Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

I was reading something on the UK BBC news on Friday (nothing to do with this thread), and they were quoting something that was said a few years ago by some US politician. It was a reply to some assertion by someone, and he said “sir your are entitled to your own opinions, but not to your own facts” …

… I don't know who politician was and I am certainly not endorsing any of his politics or any other things he may or may not have done. But that answer sums up this situation entirely -

“You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own Facts” .

...which has nothing to do with whether or not there is a word which describes people who hold certain beliefs.

Tell me, do you accept that the word "Christian" exists? Do you accept that it describes people who believe that the Christian God exists? Do you accept that some of those people will believe "God exists" to be a factually true statement - regardless of whether or not it is?

If you can answer "yes" to all three of those questions, then I don't know WTF you're actually arguing about. And if you can only answer "no" to the third question, then I have to question whether you've actually met many Christians.
 
Last edited:
A lie doesn't get better because you repeat it! He could have documented his accusation (which I've asked him to do and which he'd be able to do if if weren't a strawman) but instead he's offended. Ynot might have helped him, but he'd rather keep up the pretense.


My, we are getting into a state about this!

It would seem the "strawmen" are breeding and popping up all over the place. Squeegee has accused you of bringing one in ^ now.

I prefer not to use that sort of retort in an argument, but rather specifically point out where I see the error in an opponent's argument. It may be a tad tedious but saves time in the long run. The time spent looking behind furniture and under rocks to find and identify the "strawman" being referred to.
 
I beg your pardon.



I beg your pardon!!

I beg your pardon!

Was not Jesus walking on the waters a fact for the believers? What was it then?

You guys talk funny.

Fact: something that is known to have happened or to exist.
"In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent.'"
- Stephen Jay Gould
 
"In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent.'"
- Stephen Jay Gould

It is Gould's opinion. I should agree if we nuanced it. In another sense, there is nothing definitive about science.

But the word "fact" is not only used in science. You can't scientifically prove that your child is hungry, but you think it is a fact. When we discuss whether Catilina's death is a fact, we are speaking in a different sense than facts about the nuclear fussion.

If we could only talk about facts in science, bad business.
 
Last edited:
...which has nothing to do with whether or not there is a word which describes people who hold certain beliefs.

Tell me, do you accept that the word "Christian" exists? Do you accept that it describes people who believe that the Christian God exists? Do you accept that some of those people will believe "God exists" to be a factually true statement - regardless of whether or not it is?
If you can answer "yes" to all three of those questions, then I don't know WTF you're actually arguing about. And if you can only answer "no" to the third question, then I have to question whether you've actually met many Christians.



Well you ought to know "WTF you're we are actually arguing about", because what you have said in that highlight is totally different from what you'd been arguing before, and it's exactly what I said to you at least a dozen times already in crystal clear language ... you are now saying "some of those people will believe "God exists" to be a factually true statement - regardless of whether or not it is?" ... well as I have pointed out you at least 12 times already, that statement actually admits that it is only a "belief" (they merely believe it's a fact) ... but until now you have been constantly disagreeing with me when I pointed that out, and you have been constantly claiming instead that it is correct from them to say "I am certain God exists, it's a fact" ...

... well it most definitely is not a "fact" ... "they are entitled to their own beliefs, but not to their own facts" ...

... they believe it's a "certainty" (and similarly, apparently, for some atheists) ... well that's a belief. But it's one which they cannot support with any real "proof" showing that God is actually a certainty, and until they can do that they, and you, are entirely wrong to say they know it to be a "certainty".
 
Last edited:
It is Gould's opinion. I should agree if we nuanced it. In another sense, there is nothing definitive about science.

But the word "fact" is not only used in science. You can't scientifically prove that your child is hungry, but you think it is a fact. When we discuss whether Catilina's death is a fact, we are speaking in a different sense than facts about the nuclear fussion.

If we could only talk about facts in science, bad business.
The important thing is to realise that science recognises all "facts" as provisional. We can come to conclusions based on the best of evidence, and we can be pretty confident about those conclusions, but it is always theoretically possible to come up with some reliable evidence that shows that we have misinterpreted, or that there is something we don't yet understand. After all, we could still be brains-in-jars.

Which is why IanS said that science is not in the business of "proving" "facts". Science is about coming to conclusions based on evidence.
 
