Beating the Homeless - What's with this trend?

Mephisto

Philosopher
Joined
Apr 10, 2005
Messages
6,064
What is with this recent trend? I can't understand how someone as young as 10 years old can consider this entertainment. Is it a combination of lack or morals and bad parenting or just the fact that the world has turned more violent? Whatever it is, it's plain to see that empathy for others is in short reserve.

10-year-olds attack, beat homeless man, police say

POSTED: 3:56 a.m. EDT, March 30, 2007

By Ashley Fantz
CNN

(CNN) -- Egged on by a 17-year-old, two 10-year-old boys joined in the attack of a Florida homeless man, leaving him bruised and bloody, police said.

The incident highlights an upswing in violent crime across the U.S. against the homeless.

In 2006, there were 142 attacks and 20 murders, several involving teenagers seeking a vicious thrill, according to the Washington, D.C.-based National Coalition for the Homeless.

Tuesday's incident, which took place in Daytona Beach, Florida, may make history, said the nonprofit's acting executive director Michael Stoops.

"If we're talking about 10-year-olds, that means we've hit an all-time low," said Stoops. "The youngest person to have ever been arrested for a crime like this is 13." (Read CNN's exclusive story about homeless 'sport killings')

Daytona Police Sgt. Billy Walden said the teen and two boys were walking in their neighborhood around 9 p.m. when they saw 58-year-old John D'Amico. They began throwing rocks at the homeless man.

http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/03/29/homeless.attack/index.html
 
I think the only new thing is it being noteworthy. Violent and senseless crimes against homeless people are not new. Caring about it is.
 
Last edited:
What is with this recent trend?

Well, people get upset nowadays if you beat up n*ggers, w*ps, sp*cs, ch*nks, or f*ggots.

Even w*men have gotten uppity about this kind of thing.

Who's left to be a target of random, senseless violence?
 
Maybe these kids somehow got the message that homeless people have zero worth in our society.
 
"Egged on by a 17-year-old, two 10-year-old boys joined in the attack of a Florida homeless man, leaving him bruised and bloody, police said.
The incident highlights an upswing in violent crime across the U.S. against the homeless.

In 2006, there were 142 attacks and 20 murders, several involving teenagers seeking a vicious thrill..... "


:boggled:

OK....so these dirtbag punks are so bored/spoiled/stupid/whatever that they need a "vicious thrill?" No problem - throw em in jail. Repeat, not a detention center - JAIL. They'll get plenty. Oh and the parents are probably good candidates for this as well.

Un-believable
 
OK....so these dirtbag punks are so bored/spoiled/stupid/whatever that they need a "vicious thrill?" No problem - throw em in jail. Repeat, not a detention center - JAIL. They'll get plenty. Oh and the parents are probably good candidates for this as well.

I can see it now.

"OMG! I just got stabbed with a shank, in my kidney! Wait until my Livejournal friends hear about this! This mortal wound is teh suXX0r!one!"
 
Last edited:
This is the result of 20 plus years of dehumanizing the homeless. When most homeless have problems with mental illness but are portrayed as lazy and subhuman it is easy to cross the line from either caring or indifference to violence.
 
This is the result of 20 plus years of dehumanizing the homeless. When most homeless have problems with mental illness but are portrayed as lazy and subhuman it is easy to cross the line from either caring or indifference to violence.

Sorry, could you identify the precise event which caused the dehumanizing of the homeless, and show how homeless people were well regarded before this event two decades ago?
 
I am waiting for Jack Thompson to chime in and blame video games for this.

Fred Phelps will blame homosexuals.

Skeptigirl will blame Bush.

Rush Limbaugh will blame the liberal media.

Fox News will blame Al Franken.

Cartman will blame it on Canada.

Canada will blame the Danes.

The Danes will blame the Germans

The Germans will blame the Jews.

The Jews will shrug their shoulders and exclaim "Saw that one coming. Who do we get to blame?"

Then we'll all have tea. And goat's milk. Uh, nanny goat's milk. (WC Fields ref)

DR
 
Last edited:
Sorry, could you identify the precise event which caused the dehumanizing of the homeless, and show how homeless people were well regarded before this event two decades ago?

Don't be any stupider than you have to. Very few cultural events have single precise causes (what precise event caused the Vietnam war to be regarded badly?).

If you want to know some of the major shifts in people's view of the homeless, twenty years ago is a little too recent. Much of the currentUS policy, and by extension, current US culture, was set during the Reagan administration. By cutting funds to the relevant agencies -- most notably, cutting funds for the department of Housing and Urban Development by about 75% in 1981, which is a specific event you can look up -- the amount of subsidized housing available was drastically cut. Similarly, his appointees for HUD were among the most corrupt of his administration, which also greatly reduced the effectiveness of the agency. The general effect was to vastly increase the number and visibiliy of homeless in the United States, while at the same time establishing an effective official policy of unresponsiveness.

Similarly, Reagan was among the first to strongly publicize the image of "welfare queens" who were milking the system for unwarranted benefits, leading to a strong cutback in benefits for the needy of all sorts.

Another aspect was the increasing de-institutionalization of the mentally ill, a trend that had actually started under Carter (cf. the Mental Health Sytems Act, which tried to put a reasonable and medically-based framework in place for treatment of the chronically mentallly ill), but accelerated under Reagan, again largely due to funding cuts to the relevant professionals.

The effect of this was to change the character of the homeless over the 1980s. Instead of viewing homelessness as a result of unfortunate economic circumstances, people began to believe that it was the result of character flaws (see Reagan's famous 1984 quote "People who are sleeping on the grates…the homeless…are homeless, you might say, by choice.") Whether due to drug abuse, mental illness, or simple "choice," obviously homelessness is not a problem that people need help with.... but instead it's a self-inflicted punishment for being the wrong sort of person.
 
Don't be any stupider than you have to. Very few cultural events have single precise causes (what precise event caused the Vietnam war to be regarded badly?).

If you want to know some of the major shifts in people's view of the homeless, twenty years ago is a little too recent. Much of the currentUS policy, and by extension, current US culture, was set during the Reagan administration. By cutting funds to the relevant agencies -- most notably, cutting funds for the department of Housing and Urban Development by about 75% in 1981, which is a specific event you can look up -- the amount of subsidized housing available was drastically cut. Similarly, his appointees for HUD were among the most corrupt of his administration, which also greatly reduced the effectiveness of the agency. The general effect was to vastly increase the number and visibiliy of homeless in the United States, while at the same time establishing an effective official policy of unresponsiveness.

Similarly, Reagan was among the first to strongly publicize the image of "welfare queens" who were milking the system for unwarranted benefits, leading to a strong cutback in benefits for the needy of all sorts.

Another aspect was the increasing de-institutionalization of the mentally ill, a trend that had actually started under Carter (cf. the Mental Health Sytems Act, which tried to put a reasonable and medically-based framework in place for treatment of the chronically mentallly ill), but accelerated under Reagan, again largely due to funding cuts to the relevant professionals.

The effect of this was to change the character of the homeless over the 1980s. Instead of viewing homelessness as a result of unfortunate economic circumstances, people began to believe that it was the result of character flaws (see Reagan's famous 1984 quote "People who are sleeping on the grates…the homeless…are homeless, you might say, by choice.") Whether due to drug abuse, mental illness, or simple "choice," obviously homelessness is not a problem that people need help with.... but instead it's a self-inflicted punishment for being the wrong sort of person.

So, you're seriously suggesting that before Regean people regarded homeless people more highly.

[Insert obligatory insult to your character here]
 
So, you're seriously suggesting that before Regean people regarded homeless people more highly.

[Insert obligatory insult to your character here]
drkitten seems to be suggesting that before the Carter and Reagan administrations, the government provided a wider safety net. It cost money. Money was saved, homeless population grew. Homeless shelters had been outsourced to whoever had the heart to open and run one.

DR
 
So, you're seriously suggesting that before Regean people regarded homeless people more highly.

Er, yes. I thought that was exactly what I had written. Being homeless has never been something to aspire to -- but it didn't have nearly the stigma in, say, 1975, that it currently has.
 
Er, yes. I thought that was exactly what I had written. Being homeless has never been something to aspire to -- but it didn't have nearly the stigma in, say, 1975, that it currently has.

You must get a thrill out of being wrong.

Go to Google. Research work houses, and debtors' prisons, and learn about how for hundreds of years before by oxymoronic "compassionate conservative" destitute people have been systemetically blamed for their desperate state.

Cure your ignorance. I certainly wouldn't argue against blaming Regean era lackwits for popularizing the selfish baboon morality of blaming the victim, but by no means did they pironeer that spirit. It's as old as civilization.
 
drkitten seems to be suggesting that before the Carter and Reagan administrations, the government provided a wider safety net. It cost money. Money was saved, homeless population grew. Homeless shelters had been outsourced to whoever had the heart to open and run one.

DR

That era certainly saw a reduction in the social saftery net, but at that point the government provided safety net was only half a century old. America, like most countries until that time, provided littile, if any, assistance to the poor.
 
Wow! Amazing! The only completely unbiased and bipartisan opinion currently circulating this forum is that drkitten is a self-flagellating nutcase.

Oooops, don't take that literally I was merely using a "rhetorical flourish"! I didn't mean to say that she actually beats herself up with anything more substantial than her mangled perspectives. The other part however...is objective truth.

-z


Let's keep this impersonal and civil, please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must get a thrill out of being wrong.

Go to Google. Research work houses, and debtors' prisons, and learn about how for hundreds of years before by oxymoronic "compassionate conservative" destitute people have been systemetically blamed for their desperate state.

Cure your ignorance. I certainly wouldn't argue against blaming Regean era lackwits for popularizing the selfish baboon morality of blaming the victim, but by no means did they pironeer that spirit. It's as old as civilization.

But there was a period of time, between the end of Victorian criminalization of poverty, and the current view of the homeless as punch bags when things were slightly better. It is clear that Dr Kitten is talking about a period of time somewhere between 1833 and 1981.
 
But there was a period of time, between the end of Victorian criminalization of poverty, and the current view of the homeless as punch bags when things were slightly better. It is clear that Dr Kitten is talking about a period of time somewhere between 1833 and 1981.

I'm not aware of large scale government assistance to the poor operating continuously through the Antebellum period to the 1920's.
 
I'm not aware of large scale government assistance to the poor operating continuously through the Antebellum period to the 1920's.

I never claimed there was, however poverty was decriminalized in that period.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom