Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Originally Posted by Avicenna
There is also a fatality rate.

That is unconfirmed. At least, in the United States. I wouldn't trust most other countries where circumcision is widely practiced, to have the procedure done in.

http://www.canada.com/cityguides/ottawa/story.html?id=cb3b8281-4134-46ba-85d3-b076072bda75&k=25810

http://www.canada.com/cityguides/ottawa/story.html?id=cb3b8281-4134-46ba-85d3-b076072bda75&k=25810

While we do not save all the headlines on this topic, at least 8-10 baby boys die every month due to genital cutting in the United States.

http://www.sweetliberty.org/issues/bless/circumcise.html

Why are they charging this next guy with abuse if rabbis and doctors aren't being charged?

http://www.wxii12.com/r/15251643/detail.html

http://www.sexuallymutilatedchild.org/deaths-d.htm

It also appears that any benefit from circumcision (and the benifits are very small) are vastly outweighed by complications of the procedure.

http://www.cirp.org/library/disease/UTI/thompson/

Table 3. EXAMINATION OF POSSIBLE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN URINARY TRACT INFECTION (UTI) AND NONCIRCUMCISION IN A HYPOTHETICAL COHORT OF 2000 NEWBORN IN THE FIRST YEAR OF LIFE, WITH 1000 CIRCUMCISED, 1000 UNCIRCUMCISED.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Relative Differences UTI Rate Comment
Circumcised 0.1 Possible 10 fold
Uncircumcised 1.0 relative increase in
uncircumcised boys.

Absolute Differences UTI (No/%) Possible absolute
difference of
Circumcised 1 0.1 0.9% (9/1000) between
Noncircumcised 10 1.0 circumcised and
uncircumcised boys.

Perspective of Those Nonevent Possible boost in
without the morbid Probability chances of no
Event UTI in first year from
99% to 99.9%
Event (no UTI)
Circumcised 999/1000
Noncircumcised 990/1000

Weighing absolute benefit against absolute price paid by
those experiencing the intervention without benefit to them
for a cohort of 1000 circumcised male infants.

Possible absolute benefit 9 UTIs possibly
averted

Price in circumcision
complications for 991
with no benefit

If incidence is:
0.2 2% 4%
Early: hemorrhage,
infection,
surgical trauma Number 2 20 40
Late: surgical 1%
revision Number 10 10 10
Balance of benefits -3 -21 -41
to complications.
(Number of
individuals)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Yes. Only I am not being disgusting.

Yes, my arguments are better than yours. Your are so bad it's not even fun anymore to keep pointing out the mistakes like ... uh ... "begging the question".



Do try to read for comprehension.

And, no, if circumcision is a violation of the rights of the child there is no reason to let people get away with it.

"Begging the question?" Point me where that has happened, or this is an unwarranted accusation.

The problem with your arguments, is that you are all like "OMG! They believe in the flying spaghetti monster! That is so lame! The First Amendment has nothing to do with them!"

Basically, you are so blinded by your utter contempt of those who happen to have an opposing view from you, that you are not even trying to understand the arguments presented, any why religious freedom exists to begin with.

I know this, because as a new-comer to these forums, I have not been particularly rude or sarcastic towards you. I have no reason to be. And yet, your treatment of me just because I have an opposing view on the matter of a prohibition on circumcision is what really lowers the quality of your arguments. In fact, Kiwi, Empress, and that datam moderator guy or whatever his name is, have been the only ones in which I got some knowledge, and something approaching respect from. Especially after I made (in my mind) a pretty reasonable appeal for civility.

Now, you can either clean up your act, or continue to look like an ignorant moron with your sarcastic responses. But whatever you do, I have nothing further to say about the quality of arguments, as that is rather off-topic, and has nothing to do with the OP.
 

Out of all of these links you have provided, the only real legitimate article you have linked to is the one from Canada.com. But that is only a single case. And the child died from a urinary tract infection. Could it have been from the circumcision? The article makes the claim that was the conclusion of the coroner's office. Where's the coroner's report?

Sweetliberty.org? Looks more like a conspiracy theory site than anything else. The home page of that site has a police light thing at the top, and says how the US is going to try to re-write the Constitution. Really? I would think this would be rather big news, if it were so.....

Then you link to a site called "sexuallymutilatedchild.org." Obviously a highly biased web site. How can I trust anything from a site with such a name? Science is not biased. But inconclusive studies can be manipulated to be terribly biased.

The CIRP website is by far your best link. But the opening paragraph says thus:

Information published in the last 5 years suggests a possible association between being uncircumcised and increased risk for urinary tract infection in the first year of life.1-4 Largely because of this data, the American Academy of Pediatrics convened a task force on circumcision, which released its findings in March of 1989. This group stated that circumcision "may result in decreased incidence of urinary tract infection. However, in the absence of well designed prospective studies, conclusions regarding the relationship of urinary tract infection to circumcision are tentative." They concluded: "When circumcision is being considered, the benefits and risks should be explained to parents and informed consent obtained."5

Which is EXACTLY what the health organizations have been saying all along. I think it is a rather weak argument to prohibit a religious practice which is protected by the First Amendment, based on inconclusive studies, biased sources, and one or two cases that MIGHT have been an indirect cause of death, out of thousands (millions?) of circumcisions performed each year. Children have a much greater chance of dying while riding a bicycle, even while wearing a helmet.
 
Thanks for the link, Childlike Empress. While it is not the full documentary, it was well done, IMO, and definitely worth watching (it is a little over an hour).

Well, you and Empress are a couple of the few reasonable posters on here, so I'll look at this tonight, and try to find the full documentary at some other point, if I remember it..
 
Which is EXACTLY what the health organizations have been saying all along. I think it is a rather weak argument to prohibit a religious practice which is protected by the First Amendment ...

Female circumcision is also a religious practice and it is banned. Child abuse isn't protected by the First Amendment.
 
:confused: I think you may want to rethink and re-type that to make sense in relation to the post you responded to.

Why? I think I have made it abundantly clear what my (personal) rules are in this conversation.

To clear up, female circumcision is far more risky, and has worse consequences than male circumcision. Which goes against my first rule of thumb. Unless, of course, you would want to provide some evidence that they involve exactly the same risks and negative impact.

But even then, nobody claims first amendment right to perform female circumcision, so the argument falls flat right there anyway.
 
To clear up, female circumcision is far more risky, and has worse consequences than male circumcision. ...

But even then, nobody claims first amendment right to perform female circumcision, so the argument falls flat right there anyway.

1. Some forms of FGM, yes, others, not at all.
2. If someone did claim 1st amendment rights, would you support it?
 
1. Some forms of FGM, yes, others, not at all.
2. If someone did claim 1st amendment rights, would you support it?

Would I support what? Their rights? Not necessarily. Maybe. I dunno. But neither would I necessarily support a ban on said rights, IF "FMG" were EXACTLY like "MGM." Comparable in every way, shape, and form. Including true religious practices. Then maybe.
 
Last edited:
IF "FMG" were EXACTLY like "MGM." Comparable in every way, shape, and form. Including true religious practices. Then maybe.

So, no it is. Because obviously your criteria cannot be met.

Have we got that list of Christian sects which practise circumcision yet?
 
http://www.faqs.org/periodicals/201004/2026622071.html

Medically speaking the major risks are

1. Exsanguination. The penis bleeds painlessly. The baby seems normal and the use of diapers can absorb a lot of blood. What is minor blood loss to us is fatal to a baby.

2. Infection. Fairly common cause of death in foreign countries. MRSA cases have been seen, the cause is not the circumcision but the circumcision helped.

3. Surgical Mishaps (Whoops!!!)

4. Anaesthetic death. ANY anaesthesia carries risk. Babies especially. It's a pointless risk.

The causes of death are very rarely the circumcision itself (Around 1/500,000 hospital related deaths) because doctors often catch the bleed quickly. You wouldn't trust a guy whose only qualifications are wicked beard and knowledge of really old book with your surgery right? Yet they are the ones who do the procedure resulting in deaths and those are harder to classify since they don't keep records of how many circumcisions they do. But the other causes of death are really obvious and go down in the appropriate slot of secondary infection, anaesthetic related death and medical error.

It has been postulated as one of the reasons as to why the US has a higher infant mortality rate than equivalent european nations despite having similar socio economic status as a nation. It's a common elective that has a sufficient amount of risks done for ***** and giggles (yes that is a medical term... :)). Even for phimosis I would rather prescribe steroid cream rather than that. Only UTI infections in the mentally ill would require the surgery outright if they cannot understand the instruction. Or if the phimosis is severe enough to cause fusion.
 
Yeah, I don;t think getting into this discussion is a good idea. There are many Christian sects in the US that circumcise for religious reasons. There are many Catholics (I am one) who are circumcised. At least in my diocese. In fact, it would be quite rare to find an uncircumcised Catholic in the Diocese of Scranton.
I can't believe that you're still pushing this line. You have presented absolutely no evidence of these "Christian sects in the US that circumcise for religious reasons," as opposed to the self-evident reality that in a society where both Christianity is widespread, and circumcision is widespread for societal reasons, then obviously there will be a lot of circumcised Christians. Circumcision is demonstrably not a "Catholic thing" where you live, it is an "American thing."
 
There is one benefit that seemingly comes from circumcision. The accumulation of smegma causes penile cancer.

However the solution is proper hygiene rather than "cut it off". But it's hard to encourage that kind of hygiene since the topic is awkward and involves parents handling their children's genitalia until they are old enough to do it themselves. I cannot think of a way to tell kids how to do it.

"Don't forget to wash your hands. And your penis."
 
"Begging the question?" Point me where that has happened, or this is an unwarranted accusation.

Non sequitur.

Wanna play again?

And it was the post IO was replaying to when I said it - else it wouldn't have been funny.

The problem with your arguments, is that you are all like "OMG! They believe in the flying spaghetti monster! That is so lame! The First Amendment has nothing to do with them!"

I am not aware of anyone saying something remotely like that.

Basically, you are so blinded by your utter contempt of those who happen to have an opposing view from you, that you are not even trying to understand the arguments presented, any why religious freedom exists to begin with.

No, my contempt is of those who harm children willfully and without need.

And I do understand your arguments, I just don't agree with them at any point whatsoever. (This might have a lot to do with them being embarrassingly bad arguments. Your continuous lying about circumcision being a catholic practice just being one example. And yes, you are lying! 10 pages ago you might have been mistaken but by now you are either lying or mentally incapable of following the conversation at all. Since you insist on participating in the conversation I'll assume you know what you are saying...)

I know this, because as a new-comer to these forums, I have not been particularly rude or sarcastic towards you. I have no reason to be. And yet, your treatment of me just because I have an opposing view on the matter of a prohibition on circumcision is what really lowers the quality of your arguments.

Wrong.

I treat you this way because you are being dumb and dishonest.
Oh, and, no, the quality of my arguments has nothing to do with the form in which they are being delivered. I am still right if I am being an ass about it.



In fact, Kiwi, Empress, and that datam moderator guy or whatever his name is, have been the only ones in which I got some knowledge, and something approaching respect from. Especially after I made (in my mind) a pretty reasonable appeal for civility.

Well, no, I do not respect you and your views. I have no respect whatsoever for people that harm children or support the harming of children. So, no, I will not be more civil than I absolutely have to. I think on a scale of civility I am doing far better though than those who are in favor of chopping bits off off people.

Now, you can either clean up your act, or continue to look like an ignorant moron with your sarcastic responses.

Oh yes, I see how I am the one looking ignorant. Did you find the time yet to let us all know which Christian sects practice circumcision? No? Well, did you at least have the time to understand that the first amendment does not grant any special protection to religious rituals?

But whatever you do, I have nothing further to say about the quality of arguments, as that is rather off-topic, and has nothing to do with the OP.

Yes, it's more than clear that you don't much care about the quality of arguments so long as you feel not attacked just because people don't agree with your insane opinions.
 
http://www.faqs.org/periodicals/201004/2026622071.html

Medically speaking the major risks are

1. Exsanguination. The penis bleeds painlessly. The baby seems normal and the use of diapers can absorb a lot of blood. What is minor blood loss to us is fatal to a baby.

2. Infection. Fairly common cause of death in foreign countries. MRSA cases have been seen, the cause is not the circumcision but the circumcision helped.

3. Surgical Mishaps (Whoops!!!)

4. Anaesthetic death. ANY anaesthesia carries risk. Babies especially. It's a
pointless risk.

The causes of death are very rarely the circumcision itself (Around 1/500,000 hospital related deaths) because doctors often catch the bleed quickly. You wouldn't trust a guy whose only qualifications are wicked beard and knowledge of really old book with your surgery right? Yet they are the ones who do the procedure resulting in deaths and those are harder to classify since they don't keep records of how many circumcisions they do. But the other causes of death are really obvious and go down in the appropriate slot of secondary infection, anaesthetic related death and medical error.

It has been postulated as one of the reasons as to why the US has a higher infant mortality rate than equivalent european nations despite having similar socio economic status as a nation. It's a common elective that has a sufficient amount of risks done for ***** and giggles (yes that is a medical term... :)). Even for phimosis I would rather prescribe steroid cream rather than that. Only UTI infections in the mentally ill would require the surgery outright if they cannot understand the instruction. Or if the phimosis is severe enough to cause fusion.

Great post Avicenna, and welcome to the forum.
 
Non sequitur.

Wanna play again?

And it was the post IO was replaying to when I said it - else it wouldn't have been funny.

You have failed to point out the fallacy.



I am not aware of anyone saying something remotely like that.

Sarcasm. You seem quite adept at it's use. I'm quite surprised.



No, my contempt is of those who harm children willfully and without need.

And I do understand your arguments, I just don't agree with them at any point whatsoever. (This might have a lot to do with them being embarrassingly bad arguments. Your continuous lying about circumcision being a catholic practice just being one example. And yes, you are lying! 10 pages ago you might have been mistaken but by now you are either lying or mentally incapable of following the conversation at all. Since you insist on participating in the conversation I'll assume you know what you are saying...)

Your opinion is all well and good. I am perfectly fine and capable of respecting one's opinion. It becomes rather difficult when the same person cannot respect the beliefs of those who use the First Amendment to continue with a practice. You have yet to show any sort of respect towards religious people.

And the "harm" you are talking about is rather quite minimal at most.



Wrong.

I treat you this way because you are being dumb and dishonest.
Oh, and, no, the quality of my arguments has nothing to do with the form in which they are being delivered. I am still right if I am being an ass about it.

Right. I am being dumb and dishonest for invoking the First Amendment. And giving one's opinion as you have frequently done doesn't make you "right." opinions are subjective. Facts are not.


Well, no, I do not respect you and your views. I have no respect whatsoever for people that harm children or support the harming of children. So, no, I will not be more civil than I absolutely have to. I think on a scale of civility I am doing far better though than those who are in favor of chopping bits off off people.

That's all well and good. You just have to provide incontrivertible proof that circumcisions are actually as harmful as you say.

The post just above the one I am quoting provided a link that I have yet to look at that Avicenna has posted. I'll get onto it sometime later today. But until then, I have yet to see any proof. Therefore, your contempt is unfounded.



Oh yes, I see how I am the one looking ignorant. Did you find the time yet to let us all know which Christian sects practice circumcision? No? Well, did you at least have the time to understand that the first amendment does not grant any special protection to religious rituals?

And we have been through all of this. You must provide how society can benefit from a ban. You must provide proof that a practice causes death to many individuals.

Avicenna might have something within the link he/she has posted. I'll look through it real quick. But so far, the health organizations do not recommend any bans on circumcision, because of the lack of data.



Yes, it's more than clear that you don't much care about the quality of arguments so long as you feel not attacked just because people don't agree with your insane opinions.

You may have quality arguments. But your polarized temperament kind of makes it hard to see the forest for the trees. Therefore, "quality material" becomes highly questionable.

What if professional scientific studies were done with contemptuous remarks against their fellow scientists who have a different hypothesis? The report would rather quickly be deemed without a whole lot of merit, despite the quality of findings it may have.

I wold also like to conclude that certain other posters have shifted my view about the morality of circumcision, and that cutting off a piece of flesh for no medical reason is probably not exactly a good idea. But then again, I also am not very religiously motivated, either. But I can respect those who are.
 
Last edited:
And the "harm" you are talking about is rather quite minimal at most.


This is merely your opinion. Others believe the harm is quite significant.

Given this disagreement, how do we determine who should make the final decision on the matter?

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom