If one has an opinion, one formed it from something; probably from several somethings.
Speaking in very broad terms, when someone tells me that they know people in the past were different from us today in some particular way, I want to know how they know that, or if they are just reminiscing. They don't need reams of statistical data to prove it. I just want to know how they know that. Let's say any one of you makes this claim:
"People didn't beat up on bums in the past the way they do today."
How do you know that? It seems very important to me to understand a statement like that in order to understand the problem we're supposed to be discussing. It seems essential.
You asked for evidence. I asked what kind of evidence you wanted. You never answered.
I'd think that a skeptic would like to define the parameters of the discussion, and at least give a suggestion for how the other poster to go to find something more concrete than just memories. But I dunno, I'm not an expert apparently.
I know people fairly well, and I don't think any period in human history was ever "kinder or gentler."
Please quote where I stated that it was "Kinder or gentler"?
My sources for that opinion are my study of history and my personal observation. The former can be researched easily and the latter can't be researched at all. The latter is lousy for fact-finding.
That's fine, and I
never asked you to accept my opinion as perfectly valid. Get that straight before you continue to attack me, please.
However, if you knew how I came about my opinion, you could evaluate my opinion much better. There is nothing inherently hostile or demeaning in asking someone how they came to know a particular thing. No, the hostility comes in when they immediately rise to a defense that isn't needed. I wasn't saying LW was wrong: I was asking LW how s/he knew.
"He". And I asked, specifically, what would be required. I often hear, "evidence?" on this forum, and when someone links something, it's often ignored or, quite frankly, dismissed, somewhat arbitrarily. I wanted to cut down on meaningless conversation and dismissal, and wanted to cut to the chase: What, specifically, did you want as evidence?
I can go from personal observations and personal opinion, which is mainly what I have, but I don't want to. I can say that it doesn't make sense to me how in an era like Prohibition, where WASPs would come down to try to help everyone out in the slums, that homeless were considered to be garbage, but I don't. I want to deal with something concrete, but I don't know what you, specifically, want to tackle. That's why I asked.
Are the homeless regarded worse today than they were at certain points in, say, American history? How do you know that?
Could you please quote where I stated that the homeless are regarded as worse today? I never stated that. In fact, I lean towards the opposite; I think that they are treated, overall, better; but I don't think that mainstream society necessarily considered them as worthless garbage without meaning as human beings compared to today. That's all. I never stated that they were
worse. And this is my problem: You're asking me to prove something that
I didn't even claim!
Are more people, and especially more kids, assaulting the obviously helpless in our society today, and if so, what might be driving this increase?
I don't think that more people are assaulting the homeless more than before. I think, however, that they're getting reported on a lot more than before. That's an issue with the mass media; it's far better today than it was 50 years ago. You don't need newspapers anymore, you just need to use google. Do you need a cite on that?
As soon as that's answered, and answered satisfactorily, then perhaps we can focus on possible remedies, or else why are we even discussing it? So we can cluck our tongues in dismay and feel superior?
Once more:
Without even knowing what I'm claiming, and in fact claiming that I'm saying the opposite of what I'm actually saying, there will not be any good discussion on this topic at all!
All I asked, was what kind of evidence you wanted. That's all. You want some kind of evidence, or you want none at all; you certainly don't want me to spam all sorts of links to you that you don't find convincing, do you? You also obviously want something more than what I, myself, witnessed; you want a source you can view, don't you?
But this doesn't make me a skeptic, apparently. This makes me a "woo-woo believer". Go figure.
Apparently, expecting me to be a goddamn psychic isn't woo either...