Nihilianth
Illuminator
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,851
I said parents should not be allowed to hit their children, not that they are not allowed. What various courts have to say about various laws is irrelevant to that.
Certainly it is your right to think it's wrong for parents to spank their kids. It is certainly even your right to think it should not be allowed. I would totally commend you as a good parent if you don't have to resort to spanking. My kids are going to be swatted on the butt if they disobey something I ask of them.
At the risk of certain people thinking I am equating slavery with corporal punishment: in the days when it was legal to hold slaves, the courts would have upheld that right. That would in no way detract from the moral position that slavery should be illegal.
You yourself argued that the law has nothing to do with morals. This discussion is not about what is allowed, but what should be allowed, so no number of legal decisions has any significance.
Dred Scott vs. Sanford was perhaps one of the most famous court rulings in the nation's history. However, quite obviously, they got that one terribly wrong, and only inflamed anti-slavery forces. (Had they ruled otherwise, they would have enflamed slavery forces most likely.) The only reason why the SC ruled against Scott, was because he did not have citizenship status recognized by the United States. Therefore, he could not file a a suit for his own freedom.
Obviously, many people and states thought otherwise. However, not long afterwards, war broke out for 4 long bloody years, and eventually the Fourteenth Amendment was ratified, guaranteeing anyone who is born in the United States full citizenship.
That was probably the most difficult debate in American history, lasting for the better part of 3-4 decades, which ended in a bloody Civil War which lasted four years.
This is a terribly complicated and overly complex argument to make in respect to the debate on whether to ban circumcision or not. For it is a question born out of morality. It is also a quesiton born out of citizenship, what constitutes an American citizen, and balancing the interests of society with that of the individual.
You shall note that before the Civil War, it was thought that states' rights (by that extension, individual rights,) were far more important than the society. That was the Great Debate for the first 90 years of the nation's existence. After the South was defeated, states' and individual rights are no long the end-all, be-all argument. Now the courts must take into consideration, the rights of society.