qayak
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2006
- Messages
- 13,844
Originally Posted by Avicenna
There is also a fatality rate.
That is unconfirmed. At least, in the United States. I wouldn't trust most other countries where circumcision is widely practiced, to have the procedure done in.
http://www.canada.com/cityguides/ottawa/story.html?id=cb3b8281-4134-46ba-85d3-b076072bda75&k=25810
http://www.canada.com/cityguides/ottawa/story.html?id=cb3b8281-4134-46ba-85d3-b076072bda75&k=25810
While we do not save all the headlines on this topic, at least 8-10 baby boys die every month due to genital cutting in the United States.
http://www.sweetliberty.org/issues/bless/circumcise.html
Why are they charging this next guy with abuse if rabbis and doctors aren't being charged?
http://www.wxii12.com/r/15251643/detail.html
http://www.sexuallymutilatedchild.org/deaths-d.htm
It also appears that any benefit from circumcision (and the benifits are very small) are vastly outweighed by complications of the procedure.
http://www.cirp.org/library/disease/UTI/thompson/
Table 3. EXAMINATION OF POSSIBLE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN URINARY TRACT INFECTION (UTI) AND NONCIRCUMCISION IN A HYPOTHETICAL COHORT OF 2000 NEWBORN IN THE FIRST YEAR OF LIFE, WITH 1000 CIRCUMCISED, 1000 UNCIRCUMCISED.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Relative Differences UTI Rate Comment
Circumcised 0.1 Possible 10 fold
Uncircumcised 1.0 relative increase in
uncircumcised boys.
Absolute Differences UTI (No/%) Possible absolute
difference of
Circumcised 1 0.1 0.9% (9/1000) between
Noncircumcised 10 1.0 circumcised and
uncircumcised boys.
Perspective of Those Nonevent Possible boost in
without the morbid Probability chances of no
Event UTI in first year from
99% to 99.9%
Event (no UTI)
Circumcised 999/1000
Noncircumcised 990/1000
Weighing absolute benefit against absolute price paid by
those experiencing the intervention without benefit to them
for a cohort of 1000 circumcised male infants.
Possible absolute benefit 9 UTIs possibly
averted
Price in circumcision
complications for 991
with no benefit
If incidence is:
0.2 2% 4%
Early: hemorrhage,
infection,
surgical trauma Number 2 20 40
Late: surgical 1%
revision Number 10 10 10
Balance of benefits -3 -21 -41
to complications.
(Number of
individuals)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------