Well you ought to know "WTF you're we are actually arguing about", because what you have said in that highlight is totally different from what you'd been arguing before, and it's exactly what I said to you at least a dozen times already in crystal clear language ... you are now saying "some of those people will believe "God exists" to be a factually true statement - regardless of whether or not it is?" ... well as I have pointed out you at least 12 times already, that statement actually admits that it is only a "belief" (they merely believe it's a fact) ... but until now you have been constantly disagreeing with me when I pointed that out, and you have been constantly claiming instead that it is correct from them to say "I am certain God exists, it's a fact" ...

... well it most definitely is not a "fact" ... "they are entitled to their own beliefs, but not to their own facts" ...

... they believe it's a "certainty" (and similarly, apparently, for some atheists) ... well that's a belief. But it's one which they cannot support with any real "proof" showing that God is actually a certainty, and until they can do that they, and you, are entirely wrong to say they know it to be a "certainty".

This strikes me as an odd use of language. Christians, Muslims, etc have a certainty about the existence of their God; it is as much a fact to them as the sky is blue. They are in all likelihood wrong, of course, but they are still certain about the factual existence of God. You are right in that their certainty does not change reality, but that seems obvious and who's even arguing that? Nobody I've seen in this thread.

ETA: IOW, I totally understood what Squeegee was saying the first time and it wasn't that Christian beliefs about god were anything other than beliefs. But from the Christian perspective, God's existence is a certainty -regardless of ultimate reality.
 
Last edited:
This strikes me as an odd use of language. Christians, Muslims, etc have a certainty about the existence of their God; it is as much a fact to them as the sky is blue. They are in all likelihood wrong, of course, but they are still certain about the factual existence of God. You are right in that their certainty does not change reality, but that seems obvious and who's even arguing that? Nobody I've seen in this thread.

ETA: IOW, I totally understood what Squeegee was saying the first time and it wasn't that Christian beliefs about god were anything other than beliefs. But from the Christian perspective, God's existence is a certainty -regardless of ultimate reality.

I wish you luck.
 
In sure and certain hope of the resurrection to eternal life
through Our Lord Jesus Christ, we commend to Almighty God ......


Thus the priest drones on as the casket is lowered into the ground.

What do these words tell us and why do I show them to readers now?

Up there ^ is a discussion about fact and certainty of Christian belief. The words in the quoted prayer give us an insight into the depth of that conviction. The words are not a statement of faith but a chant to re-inforce belief. "Sure and Certain Hope" ??? Do folk talk this way about something they are sure of?

I have spoken to a number of Christians and in my opinion the strength of their convictions can be questionable. I also know that the Catholic Church for example have clergy that "help" priests, who are having "trouble with their faith". Added to this we have the work of Dan Dennett with disbelieving clergy, who, as many attest, lose their faith in seminary, when they find out the dubious origins of the scriptures they hold as sacred.
 
The important thing is to realise that science recognises all "facts" as provisional. We can come to conclusions based on the best of evidence, and we can be pretty confident about those conclusions, but it is always theoretically possible to come up with some reliable evidence that shows that we have misinterpreted, or that there is something we don't yet understand. After all, we could still be brains-in-jars.
Provisionality of science is not a sheer theoretical possibility. Theories don't turn from "true" to "false" in a second. Every scientific proposition holds its provisionality in the form of different degree of possibility. Every scientific proposition is unstable, although this instability can be negligible in many cases.

I assume that this is what Gould's means with "perverse":

"In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent.'" (S. J. Gould).

Which is why IanS said that science is not in the business of "proving" "facts". Science is about coming to conclusions based on evidence.

But I don't understand how you can say that science don't prove facts (IanS and you) and that a fact is what science confirms (Gould). Is not to confirm the same as to prove by evidence? I am confused.

Perhaps you need to revise your vocabulary a little.
 
Last edited:
This strikes me as an odd use of language. Christians, Muslims, etc have a certainty about the existence of their God; it is as much a fact to them as the sky is blue. They are in all likelihood wrong, of course, but they are still certain about the factual existence of God. You are right in that their certainty does not change reality, but that seems obvious and who's even arguing that? Nobody I've seen in this thread.

ETA: IOW, I totally understood what Squeegee was saying the first time and it wasn't that Christian beliefs about god were anything other than beliefs. But from the Christian perspective, God's existence is a certainty -regardless of ultimate reality.


Well that is a belief, NOT a "certainty".

They are calling it a "certainty", but it most definitely is NOT a certainty is it!

What they mean, what you mean, and what Squeegee presumably means is "I believe it's certain" ... but you left out the crucial word "belief"! ... that word "belief" tells you that it's not actually a "certainty" at all, and that the word "certainty" is actually erroneous and completely wrong in that sort of statement, in fact it should not be in the statement at all, because all that the statement can really accurately say is "I believe God certainly exists".


I think you and Squeegee must applying the word "certainty" to the wrong thing here. I think you are applying it to persons belief, i.e. you are saying it is the persons belief that is the certainty (i.e. "they certainly do believe it"). But that is NOT, and never was, the subject of the discussion or dispute here. The subject/dispute was, and is, whether it is correct for anyone to say "God is the certainty" ... that's completely different from saying "my belief is the certainty".

Their belief may be a certainty. But the existence of the God most definitely is not a certainty.
 
What they mean, what you mean, and what Squeegee presumably means is "I believe it's certain" ... but you left out the crucial word "belief"! ...

I really think you should call it quits before you dig too much deeper. I don't usually do this, but if you go right back to the first post of mine which contains the word "certainty", from a quoted one of yours, right back at the start of our little derail:

Well first of all agnosticism is not (or should not be) merely the position of saying “we don't know whether or not there are gods”, because none of us truly know whether God (e.g. the Christian God, or any similar supernatural gods) could possibly exist. If we did really claim to “know”, then that is a claim of literal certainty, and that means you must be able to produce a complete proof … and of course nobody has ever produced any such total proof either way.
Perhaps it could be put as believing that you know whether God(s) exist(s) or not.

Right from the off, I'm saying that it's about the person's belief that they have certitude, or absolute knowledge.

That you've kept going off at random tangents, claiming that I'm saying something wildly different, no matter how many times I said that that wasn't what I was saying and explained what I was saying in a different way, doesn't change what it is that I've been saying all this time.

I'm glad that I finally found a way to get through to you. Please don't ruin that now. You understand at last. That's good. Let's let that small but hard-won victory be the end of the matter.
 
"In science, 'fact' can only mean 'confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent.'" (S. J. Gould).



But I don't understand how you can say that science don't prove facts (IanS and you) and that a fact is what science confirms (Gould). Is not to confirm the same as to prove by evidence? I am confused.
Clearly. Gould is offering a definition of the word "fact", though you seem to be interpreting it somehow to mean that it is using it as the goal of the sentence.

Gould is saying that in science, "fact" does not mean "definitive statement about the universe that is absolutely true". He is saying that it means "statement about the universe that is provisionally agreed to as being as close to reality as it is possible to get, given that further evidence may still be found that modifies our understanding".

Perhaps you need to revise your vocabulary a little.
Perhaps you do.
 
I really think you should call it quits before you dig too much deeper. I don't usually do this, but if you go right back to the first post of mine which contains the word "certainty", from a quoted one of yours, right back at the start of our little derail:

Well first of all agnosticism is not (or should not be) merely the position of saying “we don't know whether or not there are gods”, because none of us truly know whether God (e.g. the Christian God, or any similar supernatural gods) could possibly exist. If we did really claim to “know”, then that is a claim of literal certainty, and that means you must be able to produce a complete proof … and of course nobody has ever produced any such total proof either way.


Perhaps it could be put as believing that you know whether God(s) exist(s) or not. Then again, if you choose to disappear down that rabbit hole, then you can only really say that you believe that you know anything at all. But that was solipsim lies.


Right from the off, I'm saying that it's about the person's belief that they have certitude, or absolute knowledge.

That you've kept going off at random tangents, claiming that I'm saying something wildly different, no matter how many times I said that that wasn't what I was saying and explained what I was saying in a different way, doesn't change what it is that I've been saying all this time.

I'm glad that I finally found a way to get through to you. Please don't ruin that now. You understand at last. That's good. Let's let that small but hard-won victory be the end of the matter.


Well here is the whole of your reply from page 15 -

Perhaps it could be put as believing that you know whether God(s) exist(s) or not. Then again, if you choose to disappear down that rabbit hole, then you can only really say that you believe that you know anything at all. But that was solipsim lies.

But, yes, agnosticism is the position that we don't (or can't) know whether or not God(s) exist(s). Richard Dawkins is an agnostic. That doesn't make him any less of an atheist.


And here is what I said in direct reply to that -

Perhaps it could be put as believing that you know whether God(s) exist(s) or not. Then again, if you choose to disappear down that rabbit hole, then you can only really say that you believe that you know anything at all. But that was solipsim lies.

But, yes, agnosticism is the position that we don't (or can't) know whether or not God(s) exist(s). Richard Dawkins is an agnostic. That doesn't make him any less of an atheist.


If you only "believe" that you know something, then that is only a belief ... it's a belief in which you might be right or wrong. And that is 100% different from anyone claiming to actually know something as a literally certain unarguable fact ... if they say that, then they are claiming it's a fact for everyone (not merely for their own belief or opinion ... "facts" are not personal to individuals ... a "fact" is universal for everyone and everything).


After that there were a number of exchanges in which you constantly disputed, or took issue, with I had said to you there, where I said (repeatedly in every reply) that what you are describing from theists who say “it's certain that God exists”, is not actually a statement of certainty for God's existence at all … because if it were, as you kept arguing (see your red highlight below), then it would be an actual “Fact” that the God does indeed exist, and nobody would be able to dispute that, because you/they have just told us quite indisputably that it really is a literal certainty … what I think you mean is only that theists who say that, merely “believe” it's a certainty … and that's just exactly the same as saying “I believe God exists” … it's a belief, not a “certainty” for Gods indisputable existence.

Then later you replied to me saying this about it (page 19) -


If you merely "think" you know something, then that is only a belief or opinion (and I have explained that in detail at least half a dozen times already). To say "I think it's possible to know that God does or does not exist", is totally different from saying "I do know that God does or does not exist". This is just a very simple matter of correct use of English language. If you say "I know that A is true", then you are claiming it to be an absolute fact (not merely your own belief), which means you must be able to show a proof of certainty (if you cannot produce that absolute proof, then you were wrong ever to claim that you knew the "fact" for "certain").

IOW - what you have written here is constantly talking about peoples individual belief ... you are not actually talking about "fact".

Not to the person who has that certainty.


What you should clearly see there, and what you should instantly admit to, because you have done it in every reply you have made to me, is that you are constantly disputing what I have said when I first said to you (in fact from several pages before I had said it in that reply to you on page 15) is that when theists say “I am certain God exists”, that is a statement declaring it to be a factual certainty that God really does exist, i.e. a claim of actual universal indisputable “fact” about the universe … what you keep saying in reply to me is that they do feel certain that God exists … and what I have tried to explain repeatedly to you is that if they merely “feel” certain” about it, then that is just a personal feeling, opinion or “belief” … and personal belief or opinion is very VERY different from an actual “certainty” of reality about the universe such as saying “God does exist, it's a fact, it's certain”.

If I am being charitable (and I almost always am) what I think you really mean is that when theists say “God certainly exists, I am certain of it”, they feel certain of that in their own mind … but what I keep trying to explain or point out to you is that if someone merely “feels certain of it in their own mind”, then that is actually just a statement of opinion or personal belief … it is definitely not a statement of certainty showing God's factual existence as a reality in this universe.

As I just said earlier – what I think you are doing is making the mistake (sorry, but it is actually a mistake) of confusing someone saying they are certain about their beliefs vs someone saying “it IS certain that that their belief is actually true"… you might be certain of your beliefs, i.e. we could say again “you are entitled to your own beliefs”, but you cannot be certain that your belief really is true when you claim God certainly exists as a universal fact, i.e. “you are not entitled to your own facts”.

Is that clear? Do you understand the difference? Because that difference is crucial (it changes the entire meaning of the statement), and the two statements are incompatible with one-another; that is (to repeat for the 12th time or more ) - you might claim to be certain of your beliefs about the existence of God, but that is only a statement about your belief, it is emphatically NOT the same as claiming that “God certainly does exist” … the first statement claims certainty in your own mind for the validity of your beliefs about God … BUT the second statement claims that God definitely does exist as an indisputable fact about the real world quite irrespective of what anyone believes.
 
Last edited:
Well that is a belief, NOT a "certainty".
Sure, from an atheist/agnostic perspective -indeed, perhaps from a "universal reality" perspective- you are correct. From such a high-level perspective, it is not possible for a human to be certain about anything at all because we don't know enough for such certainty. "The sun will rise tomorrow," is about as certain a statement we can make but even that is not a certainty from the "universal reality" perspective -we could be wiped out in an instant by some heretofore unknown astronomical calamity.

But from a human perspective, that flawed, limited perspective of the faithful Christian, God's existence is as much a certainty as the sun rising tomorrow. By the same token, the flawed, limited perspective of the atheist could be completely wrong as well.

They are calling it a "certainty", but it most definitely is NOT a certainty is it!
From their perspective, it is a certainty.

What they mean, what you mean, and what Squeegee presumably means is "I believe it's certain" ... but you left out the crucial word "belief"! ... that word "belief" tells you that it's not actually a "certainty" at all, and that the word "certainty" is actually erroneous and completely wrong in that sort of statement, in fact it should not be in the statement at all, because all that the statement can really accurately say is "I believe God certainly exists".
This is semantic quibbling at its finest. By your argument, the word "certain" in all it's forms should be stricken from the English language because humans can never be certain about anything at all.

I think you and Squeegee must applying the word "certainty" to the wrong thing here. I think you are applying it to persons belief, i.e. you are saying it is the persons belief that is the certainty (i.e. "they certainly do believe it"). But that is NOT, and never was, the subject of the discussion or dispute here. The subject/dispute was, and is, whether it is correct for anyone to say "God is the certainty" ... that's completely different from saying "my belief is the certainty".

Their belief may be a certainty. But the existence of the God most definitely is not a certainty.
No. They are certain that God exists. They are most likely wrong, but that's irrelevant. One can be certain about things that are not factually true because of our flawed, limited human perspective. Like I said from the beginning, this is a "use of language" issue. Squeegee and I are using the language properly and our meaning is clear. You are insisting on some hyper-literal use of language where the word "certain" must reflect "universal reality." That ain't the way it works.
 
My, we are getting into a state about this!

It would seem the "strawmen" are breeding and popping up all over the place. Squeegee has accused you of bringing one in ^ now.

I prefer not to use that sort of retort in an argument, but rather specifically point out where I see the error in an opponent's argument. It may be a tad tedious but saves time in the long run. The time spent looking behind furniture and under rocks to find and identify the "strawman" being referred to.


Yes, when you export your strawman to other threads, they actually are "breeding and popping up all over the place."
That you are good at pointing out where others (erroneously) claim to have done something, which they haven't, doesn't really make up for your lies, but it probably saves you a lot of time, which is one of the worst excuses I've heard for not trying to document your claims.
 
Last edited:
After that there were a number of exchanges in which you constantly disputed, or took issue, with I had said to you there, where I said (repeatedly in every reply) that what you are describing from theists who say “it's certain that God exists”, is not actually a statement of certainty for God's existence at all … because if it were, as you kept arguing (see your red highlight below), then it would be an actual “Fact” that the God does indeed exist, and nobody would be able to dispute that, because you/they have just told us quite indisputably that it really is a literal certainty … what I think you mean is only that theists who say that, merely “believe” it's a certainty … and that's just exactly the same as saying “I believe God exists” … it's a belief, not a “certainty” for Gods indisputable existence.

Yes, you did keep arguing that it's impossible for someone to be certain of something if they're wrong. It was, and still is, a very strange opinion to hold.

If I am being charitable (and I almost always am) what I think you really mean is that when theists say “God certainly exists, I am certain of it”, they feel certain of that in their own mind … but what I keep trying to explain or point out to you is that if someone merely “feels certain of it in their own mind”, then that is actually just a statement of opinion or personal belief … it is definitely not a statement of certainty showing God's factual existence as a reality in this universe.

Well done. Glad you've finally joined the rest of us.

As I just said earlier – what I think you are doing is making the mistake (sorry, but it is actually a mistake) of confusing someone saying they are certain about their beliefs vs someone saying “it IS certain that that their belief is actually true"… you might be certain of your beliefs, i.e. we could say again “you are entitled to your own beliefs”, but you cannot be certain that your belief really is true when you claim God certainly exists as a universal fact, i.e. “you are not entitled to your own facts”.

Of course what people believe doesn't affect objective reality. That doesn't change the fact that that's what they honestly believe.

Is that clear? Do you understand the difference?

I've never disputed that what someone says about reality isn't necessarily the same as what reality actually is. I've no idea why you even ever brought the idea of objective reality into the discussion. It's purely a tin drum you've been banging on about and has absolutely nothing whatsoever with anything I've said at any point.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom