Beating the Homeless - What's with this trend?

haha I have played A LOT of quake.

Have you seen 300 yet?
Yes, it looked like a video game put to film. I was surprised by how much I liked it, given that Frank Miller took a few liberties with history. (Spartan armor, and all that.) He wanted an epic, a legend brought to life, and he got that.

Will there be a video game to go with it?

DR
 
Has anyone read A Clergyman's Daughter, by George Orwell? The portrait of homeless people is startlingly familiar. Right down to spending time reading newspapers in the public library to keep warm. Plus ca change.
 
Has anyone read A Clergyman's Daughter, by George Orwell? The portrait of homeless people is startlingly familiar. Right down to spending time reading newspapers in the public library to keep warm. Plus ca change.

Not yet, but I have read Down and out in Paris and London which covers similar ground, and makes you very suspicious of posh restaurants.
 
It seems to me that the answer is right there in that quote:

If a 17-year-old had badgered a 10-year into having sex with him, would we be asking how a 10-year-old could be such a slut? Why is it different when kids engage in violence? The 17-year-old should be prosecuted for victimizing the homeless man and the two boys.

Are you serious? If so, you are seriously disturbed.
Of course I am serious - as are many other teachers at my school who discussed it at various times today - none had a good word for those criminals (that is literally true - no sympathy for them was implied or stated - but then this isn't the first time this happened locally and no one there during discussions was an ESE teacher - and we are a high school). Also we are pretty much burned about student response to an event last year which involved a student death - but which I can't describe because I do not broadcast my i.d. (I can either write freely on most topics or I can lurk.)
 
I really can't think of a time period where someone could beat or kill the homeless, and mainstream society would just shrug their shoulders and treat the killer as an equal. The '20s, where people were wanting to enforce morality by banning alcohol? The '50s? The '60s? (Well, okay, the '60s...)

I mean, seriously.
 
I really can't think of a time period where someone could beat or kill the homeless, and mainstream society would just shrug their shoulders and treat the killer as an equal. The '20s, where people were wanting to enforce morality by banning alcohol? The '50s? The '60s? (Well, okay, the '60s...)

I mean, seriously.

Resurrectors made a fine living providing bodies for medical research for several hundreds years and often the bodies were not, how shall we say, dead from natural causes before the resurrectors arrived. While solid date on the rates of the murder of homeless people to provide bodies for anatomical research cannot be known, there are many well recorded individual cases. It wasn't openly sanctioned murder as you describe it, but it was a tolerated gray market.
 
Resurrectors made a fine living providing bodies for medical research for several hundreds years and often the bodies were not, how shall we say, dead from natural causes before the resurrectors arrived. While solid date on the rates of the murder of homeless people to provide bodies for anatomical research cannot be known, there are many well recorded individual cases. It wasn't openly sanctioned murder as you describe it, but it was a tolerated gray market.

But you're talking about a time period where medical and scientific research had very little regulation, and a lot of gray/black market crap was around.

The "Mad doctor/scientist" archetype was fitting for that time.
 
But you're talking about a time period where medical and scientific research had very little regulation, and a lot of gray/black market crap was around.

The "Mad doctor/scientist" archetype was fitting for that time.

I don't see how that's so exceptional that it requires "but." It occurred in a time of substantially less regulation in most sectors of society, true. I'm just pointing out that there was a time when homeless people faced the real threat of being killed for the value of their dead body. Compared to that time period, we've certainly progressed.
 
I don't see how that's so exceptional that it requires "but." It occurred in a time of substantially less regulation in most sectors of society, true. I'm just pointing out that there was a time when homeless people faced the real threat of being killed for the value of their dead body. Compared to that time period, we've certainly progressed.

I agree. But I don't think that the average populace, if they heard about a particular case where a scientist that killed someone for their experiments, would tend to like that scientist. But I agree that we've progressed, but at the same time I don't think that, say, 50 years ago, people were far more uncaring for the homeless than today.
 
I agree. But I don't think that the average populace, if they heard about a particular case where a scientist that killed someone for their experiments, would tend to like that scientist. But I agree that we've progressed, but at the same time I don't think that, say, 50 years ago, people were far more uncaring for the homeless than today.

To be fair, many doctors who discovered signs of recent violence on bodies provided to them by resurrectors reported it to the authorities. Murdering to acquire dead bodies for sale does seem inherently much more risky than discrete grave robbing, to me. On the other hand, a freshly buried person might have had more concerned family members eager to have the body's disappearance investigated than a randomly chosen homeless person,which is incredibly sad to my mind.
 
To be fair, many doctors who discovered signs of recent violence on bodies provided to them by resurrectors reported it to the authorities. Murdering to acquire dead bodies for sale does seem inherently much more risky than discrete grave robbing, to me. On the other hand, a freshly buried person might have had more concerned family members eager to have the body's disappearance investigated than a randomly chosen homeless person,which is incredibly sad to my mind.

Shouldn't be. If you go by the animal control threads on this forum, you'll run into some folks that don't mind so much homeless folks getting snuffed. ;)

There's going to be a natural reason to look into homeless deaths far less often than rich white family's deaths; connections, and the fact that there are more liable to be witnesses and people to interview to talk to. So it's overall more difficult to investigate a homeless death, the people with the "right connections" push you to investigate the others ("more important", supposedly) deaths, etc.

It's not the ideal, of course. But we're changing.

The fact is that homeless deaths can be reported to the public far stronger than they do now just because, quite simply, mass media has grown in strength. At least, that's my personal estimation.
 
I agree. But I don't think that the average populace, if they heard about a particular case where a scientist that killed someone for their experiments, would tend to like that scientist. But I agree that we've progressed, but at the same time I don't think that, say, 50 years ago, people were far more uncaring for the homeless than today.


Is there any proof surrounding that appraisal, one way or another?

What about hoboes and bindle-stiffs? Were they generally better regarded than today's homeless, or more poorly, or about the same?

How about the working poor? The transient and dispossessed? Sinclair's The Jungle and Steinbeck's The Grapes of Wrath come to mind.

I would be afraid of falling into a "good old days" trap....it's too easy to romaticize certain aspects of history. I'd need to see some sort of evidence that Americans were once kinder and gentler to the homeless.

You know, what they used to call "bums."
 
Has anyone read A Clergyman's Daughter, by George Orwell? The portrait of homeless people is startlingly familiar. Right down to spending time reading newspapers in the public library to keep warm. Plus ca change.

Ah, dear Dorothy.

Poverty was a favourite subject of Orwell - he covered a lot of same ground in Keep the Aspidistra Flying as well as his non-fictions - London/Paris & Wigan Pier as well as essays.

He was fortunate in knowing all the ruses having done it himself.

If you have a look at the homeless then - circa 1930 in UK/France, it's clear that even though vagrancy was illegal, the homeless still made out ok most of the time - begging was often rewarded and they certainly only feared the Police, not random violence.
 
We had this in the UK back in the seventies. It was rapidly established by the tabloid press that it was caused by A Clockwork Orange.

Presumably the film is currently on release in Florida.
 
I'll agree with BOTH DrKitten and ImaginalDisc.

The homeless have always been a target for cruelty and violence, but I did see a rise in the number of homeless people through our local emergency room where I worked when the Reagan years rolled along.

I thought it sad that they were generally tossed aside in such great numbers by Reagan and it was frightening to see the volume of homeless who were absorbed (at least for a few hours or days at a time) by hospitals all over the country. The number of mental patients ousted from institutions was noteworthy and gladly the number of violent crimes perpetuated by the homeless never reached the proportions predicted, but it was certainly sad to see human beings treated in such a manner all for a $. It was also noteworthy that a good many of these homeless were Vietnam veterans, so if anything can be said of Republican administrations trying to save money - at least they're consistent.

Back from Iraq - and suddenly out on the streets

Social service agencies say the number of homeless vets is rising, in part because of high housing costs and gaps in pay.

NEW YORK – Veterans of the Iraq and Afghanistan conflicts are now showing up in the nation's homeless shelters.
While the numbers are still small, they're steadily rising, and raising alarms in both the homeless and veterans' communities. The concern is that these returning veterans - some of whom can't find jobs after leaving the military, others of whom are still struggling psychologically with the war - may be just the beginning of an influx of new veterans in need. Currently, there are 150,000 troops in Iraq and 16,000 in Afghanistan. More than 130,000 have already served and returned home.

http://www.csmonitor.com/2005/0208/p02s01-ussc.html


As you all probably already know the SUPPORT OUR TROOPS BS is a pet peeve of mine.


The New Wave of Homeless

They fight with honor.

But they fight with little ammunition and they fight with no armor.

They come home to inadequate services and a government that has lied to them. They come home wanting out of the service, not trusting. They come home to few resources.

They are the next generation of Homeless Veterans and we are already seeing the beginning of this wave at Operation Dignity.


I will definitely have mixed feelings about ruthless killing of A-hole punks for picking on the wrong homeless veteran. They'll get what they deserve (and maybe even learn a lesson), but we'll undoubtedly be quick to label the veteran a heartless killer.
 
Is there any proof surrounding that appraisal, one way or another?

What about hoboes and bindle-stiffs? Were they generally better regarded than today's homeless, or more poorly, or about the same?

I'd say about the same, personally. That's just my perception, from what I know and have heard. I mean, quite frankly, I doubt that the WASPs would have just overlooked a murder of a homeless man; they were all into morality and crap.

How about the working poor? The transient and dispossessed? Sinclair's The Jungle and Steinbeck's The Grapes of Wrath come to mind.

Haven't read them, but there are literary books that I could find today that talk about how horrid today's society is... doesn't necessarily mean that the author did anything but focus on it.

I would be afraid of falling into a "good old days" trap....it's too easy to romaticize certain aspects of history. I'd need to see some sort of evidence that Americans were once kinder and gentler to the homeless.

Okay, now you're creating a strawman.

1) I never claimed that the past was the "good old days".

2) I never claimed that Americans were once kinder and gentler to the homeless. I do not think that society is worse today than it was in the past; but at the same time, I don't think that we're so incredibly great compared to 50 years ago, that horrible dystopian time period or somesuch. So really, I think that you shouldn't fall into the "good new days" trap.

My point is that I doubt that the homeless were treated so incredibly horribly compared to today. I doubt that they were treated like filthy garbage with no worth as human beings, any moreso than today's homeless are. I doubt that someone could beat them, to the point of death, and be able to get away with it because "society just didn't care". And, quite frankly, the homeless are treated like garbage even today, depending on who's dealing with them.

See above about the point of resurrectors, and how they were turned in by the doctors they sold corpses to, if they created those corpses. But the doctors were supposed to not care about the homeless at all, right? So why bother?

If your point is that, on average, homeless were treated worse than today, then I could go with that; but up to a certain level. I don't think that it was so extremely horrible compared to today.

You know, what they used to call "bums."

"Used to call"? That word's still in the vernacular.
 
Last edited:
I'd say about the same, personally. That's just my perception, from what I know and have heard. I mean, quite frankly, I doubt that the WASPs would have just overlooked a murder of a homeless man; they were all into morality and crap.

Again, though, I'd rather have some facts, numbers, studies, etc. before me than just what I imagine it might have been like. I didn't live then, after all, and don't even have anecdotal personal experience to go by.



Haven't read them, but there are literary books that I could find today that talk about how horrid today's society is... doesn't necessarily mean that the author did anything but focus on it.

I find it easy to read too much into casual statements, myself. Literary works can be considered, not evidence, but perhaps a kind of window onto a time period. Perhaps a cloudy or somewhat distorted window, but even still, you can see some things through them. The trick is to balance that with hard evidence. Literature is just a clue, not the whole puzzle.



Okay, now you're creating a strawman.

Not a bit. I am not distorting your argument in order to re-present it as flawed. I am merely warning against the possibility of allowing flaws of a specific nature to creep in. It's quite easy to do. How odd you took my comment so personally.

1) I never claimed that the past was the "good old days".

I never said you did. I merely cautioned against it.

2) I never claimed that Americans were once kinder and gentler to the homeless.

I never said you did. I asked a question. Have any facts with which to answer it yet, or are you still arguing from speculation?

I do not think that society is worse today than it was in the past; but at the same time, I don't think that we're so incredibly great compared to 50 years ago, that horrible dystopian time period or somesuch. So really, I think that you shouldn't fall into the "good new days" trap.

I didn't. But thanks for the warning. Now, about those facts....

My point is that I doubt that the homeless were treated so incredibly horribly compared to today.

My point is that I'd like to discuss this based on more than your doubt.


I doubt that they were treated like filthy garbage with no worth as human beings, any moreso than today's homeless are.

They were treated about the same, in other words? Evidence?

I doubt that someone could beat them, to the point of death, and be able to get away with it because "society just didn't care".

Knowing human nature, I would never doubt such a thing was possible, or even probable. Was it rampant? Wide-spread? Or did it occur in rare, isolated incidents? I don't know. Some facts would be nice.

Anecdotally, my grandfather worked for Union Pacific. I don't know what his job was called, but he helped organize trains in the yard. He told stories of yard bulls, the guys whose job it was to get the free-riders off the trains. The free-riders didn't always live through it. The yard bulls didn't often go to jail. But that's just anecdotal. Not evidence.


And, quite frankly, the homeless are treated like garbage even today, depending on who's dealing with them.

I am not unaware. But there are also more shelters and other similar resources today. What do those two things mean, examined together? I don't know. Some facts would be nice.

See above about the point of resurrectors, and how they were turned in by the doctors they sold corpses to, if they created those corpses. But the doctors were supposed to not care about the homeless at all, right? So why bother?

I really don't know. Are there any figures regarding these occurences? You know, any facts beyond anecdotes and stories and imaginings?

If your point is that, on average, homeless were treated worse than today, then I could go with that; but up to a certain level. I don't think that it was so extremely horrible compared to today.

My point is that I cannot argue or discuss any of this, because it's all arguments from incredulity, from belief, from anecdote...from anything except hard facts or evidence of any kind.

You're arguing from induction, I do believe. Am I using that right, anyone? I always had a hard time with deduction and induction.

At any rate, some facts would be nice.


"Used to call"? That word's still in the vernacular.

Yes. I see I should have used a sarcasm smiley.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom