Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

You didn't quote the argument, and you didn't factor it into your reply. You ignored it.
 
Clearly. Gould is offering a definition of the word "fact", though you seem to be interpreting it somehow to mean that it is using it as the goal of the sentence.

Gould is saying that in science, "fact" does not mean "definitive statement about the universe that is absolutely true". He is saying that it means "statement about the universe that is provisionally agreed to as being as close to reality as it is possible to get, given that further evidence may still be found that modifies our understanding".

Perhaps you do.

Thank you. I know what Gould was doing. I don't know what you were doing. It seems impossible to say ""In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed'" and "science is not in the business of "proving" "facts"" at the same time.

I was asking for an explanation of this blatant contradiction, because I suspected that some word was used in a strange way or there was a reference to a particular idea... Nothing more.
I don't know what to think.
 
Thank you. I know what Gould was doing. I don't know what you were doing. It seems impossible to say ""In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed'" and "science is not in the business of "proving" "facts"" at the same time.

I was asking for an explanation of this blatant contradiction, because I suspected that some word was used in a strange way or there was a reference to a particular idea... Nothing more.
I don't know what to think.
Ah, I see the confusion. You have read only "In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed'" and neglected to read the rest of the statement which reads "...to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent."

Provisional assent. That's the most important part of Gould's statement, though you have thus far ignored it. It means "okay, let's go ahead and work as though this were true until we have some evidence that it is not."

That is not the same thing as finding something absolutely true. Not the same thing at all.

I repeat: science is not in the business of proving things true. It is in the business of finding the best explanation that fits the evidence. All "facts" are provisional. All "facts" can in principle be overturned under the weight of new evidence.
 
You didn't quote the argument, and you didn't factor it into your reply. You ignored it.

If you say so.

But, I'll tell you what, if your all that confident in your mind-reading skills, there's a bunch of sceptic societies who will collectively give you a lot of money.
 
That's right. Keep up the pretense at any cost.
I said that you didn't quote it, didn't comment on in and didn't "factor" it into your reply, but instead ignored it.
I never claimed that you didn't have long and deep thoughts before or even after you decided to do so.
So, no, I don't rely on mind reading. Reading what people actually write and noticing what they don't write is the only skill I rely on.
 
Last edited:
Sure, from an atheist/agnostic perspective -indeed, perhaps from a "universal reality" perspective- you are correct. From such a high-level perspective, it is not possible for a human to be certain about anything at all because we don't know enough for such certainty. "The sun will rise tomorrow," is about as certain a statement we can make but even that is not a certainty from the "universal reality" perspective -we could be wiped out in an instant by some heretofore unknown astronomical calamity.


Well at least it seems you now understand the issue. Though in your final sentence below, you again totally misunderstand that same issue! However leaving aside the fact that you are thereby saying two opposing things at once (see below re your final sentence) -

- whether or not it's possible for us ever to know anything as a certainty is another and much wider issue about everything in the entire universe, and we are certainly not going to get in a debate here & now about the entirety of everything in the universe! But specifically on definitions which say things like "theists are people who know God does exist" or "agnostics do not know whether God exists or not” … all definitions like that are fatally flawed because they all talk as if it truly is possible for atheists, theists and agnostics to know whether God exists (not just existing as their "belief", but actually existing as a real creature in this universe) … but the truth is that of course none of those people actually know whether God exists or not … you do not know, I do not know, and Squeegee does not know … if any of us as atheists say “I know God does not exist, it's certain he does not exist”, then that sort of statement is utterly and completely wrong. That's the point. And the reason it's important is because you are misleading yourself and seriously misleading others if you go around repeatedly & constantly making false and entirely untrue statements about what exists as a "known" absolute certainty in this universe (i.e. in this case definitions that talk of people who know the certainty of whether or not God exists).

Specifically, in terms of what I already explained in the post that you are replying to - “you are entitled to your own beliefs about the universe (e.g. God's existence), but you are NOT entitled to declare that your beliefs make things in the universe become actual certainties of fact (such as the existence of God) “

And that is not at all as you just called it “an atheist/agnostic perspective ... From such a high-level perspective” … it's simply a matter of correct use of English Language and what any of us can reasonably declare as “known for certainty” about a supposed supernatural creator living somewhere in this universe (or in another universe). It's simply pointing out that its utterly and completely wrong to make statements or definitions that say things like “I know God exists” … you do not actually “know” he exists, and if the theists then says “it's certain he does exist”, then all he can really mean by that is that it's his belief that such things are “certain” … but his belief does not make God a reality of any actual or "certain" existence … you cannot cause God to exist, or cause him to not exist, merely by declaring totally flawed definitions that say things like “atheists know God does not exist”, “theists know God does exist”, "agnostics do not know whether God exists” … NONE OF US “KNOW”!



But from a human perspective, that flawed, limited perspective of the faithful Christian, God's existence is as much a certainty as the sun rising tomorrow. By the same token, the flawed, limited perspective of the atheist could be completely wrong as well.

From their perspective, it is a certainty.


No!. When you choose the word “perspective” you are just trying to find a more opaque and misleading word for “belief”. When you say "from their perspective, it is a certainty", that's just trying to use the word "perspective" to hide the fact that what you really mean is "perspective belief" - “they merely think it's certain as their "belief” … it's their belief that you are saying is “certain”, but the statement says that it's is God that is “certain”!. Just because “you feel certain of your belief”, that is 100% totally different from claiming that the object of your belief (ie God) is itself is an actual certainty.

IOW – saying “their perspective” just means “in their opinion” … their “perspective” is just their opinion or belief. And their mere “belief”, however certain they may feel it is, does not make make God become reality as an actual “certainty” in this universe.



No. They are certain that God exists. They are most likely wrong, but that's irrelevant. One can be certain about things that are not factually true because of our flawed, limited human perspective. Like I said from the beginning, this is a "use of language" issue. Squeegee and I are using the language properly and our meaning is clear. You are insisting on some hyper-literal use of language where the word "certain" must reflect "universal reality." That ain't the way it works.


No! They cannot be “certain that God exists". The most they can do is “feel” certain about it. But that's only a belief in the certainty of God. If you say that you are certain of something, that means you are declaring it to be a certainty for everyone and everything in the universe … “You are not entitled to your own CERTAINTIES about things existing in the universe.

The problem is that the sentence is just a whacking great obvious mistake in the Use of English Language and Comprehension. If you write (as you just have) “they are certain that God exists” then you and they are guilty of very flawed thinking indeed, and that's a serious problem because it means you do not understand what you are actually saying! They are not actually “certain of it” … that's just very loose and entirely misleading language for saying “I believe it's certain, it seems like that to me” … OK, well that is emphatically NOT a certainty about reality of existence in this universe (NOT a certainty about God's actual existence) … at the very most it is a claim saying you “believe” it's certain, but where you deliberately left out the fact that it was only your belief (i.e. really no more than just your opinion).
 
You're right. They usually describe themselves as believers, as people of faith.
 
Ah, I see the confusion. You have read only "In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed'" and neglected to read the rest of the statement which reads "...to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent."

Provisional assent. That's the most important part of Gould's statement, though you have thus far ignored it. It means "okay, let's go ahead and work as though this were true until we have some evidence that it is not."

That is not the same thing as finding something absolutely true. Not the same thing at all.

I repeat: science is not in the business of proving things true. It is in the business of finding the best explanation that fits the evidence. All "facts" are provisional. All "facts" can in principle be overturned under the weight of new evidence.


Thanks again. I fully understand what Gould says about the provisional nature of scientific statements. I myself have added some precision in this regard in my comment #831.
I do not understand that it can be said that science deals with facts and that science does not deal with facts.
(a) In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed
(b) Science is not in the business of "proving" "facts"
You don't see any contradiction in this? Truly? Does not means (a) that facts are “the business” of science?

I see only two possibilities: either the word 'confirm' does not mean the same thing to you as 'to prove', or the word 'facts' does not mean the same thing in the two propositions. Is that so?
You should stop explaining to me the things that I have already explained - and I know well - and make an effort to explain which I am asking you. Unless the word "science" means two different things in both propositions. Or that you talk about two kinds of "truth".

As long as you don’t explain this, I'll keep thinking you're in a phenomenal mess.
 
Last edited:
NOTE: In the spirit of concorde and undoing this mess, I believe that what happens is that "facts" is used in a different sense.

"Facts" in Gould's theory would be those phenomena that are accessible to science and appear integrated into a theoretical scientific system. Science would be in charge of this type of facts and not of other types of facts that could be allegued by other forms of knowledge. And IanS and you affirm that science doesn't deal with this kind of facts.
Is this it?
 
Last edited:
That's right. Keep up the pretense at any cost.
I said that you didn't quote it, didn't comment on in and didn't "factor" it into your reply, but instead ignored it.
I never claimed that you didn't have long and deep thoughts before or even after you decided to do so.
So, no, I don't rely on mind reading. Reading what people actually write and noticing what they don't write is the only skill I rely on.

If you feel that helps.
 
Well at least it seems you now understand the issue. <snip>
I understood it from the get go.

You are meandering through a long and winding road to explain the simple concept that human certainty about something does not make that something a reality. Well no ****, Sherlock!

All I'm pointing out to you is that you are butchering the everyday usage of the English language in order to make this irrelevant point. And for what? What is gained by such a tortuous semantics quibble? We all know that when a believer says, "I am certain that God exists," that this doesn't magically cause his God to exist. That what he is really saying is that "I believe with all my heart and soul that God exists." Of course it is! The point is so obvious that it isn't even worth talking about.

In the end, we humans can be certain of absolutely nothing; "certainty" is an illusion. But when we are talking to each other and one of us says, "I'm certain that God exists," we can understand each other without having to break it down into such ostentatious frippery.
 
Last edited:
Well we started off so well but now this thread has degenerated into a slanging match between several posters.

On the subject of being reasoned out of religion, I sense the majority here are of the opinion we can expect limited success, if we try and use reason to persuade the religious. On the other hand we have a number of champions of the cause, writing very popular books and drawing on reason to challenge religious belief. Some authors, such as Richard Dawkins, claim a number of scalps, based on feedback from readers.

From my experience of exchanges with the faithful, I find the most effective arguments are those, where specific details of their own dogma are examined. It continues to surprise me, how little Biblical knowledge, is in the mind of the average Christian, and even more so the lack of thought, about the implications of Biblical teaching.

I wonder if others here have developed any strategies they find most effective.
 
Well we started off so well but now this thread has degenerated into a slanging match between several posters.

On the subject of being reasoned out of religion, I sense the majority here are of the opinion we can expect limited success, if we try and use reason to persuade the religious. On the other hand we have a number of champions of the cause, writing very popular books and drawing on reason to challenge religious belief. Some authors, such as Richard Dawkins, claim a number of scalps, based on feedback from readers.

From my experience of exchanges with the faithful, I find the most effective arguments are those, where specific details of their own dogma are examined. It continues to surprise me, how little Biblical knowledge, is in the mind of the average Christian, and even more so the lack of thought, about the implications of Biblical teaching.

I wonder if others here have developed any strategies they find most effective.
I ask theists two questions . . .

(1) What do you believe?
(2) Why do you believe it?
I haven't received a coherent answer to the first question yet. The "tactic" is, "When they can't explain it, maybe they might be more likely to question it". The "maybe and might" don't make it much "more likely" unfortunately.
 
Last edited:
I ask theists two questions . . .

(1) What do you believe?
(2) Why do you believe it?
I haven't received a coherent answer to the first question yet. The "tactic" is, "When they can't explain it, maybe they might be more likely to question it". The "maybe and might" don't make it much "more likely" unfortunately.

Theistic: I believe in a spiritual creator of the universe, aeternal, all-powerful and absolutely good, who knows all things --past, present and future.

Is it incoherent?
 
Theistic: I believe in a spiritual creator of the universe, aeternal, all-powerful and absolutely good, who knows all things --past, present and future.

Is it incoherent?


What you are suggesting as a response from the theist is not incoherent, but from my experience, perhaps ynot's also, is not a typical response. I get a much less coherent answer and personal experience of oneness with the deity almost always given. "I have a relationship with Jesus" for example, is often stated.
 
Theistic: I believe in a spiritual creator of the universe, aeternal, all-powerful and absolutely good, who knows all things --past, present and future.

Is it incoherent?
I wish I did get an answer like that. Unfortunately what I more often than not get is "Well, where do you think we/everything came from?" or "Well, what do you think happens to us when we die?". I usually don't even get incoherent answers, I get questions. When I do finally get answers it's usually goes something like this . . .

Them "Well, I believe in god".
Me "Sure, but what is god"
Them "Well god. Y'know, the god everyone believes in.
Me "I don't believe in any god"
Them "Well the god that people do believe in"
Me "There are many different gods people believe in"
. . .

These aren't normally dumb people, but being asked to think about and explain their god sure seems to make them dumb.
 
Last edited:
I understood it from the get go.

You are meandering through a long and winding road to explain the simple concept that human certainty about something does not make that something a reality. Well no ****, Sherlock!

All I'm pointing out to you is that you are butchering the everyday usage of the English language in order to make this irrelevant point. And for what? What is gained by such a tortuous semantics quibble? We all know that when a believer says, "I am certain that God exists," that this doesn't magically cause his God to exist. That what he is really saying is that "I believe with all my heart and soul that God exists." Of course it is! The point is so obvious that it isn't even worth talking about.

In the end, we humans can be certain of absolutely nothing; "certainty" is an illusion. But when we are talking to each other and one of us says, "I'm certain that God exists," we can understand each other without having to break it down into such ostentatious frippery.


OK, well that sounds like a sort of grudging way of accepting that I'm probably right in what I have said about those definitions and statements that say "X knows that God does/does-not, exist", but where you think I'm just making a mountain out of a molehill by complaining about it.

But I did try to explain above why I think it is important for all of us to avoid constantly repeating definitions that cannot be right. If we keep saying things like "theists are people who know that God exists" (or "atheists are people who know that God does not exist"), then we are quite deliberately making completely untrue statements about a claimed creator of the entire universe ... not just statements about or own mere beliefs, but statements that actually say that we (i.e. specific individual people) really do "know" that God exists as the intelligent creator of the universe ... that is absurd for us to accept as a definition of anyone or anything.

I'm just saying, please, let's avoid constantly making a whopping great error of claims like that. And in particular please lets avoid dictionary definitions which actually support such claims/descriptions without apparently any notion of why their definitions cannot be true/right ...

... otherwise if we all keep talking about defining ourselves as people who "know" God does exist or does not exist, we are just ensuring that every discussion of this subject (i.e. the existence of God, and hence the truth about everything & everyone in the entire universe) takes place entirely on the basis of deliberate self-deception (i.e. it's not true that you/me/anyone knows, or even can know, that God does or does not exist ... and we should stop trying to build arguments on the basis of faulty definitions that say we actually do “know” the fact or otherwise of God's existence … that's all, is that really too much to ask or to point out, just to say “guys, come on, please, lets not repeat definitions or statements like that which straightjacket all of us into the mistake of deliberately basing every discussion on a mistaken claim of saying that we really do know that God actually does/does-not, exist).

Look - if you want to say “well I am an atheist and I know God does not exist”, well then OK, just carry on then, say whatever you want. But it really does not help the credibility of our arguments if we keep keep building those arguments/debates/explanations on the basis of first insisting that we actually do know that God exists (or does not exist).
 
Well we started off so well but now this thread has degenerated into a slanging match between several posters.

On the subject of being reasoned out of religion, I sense the majority here are of the opinion we can expect limited success, if we try and use reason to persuade the religious. On the other hand we have a number of champions of the cause, writing very popular books and drawing on reason to challenge religious belief. Some authors, such as Richard Dawkins, claim a number of scalps, based on feedback from readers.

From my experience of exchanges with the faithful, I find the most effective arguments are those, where specific details of their own dogma are examined. It continues to surprise me, how little Biblical knowledge, is in the mind of the average Christian, and even more so the lack of thought, about the implications of Biblical teaching.

I wonder if others here have developed any strategies they find most effective.


Yeah, sure, OK ... lets get back to whether or not theists can be reasoned out of religious belief. :thumbsup:
 
Theistic: I believe in a spiritual creator of the universe, aeternal, all-powerful and absolutely good, who knows all things --past, present and future.

Is it incoherent?

I wish I did get an answer like that. Unfortunately what I more often than not get is "Well, where do you think we/everything came from?" or "Well, what do you think happens to us when we die?". I usually don't even get incoherent answers, I get questions. When I do finally get answers it's usually goes something like this . . .

Them "Well, I believe in god".
Me "Sure, but what is god"
Them "Well god. Y'know, the god everyone believes in.
Me "I don't believe in any god"
Them "Well the god that people do believe in"
Me "There are many different gods people believe in"
. . .

These aren't normally dumb people, but being asked to think about and explain their god sure seems to make them dumb.


Yes, the only answers I ever hear from theists in real life are that they reply with questions such as “where do you think everything came from, who created all of this?”. However I should add that I never engage in any discussion with theist friends or neighbours (the subject rarely comes up, and if it does then I never bother to say anything that might antagonise them). So the only time I hear what theists say is either when evangelists come to the door or if they stop me on the street (which occasionally happens), or of course here on this forum.

But as for any “strategy” of trying to reason theists out of their religious belief – people often criticise Richard Dawkins (and other well known atheists) saying that their approach is insulting to theists, that they are rude to theists and dismissive of their beliefs, and that it's counterproductive and just makes the theists resist the arguments that are made by Dawkins & others … and they say that a far better approach is to listen to what theists say, and to try having a polite respectful discussion with them.

Though, I have to say that from all the hundreds of filmed debates and conversations that I've seen on YouTube, from all the threads I have seen on forums like this, and from the far fewer direct conversations that I've ever had with theists (always Christians), I see no evidence at all that a more respectful listening approach works at all … from what I have seen it just indulges the theist into feeling even more confident when they find willing listeners who respectful talk with them of their claims of personally experiencing God or whatever.

I'm sure most theists will react with anger, hostility, or milder annoyance when atheists try to tell them in a direct way why God beliefs are really no longer credible in the light of what we have learned from the last century or two of modern science. But in the end I think that probably is the most effective approach, to be quite clear with them about how and why such things as the discovery of evolution really do show that God did not make any humans (and where that claim of creating humans was/is actually the entire basis of the religion) … or that claimed miracles such as those at Lourdes are now known to be either just outright deliberate frauds or else simply medical coincidences that are well known anyway … or even that what we have now discovered about the Big Bang and the origins of the universe has got to the position of us “knowing” quite accurately what happened right back to the very first second or so after the “bang”, so that theists who argue that we still do not know how it all began, are actually now left just arguing about that very first few seconds or even the first fraction of one second (i.e. all the other “gaps” where God was said to be hiding have now been accounted for by science, and theists have been pushed back to arguing over that last second to say that's where God must be hiding).

That said I don't think any of this would matter if theism was entirely benign, but unfortunately as we can clearly see (it should be clear, but of course all sorts of people will argue over this too) from the mass murders being carried out by groups like IS, religious belief is very far from being benign … in fact it's absolutely lethal as well as seriously anti-educational (e.g. attempts in the US to have Intelligent Design taught in school biology classes … as well of course for the overall/general need for all committed theists to reject almost all of science).

So for reasons like that, in the end, I think it's probably better for everyone on the planet if atheists do speak out against religious belief, and better if they do that in a constructive if fairly direct way (rather than trying be especially respectful as if to listen attentively to what theists believe etc.). You can do all that entirely politely of course, and without being overtly insulting or rude to anyone.
 
I wish I did get an answer like that. Unfortunately what I more often than not get is "Well, where do you think we/everything came from?" or "Well, what do you think happens to us when we die?". I usually don't even get incoherent answers, I get questions. When I do finally get answers it's usually goes something like this . . .

Them "Well, I believe in god".
Me "Sure, but what is god"
Them "Well god. Y'know, the god everyone believes in.
Me "I don't believe in any god"
Them "Well the god that people do believe in"
Me "There are many different gods people believe in"
. . .

These aren't normally dumb people, but being asked to think about and explain their god sure seems to make them dumb.

This usually happens because the theist, consciously or unconsciously, knows that there is not evidence that his god exists and even contradicts the facts on some important points. But if the theist were consistent, he should defend the existence of his god as defined in his sacred texts or theologies. (The definition I gave is catechism).

In those circumstances, vagueness is a natural answer of those that fight defensive. A vague proposition is more difficult to attack, I can derive in metaphors and become poetic without saying it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom