Ban circumcision in San Fran???

There are many Christian sects in the US that circumcise for religious reasons.


I DON'T BELIEVE YOU.

We've been through this before, and you finally realised circumcision among Christians wasn't nearly as widespread as you had thought it was. You were taking a local situation and imagining it to be universal.

You then admitted that circumcision had been BANNED by the Catholic church from the 15th century until quite recently, and that now the Vatican does not take a view on it.

You then revealed that the extent of the "religious" pressure to circumcise even in your diocese was that IF THE PARENTS BROUGHT UP THE SUBJECT the priest could discuss it with them. You had no idea what the priest would then say, other than (presumably) passing on the message that the Vatican doesn't care one way or another these days.

You've also indicated that you probably won't have your own sons circumcised, which doesn't suggest a deep religious imperative on your part.

There are many Catholics (I am one) who are circumcised. At least in my diocese. In fact, it would be quite rare to find an uncircumcised Catholic in the Diocese of Scranton.


Maybe so, but THAT DOESN'T MEAN IT WAS DONE FOR A RELIGIOUS REASON. Catholics are a social group as well as a religious group, and social norms tend to predominate. You have given us no evidence at all that any Catholic parent has had his son mutilated because he believed it was a religious obligation.

We've discussed the Council of Jerusalem, and the explicit decision of the early Church not to circumcise. We've noted that some Orthodox sects practise circumcision, principally the Copts, but in fact we don't even know the doctrinal rationale for that one and you haven't mentioned a large Egyptian population round your way.

You've given us NO CLUE AT ALL regarding any possible doctrinal justification for circumcision regarded as a religious duty within any Christian denomination, and you've made it very clear that in your own diocese circumcision is merely a social norm and not a religious duty.

SO PLEASE STOP SAYING CHRISTIANS CIRCUMCISE FOR RELIGIOUS REASONS.

Outside certain sections of the Orthodox faith, THEY DON'T.

Rolfe.
 
If this is Rasmus from 40KO then I am well and truly terrified...

Then quite frankly you shouldn't have children. How will you keep them clean, wash them, change their diapers, ...

oh hey, here's an idea: Have all their teeth pulled out! It's *much* easier than teaching them how to brush let alone floss!

I am very anti circumcision even for medical reasons. The only medical reason i can think of for circumcision is in individuals with Urinary tract infections who cannot take care of themselves.

Either that or you were being incredibly sarcastic in which case *I salute you sir...*

It's just a hard topic to broach with parents since no one likes talking about children's genitalia... Well hardly anyone.

The issue in the USA seems to be cultural and aesthetic. People just think it looks nicer and it's always been done that way.
 
If this is Rasmus from 40KO then I am well and truly terrified...

From where?



I am very anti circumcision even for medical reasons. The only medical reason i can think of for circumcision is in individuals with Urinary tract infections who cannot take care of themselves.

Either that or you were being incredibly sarcastic in which case *I salute you sir...*

Me? Sarcastic? Perish the thought! I was being entirely serious. (And I forgot the bit about it all being done for religious reasons because it follows the divine demands of the tooth fairy, too ...)

Seriously: My justification is any bit as good if not a dozen times better than what the proponents of circumcision have been offering so far.

It's just a hard topic to broach with parents since no one likes talking about children's genitalia... Well hardly anyone.

Nobody has to like it. I am sure changing diapers, cleaning beds that have been vomited in or washing a child that has decided that a bucket full of paint was fun to play with aren't the highlights of parenting - but they need to be done. And if someone is incapable of doing them, they shouldn't be a parent.

The issue in the USA seems to be cultural and aesthetic. People just think it looks nicer and it's always been done that way.

Terry Pratchett to the rescue: A million dead people couldn't have been wrong.
 
The issue in the USA seems to be cultural and aesthetic. People just think it looks nicer and it's always been done that way.

What folks may not know is how the practice became common in the US:

The Latest Fight Over the Foreskin
By RONI CARYN RABIN
Published: August 29, 2009
(...)
David L. Gollaher, author of “Circumcision: A History of the World’s Most Controversial Surgery,” traces the surge in circumcision to an influential 19th-century New York surgeon, Lewis A. Sayre, who believed that many neurological problems were caused by genital irritations.

Dr. Sayre circumcised patients with paralysis and operated on mentally ill patients in psychiatric hospitals; then he published papers about his successes, convincing physicians this was “a very powerful operation,” Dr. Gollaher said.

In the early 20th century, as childbirth moved from the home, where it was supervised by midwives who didn’t practice circumcision, and into hospitals run by doctors, more and more babies from middle- and upper-income families were being circumcised. Being without a foreskin was said to boost hygiene, and became a badge of the educated and upper classes.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/30/w...300032193-Dm5jgVZi ngItCtBUcHJwA&pagewanted=1
 
The norm for human males is to have a foreskin and it serves the function the literature summarized in sober language in this article describes in detail. That you think you and your peer group are normal is understandable, but holds no merit from a scientific point of view and the meaning of the word "normal".

I will have to go back over that article, but real quick out of curiosity:

Did the writer of the article cite a comprehensive study on circumcision-related dysfunction? If so, what was the percentage, and which country did the source cite in the study? Did they do a side-by-side comparison of % of uncircumcised men with erectile dysfunction, with circumcised men as well?

Reason why I ask, because I don't want to take an unscientific approach by assuming that circumcision does not affect sperm count, and the ability to become erect. Quite frankly, I have never heard that circumcision can cause this in males. And I think that it would be kind of difficult to pin down dysfunction of the penis to circumcision. The best a comparison between circumcised and uncircumcised can do, is to show perhaps a correlation. But correlation is not causation either.
 
It's Childlike Empress talking to you by the way. A character out of Michael Ende's book "The Neverending Story", which i highly recommend reading to your hopefully healthy and unmutilated to-be-born children. :)

haha, sorry bout that! Childlike Empress. I know the book (and the movies!) quite well. One of my favorite books growing up. :)

We probably won't have any of our kids circumcised. But I don't think that;s really anyone;s business. :D
 
Did the writer of the article cite a comprehensive study on circumcision-related dysfunction?


Nearly every sentence in the article is footnoted, and the notes lead to the full texts on the same server. You'll have to go look for yourself.

btw, re: "normal" - from Emet's NYT article:

As one of the few countries where circumcision is widely practiced for non-religious reasons, the United States is an anomaly. Most European countries have largely abandoned routine neonatal circumcision; the British stopped doing it when they started the National Health Service in 1948. The service refused to cover the practice because it was deemed not medically necessary, and some Europeans will frankly say they find the idea barbaric and unnatural. Yet in the United States, circumcision is the norm, and the vast majority of men — and in all likelihood the majority of doctors — are circumcised, even though rates have dropped in recent years.


That's just how the word is used - has nothing to do with bias of any kind.

The mentioned film "Cut" by Eli Unger-Sargon is on youtube, if somebody is interested. I only know that it contains content of Sony Music... :rolleyes:

haha, sorry bout that!


No problem.
 
There is one benefit that seemingly comes from circumcision. The accumulation of smegma causes penile cancer.

However the solution is proper hygiene rather than "cut it off". But it's hard to encourage that kind of hygiene since the topic is awkward and involves parents handling their children's genitalia until they are old enough to do it themselves. I cannot think of a way to tell kids how to do it.

Unfortunately in this sue-happy, and ban-happy society of ours, parents are reluctant to come close to touching their child while showing them how to properly clean themselves. (Sorry, I had to take that shot! :D But it has a point. )

While this comes close to a slippery slope argument and is sort of off-topic, one of the biggest reasons why I am against a ban, is simply because I think it is prudent to leave parents and families alone. The more you place restrictions on parents and charge them for rather minor issues, the more parents will be afraid to teach a child that the world can be a scary place when they get older. Parents should not be sheltering their children so much. This, I wholeheartedly believe. I think that spankings are necessary at times. That circumcision is not a very big deal. Not such a big deal that society must poke it's very public nose into private familial matters. And so forth.

However, Childlike Empress is correct. If anything, a discussion on the issue provides people with more information. Education is far more effective than prohibition. I am more convinced than ever that perhaps circumcision is not the right course for my sons, if boys they be. In fact, this was one of my earliest arguments way back when. I did suggest that maybe those who are against circumcision should create informative pamphlets they can distribute at doctors' offices, and hospitals. Pretty much, everything that the major national and international health organizations already recommend: Not to ban the practice of circumcision, but rather train doctors to explain fully the benefits and risks involved with circumcision in an unbiased manner.

It just really seems to me that a prohibition would be too drastic a measure, for something that isn't that big a problem for society.

In any case, I will really take more of a back seat in this conversation, only answering any questions and posts directed my way. Unless they are hypothetical and Christian questions. They shall go completely ignored from now on. I have no interests in continuing such a stale conversation any longer. :)
 
Seriously: My justification is any bit as good if not a dozen times better than what the proponents of circumcision have been offering so far.

What? Your disgusting sarcastic remarks are much better arguments than the sound rationale of keeping private matters private, and using the First Amendment rights for arguments? And that informing the public is far more effective and forthcoming than something as drastic as a prohibition?
 
Nearly every sentence in the article is footnoted, and the notes lead to the full texts on the same server. You'll have to go look for yourself.

I know it's footnoted. I just never took the time to go through the article with a discerning eye, and probably won't have it, either. I start back to work next week. (They had a student-teacher come in, and needed to do quite a bit of classroom/teacher moving around. So I was off for the past two weeks. :( )

I was just hoping you knew where such a study with such information might be located. It seems this information might be key to your argument you made earlier. (I also do not believe it is up to me to furnish this information either...;) )

btw, re: "normal" - from Emet's NYT article:




That's just how the word is used - has nothing to do with bias of any kind.

Well, that's all fine and good, but that still doesn't discount the fact there are Jews and Muslims in the US who do practice it for religious reasons.

After doing further research into case law, it does appear that the law can make religious exceptions. But usually, they must pass a second law, after going all the way to the Supreme Court. Personally, I probably still wouldn't vote on a prohibition measure which allowed a religious exception. Because of the ruling in the Smith case in which the judge said something to the effect of "every man could become a law unto himself." Meaning, people can very easily use the excuse of "religious obligations" to get around a law. Or to use the exception written into said law. This could inherently undermine respect for the law. Which was one of my big talking points throughout this thread.
.[/QUOTE]
 
And I think that it would be kind of difficult to pin down dysfunction of the penis to circumcision. The best a comparison between circumcised and uncircumcised can do, is to show perhaps a correlation. But correlation is not causation either.

What you think don't matter. An article has already been linked to you which discuss just that. And you know, doctor, biologist are those people which like to research to see if there is a causation. You on the other hand are just trying desperately to defend a procedure.
 
What? Your disgusting sarcastic remarks are much better arguments than the sound rationale of keeping private matters private, and using the First Amendment rights for arguments?

Yes. Only I am not being disgusting.

Yes, my arguments are better than yours. Your are so bad it's not even fun anymore to keep pointing out the mistakes like ... uh ... "begging the question".

And that informing the public is far more effective and forthcoming than something as drastic as a prohibition?

Do try to read for comprehension.

And, no, if circumcision is a violation of the rights of the child there is no reason to let people get away with it.
 
What you think don't matter. An article has already been linked to you which discuss just that. And you know, doctor, biologist are those people which like to research to see if there is a causation. You on the other hand are just trying desperately to defend a procedure.

Sarcasm doesn't earn you any extra points, you know. ;)

I never said anything about what I think. I just simply asked for a study which shows causation. The article mentioned dysfunction as a cause from circumcision. The amount of people who are circumcised being able to produce children doesn't exactly support the theory. The best that could be done, is to show a strong correlation between circumcision and erectile dysfunction. There must be a higher percentage of circumcised men who have ED, than uncircumcised men. Should there not? A comprehensive study about the nature of circumcision definitively causing dysfunction should also be forthcoming.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom