Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, here's what I see after perusing different versions of the clips.

Left to right scene: I see the rifle on Roger's right, and no canteen visible. I think he has the canteen on his left. It's probably easy to switch. This looks correct to me based on that still of Roger and his pals.

Coming at me scene: I see a canteen and no rifle and Roger with the reins apparently in his right hand. I believe this is flipped. That's why we see the canteen and not the rifle.
 
Last edited:
Seems as if the 303 would have been able to dispatch even a Volkswagon lifting S.O.B.



Consider for a moment about which side you'd place the scabbard. If you shoot stock against right shoulder you might want to place the scabbard on the left side so all you have to do is reach with your right hand grab the rifle at the base of the stock and raise it to your right shoulder and your right hand trigger finger is nearly in firing position with little wasted motion.
 
It looks to me like Roger's size is the main problem. Looks like he'd have trouble getting the rifle clear of the scabbard while he's on the horse. It looks rigged for pulling out when you are dismounted.
 
If I flip the scene of Roger riding toward the camera:

Roger rides left to right with the rifle on his right and the canteen on the left, towards the "elbow" branch, then he turns to his right and rides not quite towards the camera, but slightly angling across in front of it. Now we can see the canteen on his left, but the rifle is not visible since it's on his right side.
 
Last edited:
I see the rifle when he rides from left to right in that clip, WP.

I do not see the rifle in either the L-to-R (L-R) scene, nor the Head-On (H-O)scene. The H-O scene gives the best opportunity to see the rifle because he is much closer to the camera, and you get full H-O profiles of both sides of the horse. If that rifle is sticking out at an angle (see 'actors' shot), you are going to see it in the H-O scene.

There are two things that you may be thinking are the rifle.

1. Roger is holding the reins in one hand, which is elevated above the pommel.
2. The coiled rope and/or canteen.

I'm working from three visual evidences. All need to be examined individually and as cross-reference to each other.

1. The 'actors' shot. You see the rifle's size, angle of scabbard relative to the horse's body, and stock butt positioning relative to the horse's shoulder and the saddle pommel. The rifle would be "on top of" the rope/canteen if this scene was viewed from the side (rather than frontal angle). Roger is holding the reins above the pommel.

2. Roger in Washington with the dog. The coiled rope, canteen and chaps are all there. No rifle on the side with rope/canteen. Roger is holding the reins and/or binoculars above the pommel.

3. The Mysterious Monsters (MM) video. I can't find the rifle anywhere in either the L-R scene, nor the H-O scene. I think I can see the coiled rope and canteen in the L-R scene, and a momentary profile of these in the H-O scene. One of these scenes is definitely flipped, but that gear remains visible in both scenes in spite of the flip. Roger is holding the reins above the pommel.

If you still disagree, please lead me to the rifle at Bluff Creek.
 
Wow, LTC. It took me about 40 minutes to think about and compose my previous post. You slipped in about 6 posts that I never saw before the above post. I'll let you sort it all out. :D
 
... and I didn't see your last post above because I was composing my last post above.

We need to synchronize our postings. You, then a time lag, me, then a time lag, etc. etc.
 
Sorry, the train of thought wouldn't stop. :D

Mine can't stop either. I can't see the rifle. I can hardly tolerate the slowness of the JREF server on top of it all.

If you have the ability, please use Photo Shop (or whatever) to put red circles around the rifle in the L-R and H-O scenes.
 
I also see the rifle when Roger is coming towards the camera. Look for the butt of it on Roger's apparent left side. I can see it poke out from time to time.

This has to be correct, imo. It fits the two scenes together properly.

It's difficult to get a good still frame that clearly shows it, though.
 
That's your belief, and you are certainly welcome to it. Why you think you will ever get away with stating it as if it were an agreed upon fact is beyond me, though.


Thanks, LTC....I'm happy...and proud...to state that I can see Patty's fingers bend! It's quite easy to see.


Likewise....you're perfectly free to not see it! It's your head...do whatever you want with it. :)


I also strongly support your right (and everyone else's) to state a "default position" that "Patty is a guy-in-a-suit, until proven otherwise".

The fact of the matter is...it's a completely meaningless statement, unless you can support it with something of substance.

It's just as meaningless as me, or anyone, saying that Patty is a real Bigfoot, if we can't support it with something of substance.

In other words.....ANY "default position" is meaningless....if it can't be supported by evidence. Otherwise...it's just a belief based on personal preference.


I don't see any "fingers" at all, before we get to movement.

I'm sorry to hear that.


For arguments sake, I can talk about Patty's hand appearing to bend like a mitten, or I can even spot you the moving fingers as a fact, but only for the sake of discussion.

Of course, we've been through all this before and you have yet to show us any fingers at all. Just a hand. Yet you keep talking about fingers.

Yeah, I like to talk about Patty's fingers!
I also enjoy posting this little animated gif....:D...


handmove1ag.gif


The simplest devices available at the time could move individual fingers, couldn't they?


Yes. Good point, LTC.

But, I'm wondering why Roger didn't re-shoot the film when Bob H. failed to bend the fingers in the steady part of the film.
As Columbo would say...."it bothers me.....why would you go through all that trouble to put a mechanical device in the suit.....and then not use it in a steady part of the film, so the fingers could be seen bending very easily! It just doesn't make any sense to me." (scratches his forehead.)

And, according to Dfoot....Roger had plenty of time to work with, to re-shoot the film, before presenting it to the public, on the 21st. I wonder why he didn't bother doing another 'take'. :confused:

Does Patty have webbed fingers?


I doubt it.
 
Last edited:
Is there any reason that fingers should move? Unless its somehow a given that primates and humans out of reflex action or otherwise flex their fingers while walking then finger flexing is of minor concern. I mean if they move and it’s a suit wow great suit. If they don't move and it’s a suit boo bad suit. If they move and it’s a real animal well it’s some nice action. If they don't move and its a real animal then its a smart animal not expending useless energy flexing fingers while trying to put distance between itself and the two bozo's that interrupted its day. But let’s go back to the fingers moving and it’s a suit again. Perhaps is Big "diaper butt" Bob H. counting off the paces on his hands until he could get out of that contraption
 
Last edited:
Thanks, LTC....I'm happy...and proud...to state that I can see Patty's fingers bend! It's quite easy to see.


Likewise....you're perfectly free to not see it! It's your head...do whatever you want with it. :)


I also strongly support your right (and everyone else's) to state a "default position" that "Patty is a guy-in-a-suit, until proven otherwise".

The fact of the matter is...it's a completely meaningless statement, unless you can support it with something of substance.

It's just as meaningless as me, or anyone, saying that Patty is a real Bigfoot, if we can't support it with something of substance.

In other words.....ANY "default position" is meaningless....if it can't be supported by evidence. Otherwise...it's just a belief based on personal preference.


Yeah, I like to talk about Patty's fingers!
I also enjoy posting this little animated gif....:D...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/handmove1ag.gif[/qimg]


Yes. Good point, LTC.

But, I'm wondering why Roger didn't re-shoot the film when Bob H. failed to bend the fingers in the steady part of the film.
As Columbo would say...."it bothers me.....why would you go through all that trouble to put a mechanical device in the suit.....and then not use it in a steady part of the film, so the fingers could be seen bending very easily! It just doesn't make any sense to me." (scratches his forehead.)

And, according to Dfoot....Roger had plenty of time to work with, to re-shoot the film, before presenting it to the public, on the 21st. I wonder why he didn't bother doing another 'take'. :confused:


Oh, the irony of the part I bolded. And you still won't admit that there is a wrist band!
 
Last edited:
I also see the rifle when Roger is coming towards the camera.

I see what you see, but the location of the "rifle" (relative to the horse's shoulder and the pommel) is wrong. I think this is the rope and/or canteen.

Look for the butt of it on Roger's apparent left side. I can see it poke out from time to time.

Where is that butt plate located (relative to horse shoulder and pommel) as compared to the location of the butt plate in the 'actors' shot? It's too low. The butt plate in the 'actors' shot is located at about the same level as the pommel. That makes sense for a person carrying a rifle on horseback.

You don't grab for the butt in a quick pull - instead you grab for the actual stock grip which is just behind the trigger. In the event of a "grab-the-gun-and-shoot" situation, you never have to re-adjust your stock-grip-hand (move it from a butt grab to the stock grip position) because you already first placed that hand at the stock grip location, and then you only need to bring the other hand to the trigger before aiming and shooting. Roger has his rifle in the perfect position for this in the 'actors' shot because he is a natural lefty. Grab the stock grip with your non-dominant hand and then pull the trigger with your dominant hand after aiming with your dominant eye. I previously mentioned that he may have intentionally had the rifle on the right side in the 'actors' shot to display it, but this is also the correct side for a lefty. That 'actors' shot is not flipped because we can see Roger's and Ballard's shirt buttons on the correct side. It makes sense that a lefty would put the rifle on the horse's right side. But that is inconsequential towards the effort to determine if Roger is carrying a rifle at all at Bluff Creek.

In all scenes (clip or still), Roger appears to carry his personal gear on only one side of the horse, and in front of one of his chap-wearing legs. This personal gear could sometimes be singular, paired, or the full combination of...

1. The coiled rope.
2. The canteen.
3. The rifle.

It looks to me that if he carries any of this personal gear, it is always on one side of the horse in front of one of his legs. It is potentially confusing and non-productive to talk about 'true sides' and 'apparent sides' in various scenes when we are only trying to locate the rifle. If you can apply tight red circles to the butt plate and stock grip in these scenes.... we could get right down to the brass tacks of our disagreement.

My position/opinions at this point: I can't see the "Roger Rifle" at Bluff Creek. You think you see a rifle; but it is instead a hand holding reins, coiled rope, the canteen, or any possible combination of those. Tight red Photo Shop (or anything) rings located at the butt plate and stock grip will help me. Roger would not want to smash his chin on the pommel when reaching for the rifle.

Go!
 
In other words.....ANY "default position" is meaningless....if it can't be supported by evidence. Otherwise...it's just a belief based on personal preference.

This is just silly. A *default* position is simply the simplest, or most likely.

Its quite fine for someone to say "Patty is a guy in a suit by default unless proven otherwise" because it is most likely. What's simpler, a man made a gorilla suit, or that there is an entire race of hairy bipeds that have escaped our attention for centuries despite our concerted efforts?

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Patty being a guy in a suit is not an extraordinary claim, it is quite ordinary (we know that men, and gorilla suits, exist). The claim that Patty is *not* a guy in a suit is extraordinary, and requires extraordinary evidence.

Stating that any "default position is meaningless" rings of the logic that "god may or may not exist, therefore the chances of him existing are 50%" which some feeble minded creationists dole out ad nauseum.

There is not a 50/50 chance that bigfoot exists, and therefore the default position of Patty being a guy in a suit is very apt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom