Beating the Homeless - What's with this trend?

They were treated about the same, in other words? Evidence?

Is there evidence that they were treated more horribly?

If not, then we're both simply arguing from our perceptions..

Let's simplify this:

What's your claim, what's my claim, and what would convince you one way or the other?

Claiming that evidence would be nice is okay, but what form of evidence? Newspaper clippings would be more or less anecdotal, are there statistics of homeless slayings? Are those statistics even reliable, or were records sloppy back then?

What exactly would be required here?
 
I have no claim. I'm looking for evidence. I believe you made some statements from opinion that could probably be verified. That would be your job.

Arguments of opinion, while often interesting, prove little. You said you thought some things about the homeless and how society tends to view them. Can you prove any of the things you think, or was this just a handful of posts about how you feel?

One is a meaningful discussion.

One isn't.
 
I have no claim. I'm looking for evidence. I believe you made some statements from opinion that could probably be verified. That would be your job.

Y'know, I'm tired of this "your job" business. It is possible for two people to work together to try to verify something (GASP! O RLY?!). Scientists often discover incredible things, even when disagreeing with each other, by simply helping each other verify the facts through repeated experiments. They go, "Okay, so we disagree, what would verify your claim, what would verify mine? Let's go find out if they'll be verified!" "Skeptics", however, seem to refuse to.

You don't claim what "evidence" would be valid to change your perception. You let the other person have to go around and scrounge everything for you to dessiminate (and probably throw out). There is no provisions set; how should I know what evidence you will consider "valid" or not? What will irrefutably prove my point? I'd like to know before I engage in hours of study for your convenience. I mean, I asked you, but you still didn't define what evidence you considered to be valid. Even scientists set some sort of goalpost before conducting an experiment. What will demonstrate a hypothesis to be right or wrong? That's the stage I'm at: I have a hypothesis, and that hypothesis is that there hasn't been a radical sludge of murders of the homeless since fifty to 70 years ago, and there hasn't been a radical downfall of those murders either. There's also my hypothesis of how the homeless aren't suddenly treated in some radical new light compared to a few decades ago. How do I conduct my experiment? I have no ***in' clue, else why would I ask? How do I prove public perception? I can probably find statistics for the former, but the latter?

Instead, I just get yet another lecture.

Yes, I'm making a claim about what I feel is the case. If you disagree with that claim as being valid, then help me find evidence for or against it. Help me figure out what evidence will be valid. I don't mind people asking me for evidence, but the assumption seems to be that everyone will be able to immediately find evidence, out of thin air, provided by the Evidence Fairies. It's not always the case. And hell, I'm young and stupid, and I'm still willing to ask for some help; I want to know what is valid and what isn't before I go and try to dig it up. I really don't want to waste more forum bandwidth and more poster time going off on tangents, unlike certain other posters on this forum (and no, not you... I don't think).

Newspaper clippings will prove nothing either way. They just prove what some reporter put in as an article, and any stories are really anecdotal in the end.

Statistics? Are there valid statistics that can help prove my point? I obviously don't know, otherwise why would I ask? If someone knows, I'd love to hear. If someone can help me find statistics, I'd love for that assistance. Even if it proves my claim as wrong. Where should I look? What websites can provide that information? Are there search directories? What statistics would be considered valid? I don't know.

We're not all One-(Wo)Man Evidence Machines here.
 
Last edited:
I see.

So in your world it's wrong to ask someone to back up what they claim with any facts or figures, studies, information.....you know, proof?

People can just say whatever they want, and you accept it, because it sounds right, or maybe you trust them?

Really sorry you're tired of being asked to back up what you state. How about you just make up any old crap you like, and I'll pretend I believe it? Will that make you feel more comfortable?

Like it or not, when you make a claim, you either need to back it up with some kind of proof, or count on many people not really caring what you have to say. All I did was ask you a couple of questions and warn against a fallacy. It really wasn't a personal attack. It still isn't, though I am taking exception to your attitude.

You stated a few things as if you think they are facts. I am asking for your proof. There is nothing hostile about doing so. If you are merely stating opinion, I have no idea how informed your opinions are, nor what helped you in forming them. I have no idea why I should give any credence to your opinions. For all I know, you made it all up. Now, when you present a statement, an argument, or a claim, it really is your job to back up your own words. Want to explain to me why I should do the hard work of gathering your proof? Proof you should already have examined before making a claim?

I am a skeptic. I am skeptical of what I hear or read. I have swallowed enough crap in my life that I'm full, really, but thanks. I like facts, information, things to study, compare, contrast, and analyze. Got any?
 
I see.

So in your world it's wrong to ask someone to back up what they claim with any facts or figures, studies, information.....you know, proof?

The language used up to this point shows that you entirely missed the point of my post. I didn't bother to continue reading, as this would just be a waste of time.

I never claimed that asking for evidence was wrong. In fact, I specifically mentioned that I don't mind being asked for evidence. I just also think that it's possible for people to work together to find evidence for a claim, even if they disagree.

And the "in your world" remark was insulting. I did not realize that I had said anything to provoke such a response. I apologize if any of my remarks were insulting towards you.

I'm out. Don't bother to respond, this thread is going off my subscription.
 
Again, I see clearly. You resent being asked to back up your opinions.
I have a list, too. I put wasters of my time on it.
 
The number of mental patients ousted from institutions was noteworthy and gladly the number of violent crimes perpetuated by the homeless never reached the proportions predicted, but it was certainly sad to see human beings treated in such a manner all for a $.

The civil rights movement was a major driving force for deinstitutionalization. It wasn't just a question of dollars: people got screwed over because of misguided altruism as well.

It was also noteworthy that a good many of these homeless were Vietnam veterans, so if anything can be said of Republican administrations trying to save money - at least they're consistent.

Vietnam veterans were statistically no more likely to be homeless than their non-veteran counterparts. If you saw a disproportionate number of homeless people claiming to be vets, that may have been all it was: people claiming to be vets who weren't.
 
Again, I see clearly.

In the same way someone with cataracts sees clearly? Yeah, you do.

You resent being asked to back up your opinions.

No, I resent the straw man that you made of my last post, and this claim: "So in your world it's wrong to ask someone to back up what they claim with any facts or figures, studies, information.....you know, proof?"

Since when did I ever claim that it was wrong to ask someone to back up what they claim? In fact, if you actually read my post, I made the statement that I don't mind asking for evidence. But then you got all uppity when I stated that:

A) I think that it's possible for two people to work together on any one claim, if both are really interested in finding out the truth on the matter, even if the two disagree. I do not think that, in all cases, it should be entirely delegated to only one person. I never claimed that it was wrong to ask me for evidence, nor did I claim that you should be the one to clamber for the evidence.

And then:

B) I would like to know what kind of evidence to look for. What exactly do you want? Statistical analysis? Newspaper clippings? Please, give me some sort of reference? I'm not going to waste two goddamn hours sifting through encyclopedias, just for you to state, "Oh, that's not the evidence I was looking for. Sorry. So go and shut up, because you're not a real skeptic." You never stated what kind of evidence you would find convincing. I don't know why. It was a serious question; in this particular case, what evidence would you find convincing? The answer seems to be "nothing".

But I know, this violates your personal Skeptic Code (tm) or somesuch. Pfft, and I'm called the waste of time.


I have a list, too. I put wasters of my time on it.

That's good. I should make one myself. It would definitely save time on this forum.

I see that you not only misconstrued my statement, but also made insulting statements doing so. I expected much better from you. I actually thought you had higher standards than some other posters here. I may have very well been mistaken. It's really disappointing; I'm actually depressed over this.

Oh well. I'll probably get over it.

I know I said I'd get rid of my subscription to this thread. I did, but I couldn't resist coming back to it. I should just let it go. But I guess that I still hold out some hope for you understanding what I'm saying. Because you obviously have incredibly failed so far.



I just want to make a question to other posters in this forum:

Is it okay to ask what evidence a specific person, for a specific topic, would find convincing? Am I entirely wrong in assuming that it is a valid question, before one goes about to find that evidence?

I'm just curious here. It seems that I don't match the skeptic criteria, and I so want to be like all of you guys.
 
Last edited:
In the same way someone with cataracts sees clearly? Yeah, you do.



No, I resent the straw man that you made of my last post, and this claim: "So in your world it's wrong to ask someone to back up what they claim with any facts or figures, studies, information.....you know, proof?"

Since when did I ever claim that it was wrong to ask someone to back up what they claim? In fact, if you actually read my post, I made the statement that I don't mind asking for evidence. But then you got all uppity when I stated that:

A) I think that it's possible for two people to work together on any one claim, if both are really interested in finding out the truth on the matter, even if the two disagree. I do not think that, in all cases, it should be entirely delegated to only one person. I never claimed that it was wrong to ask me for evidence, nor did I claim that you should be the one to clamber for the evidence.

And then:

B) I would like to know what kind of evidence to look for. What exactly do you want? Statistical analysis? Newspaper clippings? Please, give me some sort of reference? I'm not going to waste two goddamn hours sifting through encyclopedias, just for you to state, "Oh, that's not the evidence I was looking for. Sorry. So go and shut up, because you're not a real skeptic." You never stated what kind of evidence you would find convincing. I don't know why. It was a serious question; in this particular case, what evidence would you find convincing? The answer seems to be "nothing".

But I know, this violates your personal Skeptic Code (tm) or somesuch. Pfft, and I'm called the waste of time.




That's good. I should make one myself. It would definitely save time on this forum.

I see that you not only misconstrued my statement, but also made insulting statements doing so. I expected much better from you. I actually thought you had higher standards than some other posters here. I may have very well been mistaken. It's really disappointing; I'm actually depressed over this.

Oh well. I'll probably get over it.

I know I said I'd get rid of my subscription to this thread. I did, but I couldn't resist coming back to it. I should just let it go. But I guess that I still hold out some hope for you understanding what I'm saying. Because you obviously have incredibly failed so far.



I just want to make a question to other posters in this forum:

Is it okay to ask what evidence a specific person, for a specific topic, would find convincing? Am I entirely wrong in assuming that it is a valid question, before one goes about to find that evidence?

I'm just curious here. It seems that I don't match the skeptic criteria, and I so want to be like all of you guys.
uh, with no offense, when you say you are leaving (not harassment - just pointing out) it works better if you actually leave - it makes your point better. As far as asking what would qualify as evidence : specifically I don't think you could find enough to prove anything about crimes to the homeless short of examining every police write up of every crime in most of the cities in the US having sufficient size to have any quantity of homeless over the last however many years your supposition covered. Reason is few if any police departments keep that type of general statistics on crimes - it is hard enough maintaining the data they actually need much less data which would really only be of advantage to social scientists. So, is the info available to prove/disprove your idea(s)? Yes!! Is it available in effective, useable form? No!!!Is it actually fair, given that circumstance to put any of the onus of research on anyone else (you take the cities west of the Rockies, you take the cities between the Rockies and the Mississippi, I'll take 'em east of the Mississippi. Let's meet up with the data in about , say, 12 years - Oh, here's your two million to live on while we do this travel and hunting!)? Not really. I assure you (I neither have nor will I attempt to find proof of this) my description of the task is pretty much correct, I assure you I am almost certainly underestimating the time it would take three people to do it (don't forget, if you don't halt it at, say, this year each has to keep up with current as well as past). Oh, if cases are filed by crime, it will help since only murders, assaults, and related need be looked for. Not sure how many police dept.s do that but...

If this sounds like a put-down, I apologise - it is not meant to be one. My purpose is to point out the following: everyone has opinions and if you are asked your opinion I believe firmly you should never be required to support it or be harassed for not doing so. If you, on the other hand, choose to give your opinion unasked, it is legitimate to ask why/how you formulated your opinion (a number of posters here do not like to distinguish this, I do.). But, I do not think in this case that your opinion can be formed from data, because the data does not exist in a form sufficient to be available to you so , by default, it must be an uninformed opinion - which you have a perfect right to but must not expect skeptics to accept. That is a key to being a skeptic - evidence must be presented for a statement to be accepted as reasonable/ more evidence to be accepted as true - and it must be easy to see the evidence in usable form (not, "you just have to look through all the US police reports for the last 100 years" or "you just have to translate and then read this 1120 page treatise in trans-Arabic to see why I am utterly correct" or "just watch this really lousy home video with sound that jumps in and out and lasts 17 hours - by the time it is through, you'll see how the laser beams made a big lizard trample the WTC - all three of them in the middle of Cincinnatti last labor day!!!):) Hope this helps!!:) :)
 
uh, with no offense, when you say you are leaving (not harassment - just pointing out) it works better if you actually leave - it makes your point better.

Yeah, well, I didn't.

I should have, though.

fuelair backwards said:
If this sounds like a put-down, I apologise - it is not meant to be one. My purpose is to point out the following: everyone has opinions and if you are asked your opinion I believe firmly you should never be required to support it or be harassed for not doing so.

And my question is this:

Why can't I ask you to define what kind of evidence you require?

How the hell do I prove common mindset of the time period? I don't know. Do you have advice? What's what I was asking for.

For some reason, this seems to = "I don't need to support my claim with evidence". I fail to see why. And quite frankly, if Slingblade is going to get snippy when I ask what evidence, in particular, she requires, then quite frankly I'm done with her.
 
If one has an opinion, one formed it from something; probably from several somethings.

Speaking in very broad terms, when someone tells me that they know people in the past were different from us today in some particular way, I want to know how they know that, or if they are just reminiscing. They don't need reams of statistical data to prove it. I just want to know how they know that. Let's say any one of you makes this claim:

"People didn't beat up on bums in the past the way they do today."

How do you know that? It seems very important to me to understand a statement like that in order to understand the problem we're supposed to be discussing. It seems essential.

I know people fairly well, and I don't think any period in human history was ever "kinder or gentler." I think that's nostalgic bushwa. My sources for that opinion are my study of history and my personal observation. The former can be researched easily and the latter can't be researched at all. The latter is lousy for fact-finding.

However, if you knew how I came about my opinion, you could evaluate my opinion much better. There is nothing inherently hostile or demeaning in asking someone how they came to know a particular thing. No, the hostility comes in when they immediately rise to a defense that isn't needed. I wasn't saying LW was wrong: I was asking LW how s/he knew.

Are the homeless regarded worse today than they were at certain points in, say, American history? How do you know that? Are more people, and especially more kids, assaulting the obviously helpless in our society today, and if so, what might be driving this increase?


As soon as that's answered, and answered satisfactorily, then perhaps we can focus on possible remedies, or else why are we even discussing it? So we can cluck our tongues in dismay and feel superior?

So, if it's true, if the homeless were generally better regarded 50 years ago, then what might have happened between now and then to make this change? But if it's not true, if the homeless are no better regarded today, then where do we look for any kind of explanation or answer to the current problem?

Look, the thread title itself begs the question: No one has yet established that beating the homeless IS a trend, have they? I'm not willing to let such statements simply pass, unchallenged. We can't have a discussion if we do--we can have only mental wanking and glad-handing ourselves for being so socially conscious that we have noticed this trend. Oh, big deal.

It's possible the discussion may be going wrong if we are focusing first on the "fact" that this is a new trend, before we've even established that "fact."

I read the whole thread, and then picked one recent poster who had pretty much encaspulated my concern in his/her posts. And I asked in the most passive, neutral language I owned: "How do you know this?" I also stated, by focusing on myself, that I would be wary of falling into a "good old days" trap when looking at the history of this particular social phenomenon.

The poster responded, it seems to me, as if to an assault. Go read that post of mine again. All I asked was "how do you know that?"

If this is a problem, then I fully miscomprehend the very notion of skepticism and hereby resolve to go back to Woo-land, where evidence and proof don't matter, either. There won't be any difference.
 
Last edited:
If one has an opinion, one formed it from something; probably from several somethings.

Speaking in very broad terms, when someone tells me that they know people in the past were different from us today in some particular way, I want to know how they know that, or if they are just reminiscing. They don't need reams of statistical data to prove it. I just want to know how they know that. Let's say any one of you makes this claim:

"People didn't beat up on bums in the past the way they do today."

How do you know that? It seems very important to me to understand a statement like that in order to understand the problem we're supposed to be discussing. It seems essential.

You asked for evidence. I asked what kind of evidence you wanted. You never answered.

I'd think that a skeptic would like to define the parameters of the discussion, and at least give a suggestion for how the other poster to go to find something more concrete than just memories. But I dunno, I'm not an expert apparently.

I know people fairly well, and I don't think any period in human history was ever "kinder or gentler."

Please quote where I stated that it was "Kinder or gentler"?

My sources for that opinion are my study of history and my personal observation. The former can be researched easily and the latter can't be researched at all. The latter is lousy for fact-finding.

That's fine, and I never asked you to accept my opinion as perfectly valid. Get that straight before you continue to attack me, please.

However, if you knew how I came about my opinion, you could evaluate my opinion much better. There is nothing inherently hostile or demeaning in asking someone how they came to know a particular thing. No, the hostility comes in when they immediately rise to a defense that isn't needed. I wasn't saying LW was wrong: I was asking LW how s/he knew.

"He". And I asked, specifically, what would be required. I often hear, "evidence?" on this forum, and when someone links something, it's often ignored or, quite frankly, dismissed, somewhat arbitrarily. I wanted to cut down on meaningless conversation and dismissal, and wanted to cut to the chase: What, specifically, did you want as evidence?

I can go from personal observations and personal opinion, which is mainly what I have, but I don't want to. I can say that it doesn't make sense to me how in an era like Prohibition, where WASPs would come down to try to help everyone out in the slums, that homeless were considered to be garbage, but I don't. I want to deal with something concrete, but I don't know what you, specifically, want to tackle. That's why I asked.

Are the homeless regarded worse today than they were at certain points in, say, American history? How do you know that?

Could you please quote where I stated that the homeless are regarded as worse today? I never stated that. In fact, I lean towards the opposite; I think that they are treated, overall, better; but I don't think that mainstream society necessarily considered them as worthless garbage without meaning as human beings compared to today. That's all. I never stated that they were worse. And this is my problem: You're asking me to prove something that I didn't even claim!

Are more people, and especially more kids, assaulting the obviously helpless in our society today, and if so, what might be driving this increase?

I don't think that more people are assaulting the homeless more than before. I think, however, that they're getting reported on a lot more than before. That's an issue with the mass media; it's far better today than it was 50 years ago. You don't need newspapers anymore, you just need to use google. Do you need a cite on that?

As soon as that's answered, and answered satisfactorily, then perhaps we can focus on possible remedies, or else why are we even discussing it? So we can cluck our tongues in dismay and feel superior?

Once more: Without even knowing what I'm claiming, and in fact claiming that I'm saying the opposite of what I'm actually saying, there will not be any good discussion on this topic at all!

All I asked, was what kind of evidence you wanted. That's all. You want some kind of evidence, or you want none at all; you certainly don't want me to spam all sorts of links to you that you don't find convincing, do you? You also obviously want something more than what I, myself, witnessed; you want a source you can view, don't you?

But this doesn't make me a skeptic, apparently. This makes me a "woo-woo believer". Go figure.

Apparently, expecting me to be a goddamn psychic isn't woo either...
 
Last edited:
Double post

(My first one, too)

I like rubber duckies.

Here's a quote of myself:

I agree. But I don't think that the average populace, if they heard about a particular case where a scientist that killed someone for their experiments, would tend to like that scientist. But I agree that we've progressed, but at the same time I don't think that, say, 50 years ago, people were far more uncaring for the homeless than today.

Bolding mine.

This reads the same as claiming, "WOW, today the homeless are treated so much worse than the past!!"?

Looking back to what I said, I somewhat disagree with myself. New immigrants were forced into slums (though that was prejudice against immigrants, not necessarily the poor), and quality of life was poor. Pollution was great. That's great and all, but were homeless considered as less than human? If a homeless man was killed, and some group of protestant old women heard about it, wouldn't they give a damn? I would think so. I dunno, I could be wrong. On the average, I think that people may have accepted some more horrible things than we would do now, mainly because such horrible things were seen in average day life. I mean, slum life was godawful, and I would be the first to admit that.

I can't prove anything, 'cause I don't know the first f***ing place to look. I WOULD know if someone was kind enough to help guide me, but that's not skeptical of me to ask!
 
Last edited:
uh, I wasn't kidding - the only place you will find most records of crimes (treatment) of the homeless are in the police files and those are vast - but there is a lot of sociological data that could be mined from them. Any other source is not going to be nearly that extensive.
 
uh, I wasn't kidding - the only place you will find most records of crimes (treatment) of the homeless are in the police files and those are vast - but there is a lot of sociological data that could be mined from them. Any other source is not going to be nearly that extensive.

And I thank you that you provided that information.

But, still, I'm mainly making a point here, for Slingblade.

I'll look into that when I have free time. I got a lot of work on my hands thanks to school, and I haven't searched through police records before. :boggled:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom