Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
But I as a researcher will continue to press on to find that one piece of the puzzle that proves once and for all that these hairy bipeds exist, and I think that is what all Bigfooters should do.

And why would your continued research be more than " just spinning your wheels ', in the absence of better evidence than has been collected so far ?

Meanwhile the purpose of this thread is to discuss the pros and cons of this film ..


What's your opinion, and why ?
 
... But I as a researcher will continue to press on to find that one piece of the puzzle that proves once and for all that these hairy bipeds exist, and I think that is what all Bigfooters should do. Just my 2 cents.
Well said, bf2006 and good luck in your search. You already know how we think it'll turn out so I'll spare you. I would though be interested to hear about what you saw on the highway. BTW, your posts thus far have been a breath of fresh air compared to many of the proponents we've been hearing from lately. You're a benefit to your cause.

ETA: Woops. Missed this part:
After 239 pages, this seems to be an exercise in spinning our wheels.
That part I disagree with. If you look at the things we've learned over the last two years with this thread, I'd say it's anything but an excercise in futility.
 
Last edited:
OK, well, I think what I saw on that highway was a Sasquatch and not a guy in a suit, because it was absolutely massive and muscular and stood about 7 1/2-8 feet tall. My opinion on the P/G Movie is that I do not think the technology was available in 1967 to make a sophisticated suit such as is allegedly shown in the film, but I could be wrong. I realize I am fighting an uphill battle with most of you here, but it does not deter me from my research and my belief that it will come out for the better for Bigfooters in the end. I completely respect your opinions and your rights to your opinions even if I do not necessarily agree with them. I do not mind diverse opinions or ones which are contrary to my own. I can put the link to my sighting reports in here if y'all wish. In fact, here it is: http://www.geocities.com/giantape20042000/Mysightingreports.html My first sighting I am a bit dubious of because it COULD have been a guy in a suit. The second one, well, there is about a 95% chance I saw an actual Sasquatch. Hope you guys enjoy reading those reports. Well, Kitikaze, what I meant by that statement was that neither side seems to be gaining an inch of ground for their side in the debate over this film. Oh, and I did promise you guys this bit of news a few months ago-I spoke to Bob Gimlin back in September by telephone, and he confirmed to me that he had NOT taken a polygraph, that John Freitas mixed him up with Roger Patterson, and he does not do interviews anymore out of respect to his wife.
 
Last edited:
My opinion on the P/G Movie is that I do not think the technology was available in 1967 to make a sophisticated suit such as is allegedly shown in the film, but I could be wrong.
What do you see in the film that you think could not be done in 1967? I think we've shown countless times that such an argument is invalid. We don't really consider too low, hairy cans as being sophisticated.

I realize I am fighting an uphill battle with most of you here, but it does not deter me from my research and my belief that it will come out for the better for Bigfooters in the end.
As long as you acknowledge that there is no reliable evidence thus far for bigfoot in your continued search (you already did that in your previous post) then there really is no battle. I can tell you I think you're wasting your time in your search but why should I? It won't stop you and if the search for bigfoot gets you into the forest and gives you a better understanding of nature then who am I to complain? I mean I could say that I wish it didn't take mythical creatures to get people into nature but that's not going to change the appeal of bigfoot.

My first sighting I am a bit dubious of because it COULD have been a guy in a suit. The second one, well, there is about a 95% chance I saw an actual Sasquatch. Hope you guys enjoy reading those reports.

Sighting Report: Cherokee County, Georgia, Woodstock
Date: 1-31-84
Time: around 10:00 P.M. EST
Witness: Henry M.
Henry saw a large, rust-brown-colored Sasquatch-type creature, standing approximately 8 feet tall, behind a residence, standing under a porchlight. The creature's face was apelike and humanlike, flat nose, thin slit for lips and large black eyes.

Terrain: Wooded, mountainous region
Activities of witness: Standing on elevated back patio, watching creature 50 yards away at bottom of hill; witness left first.


Sighting Report: Bolivar County, Mississippi, 3 miles south of Shaw, on Highway 61
Date: 1-13-98
Time: 1:15 A.M. CST
Witness: Henry M.
Henry saw a large, dirty-white-colored Sasquatch-type creature walking across the highway approximately 150 yards ahead of him from left to right. When he reached the point where the creature had crossed, saw large, approximately 7 1/2-8 foot tall creature standing in a ditch with its back turned. Witness saw creature for approximately 15 seconds.

Terrain: 4-lane highway, going towards wooded area
Activities of witness: Driving north from Greenville, Mississippi towards the town of Shaw

My first question on first reading is why did you leave first in the first case? Second is why do you think the second case is more credible when you saw more detail in the first? I'm not saying it doesn't make sense but I'd like to know exactly why you think so. Third is how did you verify the height estimate?

Well, Kitikaze, what I meant by that statement was that neither side seems to be gaining an inch of ground for their side in the debate over this film.
I don't know about you but any doubts I had went out the window when William pointed out that Heironimus was in the film. BF proponents often say that nothing short of a body will suffice for us and that even then it might not. I think even if Heironimus came up with a suit that matched what's in the film, you'd have believers unwilling to give up

Oh, and I did promise you guys this bit of news a few months ago-I spoke to Bob Gimlin back in September by telephone, and he confirmed to me that he had NOT taken a polygraph, that John Freitas mixed him up with Roger Patterson, and he does not do interviews anymore out of respect to his wife.
"No, I haven't taken a polygraph and don't ask." Got it.
 
What do you see in the film that you think could not be done in 1967? I think we've shown countless times that such an argument is invalid. We don't really consider too low, hairy cans as being sophisticated.

As long as you acknowledge that there is no reliable evidence thus far for bigfoot in your continued search (you already did that in your previous post) then there really is no battle. I can tell you I think you're wasting your time in your search but why should I? It won't stop you and if the search for bigfoot gets you into the forest and gives you a better understanding of nature then who am I to complain? I mean I could say that I wish it didn't take mythical creatures to get people into nature but that's not going to change the appeal of bigfoot.





My first question on first reading is why did you leave first in the first case? Second is why do you think the second case is more credible when you saw more detail in the first? I'm not saying it doesn't make sense but I'd like to know exactly why you think so. Third is how did you verify the height estimate?

I don't know about you but any doubts I had went out the window when William pointed out that Heironimus was in the film. BF proponents often say that nothing short of a body will suffice for us and that even then it might not. I think even if Heironimus came up with a suit that matched what's in the film, you'd have believers unwilling to give up

"No, I haven't taken a polygraph and don't ask." Got it.

Well, I left first because I was scared. LOL I think the second case is more credible because there were people in that Georgia neighborhood who knew of my interest in Bigfoot and could have taken advantage of that. The second sighting was on a highway in front of total strangers' house, and i doubt any 8-foot tall people are living in that area with a dirty-white gorilla suit. As to height, well, I just kind of compared it to the size of the home it took place in front of and got the height estimate from that. Hope that answers your questions.
 
Well, I left first because I was scared.
Fair enough but weren't you on a patio? Also I think your mention of people in the area knowing about your interest in BF explains a lot but if you had an interest in bigfoot and POW, there's one! wouldn't that be all the more reason for you not to take off?
The second sighting was on a highway in front of total strangers' house, and i doubt any 8-foot tall people are living in that area with a dirty-white gorilla suit.
Did you ask the residents if they've seen any dirty-white 8ft gorillas? And on top of that, it's '98, you've been into bigfoot for forever, you think you may have seen one in Georgia, you're driving on the highway in Mississippi not even in the forest, and POW, there's a big, white one standing in front of somebody's house and you... keep driving?:boggled:
 
Last edited:
It came from Wikipedia

The closest we came recently was that DNA sequence taken from that screwboard at Snelgrove Lake in the Canadian Province of Ontario which came out to have mostly human DNA except for one Nucleotide of Polymorphism which was Chimpanzee.

For more on why the DNA results are highly suspect, please check these out.

Part of the Bigfoot Wikipedia entry notes:

Indeed, many scientists insist that the breeding population of such an animal would be so large that it would account for many more purported sightings than currently occur, making the existence of such an animal an almost certain impossibility.

However, this is uncited (but still very interesting).

And if we go to the entry on the P/G film:

Patterson claimed to have screened the film for unnamed technicians "in the special effects department at Universal Studios in Hollywood ... Their conclusion was: ‘We could try (faking it), but we would have to create a completely new system of artificial muscles and find an actor who could be trained to walk like that. It might be done, but we would have to say that it would be almost impossible'"(Hunter and Dahinden, 119).

Wait, Patterson is the one who said this? If this is indeed correct, then the whole story just lost all of its credibility. Interestingly enough, I had thought this claim had been from Ivan Sanderson. Here's a quote from chapter 5 of Sanderson's book More "Things":

What all these true experts in design, delusion (legitimate) and technology have told me is simply this: "We have been asked if we could make a suit like the one in this film-strip. Our answer is 'Yes'--but given two things: time and a lot of money and a copy of the film to copy from." This is the point. Anybody can make a "King Kong", or a gorilla, or a Frankenstein monster provided they know what the producer wants, but they cannot and will not attempt to make a "something" that nobody has previously thought of. In this case, they one and all have pointed out that in view of the way in which the muscles moved reciprocally under the skin that they would have had to design a whole new set of muscles, somehow inflatable and controlled by the actor wearing the suit. These muscles would have to be moved in a manner quite different from his own, and quite differently from that of a gorilla or a "King Kong." To invent these from a still drawing, such as Kunsler's mentioned above, is difficult even for anatomists with a lifetime knowledge of pongid and hominid musculature and their movements. If then, this film is of a man wearing a "monkey-suit", whoever made it must have had very remarkable knowledge of both ape and human anatomy and also that of ABSMs. Just where did he get this?

So who showed the film to people at Hollywood? Sanderson or Patterson?

I should also note that this chapter has Bob Gimlin saying that Patty ran away, with contradicts his statement in that "Mysterious World" clip that was posted earlier.

From a portion of the P/G film entry's talk section:

Before the film was edited, the figure went from right to left, then there were several blank frames, then the figure walked from left to right. This proves that the film was shot in two takes and that the so-called Bigfoot is actually a human actor in a costume.

I believe the so-called "blank frames" were already discussed here, but what's this about the change in direction?

Also:

Reply 9: Actually, the arms, as measured from shoulder to wrist, match human arms, which is why Bob Heironimus has the same proportions as the creature as is clear from a video capture of his Bigfoot acting. The reason the arms seem too long to be human in the eyes of many supporters of the film’s authenticity is that the distance from wrist to fingertip is long, but this can indeed be reproduced with prosthetics.

This section notes that John Green is the one who screened the film for a Disney executive. I also recommend reading the other parts of the talk section.
 
From wikipedia's entry on formal studies of bigfoot:

In 2007, the History Channel aired a series called Monster Quest. The series was formed to investigate cryptozoologic monsters such as the bigfoot and sasquatch. In November 2007, two episodes were aired about the bigfoot phenomena. The first episode was about sasquatch in the Canadian forests, where many people claim to have seen the sasquatch. A team of people was sent to the Canadian forests to investigate what was happening. During one night near their cabin, the team heard rocks being thrown at their cabin. Cameras did record sounded of rocks being thrown. The next day, the team found several rocks on the roof of the cabin. The team found possible hair and blood of the animal. Biological tests concluded that the hair test was inconclusive, however the blood test concluded that the animal is a link between man and chimpanzee.
And it's entry on Monster Quest:
Does Canada have its own Bigfoot? Owners of a fly-in fishing cabin report attacks by an unknown creature. Can DNA tests on blood and tissue from the alleged beast reveal its true identity? The test results will surprise you. The best evidence available will be examined, from pictures and video, to hair and bones. Scientists will be brought in to tell viewers what the evidence reveals. Discover the truth behind these beasts and take a scientific look at legendary creatures around the world.
Results: DNA evidence of some unknown animal that is a cross between human and ape.
BTW, did anybody else feel a pang of dumbness at the "Does Canada have its own Bigfoot?"?
 
Chambers was usually called in to make something that looked pretty good close up and in focus. Like turning a little boy into a Dr. Smith look-a-like. "Patty" was an embarrassing joke - not something one would brag about (as alleged by fanatics). All of the top creature fx people agree on this.

Patty was just as John Vulich said it was; a quick thrown together job. It's what's known as "cannabilizing" a suit. Mask from one place. Body from another. Paint. Add hands, feet and hair. Rent it.

Patterson and Al DeAtley made a ton of money off the footage by selling Roger as the only man to ever film a live Bigfoot - just as the advert DeAtley paid for says.

Why is Patty somehow better than the Gorn with hair? Is it the out of focus shaky footage or the smooth-talking con man selling it? Is it the paddle foot dangling? Is it the obvious wrinkling above the thigh?

The "expert" often quoted from Disney is nothing of the sort. He was an exec in charge of cartoonists. He'd never touched a creature suit in his life. Real experts all agree... it's a suit with problems.

I can see what Vulich and others talked about now that I've looked into it. Why do people deliberately post photos of suits that have no resemblance to Patty as if it were some "best attempt by Hollywood" to duplicate Patty? Vulich never thought in his wildest dreams that anyone would ever look at the red hair suit (with a hand-like foot no less) and keep misunderstanding what it is or what the demo was about. It's fascinating to see how such thought processes go on.
Currently I'm trying to figure out why Patty fans think that if someone makes a suit with lots of hair (like those ape suits they keep showing) they also seem to think no one can build anything that has less hair - yet the Gorn and other things show that was not true at all. Strange.

I'm also attempting to comprehend why the man in this gorilla suit has such a long body and such short legs. By Patty research standards it's impossible for him to fit into this suit. Let's draw lines on the pic or make a CGI gorilla skeleton for him. Cartoons seem to help us make Patty real.

Anyway... back to work for a couple of days. If anyone finds Patty before I get back please email me.
 
Heironious digs what he thinks is a believable Bigfoot costume, out of the trunk of his car, just to show everyone how easy it is to duplicate the P-G Bigfoot. Apparently, he does not realize what a fool he is making of himself. But the skeptics here, should nominate him for an OSCAR, and erect a statute in his honor in Yakima Washington. Or better yet, they can change this website to the Bob Heironious Educational Foundation site. And you can all send Bobby a donation for him to go back and get his GED, so that he can someday pass an I.Q. test. Any I.Q. test. And you can also make him the keynote speaker at the annual Skeptics Convention! Except he won't be able to read his speech, so he will most likely just have to make something up. Naw, Bobby wouldn't make anything up. Tell me it isn't so!
 
Last edited:
Naw, Bobby wouldn't make anything up. Tell me it isn't so!

Heironimous has numerous witnesses that support his version of events -- people who claim he SHOWED THEM the costume. Patterson and Gimlin have no witnesses to support them.

Also, Herionimous has passed a polygraph test. In forty years, Gimlin has never taken one. Why?

Gimlin and Al DeAtley and Patricia Patterson went to court over the profits from the film in the mid-1970s. They reached a settlement, the details of which were kept confidential. Why confidential? Was part of that settlement an agreement that Gimlin could never reveal the film was a hoax?
 
Do you consider yourself an expert on eskimo anthropology? They have pronounced sagittal crests, more like homo neanderthalensis.

And crap isn't holy, that is a reference to the crusaders who smeared themselves with the pope's (they thought) feces.


Just as a friendly aside, there is more to homo spaiens neanderthalis than the crest, they also have the eye ridges and the bulge at the back of the skull.

Olga Sofer-Babyshef did point out in class that morphologically the body type of h.s.n. was more cold adapted like those of the northern peoples. But they could also pick up a Volkswagen bug one handed.

:)
 
Not off hand. I apologized for the way that I phrased the remark. And I explained myself also. It is a legitimate question. I am not questioning their humanity, only our understanding of 'human' evolution. I would respect the eskimos even more if it were found that they were carrying neanderthal genes. That would be a major anthropological development also.

But, what tribe do you ascribe those photographs to?


Lumpers believe that HS neanderthalis and HS sapiens are the same species, expecialy since there is a site in Israel that might indicate a time period of mixed morphology before the advent of modern HS sapiens.

Moderate splitters think that HS neanderthalis is a local population seperated during the ice ages.

Extreme splitters feel HS neanderthalis is a seperate species from HS sapiens.

All modern HS sapiens are almost identical geneticaly speaking. Just like wolves and dogs.
 
Last edited:
After 239 pages, this seems to be an exercise in spinning our wheels. In my opinion, no matter the truth of the film, real or hoax, it does not disqualify from what I saw 10 years ago on a desolate highway or the thousands of reports that are in various databases. Certainly, a good number of those reports can be attributable to hoaxes or misidentifications or wishful thinking or hallucinations, but as John Green pointed out in his book Sasquatch: The Apes Among Us

Perceptions are real, the attributions of the cause of the perceptions can be misleading.. I met an anthrolopologist who was atatcked by a were jaguar in central america, and he also saw blue lights and heard voices in africa.

The human perception is a wonderful thing , yet we must be careful is ascribing the causation of the perceptions.

I have seen many a strange thing in the world. Some have valid causitive factors some are products of perception.

The coolest was when i was in a forest after dark, just after the start of twilight. I saw this critter and heard this critter, I would have sworn that it was the size of a large dog. It was a beaver.

Or when i was taking a moonlight walk in a forest very cool and ocean like. I had the bejeeps cared out of me by a buck deer giving me a warning. The deer looked like pup tents while they were resting on the ground.

I sure was charged up and scared however.

I have seen people who weren't there, I have met the spirit world and journeyed in it. Those are valid perceptions, but to attribute causation is another matter.
 
Try looking in the mirror and retyping the above.

...snip...

No.
It was a clear reflex of your previous posts.

Posts that given their provocative tone, you should actually have been gratefull for me to have replied with directions of where you could find the information, assuming they eventually could be something other than feeble flame attempts.

Inform yourself about the many possible meanings and origins of myths. About how the may be created, about the shortcomings of myth interpretation.

And yet, kitakaze has free reign to insult at will. Neto also.
This is a claim. Back it. Show me where I have "insulted at will."

If you really are interested on the subject then inform yourself instead pretending to feel offended by having exposed your little knoweledge on it. Remember, it was your decision to debate about it here. It was your decision to appeal for insults and provocations.

If you want to debate, lets go ahead. If all you have to offer are insults, sorry, not buying.
 
First pic...it's arm proportion is way out of whack....


[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/DreamerBoy11.jpg[/qimg]
Questions:
1. The "proportion is way out of whack" relative to what? Patty? Real gorillas? Humans?
2. How can you be so sure of the locations of the articulations?
3. Why extend the forearm's line down to the fingers?
4. Why use the left arm, specially when one notices how fuzzy is the hand?
4. You took perspective issues in to account?

Here's my take on the proportions (my best guess for location of articulations are the red dots; other possible articulation locations are within the red circles):
keepdreamingbaby.jpg

As you can see, I came to very different results. You can even try deriving some IM. Look at those legs! The proportions! That thing can not be a man!

Oh, and those hands! Can't be human hands! The fingers are too long, among other things!

Conclusions?
This sort of photographic studies can not prove if its subject are human or not. The lack of propper calibrations render them useless. Can one present them as "scientific analysis?" Only as bad science. Draw as many lines as you wish. It will still be bad methodology. In PGF's case, given its fishy's background, I have no reasons why not saying its junk science.

Second pic....the back of the leg has absolutely NO body contour....

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/DreamerBoy22.jpg[/qimg]
First of all, you should have noticed the exposure, background and resolution issues. Second, in case you have not noticed these are gorilla costumes... They are not bigfoot costumes.

