Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

If we keep saying things like "theists are people who know that God exists" (or "atheists are people who know that God does not exist"), then we are quite deliberately making completely untrue statements about a claimed creator of the entire universe

But since nobody in this thread has made statements like that, you're just blowing smoke up your own exhaust.
 
I wonder if others here have developed any strategies they find most effective.


Wikipedia
Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people.
The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.
Meaning
Marx was making a structural functionalism argument about religion, and particularly about organized religion. Marx believed that religion had certain practical functions in society that were similar to the function of opium in a sick or injured person: it reduced people's immediate suffering and provided them with pleasant illusions which gave them the strength to carry on.


The Wikipedia interpretation is a little off: Religion doesn’t really reduce people’s immediate suffering. It comforts them and enables them to accept the oppressive conditions that make them suffer. This is why they need religion - the same way an addict needs drugs as long as they don’t fight against those conditions.
The more you depend on the drug to enable you to tolerate these conditions, the worse are the withdrawal symptoms when you try to wean yourself off the drug.
Some people slip several times before they are completely clean.

The only really efficient way to help the addicts is to do away with the conditions that makes them need religion: ”To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions.”
 
Last edited:
The Wikipedia interpretation is a little off: Religion doesn’t really reduce people’s immediate suffering. It comforts them and enables them to accept the oppressive conditions that make them suffer. This is why they need religion - the same way an addict needs drugs as long as they don’t fight against those conditions.
The more you depend on the drug to enable you to tolerate these conditions, the worse are the withdrawal symptoms when you try to wean yourself off the drug.
Some people slip several times before they are completely clean.

The only really efficient way to help the addicts is to do away with the conditions that makes them need religion: ”To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions.”


Be interesting to hear how this can be done.

(Oh, The Big Dog may be miffed about you bringing the writings of Karl Marx into the discussion here. That's his speciality.:D)

Whilst I agree that the supposed comfort the religious get from their beliefs may be important *, I think the effects of religious doctrinal beliefs on communities, outweighs this consideration. As IanS wrote:

That said I don't think any of this would matter if theism was entirely benign, but unfortunately as we can clearly see (it should be clear, but of course all sorts of people will argue over this too) from the mass murders being carried out by groups like IS, religious belief is very far from being benign … in fact it's absolutely lethal as well as seriously anti-educational (e.g. attempts in the US to have Intelligent Design taught in school biology classes … as well of course for the overall/general need for all committed theists to reject almost all of science).

So for reasons like that, in the end, I think it's probably better for everyone on the planet if atheists do speak out against religious belief, and better if they do that in a constructive if fairly direct way (rather than trying be especially respectful as if to listen attentively to what theists believe etc.). You can do all that entirely politely of course, and without being overtly insulting or rude to anyone.

To cite some specific examples of this, (apart from the work of those who fly planes into buildings and so on - this often being hand waved away as the actions of fanatics), we have the case of the Egyptian atheist blogger Sherif Gaber who has a pending blasphemy case against him, Sina Dehghan on death row in Iran for "insulting the prophet", Ayaz Nizami facing the death penalty on accusations of blasphemy in Pakistan and Ahmad Al-Shamri and Raif Badawi charged with apostasy and blasphemy in Saudi Arabia.

Many in the West show little concern about these goings on in other countries, and if you are a straight male, you may not be all that worried about the religious institutions in your own countries, fighting hard to keep discrimination against homosexuals alive and well, and denying women the right to control their own bodies. Some, myself included, are however.

* I doubt the veracity of this notion. Many ex- Christians claim a feeling of relief when they leave their faith behind - I am one of those.:):):)
 
Perhaps some who were theists and became atheists can give their reasons?

I know that I believed in Christian doctrine when I was a freshman in high school. I think it was in my sophomore year I stopped believing. The stories in the Old Testament seemed ridiculous to me, but I felt that they must be true if they were supported by the chronologically more recent, New Testament. And then something occurred to me. I realized that people today reference the New Testament in support of their beliefs and that people in the New Testament referenced people from the Old Testament like Elijah, Moses, and Abraham. I realized that people today were not different than people who lived when the New Testament was written and that just as people today can assume that miracles are true so did people then. So, rather than the New Testament supporting the Old Testament it was actually relying on it. And, if the Old Testament was untrue then so was the New Testament.

When I got to college I started doing research on other claims like psychic phenomenon and discovered that people readily engaged in dishonest reporting. This has only grown more over time. For example, Oral Roberts employed a man who traveled with him. This man would make his way up to the front on crutches and pretend to be healed. Pat Robertson daily pretends to heal people in a way that can't be verified. Could he possibly be unaware of this fact?

The serpent in the Garden of Eden is an old myth. People observed that snakes became shiny and new looking when they shed their skin. This led to the belief that snakes became young again and lived forever. The original story was that the snake convinced a man to trade immortality for intelligence. After the man became intelligent he realized that immortality was better and cursed the snake. The reference to immortality with the Tree of Life is still there as a vestige. The story as written makes no sense. But it makes more sense as a version of an older, primitive myth.

The original creation story involves blood. I don't know if God slew a monster to spill the blood or it was his own blood. At any rate, the blood explained why the soil in that region is red. Blood mixed with soil is what living things were made from. Later, the Hebrew mythology changed and the concept shifted to the breath of life rather than blood although strangely they retained the concept of blood sacrifice. So the only link to the original story is the root word for red. The soil there is still red and wild grapes still grow there. This story probably gained traction in Mesopotamia when they discovered that irrigation led to salting that made the ground sterile.

I can't read the stories in the Old Testament as an adult and give them any weight. So, I can't give weight to the New Testament either. A belief in religion or the supernatural seems irrational to me, much like the idea of voting for Donald Trump or buying self-help books or thinking that you can talk to dead people. None of this made any sense until I started working on cognitive theory. Oddly enough, behaviors like these that seem so irrational fit within the theory. Further, Knowledge Theory provides fairly straightforward disproofs of life after death and the idea of an intelligent creator as well as philosophical concepts like Idealism. So, before I could entertain any idea not based on materialism, I would need Knowledge Theory demolished. On the other hand, if Knowledge Theory were to be proven correct then what would happen to these non-material beliefs? It's one of my concerns, much as it was for Darwin.
 
Let me break it down.

I do not understand that it can be said that science deals with facts and that science does not deal with facts.
I didn't say that science does not deal with facts, I said that science is not in the business of proving facts. Do you see the difference? Science definitely deals with facts, given the definition that Gould provided.

(a) In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed
There you go again quoting only half of the sentence! Until you acknowledge that the other half of the statement exists, the rest of your argument is meaningless and I will ignore it.

Understand the qualifying part of the statement and how it modifies the first clause. Perhaps it would help if I reproduced it like this: In science, "fact" can only mean "confirmed to such an extent that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent.
 
You're focusing on the fact that the word "fact" is used in the statement, and you think we are arguing that the word "fact" should not be used in any definition of science. No-one is saying that, least of all Gould. I'm not saying that, whoever it was you were originally arguing with before I hijacked this part of the discussion wasn't saying that, no-one has been saying that.
 
I didn't say that science does not deal with facts, I said that science is not in the business of proving facts. Do you see the difference? Science definitely deals with facts, given the definition that Gould provided.

There you go again quoting only half of the sentence! Until you acknowledge that the other half of the statement exists, the rest of your argument is meaningless and I will ignore it.
I wasn't discussing the way science confirms or proves facts. I wasn't even discussing the difference between the scientific concept of fact and that of common language. I was discussing IanS' assertion that "science does not deal with facts". The second part of Gould's sentence is not relevant to what I wanted to discuss because it points to the scientific concept of 'fact'.

If you do not take up the proposition "science does not prove facts", our discussion has no sense. If you think that science is about proving facts, there is no question about it.

You're focusing on the fact that the word "fact" is used in the statement, and you think we are arguing that the word "fact" should not be used in any definition of science. No-one is saying that, least of all Gould. I'm not saying that, whoever it was you were originally arguing with before I hijacked this part of the discussion wasn't saying that, no-one has been saying that.
IanS: “Well first of all science does not claim to prove "facts".” Here
Yourself: “Which is why IanS said that science is not in the business of "proving" "facts". Science is about coming to conclusions based on evidence”. Here

I repeat: you have a problem with the words 'fact', 'proof', ‘evidence’ or 'confirmation'.
It is up to you.
 
IanS: “Well first of all science does not claim to prove "facts".” Here
Yourself: “Which is why IanS said that science is not in the business of "proving" "facts". Science is about coming to conclusions based on evidence”. Here

I repeat: you have a problem with the words 'fact', 'proof', ‘evidence’ or 'confirmation'.
It is up to you.
You have misunderstood and/or misrepresented the entire discussion from square one, and I am disinclined to continue beating my head against this particular brick wall. I have explained myself to you at least three times now, and will not attempt to do so again.
 
OK, now we have the science and facts thing sorted lets get back to the Being Reasoned Out Of Religion theme.:)

GDon was good enough to post the following a while back, and although there have been a number of accounts from those who claim to have been reasoned out, I have yet to see an account by one who was reasoned in. (That is apart from GDon's own experience where the reasonings were questioned as being that.)


I'd be interested in hearing the experiences of those who have been reasoned out of religion. If it is because of some tragedy in their lives, resulting in "no good God would allow that", then that is a philosophical/metaphysical argument. It's certainly not something that is empirically true, since it needs to make certain assumptions about God. It seems as valid as the reverse.

Perhaps some who were theists and became atheists can give their reasons?


Interesting that you should bring this up GDon - about the tragedy being a catalyst for disbelief that is. Having read many accounts written by those who have experienced tragedies, I have been confounded by the claims by some, that the tragedy has reenforced their faith.:confused:
 
Well, the subject isn't about being reasoned out of "belief in some sort of gods, any at all". It's about being reasoned out of "religion". And any religion already makes "certain assumptions about God", so debunking any of those is enough to reason someone out of the religion that makes them, regardless of whether or not it's enough to reason someone out of some other belief too (such as a real god who's just a cruel abusive jackass, which is not what Christians claim he's supposed to be).
 
Be interesting to hear how this can be done.


No, it wouldn't be, because what Marx is saying with the sentence you highlighted - ”To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions” - is that you are asking them to be 'reasoned' out of the thing that they weren't reasoned into in the first place.
So on the one hand, you misunderstand what Marx is saying, and on the other hand, you ignore my introduction to his sentence where I said explicitly "how this can be done":
"The only really efficient way to help the addicts is to do away with the conditions that makes them need religion."*
That is not only "how this can be done." That is also how it has already been done - in particular in my part of the world: The conditions that makes the religious need religion have been done away with - unfortunately not completely and not in any way consistently, but still ... - and that is what explains the apparent paradox that the majority of the population are non-religious while at the same time being members of the state church.
Since you have such a hard time grasping this, I'll quote from another very secular (in the sense of non-religious, not atheist) book: The Year of Living Danishly - Uncovering the Secrets of the World's Happiest Country]:

Psychologists at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada, found that the better educated and wealthier a nation is, the less likely its population is to believe in a higher being. The Global Index of Religion and Atheism also assessed that poverty was a key indicator of a society's tendency towards religion - so that poorer countries tend to be the most religious. The one exception to the rule? America. But in the strongly religious USA, despite the country's wealth, there's no universal health care, little job security, and a flimsy social welfare safety net. This means that the USA has a lot more in common with developing countries than she might like to think.


As long as you don't get that point, you don't really understand what religion is. Your only message is that religion is bad so you go on and on about the tired old stories of people flying "planes into buildings" as if that is what the average Christian is spending his Sunday mornings plotting:

Whilst I agree that the supposed comfort the religious get from their beliefs may be important *, I think the effects of religious doctrinal beliefs on communities, outweighs this consideration. As IanS wrote:

To cite some specific examples of this, (apart from the work of those who fly planes into buildings and so on - this often being hand waved away as the actions of fanatics), we have the case of the Egyptian atheist blogger Sherif Gaber who has a pending blasphemy case against him, Sina Dehghan on death row in Iran for "insulting the prophet", Ayaz Nizami facing the death penalty on accusations of blasphemy in Pakistan and Ahmad Al-Shamri and Raif Badawi charged with apostasy and blasphemy in Saudi Arabia.


And you do so because of your own delusion: You seem to think that what I am doing (and what Marx was doing) is to cherry pick benevolent aspects of religion. (As if Marx called religion "the opium of the people" because he thought that it was a blessing for the working classes!) You notice that we talk about the need** that religion satisfies and the comfort that it gives the believers, and you immediately jump to the conclusion that we're saying that religion is a good thing.
We're not.
Religion is a delusion, obviously, and delusions aren't good. (Nor is opium, by the way, but it has its uses in emergencies ...)

Many in the West show little concern about these goings on in other countries, and if you are a straight male, you may not be all that worried about the religious institutions in your own countries, fighting hard to keep discrimination against homosexuals alive and well, and denying women the right to control their own bodies. Some, myself included, are however.


For the most part, religious institutions in my country aren't "fighting hard to keep discrimination against homosexuals alive and well," and even the Muslim minority is 'beginning to see the light.'

* I doubt the veracity of this notion. Many ex- Christians claim a feeling of relief when they leave their faith behind - I am one of those.:):):)


Feel free to doubt the veracity. You're entitled to your own delusions.
That people feel relief when they give up religion does not in any way contradict the fact that it comforts most believers. (And, again, since you don't seem to grasp the idea: That statement is not in any way in defence of religion!)


* It's like the old adage about atheists in foxholes. Even though it's not true, the claim that there are no atheists in foxholes is a very poor argument against religion. It's a much better argument against foxholes! See James Morrow!

** I think that I have already mentioned in this thread that the atheist James Randi always says that believers not only want but actually need. A grotesque number of skeptics don't seem to get this point of religion and superstition, and many of them seem to be in total denial about in.
 
Last edited:
OK, now we have the science and facts thing sorted


I don't think that you actually do have the science and facts sorted.

lets get back to the Being Reasoned Out Of Religion theme.:)


OK.

GDon was good enough to post the following a while back, and although there have been a number of accounts from those who claim to have been reasoned out, I have yet to see an account by one who was reasoned in. (That is apart from GDon's own experience where the reasonings were questioned as being that.)


Interesting that you should bring this up GDon - about the tragedy being a catalyst for disbelief that is. Having read many accounts written by those who have experienced tragedies, I have been confounded by the claims by some, that the tragedy has reenforced their faith.:confused:


If you had the science and the facts of religion sorted out, you would be neither confounded nor confused, obviously. Your confusion is the point where you should ask yourself what it is that you haven't understood, what is wrong with your so-called science of religion: There is nothing confounding about tragedies reinforcing people's faith if you actually know what religious faith is! But if you need to believe in a delusion about what constitutes religion, you have to make up your mind: This obvious cognitive dissonance of yours is trying to tell you something! You can either solve the problem by coming to terms with what religion actually is, or you can insist on your delusion and go on being confounded, i.e. you can console yourself with your cognitive dissonance and learn to live with it.
The red pill or the blue pill?!
 
any religion already makes "certain assumptions about God", so debunking any of those is enough to reason someone out of the religion that makes them
Except it isn't is it? Not always, anyway. I participated in an online discussion with a Mormon once in which most of his church's teachings were demonstrated to be false, but it made no difference to his faith. He went through all sorts of mental gymnastics to explain away inconvenient facts, and when it was impossible to do so he simply declared that it would all become clear after he died. He knew it was all true, you see, because God had personally confirmed that to him (he could self induce the "burning in the bosom" on demand) so there must be an explanation for anything that didn't seem to make sense, he just didn't know it yet.
 
The thing to remember about ideological belief is that it does not matter if it is non falsifiable or illogical or irrational as long as the one believing it thinks
it is true. Absolute belief is immune to reason or logic because those types of believers value emotional right brain thinking over logical left brain thinking
They cannot be persuaded that their world view is wrong and consequently deny anything that can demonstrate this regardless of how compelling it may
actually be. My own approach is to avoid holding on too rigidly to anything less it is definitely true and even then I will just accept it absent any intensity
 
No, I don't think so. Unlike other kinds of "ideological belief", let's say libertarianism, for instance, you can't really say that religion is a belief where "the one believing it thinks it is true." At least not 24-7. Even the most extreme fanatics seem to know that there's a difference between the real world and the world of their fantasies.
Not even Thor 2's favourite examples, the guys who fly airplanes into buildings, expect God/Allah to take over the steering wheel: They were actually aware that they had to take ordinary secular flying lessons!!! (They may have wanted to skip the part about landing planes, but that only goes to show the basic realism of their attitude: If they had read the Quran properly - and I'm thinking specifically of the story of Abraham's sacrifice of Isaac - they would at least have suspected that God/Allah might change his mind and say something along the lines of: 'Well, you have no proved to Me that you're willing to sacrifice not only your own life but the lives of thousands of others, so feel free to land this thing safely at the nearest airport - or even the Hudson River if there's not too much traffic at this hour.' Having skipped the landing lessons in that situation would have been so awfully embarrassing!)
 
Correction:

* It's like the old adage about atheists in foxholes. Even though it's not true, the claim that there are no atheists in foxholes is a very poor argument against religion.


It should have been:
"Even though it's not true, the claim that there are no atheists in foxholes is a very poor argument against atheists. It's a much better argument against foxholes! See James Morrow!"
 
No, I don't think so. Unlike other kinds of "ideological belief", let's say libertarianism, for instance, you can't really say that religion is a belief where "the one believing it thinks it is true." At least not 24-7. Even the most extreme fanatics seem to know that there's a difference between the real world and the world of their fantasies.
Not even Thor 2's favourite examples, the guys who fly airplanes into buildings, expect God/Allah to take over the steering wheel: They were actually aware that they had to take ordinary secular flying lessons!!! <snip>

Nope. The guys flying airplanes into buildings had a belief that they are the soldiers of Allah and they are therefore commanded to destroy the infidels. They don't expect Allah to do that work for them; they have to carry it out as instruments of the will of Allah or whatever. They carried it out because they believed it was all real. So yes indeed, a religion can be a belief system where the one believing it thinks it's true -24-7. 365 even. You aren't going to reason those believers out of flying planes into buildings for Allah.

Of course, one can be a member of a religion but not have strong beliefs regarding all of it's teachings. Most American Catholics come to mind. But the soldier of Allah who has committed himself to die for his beliefs? For them their religion IS reality.

Even for the Catholics, they may not agree with the Church on stuff like birth control, pre-marital sex, etc but most of them damn sure believe that God is real, Jesus was his son and they are now joined in the holy trinity. They believe that missing mass or not observing lent is wrong. Otherwise, why would they observe these things?
 
They don't expect Allah to do that work for them;


No, you're right, they don't! That's what I said!

they have to carry it out as instruments of the will of Allah or whatever.


"whatever" is right! That is the one thing they actually do know: that they can't depend on Allah, the omnipotent, to do stuff like that (or any stuff).

They carried it out because they believed it was all real. So yes indeed, a religion can be a belief system where the one believing it thinks it's true -24-7. 365 even. You aren't going to reason those believers out of flying planes into buildings for Allah.


You confuse two things. That you aren't going to reason them out of flying planes into buildings for Allah has nothing whatsoever to do with thinking "it's true." That's the difference between religious faith and 'thinking it's true.'
The jihadists obviously don't think it's true. Otherwise they wouldn't do what they do:

The Navy SEALs who killed Osama bin Laden found a fairly extensive stash of modern pornography in his possession.
The 9/11 jihadists visited strip clubs, paid for lap dances, and for prostitutes in their motel rooms in Boston, Las Vegas and Florida.
Why are jihadis so obsessed with porn? (New York Post, Feb. 17, 2015)


And in your fantasy these guys actually believed that it was true that 72 virgins were waiting for them in Heaven.
That is very far from the behaviour that I (or any other) would exhibit if I thought that the idea of Allah, the omniscient, was true!
(And this is one of the things that A Handmaid’s Tale gets right: series 1, episode 8 & 9)

Of course, one can be a member of a religion but not have strong beliefs regarding all of it's teachings. Most American Catholics come to mind. But the soldier of Allah who has committed himself to die for his beliefs? For them their religion IS reality.


No, it obviously isn't! (Or to be more specific: Religion is reality, but the religious don't actually think that "it's true." Religious faith is very different from thinking (= knowing) that something is true!)

Even for the Catholics, they may not agree with the Church on stuff like birth control, pre-marital sex, etc but most of them damn sure believe that God is real, Jesus was his son and they are now joined in the holy trinity. They believe that missing mass or not observing lent is wrong. Otherwise, why would they observe these things?


Yes, they believe it's wrong to skip mass, but you don't seem to "grok" that this does not mean that they think "it's real." Skipping mass shows that they know it's not real, and yet, in spite of this, they don't give up their faith because it comforts them - so they go when they need that. And they need it so much that they're even willing to fly planes into buildings if that's what it takes to keep faith!
 
No, you're right, they don't! That's what I said!




"whatever" is right! That is the one thing they actually do know: that they can't depend on Allah, the omnipotent, to do stuff like that (or any stuff).




You confuse two things. That you aren't going to reason them out of flying planes into buildings for Allah has nothing whatsoever to do with thinking "it's true." That's the difference between religious faith and 'thinking it's true.'
The jihadists obviously don't think it's true. Otherwise they wouldn't do what they do:




And in your fantasy these guys actually believed that it was true that 72 virgins were waiting for them in Heaven.
That is very far from the behaviour that I (or any other) would exhibit if I thought that the idea of Allah, the omniscient, was true!
(And this is one of the things that A Handmaid’s Tale gets right: series 1, episode 8 & 9)




No, it obviously isn't! (Or to be more specific: Religion is reality, but the religious don't actually think that "it's true." Religious faith is very different from thinking (= knowing) that something is true!)




Yes, they believe it's wrong to skip mass, but you don't seem to "grok" that this does not mean that they think "it's real." Skipping mass shows that they know it's not real, and yet, in spite of this, they don't give up their faith because it comforts them - so they go when they need that. And they need it so much that they're even willing to fly planes into buildings if that's what it takes to keep faith!


I agree with the rest of what you say, but re. the highlighted portion, while what you suggest is doubtless often true, there are also instances when people "sin" even while fully believing they'r sinning, and that the wages of sin is death. They sin, and then they try to make up for it by confessing. I suppose like someone not being able to give up cancer sticks despite knowing they're poison.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom