Rolfe
Adult human female
There are many Christian sects in the US that circumcise for religious reasons.
I DON'T BELIEVE YOU.
We've been through this before, and you finally realised circumcision among Christians wasn't nearly as widespread as you had thought it was. You were taking a local situation and imagining it to be universal.
You then admitted that circumcision had been BANNED by the Catholic church from the 15th century until quite recently, and that now the Vatican does not take a view on it.
You then revealed that the extent of the "religious" pressure to circumcise even in your diocese was that IF THE PARENTS BROUGHT UP THE SUBJECT the priest could discuss it with them. You had no idea what the priest would then say, other than (presumably) passing on the message that the Vatican doesn't care one way or another these days.
You've also indicated that you probably won't have your own sons circumcised, which doesn't suggest a deep religious imperative on your part.
There are many Catholics (I am one) who are circumcised. At least in my diocese. In fact, it would be quite rare to find an uncircumcised Catholic in the Diocese of Scranton.
Maybe so, but THAT DOESN'T MEAN IT WAS DONE FOR A RELIGIOUS REASON. Catholics are a social group as well as a religious group, and social norms tend to predominate. You have given us no evidence at all that any Catholic parent has had his son mutilated because he believed it was a religious obligation.
We've discussed the Council of Jerusalem, and the explicit decision of the early Church not to circumcise. We've noted that some Orthodox sects practise circumcision, principally the Copts, but in fact we don't even know the doctrinal rationale for that one and you haven't mentioned a large Egyptian population round your way.
You've given us NO CLUE AT ALL regarding any possible doctrinal justification for circumcision regarded as a religious duty within any Christian denomination, and you've made it very clear that in your own diocese circumcision is merely a social norm and not a religious duty.
SO PLEASE STOP SAYING CHRISTIANS CIRCUMCISE FOR RELIGIOUS REASONS.
Outside certain sections of the Orthodox faith, THEY DON'T.
Rolfe.