Now look at the red arrows. See? The woman and the gorilla share the same shadow pattern, due to the muscles! The orange arrow points to a butt that looks like Patty's diaper butt!
delusion.jpg

Third pic....again, the arm is way out of proportion...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/DreamerBoy33.jpg[/qimg]
I'll ask again:
1. Out of proportion relative to what? Patty? Real gorillas? Humans?
2. How can you be so sure of the location of the articulations?
3. Why extend the forearm's line down to the fingers?
4. You took perspective issues in to account?

And the obvious muscles bulging at the arms? Have you noticed them?
And the extremely long fingers? How could a man in a suit hold a woman with fragile fake hands? What if the fingers move?

Face it, sweaty, this sort of analysis is a dead end, regardless on how you try to dodge and switch subjects.

Fourth pic....the suit, like pretty much all of them do....suffers from Shag-itis....and as a result has jagged outlines...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/DreamerBoy44.jpg[/qimg]

You know, there's that tool called scissors... Can be used to cut stuff like hair...

But don't let these little details stop you from pretending, Correa. I bet if you fuzzed the pictures up a little bit, they'd look much more realistic than Patty does!! :D
Sweaty, don't let these following "little details" stop you:
1. Costumes can change human proportions
2. Moving hands at the ends of long arms are easy to make in costumes
3. Gorilla suits from PGF time and before could as "realistic" as Patty
4. There is evidence that Patterson bought and modofied a gorilla suit for a prank
5. 40 years and ?
6. The walk can be replicated
7. Patty's incongruent anatomy
I could go on, but its already been exposed ad nauseaum...

Oh, one thing I must conceed- The fuzzy stuff. Patty's image is so fuzzy that opens plenty of space for pareidolia and doubtfull interpretations. That's what make belivers keep beliving Patty is the real deal.
 
Yes, it would be nice to see Patterson's admitted fake tracks and compare them to the Bluff Creek Patty tracks. What would be the odds of him making tracks that look remarkably like the Patty tracks?

My opinion is that RP had already decided what the Patty prints would look like before he went to Bluff Creek. If making the prints required a fake foot (plaster, wood or whatever) then he probably brought those devices with him to Bluff Creek.

I don't think the differences are major between accounts, we have established that Patterson could and did make fake tracks for whatever reason. Remember how Hieironimus said when he left Bluff Creek Roger and Bob were going to lay down fake tracks?

The major difference is that Krantz's version confirms that Roger had what was necessary to create faked prints with him at Bluff Creek. Why do we see a switch from conventional saddlebags to wooden boxes when Roger is riding with a packhorse at Bluff Creek?

If Roger told the truth to Krantz, then both he and BH are 'in agreement' that Roger was making fake prints at Bluff Creek. In a way, BH ends up corroborating RP and we don't learn of it until we read Krantz.

BH's testimony on the fake trackway is interesting. He says that P&G helped him get into the costume, filmed him, helped him out of the costume, sent him on his way home with the roll of film and the costume, then were to proceed to make a faked trackway using plaster casts. Why not just pour plaster into the prints left in the sandbar that had just been created by the feet on the costume? Why go and make some fake prints when a guy just walked through sand wearing the huge "perfectfeet"? My suspicion is that the feet on the costume did not leave very convincing or precise impressions in the sand. Some might be smudgy or incomplete. But regardless of what the feet impressions looked like... the stride measurement would be humanlike. Bob could not make abnormally long strides in that costume. That would also be true if someone other than BH was wearing the costume. We could ask how tall a human would need to be in order to create a stride measurement as was found at Bluff Creek (Patty) by Bob Titmus after the encounter.

The most frustrating thing is that we really don't know if the plaster pour scene is a demo or the actual event of casting Patty's prints. The cast display scene certainly did not soon follow that plaster pour scene. Enter Chris Murphy. He matters because his writings and research form a significant 'body of knowledge' used by Bigfooters and skeptics alike. Murphy seems to insist that the cast display scene was filmed at Bluff Creek very soon after Roger poured plaster into Patty's prints. If this is true, then the plaster pouring scene is almost certainly a demo (not the Patty prints) and additionally the timeline and events given by P&G are false. It was either too dark or pouring rain at the only times they could have filmed the cast display scene at Bluff Creek.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom