Sure, from an atheist/agnostic perspective -indeed, perhaps from a "universal reality" perspective- you are correct. From such a high-level perspective, it is not possible for a human to be certain about anything at all because we don't know enough for such certainty. "The sun will rise tomorrow," is about as certain a statement we can make but even that is not a certainty from the "universal reality" perspective -we could be wiped out in an instant by some heretofore unknown astronomical calamity.
Well at least it seems you now understand the issue. Though in your final sentence below, you again totally misunderstand that same issue! However leaving aside the fact that you are thereby saying two opposing things at once (see below re your final sentence) -
- whether or not it's possible for us ever to know
anything as a certainty is another and much wider issue about everything in the entire universe, and we are certainly not going to get in a debate here & now about the entirety of everything in the universe! But specifically on definitions which say things like "theists are people who know God does exist" or "agnostics do not know whether God exists or not” … all definitions like that are fatally flawed because they all talk as if it truly is possible for atheists, theists and agnostics to know whether God exists (not just existing as their "belief", but actually existing as a real creature in this universe) … but the truth is that of course none of those people actually
know whether God exists or not … you do not know, I do not know, and Squeegee does not know … if any of us as atheists say “I know God does not exist, it's certain he does not exist”, then that sort of statement is utterly and completely wrong. That's the point. And the reason it's important is because you are misleading yourself and seriously misleading others if you go around repeatedly & constantly making false and entirely untrue statements about what exists as a "known" absolute certainty in this universe (i.e. in this case definitions that talk of people who know the certainty of whether or not God exists).
Specifically, in terms of what I already explained in the post that you are replying to -
“you are entitled to your own beliefs about the universe (e.g. God's existence), but you are NOT entitled to declare that your beliefs make things in the universe become actual certainties of fact (such as the existence of God) “
And that is not at all as you just called it
“an atheist/agnostic perspective ... From such a high-level perspective” … it's simply a matter of correct use of English Language and what any of us can reasonably declare as “known for certainty” about a supposed supernatural creator living somewhere in this universe (or in another universe). It's simply pointing out that its utterly and completely wrong to make statements or definitions that say things like “I know God exists” … you do not actually “know” he exists, and if the theists then says “it's certain he does exist”, then all he can really mean by that is that it's his
belief that such things are “certain” … but his belief does not make God a reality of any actual or "certain" existence … you cannot cause God to exist, or cause him to not exist, merely by declaring totally flawed definitions that say things like “atheists know God does not exist”, “theists know God does exist”, "agnostics do not know whether God exists” … NONE OF US “KNOW”!
But from a human perspective, that flawed, limited perspective of the faithful Christian, God's existence is as much a certainty as the sun rising tomorrow. By the same token, the flawed, limited perspective of the atheist could be completely wrong as well.
From their perspective, it is a certainty.
No!. When you choose the word “perspective” you are just trying to find a more opaque and misleading word for “belief”. When you say
"from their perspective, it is a certainty", that's just trying to use the word "perspective" to hide the fact that what you really mean is "
perspective belief" - “they merely think it's certain as their "belief” … it's their
belief that you are saying is “certain”, but the statement says that it's is God that is “certain”!. Just because “you feel certain of your belief”, that is 100% totally different from claiming that the object of your belief (ie God) is itself is an actual certainty.
IOW – saying “their perspective” just means “in their opinion” … their “perspective” is just their opinion or belief. And their mere “belief”, however certain they may feel it is, does not make make God become reality as an actual “certainty” in this universe.
No. They are certain that God exists. They are most likely wrong, but that's irrelevant. One can be certain about things that are not factually true because of our flawed, limited human perspective. Like I said from the beginning, this is a "use of language" issue. Squeegee and I are using the language properly and our meaning is clear. You are insisting on some hyper-literal use of language where the word "certain" must reflect "universal reality." That ain't the way it works.
No! They cannot be “certain that God exists". The most they can do is “feel” certain about it. But that's only a
belief in the certainty of God. If you say that you are certain of something, that means you are declaring it to be a certainty for everyone and everything in the universe … “You are not entitled to your own CERTAINTIES about things existing in the universe.
The problem is that the sentence is just a whacking great obvious mistake in the Use of English Language and Comprehension. If you write (as you just have)
“they are certain that God exists” then you and they are guilty of very flawed thinking indeed, and that's a serious problem because it means you do not understand what you are actually saying! They are not actually “certain of it” … that's just very loose and entirely misleading language for saying “I believe it's certain, it seems like that to me” … OK, well that is emphatically NOT a certainty about reality of existence in this universe (NOT a certainty about God's actual existence) … at the very most it is a claim saying you “believe” it's certain, but where you deliberately left out the fact that it was only your belief (i.e. really no more than just your opinion).