Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I said parents should not be allowed to hit their children, not that they are not allowed. What various courts have to say about various laws is irrelevant to that.

Certainly it is your right to think it's wrong for parents to spank their kids. It is certainly even your right to think it should not be allowed. I would totally commend you as a good parent if you don't have to resort to spanking. My kids are going to be swatted on the butt if they disobey something I ask of them.

At the risk of certain people thinking I am equating slavery with corporal punishment: in the days when it was legal to hold slaves, the courts would have upheld that right. That would in no way detract from the moral position that slavery should be illegal.
You yourself argued that the law has nothing to do with morals. This discussion is not about what is allowed, but what should be allowed, so no number of legal decisions has any significance.

Dred Scott vs. Sanford was perhaps one of the most famous court rulings in the nation's history. However, quite obviously, they got that one terribly wrong, and only inflamed anti-slavery forces. (Had they ruled otherwise, they would have enflamed slavery forces most likely.) The only reason why the SC ruled against Scott, was because he did not have citizenship status recognized by the United States. Therefore, he could not file a a suit for his own freedom.

Obviously, many people and states thought otherwise. However, not long afterwards, war broke out for 4 long bloody years, and eventually the Fourteenth Amendment was ratified, guaranteeing anyone who is born in the United States full citizenship.

That was probably the most difficult debate in American history, lasting for the better part of 3-4 decades, which ended in a bloody Civil War which lasted four years.

This is a terribly complicated and overly complex argument to make in respect to the debate on whether to ban circumcision or not. For it is a question born out of morality. It is also a quesiton born out of citizenship, what constitutes an American citizen, and balancing the interests of society with that of the individual.

You shall note that before the Civil War, it was thought that states' rights (by that extension, individual rights,) were far more important than the society. That was the Great Debate for the first 90 years of the nation's existence. After the South was defeated, states' and individual rights are no long the end-all, be-all argument. Now the courts must take into consideration, the rights of society.
 
Not sure if I can be bothered to wade through this entire thread, but you've claimed the above at least twice before, and I dearly hope someone has corrected you already, but circumcism is not required of Christians, as it is of Jews and Muslims. I went to a Catholic boys senior school, and from locker room observations, there was only one kid in my class who was circumcised, and that was certainly seen as "unusual" enough to have the piss ripped out of him for it. Then again, the prevalence of circumcision in the UK is nowhere near that of the US.

Yeah, I don;t think getting into this discussion is a good idea. There are many Christian sects in the US that circumcise for religious reasons. There are many Catholics (I am one) who are circumcised. At least in my diocese. In fact, it would be quite rare to find an uncircumcised Catholic in the Diocese of Scranton.

In any case, I am perfectly fine with only talking about Jews and Muslims. It doesn't change the dynamics of my arguments at all.
 
Yes.

Of course, he also said that it was allowed to those that do have it as a religious ritual it could not be forbidden to anyone else either. So why he would insist that it is a Christian/Catholic ritual is still beyond me. He could simply admit that it is not so and the rest of his argument would be just as good or bad as it is now.

The bolded is the reason why I quit commenting and arguing about it. It has no basis whatsoever with my arguments, for there are still Jews and Muslims who practice it for religious purposes.
 
http://www.cirp.org/library/sex_function/

clearly a biased site with a clear agenda.

for example:

It plays an important role in normal human sexual response and is necessary for normal copulatory behavior.40 An understanding of this role is now emerging in the scientific literature. Removal of the foreskin (circumcision) interferes with normal sexual function.

I, my father, my uncles, my cousins, all function normally, as far as sex is concerned. I have never heard of any of my Jewish male friends or non-Jewish male friends who were circumcised, of having any sexual disfunction due to this procedure.

Ouch! Good point! I skimmed through that site, and found nothing terribly wrong, or nothing that I could personally refute. I obviously missed that part.

I hate to say it Childless Empress, but this statement alone kind of makes that site lose a lot of merit. :o
 
I, my father, my uncles, my cousins, all function normally, as far as sex is concerned. I have never heard of any of my Jewish male friends or non-Jewish male friends who were circumcised, of having any sexual disfunction due to this procedure.
A woman from a society who performed female circumcision would say "I, my mother, my aunts, my cousins, all function normally, as far as sex is concerned. I have never heard of any of my Sudanese female friends or non-Sudanese female friends who were circumcised, of having any sexual dysfunction due to this procedure."
 
Ouch! Good point! I skimmed through that site, and found nothing terribly wrong, or nothing that I could personally refute. I obviously missed that part.

I hate to say it Childless Empress, but this statement alone kind of makes that site lose a lot of merit. :o


The norm for human males is to have a foreskin and it serves the function the literature summarized in sober language in this article describes in detail. That you think you and your peer group are normal is understandable, but holds no merit from a scientific point of view and the meaning of the word "normal".
 
Last edited:
I hate to say it Childless Empress, but this statement alone kind of makes that site lose a lot of merit. :o


It's Childlike Empress talking to you by the way. A character out of Michael Ende's book "The Neverending Story", which i highly recommend reading to your hopefully healthy and unmutilated to-be-born children. :)
 
Last edited:
I haven't read the entire thread but my view is this:

Circumcision, except for medical necessity, before the age of majority is child abuse and it should be banned EVERYWHERE.

Every male in my family is circumcised, including my son. I was not consulted on that. I was away when he was born and my ex-wife assumed that because I am, and her male relatives are, our son should be too.

Regardless, it's child abuse. Neither of my grandsons are circumcised. I had a long talk with both my daughters about it. My ex-wife, their mother, also argued against it. Minds can be changed.
 
Last edited:
It's Childlike Empress talking to you by the way. A character out of Michael Ende's book "The Neverending Story", which i highly recommend reading to your hopefully healthy and unmutilated to-be-born children. :)

A great book, and a great movie. A must for any child, or childlike adult. :D
 
Regardless, it's child abuse. Neither of my grandsons are circumcised. I had a long talk with both my daughters about it. My ex-wife, their mother, also argued against it. Minds can be changed.


A change of mind is certainly preferable to prohibition. Whatever one thinks about the initiative to ban circumcision in San Francisco, and whatever the result of it will be, a positive outcome is that it generates discussion and awareness.
 
A change of mind is certainly preferable to prohibition.

I wouldn't prohibit it. It would be allowed for anyone over the age of majority . . . or at least the age of consent. That serves two purposes, it allows the person affected to make the decision when they are far better able to and it allows the person affected to make the decision when they are better able to. :D

Whatever one thinks about the initiative to ban circumcision in San Francisco, and whatever the result of it will be, a positive outcome is that it generates discussion and awareness.

Agreed.
 
There is one benefit that seemingly comes from circumcision. The accumulation of smegma causes penile cancer.

However the solution is proper hygiene rather than "cut it off". But it's hard to encourage that kind of hygiene since the topic is awkward and involves parents handling their children's genitalia until they are old enough to do it themselves. I cannot think of a way to tell kids how to do it.
 
I was just told to pull the skin back to wash.

I did not understand how far back it could be pulled back for a few years, however, so I wasn't doing it properly. It just means that the child has to show the parents that they understand. This shouldn't be awkward at that age for the child or parents.
 
There is one benefit that seemingly comes from circumcision. The accumulation of smegma causes penile cancer.

Yes. And a good 68% of European boys over the age of 4 need to have their penises amputated because of it! :rolleyes:

However the solution is proper hygiene rather than "cut it off". But it's hard to encourage that kind of hygiene since the topic is awkward and involves parents handling their children's genitalia until they are old enough to do it themselves. I cannot think of a way to tell kids how to do it.

Then quite frankly you shouldn't have children. How will you keep them clean, wash them, change their diapers, ...

oh hey, here's an idea: Have all their teeth pulled out! It's *much* easier than teaching them how to brush let alone floss!
 

Oh come on, it only hurts a little and the pain is soon forgotten. (We don't actually know if it really hurts - babies cry for all sorts of reason, anyway, and it might be a pure coincidence that they cry when their teeth are pulled out, really!)

And anyways, if we do it with children the procedure is much easier and less painful than with adults.

In fact: Since the children will later grow a second set of teeth, they actually *do* get a choice!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom