Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
8e099e4c.jpg
 
You can't be serious? Didn't you see what happens to that diagram when you scale both figures to the same size?
Yes, serious. I am serious. It seems to my eye that if the skeletal model in Patty's position turned around and stood up in BH's position, they would be the same.

BTW, did I miss you somewhere explain on what grounds Sweaty should ream out mangler for using the same image Sweaty got here for his demonstration?
 
WP:

"Bill, have you determined that this is not a man in a costume?"

When I answer that question in public, which I will at some point in the coming months, a whole buch of people on one side of the argument will say "prove it!", and I need to get the proof in order. Won't happen before spring, because measurements of the site are part of the proof and I'd like, if possible, to go there and take my own measurements (of anything still there and reliably hasn't moved, like very big old trees, tree stumps, rock formations, etc. that can be referenced to what's in the film relaibly). ideally, I'd like a second set of site measurements to compare to Rene Dehindan's site measurements of the 1970's.

My going there won't be before early to mid-March.

Bill

ps: I suppose, this being the holiday season, you could say I'm "making my list and checkin' it twice, going to find out who's naughty and nice. . . ."
 
I explained what is wrong with the comparison....it's very simple. I don't see any reason to spend any more time on it.

As I thought, just blowing bubbles.

I don't understand what you're asking me.....reprimand mangler for what?? Can you explain in more detail exactly what the issue here is?

I'm talking about this:

If I was Sweaty I'd ream you for using the same photos he's been demonstrating with.

She thinks you are warranted in reprimanding mangler for using the same image of BH for his skeletal model demo as you first got here at the JREF. If you still don't understand, click the link box in the quote to go back to page #2.

Do you or do you not agree with log?
 
WP:

"Bill, have you determined that that is not a costume foot?"

My opinion is the film resolution does not support any conclusion about the feet being real or costume. A conclusion of whether Patty is real or a costume will more or less dictate the conclusion about the feet (if it's a costume, so are the feet, and if she's real, so are the feet), but looking at just the feet and arguing anything from those images is an exercise in futility.

Bill
 
...but looking at just the feet and arguing anything from those images is an exercise in futility.

But Bill, you can see that I provided the exact same image that you used as a point of argument about the neck. The foot is futile, but the neck isn't?
 
WP:

"But Bill, you can see that I provided the exact same image that you used as a point of argument about the neck. The foot is futile, but the neck isn't?"

Same photo, agreed. I did that chart about 8 month ago. Lots happened since. New research, new things to study and analyse.

But I'm not using the photo in my current research and it's my current research that's going to lead to the answer you asked for.

My original chart was about the dark spot on the neck, and my best guess as for explaining it was hair raised away from the base or skin, so it caused more shadow and less hair sheen, which hair (real or fake) laying flatter does have. And I discussed both alternatives, real and fake and simply pointed out the challenges of doing that with a suit fur. But neither the neck spot or the feet will be a determining factor in my current effort.

Back then, I analysed Patty with what I had in image material. I couldn't see the big picture because I didn't have copies of "the big picture" (full frame sequence of the film). Now I've got a 90% of the "big picture" and so I'm working on a different level than all of you in this thread. Different data, different analysis method, different criteria, etc.

You all can keep arguing till you're blue in the face (or your keyboards wear out) but you're all arguing about petty stuff, most of which just isn't conclusive either way. I don't know why you all keep at it. Guess you just love to argue for the sake of arguing.

Bill
 
Same photo, agreed. I did that chart about 8 month ago. Lots happened since. New research, new things to study and analyse.

But I'm not using the photo in my current research and it's my current research that's going to lead to the answer you asked for.

:rolleyes: No, no. That wasn't the good stuff, you see. Now he's got the good stuff and it's really off the hook now. Slipperfoot is not his issue. He went into the PGF objectively questioning whether it was real or fake. The good stuff is coming.

My original chart was about the dark spot on the neck, and my best guess as for explaining it was hair raised away from the base or skin, so it caused more shadow and less hair sheen, which hair (real or fake) laying flatter does have. And I discussed both alternatives, real and fake and simply pointed out the challenges of doing that with a suit fur. But neither the neck spot or the feet will be a determining factor in my current effort.

You can't admit it looks like a big stupid slipper, can you?

Back then, I analysed Patty with what I had in image material. I couldn't see the big picture because I didn't have copies of "the big picture" (full frame sequence of the film). Now I've got a 90% of the "big picture" and so I'm working on a different level than all of you in this thread. Different data, different analysis method, different criteria, etc.

Are you referring to the LMS dvd? Some of us have that, BTW.



You all can keep arguing till you're blue in the face (or your keyboards wear out) but you're all arguing about petty stuff, most of which just isn't conclusive either way. I don't know why you all keep at it. Guess you just love to argue for the sake of arguing.

Bill

Patty has a big slipperfoot. It's petty. :rolleyes:
 
Kitakaze:

"The good stuff is coming."

Yes.


"You can't admit it looks like a big stupid slipper, can you?"

No.


"Are you referring to the LMS dvd?"

No.


"It's petty."

Yes.
 
Kitakaze:

"The good stuff is coming."

Yes.

And the other stuff... not so good.

"You can't admit it looks like a big stupid slipper, can you?"

No.
Yes, I think that's the very interesting thing when you are here. It really takes so little to demonstrate that you are not now or ever have been objective and unbiased about the PGF or Bigfoot in general. You can't even admit that this pretty lady:

90dc13cc.jpg


...looks like Nel Carter in her morning slippers.

"Are you referring to the LMS dvd?"

No.

You don't use the LMS dvd?


"It's petty."

Yes.

Again, a clear demonstration of your lack of objectivity. William points at a very glaring detail with Patty using your own material and you actually try a resolution cop out. Nice.
 
Last edited:
Bill - What generation copy are you using?

Are you able to provide proof of it's provenance?
 
Kitakaze:

You're just trying to pick a fight, and a really petty one at that.

Take it somewhere else. As soon as the thread flips to a new page, all your comments are just history. Rant all you like. Tomorrow nobody cares.

Bill
 
rockinkt:
"Bill - What generation copy are you using? "
described in the Gimlin event thread. All the info I have on it.

"Are you able to provide proof of it's provenance? "

Provenance, from the French provenir, "to come from", means the origin, or the source, of something, or the history of the ownership or location of an object,[1] especially a work of art, or some object of value such as is found in archaeology, or paleontology, or some document, such as a manuscript, or even an item of literature in the broadest sense, including a first edition of a very rare published work. The primary purpose of provenance is to confirm the time, place, and if appropriate the person responsible, for the creation, production or discovery of the object. Comparative techniques, expert opinions, written and verbal records and the results of various kinds of scientific tests are often used to help establish provenance.

You mean this provenance?

Notes on this issue will be in the addressed in the completed research.
 
Kitakaze:

You're just trying to pick a fight, and a really petty one at that.

I disagree and here's why - If I was only trying to pick a fight with you then I would take any opportunity to contradict you. In fact, on many occasion I've agreed with you on a variety of issues. When you make a good point I acknowledge it. If I make a mistake, I acknowledge it.

I don't consider the issue to be petty. I think there is a consistent pattern of you disregarding and refusing to engage issues that contradict your preconceived notions regarding the PGF and Bigfoot.

Take it somewhere else. As soon as the thread flips to a new page, all your comments are just history. Rant all you like. Tomorrow nobody cares.

Bill

This is exactly the place to discuss it so here is where I'll keep it. Tomorrow we'll be on to another page and have yet another example that Bill Munns is a Bigfoot enthusiast trying to make the data fit his beliefs.

I don't mean that as a personal attack, that's just the situation as it presents itself to me.
 
"Are you able to provide proof of it's provenance? "

Provenance, from the French provenir, "to come from", means the origin, ...

You mean this provenance?

dis⋅in⋅gen⋅u⋅ous   /ˌdɪsɪnˈdʒɛnyuəs/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [dis-in-jen-yoo-uhs] Show IPA Pronunciation

–adjective lacking in frankness, candor, or sincerity; falsely or hypocritically ingenuous; insincere: Her excuse was rather disingenuous.

Origin:
1645–55; dis- 1 + ingenuous

Notes on this issue will be in the addressed in the completed research.

He means "No, not at the present."
 
Kitakaze;

"I don't mean that as a personal attack"

If you say so . . .

Added;

"He means "No, not at the present."

No. It mean the material is not complete, the work is still im progress, and a better copy of the material might become available to me, and if so, that copy will be noted for it's provenance in the completed research. Nothing disingenuous.
 
Last edited:
No. It mean the material is not complete, the work is still im progress, and a better copy of the material might become available to me, and if so, that copy will be noted for it's provenance in the completed research. Nothing disingenuous.

Rock's questions were pretty simple, Bill:

Q: What generation copy are you using?

Q: Are you able to provide proof of it's provenance?

You don't have to pull out the dictionary and give the run around.

A: It's the blah blah copy

A: Not right now, I'm working on it.

How hard is that?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom