Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
A Book Afficionado

NOW --- NAME YOUR FAVORITE BIGFOOT BOOK, AND TELL WHY----

assuming you read any.

Monstro

I truly appreciate books, especially signed editions. If someone could personally suggest where I may obtain a signed book, preferably personally recommended, that would be nice.
 
I didn't mean to offend, with the eskimo remarks. (I admire their lifestyle) It was phrased that way because most statements are shockingly presented. I believe it is legitimate question in the sense that they have a) sagittal crest b) shoulder width c) body type of h. neanderthalensis.
I still call myself indian as opposed to native alaskan, and consider eskimo a nonoffensive term for inuit (or whatever).
I'll now defer.

No need to apologize. I got smacked here one time (but all is forgiven) because I didn't use the word "part" Native American. We are what we are. And we use the terms we're taught. My grandma didn't care about labels...it was what was in your heart that mattered.
 
239 pages and STILL you are talking about bigfoot every day.

Get...............................some...........................friends, you sad .:rolleyes:

Pst, how goes it Sweaty? Still running rings around these buffoons I see.

Edited by tim: 
I have edited three insults or expletives from this one post. You are on shaky ground here, carcharodon. Please desist.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Eskimos were the critters that conducted illegal hunts on my tribe's territory. Their acceptance into h. sapien should be questioned.
Ho...ly...crap.

http://alt.tnt.tv/movies/tntoriginals/glory/arctic/imgessay/inuit003.jpg

http://weblog.leidenuniv.nl/fdr/1948/Holman Inuit Girl (A).jpg

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/VirtualContent/84882/inuit.jpg

http://i.treehugger.com/images/2007-2-7/inuit tea.jpg

I missed the sagittal crests.

Do not hotlink images.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jesus feckin' christ. 239 pages and STILL you plonkers are talking about bigfoot every day.
This sad, angry man hates us non-believers talking about bigfootery. He knows perfectly well why critically-minded people would be interested in discussing bigfootery, 9/11 CT's, psychic scammers, homeopathy peddlers, etc. Even so, because of his anger at skeptics for pointing out the flaws in his precious bigfoot beliefs and frustration with not being able to counter them with reliable evidence he lashes out with insults and ridiculous statements about people being interested in something they don't believe in.

Get...............................some............ ...............friends, you sad bastards.
This charming man, the writer of such classics as:
I haven't even been posting here for months but you sure know when you have been beaten in a debate you pathetic faggot.
Nice.

Pst, how goes it Sweaty? Still running rings around these buffoons I see.
I'm dizzy:

I'm overjoyed at your answer, though...I must say!
I can't believe you actually said you don't see any difference in the realism of the 2 legs. But I'll take it....it'll come in handy for future use!! :)
Apparently Lyndon and Sweaty consider this effective debate.
 
No really, it's coming out!! We've just been delayed due to the amount of historic photos and their color bleeding into the text. It should be out this spring.

Just for the record too, after reading a bit (and knowing full well it will result in some sort of torture from him), anything that historian (aka Neal) says, I believe the exact opposite. In fact, I'd rather not believe in bigfoot than believe anything that he does.
Hi, Kathy. Nice to see you stop by. BTW, just in case it came across the wrong way, my question wasn't meant to be sarcastic. I was actually curious if your book had come out yet.

Couple of questions for you:

The recording of the Tahoe Scream that Neal uses for his 'calling' he obtained from you on a BFRO expedition, correct? By obtained I don't mean that you gave it to him.

Manofthesea was looking for a Native American bigfoot myth. Can you list what you consider to be a prime candidate?
 
Last edited:
This sad, angry man hates us non-believers talking about bigfootery. He knows perfectly well why critically-minded people would be interested in discussing bigfootery, 9/11 CT's, psychic scammers, homeopathy peddlers, etc. Even so, because of his anger at skeptics for pointing out the flaws in his precious bigfoot beliefs and frustration with not being able to counter them with reliable evidence he lashes out with insults and ridiculous statements about people being interested in something they don't believe in.

This charming man, the writer of such classics as:Nice.

I'm dizzy:

Apparently Lyndon and Sweaty consider this effective debate.

He's also been reported
 
I just obtained a tape of the 1996 Harrison Hot Springs BF conference in which Rene Dahinden did a hatchet job on Grover Krantz's book. During Dahinden's speech he said that Patterson ackowledged making tracks and casting them for his documentary. He said Patterson did this to explain how he casted prints and it was months before he took the famous film and it was not in Bluff Creek. This is most likely the film and explains Roger's lack of beard growth compared to the pictures of him holding the casts.

This is both interesting and frustrating. A student of the PGF is continually presented with conflicting testimonies from those principals who had the best access (mostly because of personal relationships and time proximity to the event) to information. Krantz and Dahinden's claims about Patterson's "demo trackway" are similar but also importantly different. Both say he made a fake trackway, did some plaster casting and filmed it - all before his Patty encounter. But Krantz said Roger told him the demo was at Bluff Creek only days before Patty showed up. Dahinden says the demo happened in Washington months before he went to Bluff Creek. Those are critical differences.

Neither person specifically states that footage was taken of the resulting casts from the demo trackway. It would make sense that Roger would want a shot of the casts after drying as part of documenting the process of casting Bigfoot prints. Here's how I do it, and here's what I have afterwards.

So we have these two filmed scenes. One is Roger pouring plaster into a trackway and the other is him displaying two plaster casts (which are obviously Patty prints). We are unable to place these scenes in space or time. We can only say with near certainty that the display scene was not filmed at Bluff Creek according to the timeline given by P&G. If we had access to the original films straight from the processor with no cuts or splices, we could determine the exact sequence of filmed events (at least to say that specific scenes occured before or after something else). But it is quite obvious that the copies of the PGF that we access now are edited from various scenes from different rolls. We see that the casting scene immediately follows the Patty walk scene, but we don't really know that it was filmed afterwards in real time. Same for the cast display scene.

Anyone should wonder what became of the demo trackway plaster casts. Were they ever filmed or photographed? Were they ever publicly or privately displayed or given away? Can any be accounted for now? Were they all destroyed?
 
I know this is hard for you

Hi, Kathy. Nice to see you stop by. BTW, just in case it came across the wrong way, my question wasn't meant to be sarcastic. I was actually curious if your book had come out yet.

Couple of questions for you:

The recording of the Tahoe Scream that Neal uses for his 'calling' he obtained from you on a BFRO expedition, correct? By obtained I don't mean that you gave it to him.

Manofthesea was looking for a Native American bigfoot myth. Can you list what you consider to be a prime candidate?

Can you try sticking to the truth, for a change? What I was asking for was an answer from CN. He suggested myth, and I challenged HIM. I wasn't asking Hairy Man to stand up for Correa Neto. He should answer his own questions.
 
Ho...ly...crap.

[qimg]http://alt.tnt.tv/movies/tntoriginals/glory/arctic/imgessay/inuit003.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://weblog.leidenuniv.nl/fdr/1948/Holman%20Inuit%20Girl%20(A).jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/VirtualContent/84882/inuit.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://i.treehugger.com/images/2007-2-7/inuit%20tea.jpg[/qimg]

I missed the sagittal crests.

Do you consider yourself an expert on eskimo anthropology? They have pronounced sagittal crests, more like homo neanderthalensis.

And crap isn't holy, that is a reference to the crusaders who smeared themselves with the pope's (they thought) feces.
 
239 pages and STILL you are talking about bigfoot every day.

Get...............................some...........................friends, you sad .:rolleyes:

Pst, how goes it Sweaty? Still running rings around these buffoons I see.

Edited by tim: 
I have edited three insults or expletives from this one post. You are on shaky ground here, carcharodon. Please desist.

And yet, kitakaze has free reign to insult at will. Neto also.
 
Last edited:
Can you try sticking to the truth, for a change? What I was asking for was an answer from CN. He suggested myth, and I challenged HIM. I wasn't asking Hairy Man to stand up for Correa Neto. He should answer his own questions.
Why is it necessary for only Correa to provide an example of a myth associated with bigfoot?

There are myths about bigfeet...

Why don't you tell us one of your bigfoot myths? Not a sighting report, but a MYTH.
BTW, Correa did tell you where to find the info you requested:

Please allow me to provide some directions that may help you to educate yourself.

Ever heard of Kathy Strain (AKA Hairy Man)?
She's a regular at BFF. IIRC she's writing a book on the many Native American myths that were incorporated in to current bigfoot lore. Try using the search function at JREF (she posted here for a while) or at BFF. You'll find plenty of mythical creatures that may be correlated with bigfoot.

Even tough you already asked (and received an answer) about South American myths that are interpreted by cryptozoologists as bigfoot-like creatures, I will suggest performing a search at JREF forum with the word "mapinguari" (mapinguary, as you can find at some sites, is an old spelling).
 
Do you consider yourself an expert on eskimo anthropology? They have pronounced sagittal crests, more like homo neanderthalensis.
I did not know that some Inuit males have sagittal crests. Now I do:

http://www.trueorigin.org/skull1470.asp

Comparative lateral skull profiles of the Taung ‘Child’ and juvenile chimps bear an uncanny likeness to each other, while the latest profiles of East Turkana habilines such as ER 1470 and KNM–ER 1813 appear to reflect an increasing simian appearance, accompanied by morphological shrinkage.26 Comparisons of KNM–ER 1813 and the skull of a pygmy chimpanzee are instructive.27 These interpretations are compatible with the remarkable lack of chimp and gorilla forms in the fossil record. It strongly supports Pliocene and Pleistocene australopithecines being ancestral not to humans but to modern African pongids. Strong nuchal cresting28 is present in ER 1470, ER1805, and to a lesser extent in ER 1813. It is interesting to note that the development of saggital crests in living chimpanzees is not altogether common, and is generally restricted to males of the species. Indeed, saggital crests are not particularly diagnostic, since they can be found in some Inuit (Eskimo) males.
I thought you were wrong yet I was the one that was mistaken. I apologize. I do, however, very strongly object to your questioning the humanity of the Inuit.

BTW, I searched for images of an Inuit with a sagittal crest but could not find any. Do you know of any?
 
I did not know that some Inuit males have sagittal crests. Now I do:

http://www.trueorigin.org/skull1470.asp

I thought you were wrong yet I was the one that was mistaken. I apologize. I do, however, very strongly object to your questioning the humanity of the Inuit.

BTW, I searched for images of an Inuit with a sagittal crest but could not find any. Do you know of any?

Not off hand. I apologized for the way that I phrased the remark. And I explained myself also. It is a legitimate question. I am not questioning their humanity, only our understanding of 'human' evolution. I would respect the eskimos even more if it were found that they were carrying neanderthal genes. That would be a major anthropological development also.

But, what tribe do you ascribe those photographs to?
 
Not off hand. I apologized for the way that I phrased the remark. And I explained myself also.
I didn't quite understand the explanation:
It was phrased that way because most statements are shockingly presented.

It is a legitimate question. I am not questioning their humanity, only our understanding of 'human' evolution. I would respect the eskimos even more if it were found that they were carrying neanderthal genes. That would be a major anthropological development also.
If you believe there is a Neanderthal/Inuit connection and you think it's an interesting prospect then I would suggest starting a thread on the subject in the Math, Medicine, Science, and Technology section. You are bound to learn much.

But, what tribe do you ascribe those photographs to?
I wouldn't know just by looking but I might be able to find out. Is there a point?
 
This is both interesting and frustrating. A student of the PGF is continually presented with conflicting testimonies from those principals who had the best access (mostly because of personal relationships and time proximity to the event) to information. Krantz and Dahinden's claims about Patterson's "demo trackway" are similar but also importantly different. Both say he made a fake trackway, did some plaster casting and filmed it - all before his Patty encounter. But Krantz said Roger told him the demo was at Bluff Creek only days before Patty showed up. Dahinden says the demo happened in Washington months before he went to Bluff Creek. Those are critical differences.

Neither person specifically states that footage was taken of the resulting casts from the demo trackway. It would make sense that Roger would want a shot of the casts after drying as part of documenting the process of casting Bigfoot prints. Here's how I do it, and here's what I have afterwards.

So we have these two filmed scenes. One is Roger pouring plaster into a trackway and the other is him displaying two plaster casts (which are obviously Patty prints). We are unable to place these scenes in space or time. We can only say with near certainty that the display scene was not filmed at Bluff Creek according to the timeline given by P&G. If we had access to the original films straight from the processor with no cuts or splices, we could determine the exact sequence of filmed events (at least to say that specific scenes occured before or after something else). But it is quite obvious that the copies of the PGF that we access now are edited from various scenes from different rolls. We see that the casting scene immediately follows the Patty walk scene, but we don't really know that it was filmed afterwards in real time. Same for the cast display scene.

Anyone should wonder what became of the demo trackway plaster casts. Were they ever filmed or photographed? Were they ever publicly or privately displayed or given away? Can any be accounted for now? Were they all destroyed?

Dahinden pointed out how fast Krantz was to proclaim tracks real when every other researcher thought they were fake, especially Paul Freeman's various tracks. Even when tracker Joel Hardin told him they were fake, Krantz ignored him because he fell for the fake dermal ridges.

Yes, it would be nice to see Patterson's admitted fake tracks and compare them to the Bluff Creek Patty tracks. What would be the odds of him making tracks that look remarkably like the Patty tracks?

I don't think the differences are major between accounts, we have established that Patterson could and did make fake tracks for whatever reason. Remember how Hieironimus said when he left Bluff Creek Roger and Bob were going to lay down fake tracks?

This tape from 1996 also has a speech by John Green including various casts from Bluff Creek over the years 58 to 67. I was surprised to see the Ray Wallace double ball cast that years later was exposed by his family.
 
..... But it is quite obvious that the copies of the PGF that we access now are edited from various scenes from different rolls. We see that the casting scene immediately follows the Patty walk scene, but we don't really know that it was filmed afterwards in real time. Same for the cast display scene. ....
This is a good time to note, that while proponents like to talk about the ' 1st reel ' and the ' 2nd ' reel, and even go so far as to say

" THE SECOND FILM ROLL was definitely shown at UBC [Univ. of British Columbia] on October 26, 1967 "....

No complete roll of film has been brought forth in forty years, as far as we can tell..

We hear claims of various people, including John Green, as having a first generation copy.. but of what ? Just the ~ 23 feet of footage that shows Patty ?

That is the only ( for the most part ) continuous segment of film we have been shown .. With no indication ( other than anecdotal ) of where it may have been located within a longer piece of film ..
 
After 239 pages, this seems to be an exercise in spinning our wheels. In my opinion, no matter the truth of the film, real or hoax, it does not disqualify from what I saw 10 years ago on a desolate highway or the thousands of reports that are in various databases. Certainly, a good number of those reports can be attributable to hoaxes or misidentifications or wishful thinking or hallucinations, but as John Green pointed out in his book Sasquatch: The Apes Among Us
if just ONE of these stories is true, than it validates the whole subject matter and should be pursued. This film for better or worse has garnered a great deal of attention (maybe too much attention) and in my opinion should be put in the vault and locked away for about another ten years till the 50th anniversary and the current forms of evidence should be explored and examined. The closest we came recently was that DNA sequence taken from that screwboard at Snelgrove Lake in the Canadian Province of Ontario which came out to have mostly human DNA except for one Nucleotide of Polymorphism which was Chimpanzee. Of course, there is always the contamination factor because of the galvanization on the screws, and the fact that the board was left outside for 2 years. Plus from what I have found out, that particular location is not as remote as it was portrayed to be; apparently there is a First Nations reservation about 9 miles from the location of that cabin, and it is entirely possible that a human stepped on that board and destroyed that cabin. I am not saying now that that DNA was from a Sasquatch or that a Sasquatch destroyed that cabin. It seemed promising until I found out that there was a reservation close by. Pretty much, since that DNA proves nothing, we as Bigfooters are back to Square One. I would love if that DNA was not so questionable and could be the absolute proof, but I can't say that with any authority, unfortunately. But I as a researcher will continue to press on to find that one piece of the puzzle that proves once and for all that these hairy bipeds exist, and I think that is what all Bigfooters should do. Just my 2 cents.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom