Mr. Caddy showed enhancements of the face in the PG film. My father said that the face was more ape like than human and that the mouth opened and closed. Mr. Caddy said out of respect for Mrs. Pattersons copyrights on the film he was not posting the enhancements online.


Here: http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?s=&showtopic=21820&view=findpost&p=443219 you will find Bill Munns conceding that the shoulders on Patty do not look overly out of proportion for a human in a suit.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps Titmus mentioned the Boot Prints that were all around the BF prints, and Roger said, "Aww don't worry about those, a logging crew came through here and they were looking at them." So he didn't mention it again.

Then you are describing a conspiracy to withhold factual information about what was found on that sandbar by Titmus. What else may have been withheld if Patterson & Titmus spoke to each other before Titmus told the world what he saw?

The famous photo (tightly cropped) by Laverty as you see it on the web and in books...

018.jpg


Same photo with less cropping (full frame?)...

23_5f.jpg


That work boot print in the lower right should be from Laverty or one of his crew members.
 
Devnull wrote:


Why does anybody need to provide solid evidence, or proof, that Patty is a real-live Bigfoot?

I don't understand exactly what you mean by that, Devnull.

Exactly, Sweaty.

Bigfoot is a nice thought to think about.

Pointing out problems with bigfootology is besides the point (and, if you ask me, bad form. How would you -- I'm talking to you, you denialists -- like it if I questioned your interest in pressed flowers, Sudoku puzzles, or Civil War reenactments?).

If we have fun drawing lines on photos, contemplating the differences between evidence and proof, or weighing certain degrees of probability with our imaginary probability-weighing scales (mine's digital:)), then who are you to bring us down?
 
Last edited:
Where is the report that Titmus gave? Is there any mention of boot prints in the report? Was anyone there to guide him? If not, how after 10 days, some of it raining hard enough to flood the creek, could he be certain that these were the same foot prints even?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom