Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
My answering Paul's email by telling him that he needed to change his own behavior is apparently going against the religion.

Paul was the winner who banned me for three days for pointing out that the BFF treated the PGF as a religious artifact. Yeah, real winner, that one.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again: The BFF PGF behavior is a Master's Thesis paper waiting to be written...

Avindair
 
Paul was the winner who banned me for three days for pointing out that the BFF treated the PGF as a religious artifact. Yeah, real winner, that one.

It seems that at some time in the past they started to enforce a strict ban on mentioning or discussing religion. I've read mention of it numerous times in mod posts that warn and stop it immediately.

I think the reason for the ban may be because there are so many religious people on that board, and they are quick to argue about it with each other and with the non-religious. I've seen posts from years ago that show creationists are among the crowd and that can lead to very heated arguments concerning Bigfoot evolution, etc.

Cryptozoology.com actually has a resident featured blogger that is a Young Earth Creationist. The blogger himself is young, and many other posters there are furious that the website hosts his YEC views in the context of cryptozoology.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again: The BFF PGF behavior is a Master's Thesis paper waiting to be written...

Should the thesis try to differentiate between true personal beliefs and pretending to believe? Or, does it simply take the BFF PGF postings at face value? A thesis on Bigfootery role-playing or the real deal? A sociology thesis using the Internet as a database must already reckon with the fact that lecherous geezers pretend to be 16 year old girls.

Watch me pretend to be a cryptozoologist with a chubby for Champ. I announced that I would be pretending. But if I had arrived with an undetected sock puppet, I could have gone on forever pretending to believe.
 
Last edited:
I suspect cryptozoology has a special lure for YECs. Finding extinct species, in their minds, would deny evolution. A real bigfoot, specially if belonging to the genus Homo would "prove" evolution is wrong, for it could not be our antecessor and be still alive. Of course, this is nothing but another evidence of how biased and ignorant YEC folks are.

Aniway, BFF is not the only bigfoot forum where religion is off limits. I suspect this is to avoid more schisms among the community, since such rule presents an obstacle for open dialogue and questioning.

As for the "who really believe and who only pretend to believe", well, at any community created around a fringe subject (as well as in any religion/cult) both types will be present. And you will also have those who believe and think the ends justify the means. These people will lie, cheat and hoax to pass the message. The tools they will use will be things such as the spear that crossed Christ's heart, pictures of fake alien ships and footage of a guy in a gorilla suit...

I agree with Avindair. There's material for a PhD thesis. Actually perhaps more than one. And since its a relatively small community, the specimens could be observed directly in bigfoot conventions, for example. The way beliefs are spreaded, how "facts" and official versions are created and shaped, how leaders are formed, the schisms, the reactions to the infidels, the whole community dynamics can be studied by the WWW.
 
Sweaty I don't disagree whith the informatin you've culled concerning Giganto. But sadly you're casting your pearls before swine here.


You got that right, Crowlogic! :)

I've refered to this forum as a 'sewer of a discussion board' more than a few times.

Here is a fresh example of the sewer-like responses that permeate the "debates" here....

In response to my post to William Parcher, in which I talked about whether or not Bigfoot's existence is plausible.... William had this fine piece of thoughtfulness to contribute:

If you can't show that Bigfoot exists... just grab a dictionary instead.

GOOD stuff from William......no need to respond with anything intellectual, just hiss at me for using a dictionary. :boggled:

I've managed to have a chuckle or two even as my kind of skepticism is being called into question because it dosen't fit the "official" brand of skeptism here at the church of JREF.


That's the ONLY reason to post here, Crowlogic....for the fun of it!

You should see what the skeptics dreamed-up, for alternate explanations, in response to this little animated clip.....

handmove1.gif



This joint is a joke.

BTW....I enjoy reading your posts, Crow....you make a lot of sense! :)
 
Last edited:
Blackdog, I agree. I'm intrigued with flipped scenes, but don't know what to think about it. If there are flipped scenes on 1st Gen copies then we know editing occured. There are still some BFF claims that these are not edited. The burden of proof for that falls entirely onto those with 1st Gen copies; and those making these claims need to show proof.

The real wildcard editing would be cut-and-splice manipulations. People have seen more than one indicator of this during the Patty walk. PGF believers like to say it must be a real BF because we see a perfect walk done in one take. But editing allows you to remove anything you want, or move stuff around. If it took two takes to get the walk right, one of them could be discarded and nobody would be the wiser. The only indication that this might have occured is when you see these edits (instant scene change) - and they are seen during the walk. A stumble in the walk (or major thigh pad bulging at some point) could be pulled out of the true original film, leaving the better part before and the better part after. Make a nice copy of your patch editing efforts, and then tell lies that you are getting a true copy of the true original. The copy will show no cuts or splices in the celluloid. It looks pristine and unedited until you perform the analysis that shows immediate scene changes within the walk.

I can imagine that one particular scene may have been flipped for continuity. You can see it in the above clip. Roger is pulling a packhorse at Bluff Creek and is riding left-to-right. Dfoot says this scene has been flipped, and the correct direction of travel is right-to-left. Now watch that scene in this clip and listen to the narration. At the moment he says, "...suddenly his horse shied...", Roger pulls that horse to an abrupt stop. The action matches the narration, but neither Gimlin nor Patty is there. It's like a cheesy B-movie at that moment - and then we see Patty.

But why the flipped scene? Possibly because in the original orientation he is riding in the wrong direction to encounter Patty. When you look at that scene, it appears that the cameraman is on, or near, the logging road, and Roger is on the far side of the creek wash with a steep hill to his side (same hillside that is just beyond Patty during her walk). To make the continuity work as if Roger is riding towards the Patty encounter, you need to show him riding away from Louse Camp, not towards it. You need him to ride from left-to-right. It's just a guess for that particular flipped scene.
 
Should the thesis try to differentiate between true personal beliefs and pretending to believe?

I think it would make a fascinating study in the creation and subsequent defense of myth structures in small, cult-like groups. All of the ingredients are there:

  • An easily identifiable topic: Bigfoot.
  • The faithful adherents: The BFF members.
  • The article of faith: The PGF is real.
  • The heretics: Skeptics.
  • The keepers of the word: Meldrum, Fanny-Print boy, et. al.
  • The crisis of faith: Long's publication of The Making of Bigfoot.

It screams out for publication and analysis.

Avindair
 
How would a Bigfooter begin to go about proving to anyone that they actually believe that Patty is a real Bigfoot?

Why would a person pretend to believe in bigfoot? Economics?

1) They have a sugar daddy who funds their "research".
2) They sell expeditions where you can go bang on trees with sticks and "call blast".
3) They write books, magazine articles, or produce TV programs featuring bigfoot.
4) They are paid speakers.

But how do you go about proving that such people are "pretend believers"?

With the exception of people who have a vested $ interest in BF, and making allowances that some nonbelievers may be involved in BF for some reason known only to themselves, I take most people at their word when they say they believe in BF. You see, I live in the bible belt and I feel like a lone skeptic swimming in a sea of "everything in the bible is literally true" fundies. If people can believe, against all reason, that the earth was created in six day, etc, etc then I see no reason to doubt anyone's professed belief in BF who are not in it for the easy con and the $.
 
WP/Blackdog, I'm just poking around, turning over rocks, and looking into holes to see what I can see. You never know what you'll find in the details. Something that seems insignificant at one time, may match up with something discovered at another time and turn into a relevant bit of info.

Or not. :D

Crow, good point about the hat.
 
Now look at the toes of the 63’ or 64’ (depending on who you believe) Laird Meadow cast compared to the 67’ Bluff Creek cast. One is 16 or 17 inches long (depending on who you believe) and the other is 14.5. I find this overlay quite interesting.


m :bike:

Click Image?
 

Attachments

  • 776647a753c4ca4af.jpg
    776647a753c4ca4af.jpg
    110.7 KB · Views: 9
WP/LT, I don't disagree that if there are actually flipped scenes in that clip, and I'm not saying there aren't, that they may be important, but since there is no way of telling if they are on the original (after editing) on a first gen copy (after editing) or if they exist only on that documentary we can only guess and that's what people have been doing since the film was released.

Is this the only source of these frames? Were there other documentaries that show these scenes too? At this point I kind of doubt it because we would have known about them by now. I was eight years old in 1967 and my Dad was interested in it and other things related and I'm sure I've seen most of the documentaries and movies but my recollection is pretty poor about them, I probably only cared about the main subject and wasn't worried about dissecting the details.

One thing I'm quite sure of though is that as long as someone can make a buck off the short clip we are allowed to see we won't be seeing anything else, so my point is that if anyone is really interested in debunking the film there are other point that are, or may be, better documented, such as the time line, inconsistencies in the testimony and maybe a paper trail.

I wouldn't waste time arguing with people who don't know anything (Sweaty) or people who wouldn't tell you anything even if they did know (Noll) because we won't learn anything from them anyway. Noll likes his secret squirrel, bigfoot guru standing too much and has been dodging questions for too long to make such a big mistake and Sweaty, well...need I say more? Finger bend? LMAO... And don't even get me started on his delusional view of the MDF.
 
THE LATEST FROM MY HIJACKED BFF SKEPTICAL THREAD ---

I just read on the thread I started for people to leave their Skeptical Info on that I have been banned FOREVER AND EVER. This because I answered yet another threatening PM telling me I would be banned (after I'd already been banned) WTF?
Dfoot, could you share any details on what Paul is talking about here?:

I'm afraid to say that following receipt of a PM from dfoot today, I am left with no alternative but to ban him permanently.

For the record, we gave Dfoot several warnings about his behaviour here, some gentle, some not so gentle. I PM'd him a final warning, and rather than respond with the decorum I would expect from a Hollywood professional, he resorted to name calling, knowing that it would result in him being banned. I guess it was easier than taking up my offer to pay for a completed Patty suit.


Enough is enough.



I'm sure there will be people who will claim that we are 'supressing the truth', or that we are trying to silence him - if that is what you believe then I suggest you go back and read *everything* that Dfoot has said and done since he first visited this forum.
Was there name calling and if so, what was it?
 
Last edited:
Sweaty I don't disagree whith the informatin you've culled concerning Giganto. But sadly you're casting pearls before swine here.

Hit it with your purse, Alice.

I've managed to have a chuckle or two even as my kind of skepticism is being called into question because it dosen't fit the "official" brand of skeptism here at the church of JREF.

Keep chuckling, you're still no skeptic. If you'd like to keep playing pretend, you can bust out the spell checker and give your 'brand of skepticism' a workout. According to you bigfoot is extinct and its range did not extend east of Idaho. So, what did Sweaty's beloved Joyce see in the cow pasture in New York?

http://www.bfro.net/GDB/show_report.asp?id=5245

Of course, if substantiating what you say continues to be too difficult for you, you're welcome to use the 'why do I have to dance to your tune?' dodge.
 
Last edited:
You should see what the skeptics dreamed-up, for alternate explanations, in response to this little animated clip.....
Too difficult for you, huh?:

Sweaty,

Either...

1) Stick your fingers on the keyboard and type the handle of the regular member who asserts that mechanically-controlled fingers were used in the PGF.

And/Or...

2) Stick your fingers on the keyboard and type an explanation as to why mechanically-controlled fingers are the most likely explanation for your two frame comparison if the PGF subject is indeed a man in a suit.

If you can not...

Spare us from ever having to suffer your finger bending idiocy again.
Sweaty appears to think that the two frame comparison he constantly posts somehow makes Patty being a bigfoot more likely than a man in a suit but is tellingly unable to substantiate the belief.

I enjoy reading your posts, Crow....you make a lot of sense! :)
Sweaty enjoys reading Crowlogic's posts and thinks she makes a lot of sense:

I think Sasquatch went extinct.

I do not subscribe to the idea that Sasquatch range extended below Santa Cruz CA or east beyond Idaho
 
Last edited:
WP/Blackdog, I'm just poking around, turning over rocks, and looking into holes to see what I can see. You never know what you'll find in the details. Something that seems insignificant at one time, may match up with something discovered at another time and turn into a relevant bit of info. Or not. :D

You won't get criticism from me for doing that. Your reasons for doing this are the same as mine.

Crow, good point about the hat.

We know that the cast display scene is not flipped because of the position of the jacket buttons. Unfortunately, we can't see the shirt buttons in the plaster pour scene. Assuming that this scene is not flipped, we learn something about Roger (a lefty). He is using his right hand to do things with that plaster that one might think should be done with his dominant hand. I stand firm with my previous warnings about using 'handedness' in filmed scenes and stills as a significant indicator of the person in question.

Blackdog, you will find that there is research and critical analysis done on the PGF here at JREF that is quite unlike that done elsewhere (particularly that of pro-Patty analysts). Some of our factual discoveries of the PGF and ancillary footages seem to have been exclusive to the skeptics on this forum. Unfortunately, finding this stuff is made difficult because of the nature of this forum which is General Skepticism. We put nearly everything about Bigfoot into only a few threads. I have an aversion to creating new BF threads here because they become lost and buried amongst skeptical threads about UFOs, psychics, numerology, Indigo Children, etc. etc. If JREF were to create a Bigfoot subforum, we might see many different topical threads like you do on BFF. The PGF thread here is dauntingly massive. One is forced to use good search skills to find topical discussions within it.
 
Hit it with your purse, Alice.



Keep chuckling, you're still no skeptic. If you'd like to keep playing pretend, you can bust out the spell checker and give your 'brand of skepticism' a workout. According to you bigfoot is extinct and its range did not extend east of Idaho. So, what did Sweaty's beloved Joyce see in the cow pasture in New York?

http://www.bfro.net/GDB/show_report.asp?id=5245

Of course, if substantiating what you say continues to be too difficult for you, you're welcome to use the 'why do I have to dance to your tune?' dodge.

Good morning Kitakaze! You still haven't answered my question to you of why it is important to you speciffically to know why I have to dance to your tune? All you have to do is put your fingers on Mr. keyboard and type out why you are calling the dance here. Come on it'll be fun! I promise I'll read it.
 
Originally Posted by kitakaze

Keep chuckling, you're still no skeptic. If you'd like to keep playing pretend, you can bust out the spell checker and give your 'brand of skepticism' a workout. According to you bigfoot is extinct and its range did not extend east of Idaho. So, what did Sweaty's beloved Joyce see in the cow pasture in New York?

Perhaps she saw you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom