Be interesting to hear how this can be done.
No, it wouldn't be, because what Marx is saying with the sentence you highlighted -
”To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions” - is that you are asking them to be 'reasoned' out of the thing that they weren't reasoned into in the first place.
So on the one hand, you misunderstand what Marx is saying, and on the other hand, you ignore my introduction to his sentence where I said explicitly
"how this can be done":
"The only really efficient way to help the addicts is to do away with the conditions that makes them need religion."*
That is not only
"how this can be done." That is also how it
has already been done - in particular in my part of the world: The
conditions that makes the religious
need religion have been done away with - unfortunately not completely and not in any way consistently, but still ... - and
that is what explains the apparent paradox that the majority of the population are non-religious while at the same time being members of the state church.
Since you have such a hard time grasping this, I'll quote from another very
secular (in the sense of non-religious, not atheist) book:
The Year of Living Danishly - Uncovering the Secrets of the World's Happiest Country]:
Psychologists at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada, found that the better educated and wealthier a nation is, the less likely its population is to believe in a higher being. The Global Index of Religion and Atheism also assessed that poverty was a key indicator of a society's tendency towards religion - so that poorer countries tend to be the most religious. The one exception to the rule? America. But in the strongly religious USA, despite the country's wealth, there's no universal health care, little job security, and a flimsy social welfare safety net. This means that the USA has a lot more in common with developing countries than she might like to think.
As long as you don't get that point, you don't really understand what religion is. Your only message is that religion is
bad so you go on and on about the tired old stories of people flying
"planes into buildings" as if that is what the average Christian is spending his Sunday mornings plotting:
Whilst I agree that the supposed comfort the religious get from their beliefs may be important *, I think the effects of religious doctrinal beliefs on communities, outweighs this consideration. As IanS wrote:
To cite some specific examples of this, (apart from the work of those who fly planes into buildings and so on - this often being hand waved away as the actions of fanatics), we have the case of the Egyptian atheist blogger Sherif Gaber who has a pending blasphemy case against him, Sina Dehghan on death row in Iran for "insulting the prophet", Ayaz Nizami facing the death penalty on accusations of blasphemy in Pakistan and Ahmad Al-Shamri and Raif Badawi charged with apostasy and blasphemy in Saudi Arabia.
And you do so because of your own delusion: You seem to think that what
I am doing (and what Marx was doing) is to cherry pick benevolent aspects of religion. (As if Marx called religion
"the opium of the people" because he thought that it was a blessing for the working classes!) You notice that we talk about the
need** that religion satisfies and the
comfort that it gives the believers, and you immediately jump to the conclusion that we're saying that religion is a
good thing.
We're not.
Religion
is a delusion, obviously, and delusions aren't
good. (Nor is opium, by the way, but it has its uses in emergencies ...)
Many in the West show little concern about these goings on in other countries, and if you are a straight male, you may not be all that worried about the religious institutions in your own countries, fighting hard to keep discrimination against homosexuals alive and well, and denying women the right to control their own bodies. Some, myself included, are however.
For the most part,
religious institutions in
my country aren't
"fighting hard to keep discrimination against homosexuals alive and well," and even the
Muslim minority is 'beginning to see the light.'
Feel free to doubt the veracity. You're entitled to your own delusions.
That people feel relief when they give up religion does not in any way contradict the fact that it comforts most believers. (And, again, since you don't seem to grasp the idea: That statement is not in any way in defence of religion!)
* It's like the old adage about
atheists in foxholes. Even though it's not true, the claim that there are no atheists in foxholes is a very poor argument against religion. It's a much better argument against foxholes! See
James Morrow!
** I think that I have already mentioned in this thread that the
atheist James Randi always says that believers not only
want but actually
need. A grotesque number of skeptics don't seem to get this point of religion and superstition, and many of them seem to be in total denial about in.