Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I'd have been pretty narked if my parents had decided to have my earlobes cut off, I have to say. I like my earlobes fine the way they are. I have decided not even to have them pierced.

My decision. Not one I would have wanted pre-empted by anyone when I was too young to object.

Rolfe.
 
I have no foreskin, and I think I'm doing just fine. Penis works perfectly. I see no harm in this procedure.

However, if someone wanted to remove their child's foreskin because they saw foreskin as a good thing that makes sex feel good, and they don't want their child to enjoy sex, then I would be against that procedure.


So it's OK just as long as you personally weren't harmed - or at least don't see yourself as harmed?

Doesn't matter about the babies damaged for life when things didn't go entirely to plan?

Did you look at this page?
Warning, not for the faint hearted. It's one baby. Is that OK, it was just the one, because it didn't happen to be you?

Rolfe.
 
I can think of a lot of harm people can do, even when it's not their conscious purpose to cause harm.

It does cause harm. It's blindingly obvious it causes harm. The motives and intentions of those who blindly cause such harm do not make it harmless.

Rolfe.

Look, as long as you weren't trying to hurt anyone, it's all good. This is why I take most of my naps while driving down the highway.
 
I'm accusing you of lying about me misstating you.

but you did indeed misstate me.

I do not believe that simply one person has the right to cut off bits from another person.

I believe that a parent has the right to remove their child's foreskin, as long as it is not for purposes of causing permanent harm.

your misstating of my view, may not be a lie...but it is a strawman.
 
Thunder, we get it that you're fine with the way you are. Presumably you'd have decided to have the op even if you'd had to wait and have it as part of your bar-mitzvah ceremonies.

Why do you want to deny others the opportunity of making a free choice to do just that?

And I'll tell you something. I don't buy this BS about the surgery being better done in the neonate. The only advantage to that is that the neonate can't object, and doesn't remember the horror consciously.

Having seen the pics, the surgery on such a tiny organ is quite obviously massively more difficult and error-prone than doing the same thing to a young adult. Do that to an adult, and you wouldn't have a tenth of the minor irregularities and stuff pictured on that web site. You'd be working with something big enough to see what you were doing.

That men quite obviously are horrified by the idea of having that done to them as adults, when they could have a proper GA and have a neat job done by a surgeon who didn't need to use a dissecting microscope, will nevertheless inflict such horror on an unanaesthetised baby - I find it sickening.

Rolfe.
 
Doesn't matter about the babies damaged for life when things didn't go entirely to plan?

men without their foreskin are "damaged"...for life? more hyperbole I see. this thread is full of it.

interesting. too bad the scientists & doctors don't agree with you.

I and other circumcised men have a fully-functioning penis. Able to perform all of its required & desired duties.


......by the way, does anyone have a logical argument as to how my circumcised penis is not fully functioning?
 
Last edited:
I believe that a parent has the right to remove their child's foreskin, as long as it is not for purposes of causing permanent harm.


BUT IT DOES CAUSE PERMANENT HARM.

Obvious, serious and irreparable harm in some cases, minor cosmetic harm in a lot more. And harm to the free choice of every single victim.

It DOESN'T MATTER whether the parent's motive is "pure", it is still harm.

You could make exactly the same argument for FGM, and people do, all the time. There's none so blind as the self-righteous who can't see that there's no difference between them and the people they reject.

Rolfe.
 
#1. I fully support clitoran reduction surgery.

#2. I fully support the right of parents to decide to circumcise their male baby.

as far as FGM, I don't know that much about it yet, but I am against any surgery designed to reduce the person's sexual pleasure or sexual activity. But as far as what I see in level 1a, which simply removes the hood and leaves the clitoris alone, I guess I could maybe be ok with that.

...maybe. but it again depends on what the purpose is.

..........ok, I have now read that many women actually choose to have female circumcision level 1a, performed on themselves, in order to fully expose the clitoral hood. this suggests to me that such a procedure does not lead to a painful situation. I then read that this procedure used to be done to girls in the Western world, in order to discourage masterbation. I'm confused.

I'm puzzled as to why you quoted my post, then completely ignored it.
I know you think parents should have the right to circumcise their babies.
What I have asked more than once is why do you think that is a good thing, rather than letting the boy choose when he is old enough to give informed consent?
 
are you against parents having surgery performed on their baby girl's enlarged clitoris?


Yes.

Particularly if the idea is coming from the parents, as opposed to the child's doctor saying it's recommended.

But basically yes. Let the girl decide what to do when she sees what it's like when she's a bit older.

Rolfe.
 
people here have accused me of hating babies & hating children.

people here have accused me of supporting child abuse.

people here have accused me of being a Conspiracy Theorist.

people here have accused me of being evil, due to my views.

.......please tell them to shut up as well.

You have accused people of hating Jews
You have accused people of hating Muslims
You have accused people of hating freedom
You have accused people of saying all Muslim and Jewish men are liars.

Your hypocrisy is impressive
 
Thunder, which of these do you think is more important:
1) An adult's right to make choices that affect his own body
2) An adult's right to make choices that affect another adult's body
 
Rolfe said:
Doesn't matter about the babies damaged for life when things didn't go entirely to plan?


men without their foreskin are "damaged"...for life? more hyperbole I see. this thread is full of it.

interesting. too bad the scientists & doctors don't agree with you.

I and other circumcised men have a fully-functioning penis. Able to perform all of its required & desired duties.


......by the way, does anyone have a logical argument as to how my circumcised penis is not fully functioning?


Maybe it's causing you some eyesight problems?

Did you click on the link I posted earlier? Don't you have the stomach to look at what can happen to some children who are forced to undergo the entirely unnecessary mutilation you're so enamoured of?

Rolfe.
 
What I have asked more than once is why do you think that is a good thing,

I don't believe that circumcision is a good thing. I also don't think its a bad thing.

I don't believe that removing the clitoral hood is a good thing. I have also seen no evidence yet that its a bad thing.

I don't believe that reducing the size of a clitoris is a good thing or bad thing. It may be helpful, but it may be unneccessary.

My issue is not whether these specific surgeries are good or bad. I see no evidence either way, for the most part.

My issue...is whether parents should have the right to have them performed on their child, without their child's consent.

And until I see good evidence that male-circumcion is indeed harmful, or clitoral reduction is indeed harmful, or removing the clitoral hood is indeed harmful, I shall defer to parental rights.

However, if the motivation of the surgery IS to cause harm, such as to reduce sexual enjoyment, then I DO have a problem with it.

If someone tells me that they want to circumcise their baby boy, because they believe that the foreskin provides additional pleasure, and they want their child's sexual experiences to be painful and unpleasant, and they want my consent....I would NOT give it.

Perhaps my view on these matters is too sophisticated and complicated. If that is the case, I do apologize...but its my opinion and I have the right to it.
 
Thunder, which of these do you think is more important:
1) An adult's right to make choices that affect his own body
2) An adult's right to make choices that affect another adult's body


That's the one I want him to answer. Just keep re-posting it....

Rolfe.
 
please don't mistate what I say.

I said that its ok for parents to remove their child's foreskin, as long as the purpose is not to harm the child.

Circumcision does harm the child. Cutting off the foreskin is harmful. Sometimes it is very harmful and the baby is infected. Sometimes it is very, very harmful and the baby suffers serious injury. Sometimes it is very, very, very harmful and the baby dies.
But it is always harmful.
No baby ever suffered an infection or serious injury or death from not having medically unnnecessary circumcision.
Why do you think it is good to do this to a baby rather than allow him to decide when he is able to give informed consent?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom