Beating the Homeless - What's with this trend?

Go to Google. Research work houses, and debtors' prisons, and learn about how for hundreds of years before by oxymoronic "compassionate conservative" destitute people have been systemetically blamed for their desperate state. p

"For hundreds of years"?

You seem to think that Dickensian London was in 1975? Oliver Twist, perhaps, had fallen in with a group of IRA terrorists?

Part of the reason that the adjective "Dickensian" exists is precisely because of the attitude shift that occurred in most of "civlilzed" society during the latter half of the 19th century and first half of the 20th. Debtors' prison, for example, was abolished in the UK in 1869, in the United States in 1833. The work houses were a legacy of previous eras, and we now had a more "civilized" view of social problems such as homelessness.

Or so ran public opinion in much of the 1970s.

I certainly wouldn't argue against blaming Regean era lackwits for popularizing the selfish baboon morality of blaming the victim, but by no means did they pironeer that spirit. It's as old as civilization.

Yup. And while Reagan and his lackwits didn't pioneer that spirit, they re-discovered and re-popularized it. Similarly, Biblical literalism has been around for as the Bible (longer, if the tales of the Pharisees are to be believed), but it had more or less died out in the English-speaking world by the 1700s, only to be rediscovered and repopularized by late 19th- and early 20th-century fundamentalists.
 
That era certainly saw a reduction in the social saftery net, but at that point the government provided safety net was only half a century old.

Goodness me... So you admit that there was a shift in government policy towards the poor and homeless sometime in 1930-ish (half a century before Reagan), and another shift, reversing the prior one, under Reagan?

Could it possibly be that the shift in 1930 was caused by a more positive public view of homelessness and poverty, a more positive view that changed during the 1980s and has continued to change since then?
 
Reasons to target the homeless:

(1) You can identify them as a group.
(2) They can't identify you as individuals.

These are the necessary conditions for terrorism.

A while back I read about a town where some of the children had decided to persecute those people who push around those mechanical street-sweeping machines. Because the sweepers could be recognised by the children, without conversely knowing who exactly the children were, the children could keep them in a permanent state of terror and humiliation without fear of reprisals.

I have no idea why this is fun, but evidently it gratifies certain tastes.
 
Last edited:
What is with this recent trend? I can't understand how someone as young as 10 years old can consider this entertainment. Is it a combination of lack or morals and bad parenting or just the fact that the world has turned more violent? Whatever it is, it's plain to see that empathy for others is in short reserve.

What, to me was worse by far was that when the homeless man was interviewed he said was afraid to defend himself because they (the two 10 year olds) were young. Nobody should need/have to fear defending him/herself!:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

On the plus side, seeing two 10 year old rectums chained and prison garbed brought joy to my heart.:D :D :D
 
Goodness me... So you admit that there was a shift in government policy towards the poor and homeless sometime in 1930-ish (half a century before Reagan), and another shift, reversing the prior one, under Reagan?

Could it possibly be that the shift in 1930 was caused by a more positive public view of homelessness and poverty, a more positive view that changed during the 1980s and has continued to change since then?

Please. It was called The GREAT Depression not the "Amazing Happy Time When Everyone Suddenly "got" the Hobos, Bums, etc..."

-z
 
Last edited:
I never claimed there was, however poverty was decriminalized in that period.

Granted. However, I'm trying to emphasise that the socially progressive attitude towards homelessness and poverty that prevailed between FDR and Regean was a mere half century long upswing. For roughly a century before that, poverty was not significantly addressed by the government, and only sporadically at the local level. For a significant time before that, it was, as you say, criminalized.

Sure, the past twenty years had seen an increase in negative social attiudes towards poverty, though I'll insist they existed before in far hasher form. I'll conceed the point.

P.S. Rik, the fastest way for you to get me to reconsider a position is to agree with me.
 
Last edited:
Granted. However, I'm trying to emphasise that the socially progressive attitude towards homelessness and poverty that prevailed between FDr and Regean was a mere half century long upswing.

And for the thirty-odd years since the Carter administration, (US) attitudes towards the homeless have been on a socially regressive downswing. You seem to accept this.

TheJim claims the current upswing in violence against the homeless is a natural outgrowth of this downswing. That's certainly an explanation, although I'd want to see more evidence for it before I nailed my colours to the mast on that one. But I think the downswing itself -- and its approximate timing -- should be uncontroversial.
 
Please. It was called The Depression not the "Amazing Happy Time When Everyone Suddenly "got" the Hobos, Bums, etc..."

-z

exactly, which made people more aware that at times poverty was not always (or even often) self inflicted. Public policy after those years began to reflect that more than ever, after a while public perception and policy swung back the other way to lead us to where we are now.
 
And for the thirty-odd years since the Carter administration, (US) attitudes towards the homeless have been on a socially regressive downswing. You seem to accept this.

TheJim claims the current upswing in violence against the homeless is a natural outgrowth of this downswing. That's certainly an explanation, although I'd want to see more evidence for it before I nailed my colours to the mast on that one. But I think the downswing itself -- and its approximate timing -- should be uncontroversial.

Certainly, but violence against the homeless, even of the egregious nature of this particular case, is not peculiar to our era, which is what I was trying to empahsise, only the numbers and particularly deperate situation. When Mephisto asks "What is with this recent trend?" that strikes a bit like deja vu. Homeless people and the very poor have always been the targets of senseless violence.
 
Beating up the homeless was a popular sport when I was in high school some 30 years ago. This may just reflect the fact that my high school was pretty horrid.
 
I wonder if this is, in fact, some kind of new trend. In years past, the homeless would incur the wrath of many, including the police. Under such situations, reporting such harassment might be futile at best. Hobos and bums were easy, and voiceless, scapegoats for some of society's nastier inclinations.

I think people today may actually be more sympathetic to the plight of the homeless than they were, say, 30 years ago.
 
What is with this recent trend? I can't understand how someone as young as 10 years old can consider this entertainment. Is it a combination of lack or morals and bad parenting or just the fact that the world has turned more violent? Whatever it is, it's plain to see that empathy for others is in short reserve.
It seems to me that the answer is right there in that quote:
Egged on by a 17-year-old, two 10-year-old boys joined in the attack of a Florida homeless man, leaving him bruised and bloody, police said.

If a 17-year-old had badgered a 10-year into having sex with him, would we be asking how a 10-year-old could be such a slut? Why is it different when kids engage in violence? The 17-year-old should be prosecuted for victimizing the homeless man and the two boys.

On the plus side, seeing two 10 year old rectums chained and prison garbed brought joy to my heart.:D :D :D
Are you serious? If so, you are seriously disturbed.
 
Since when did the homeless matter?

They're handy for when I'm in for a bit of the ultraviolence.
 
Thinking more on the subject, I don't even know what social safety net policies towards the homeless and violence targeting thre homeless have to do with one another. Can the case even be made that there is a negative correlation?
 
Is it a trend? Or is this the equivalent of the summer of shark attacks?
Good question. The article just says "The incident highlights an upswing in violent crime across the U.S. against the homeless" but doesn't compare one year/years to others.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom